Recent Progress on Two-Dimensional Materials
2021-12-27ChengChangWeiChenYeChenYonghuaChenYuChenFengDingChunhaiFanHongJinFanZhanxiFanChengGongYongjiGongQiyuanHeXunHongShengHuWeidaHuWeiHuangYuanHuangWeiJiDehuiLiLainJongLiQiangLiLiLinChongyiLingMinghuaLiuNanLiu
Cheng Chang , Wei Chen , Ye Chen , Yonghua Chen , Yu Chen , Feng Ding , Chunhai Fan ,Hong Jin Fan , Zhanxi Fan , Cheng Gong 0, Yongji Gong , Qiyuan He , Xun Hong , Sheng Hu ,Weida Hu , Wei Huang , Yuan Huang , Wei Ji , Dehui Li , Lain-Jong Li , Qiang Li 0, Li Lin ,Chongyi Ling 0, Minghua Liu , Nan Liu , Zhuang Liu , Kian Ping Loh , Jianmin Ma , Feng Miao ,Hailin Peng , Mingfei Shao , Li Song , Shao Su 0, Shuo Sun , Chaoliang Tan , Zhiyong Tang ,Dingsheng Wang , Huan Wang , Jinlan Wang 0, Xin Wang , Xinran Wang , Andrew T.S.Wee ,Zhongming Wei , Yuen Wu , Zhong-Shuai Wu , Jie Xiong 0, Qihua Xiong , Weigao Xu , Peng Yin ,Haibo Zeng , Zhiyuan Zeng , Tianyou Zhai , Han Zhang , Hui Zhang , Qichun Zhang ,Tierui Zhang , Xiang Zhang , Li-Dong Zhao , Meiting Zhao , Weijie Zhao 0, Yunxuan Zhao ,Kai-Ge Zhou , Xing Zhou , Yu Zhou 0, Hongwei Zhu , Hua Zhang ,*, Zhongfan Liu ,*
1 Institute of Science and Technology Austria, Am Campus 1, 3400 Klosterneuburg, Austria.
2 Department of Chemistry, National University of Singapore, 3 Science Drive 3, 117543, Singapore.
3 Department of Chemistry, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shatin, New Territories, Hong Kong, China.
4 Key Laboratory of Flexible Electronics and Institute of Advanced Materials, Nanjing Tech University, Nanjing 211816, China.
5 School of Life Sciences, Shanghai University, Shanghai 200444, China.
6 Centre for Multidimensional Carbon Materials, Institute for Basic Science, Ulsan 44919, Korea.
7 School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, China.
8 School of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore 637371, Singapore.
9 Department of Chemistry, City University of Hong Kong, Kowloon, Hong Kong, China.
10 Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering and Quantum Technology Center, University of Maryland, College Park,Maryland 20742, USA.
11 School of Materials Science and Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, China.
12 Department of Materials Science and Engineering, City University of Hong Kong, Kowloon, Hong Kong, China.
13 Center of Advanced Nanocatalysis (CAN), Hefei National Laboratory for Physical Sciences at the Microscale, Department of Applied Chemistry, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230026, China.
14 College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, State Key Laboratory of Physical Chemistry of Solid Surfaces, Collaborative Innovation Center of Chemistry for Energy Materials (iChEM), Xiamen University, Xiamen, 361005, Fujian Province, China.
15 State Key Laboratory of Infrared Physics, Shanghai Institute of Technical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences,Shanghai 200083, China.
16 Advanced Research Institute of Multidisciplinary Science, Beijing Institute of Technology, Beijing, 100081, China.
17 Beijing Key Laboratory of Optoelectronic Functional Materials & Micro-Nano Devices, Department of Physics,Renmin University of China, Beijing 100872, China.
18 School of Optical and Electronic Information, Wuhan National Laboratory for Optoelectronics, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, China.
19 Department of Mechanical Engineering, The University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam Road, Hong Kong, China.
20 School of Physics, Southeast University, Nanjing 211189, China.
21 Department of Materials Science and Engineering, National University of Singapore, Singapore 117575, Singapore.
22 CAS Key Laboratory of Colloid, Interface and Chemical Thermodynamics, Institute of Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100190, China.
23 College of Chemistry, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China.
24 Institute of Functional Nano & Soft Materials (FUNSOM), Jiangsu Key Laboratory for Carbon-based Functional Materials and Devices, Soochow University, Suzhou 215123, Jiangsu Province, China.
25 School of Materials and Energy, University of Electronic Science and Technology of China, Chengdu 611731, China.
26 School of Physics, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210093, China.
27 Center for Nanochemistry (CNC), Beijing National Laboratory for Molecular Sciences, College of Chemistry and Molecular Engineering, Beijing Graphene Institute (BGI), Peking University, Beijing 100871, China.
28 State Key Laboratory of Chemical Resource Engineering, Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing 100029, China.
29 National Synchrotron Radiation Laboratory, CAS Center for Excellence in Nanoscience, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230029, China.
30 State Key Laboratory of Organic Electronics and Information Displays & Jiangsu Key Laboratory for Biosensors, Institute of Advanced Materials (IAM), Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications, Nanjing 210023, China.
31 Department of Physics, National University of Singapore, 2 Science Drive 3, 117551, Singapore.
32 Department of Electrical Engineering, City University of Hong Kong, Kowloon, Hong Kong, China.
33 CAS Key Laboratory of Nanosystem and Hierarchical Fabrication, CAS Center for Excellence in Nanoscience, National Center for Nanoscience and Technology, Beijing 100190, China.
34 Department of Chemistry, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China.
35 Key Laboratory of Advanced Energy Materials Chemistry (Ministry of Education), Renewable Energy Conversion and Storage Center (RECAST), College of Chemistry, Nankai University, Tianjin 300071, China.
36 School of Chemistry and Materials Science, iChEM (Collaborative Innovation Center of Chemistry for Energy Materials), Hefei National Laboratory for Physical Sciences at the Microscale, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230026, China.
37 National Laboratory of Solid State Microstructures, School of Electronic Science and Engineering, Collaborative Innovation Center of Advanced Microstructures, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210023, China.
38 Institute of Semiconductors, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100083, China.
39 State Key Laboratory of Catalysis, Dalian Institute of Chemical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Dalian 116023, Liaoning Province, China.
40 State Key Laboratory of Electronic Thin Film and Integrated Devices, University of Electronic Science and Technology of China,Chengdu 610054, China.
41 State Key Laboratory of Low Dimensional Quantum Physics, Department of Physics, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China.
42 Key Laboratory of Mesoscopic Chemistry, School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210023,China.
43 Institute of Microscale Optoelectronics, Shenzhen University, Shenzhen 518060, Guangdong Province, China.
44 MIIT Key Laboratory of Advanced Display Materials and Devices, College of Material Science and Engineering, Nanjing University of Science and Technology, Nanjing 210094, China.
45 School of Materials Science and Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, China.
46 Technical Institute of Physics and Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China.
47 Faculties of Sciences and Engineering, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
48 Tianjin Key Laboratory of Molecular Optoelectronic Sciences, Department of Chemistry, Institute of Molecular Aggregation Science, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300072, China.
49 Institute of Molecular Plus, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300072, China.
50 School of Physics and Electronics, Hunan Key Laboratory of Nanophotonics and Devices, Central South University,Changsha 410083, China.
51 State Key Lab of New Ceramics and Fine Processing, School of Materials Science and Engineering, Tsinghua University,Beijing 100084, China.
Abstract: Research on two-dimensional (2D) materials has been explosively increasing in last seventeen years in varying subjects including condensed matter physics, electronic engineering, materials science, and chemistry since the mechanical exfoliation of graphene in 2004.Starting from graphene, 2D materials now have become a big family with numerous members and diverse categories.The unique structural features and physicochemical properties of 2D materials make them one class of the most appealing candidates for a wide range of potential applications.In particular, we have seen some major breakthroughs made in the field of 2D materials in last five years not only in developing novel synthetic methods and exploring new structures/properties but also in identifying innovative applications and pushing forward commercialisation.In this review, we provide a critical summary on the recent progress made in the field of 2D materials with a particular focus on last five years.After a brief background introduction, we first discuss the major synthetic methods for 2D materials, including the mechanical exfoliation, liquid exfoliation, vapor phase deposition, and wet-chemical synthesis as well as phase engineering of 2D materials belonging to the field of phase engineering of nanomaterials (PEN).We then introduce the superconducting/optical/magnetic properties and chirality of 2D materials along with newly emerging magic angle 2D superlattices.Following that, the promising applications of 2D materials in electronics, optoelectronics, catalysis, energy storage, solar cells, biomedicine,sensors, environments, etc.are described sequentially.Thereafter, we present the theoretic calculations and simulations of 2D materials.Finally, after concluding the current progress, we provide some personal discussions on the existing challenges and future outlooks in this rapidly developing field.
Key Words: Two-dimensional materials; Transition metal dichalcogenides; Phase engineering of nanomaterials;Electronics; Optoelectronics; Catalysis; Energy storage and conversion
CONTENTS
1 Introduction 4
2 Synthetic methods 5
2.1 Mechanical exfoliation 5
2.2 Liquid exfoliation 7
2.3 Gas vapor growth 8
2.3.1 Chemical vapor deposition 8
2.3.2 Thermally assisted conversion in CVD system 10
2.3.3 Pulsed laser deposition 10
2.4 Chemical synthesis 11
2.4.1 2D metal nanomaterials 11
2.4.2 Layered double hydroxides 11
2.4.3 2D metal-organic framework 13
2.4.4 Xenes 14
2.4.5 2D covalent organic framework 15
2.4.6 Other emerging 2D materials 16
2.5 Phase engineering of 2D materials 17
2.5.1 Overview of phase engineering in 2D materials 17
2.5.2 Phase engineering of transition metal dichalcogenides 17
2.5.2.1 Phase transition of TMDs 17
2.5.2.1.1 Phase transitionviadirect electron injection 17
2.5.2.1.2 Phase transitionviathermal activation 18
2.5.2.2 Direct synthesis of metastable-phase TMDs 18
2.5.3 Phase engineering of other 2D nanosheets 19
2.5.4 Amorphous 2D materials 19
2.5.5 X-ray based characterizations on phase engineering in 2D materials 19
2.5.5.1 XAS study on phase engineering in 2D materials 19
2.5.5.2 ARPES study on phase engineering in 2D materials 20
3 Physical properties 20
3.1 Optical properties 20
3.1.1 Optical absorption 20
3.1.2 Raman scattering 21
3.1.3 Optical emission 21
3.1.4 Light-matter strong coupling and exciton polaritons 23
3.1.5 Nonlinear optical properties 23
3.2 Magnetic properties 24
3.3 Thermoelectric properties 25
3.4 Ferroelectric properties 26
3.5 Superconductivity 29
3.5.1 BCS 2D superconductors 29
3.5.2 2D high-temperature superconductors 29
3.6 Magic-angle 2D superlattices 30
3.7 Chirality 32
3.7.1 General concepts of 2D chirality 32
3.7.2 Some typical application of chiral 2D materials 33
3.7.2.1 Chiral graphene 33
3.7.2.2 Chiral TMDs 33
3.7.2.3 Chiral 2D perovskites 33
3.7.2.4 Other chiral 2D materials 34
4 Potential applications 34
4.1 Electronics 34
4.1.1 Fabrication and architecture of 2d field-effect transistors 34
4.1.1.1 Status of n-FET and p-FET 35
4.1.1.2 CMOS demonstration 35
4.1.2 Key challenges for 2D electronics 35
4.1.2.1 Contact issue 35
4.1.2.2 Doping of 2D semiconductors 36
4.1.2.3 Mobility engineering 37
4.1.2.4 Gate dielectrics 38
4.1.3 Emerging computing technology based on 2D materials 38
4.1.3.1 Logic circuits 38
4.1.3.2 Neuromorphic computing 39
4.2 Optoelectronics 40
4.2.1 Categorization and figure of merit for optoelectronics 40
4.2.1.1 Categorization of optoelectronics 40
4.2.1.1.1 Photodetectors 40
4.2.1.1.2 Photovoltaic devices 40
4.2.1.1.3 Optical modulator and lasers 40
4.2.1.2 Figure of merit of optoelectronics based on photocurrent generation mechanisms 41
4.2.1.2.1 Photoconductive effect 41
4.2.1.2.2 Photovoltaic effect 42
4.2.1.2.3 Photogating effect 42
4.2.1.2.4 Photothermoelectric effect 42
4.2.1.2.5 Bolometric effect 42
4.2.2 Key challenges for optoelectronics 42
4.2.2.1 Wide and narrow bandgap 42
4.2.2.2 2D heterostructures for optoelectronics 43
4.2.3 Unique applications of 2D functional optoelectronics 43
4.2.3.1 Wide-spectrum photodetectors 43
4.2.3.2 2D polarization-sensitive photodetectors 44
4.2.3.3 2D neural network image sensors 44
4.2.3.4 Near/in-sensor computing 44
4.3 Catalysis 45
4.3.1 Electrocatalysis 45
4.3.1.1 Oxygen reduction reaction 45
4.3.1.2 CO2reduction reaction 47
4.3.1.3 Nitrogen reduction reaction 48
4.3.1.3.1 2D metal-based NRR catalysts 48
4.3.1.3.2 Graphene-based NRR catalysts 49
4.3.1.4 Methanol oxidation reaction/ethanol oxidation reaction 51
4.3.1.5 Formic acid oxidation reaction 52
4.3.1.6 Hydrogen evolution reaction 52
4.3.1.6.1 Transition metal chalcogenides 52
4.3.1.6.2 Xenes 53
4.3.1.6.3 MXenes 54
4.3.1.6.4 Layered double hydroxides 54
4.3.1.7 Oxygen evolution reaction 54
4.3.1.7.1 Metal organic frameworks 55
4.3.1.7.2 Transition metal chalcogenides 55
4.3.1.7.3 Layered double hydroxides 55
4.3.2 Photocatalysis 56
4.3.2.1 Water splitting 56
4.3.2.2 CO2photoreduction 57
4.3.2.3 Nitrogen reduction reaction 58
4.3.2.4 Photocatalytic environmental treatment 59
4.3.2.5 Photocatalytic organic synthesis 60
4.4 Energy storage 61
4.4.1 Batteries 62
4.4.2 Supercapacitors 64
4.4.3 2D materials for micro-supercapacitors 65
4.5 Solar cells 67
4.5.1 Electrodes 67
4.5.2 Charge transport layers 68
4.5.3 Photoactive layer 68
4.6 Biomedical applications 68
4.7 Sensing applications 70
4.7.1 Fluorescence sensing platforms 70
4.7.2 SPR sensing platforms 70
4.7.3 Surface-enhanced Raman scattering sensing platforms 71
4.7.4 Field-effect transistor sensing platforms 72
4.7.5 Electrochemical sensors 72
4.7.6 Colorimetric sensors 73
4.8 Flexible electronics 74
4.9 Environmental applications 76
4.9.1 Water treatments 76
4.9.2 Carbon neutralization and exhaust gas treatment 78
4.9.3 Rare earth enrichments and soil remediation 79
4.10 Proton permeation 79
4.10.1 Origin of the proton permeation 80
4.10.2 Applications of proton transport 81
4.10.3 Various approaches to enhance proton conductance 82
4.11 Other applications 82
5 Theoretical calculations and simulations 83
5.1 Growth mechanism of 2D materialsviabottom-up synthesis 83
5.1.1 Role of substrate in bottom-up synthesis of 2D materials 84
5.1.2 Epitaxy of 2D materials on low-symmetry substrates 85
5.1.3 Growth mechanisms of TMDs on gold substrates 88
5.1.4 Growth of polycrystalline 2D materials on liquid substrates 88
5.1.5 Growth mechanism of graphene on insulating substrates 89
5.1.6 Summary 90
5.2 Surface reactivity of 2D materials 90
5.2.1 Oxidation and degradation mechanisms 91
5.2.1.1 Light-induced oxidation 91
5.2.1.2 Water catalyzed oxidation 91
5.2.1.3 Defect induced oxidation 91
5.2.2 Surface vacancies and performance control 92
5.2.3 2D materials supported single atom catalysts 93
5.2.3.1 Activity descriptors 93
5.2.3.2 Strategies for materials discovery 94
5.3 2D magnetic materials 95
5.3.1 Magnetic ground state determination 95
5.3.2 Curie temperature calculation 96
5.3.3 Interlayer magnetic coupling 96
5.3.4 External field modulation 97
5.3.5 2D topological magnets 98
5.3.6 High throughput search magnetism 99
6 Conclusions and outlooks 99
References 101
1 Introduction
The first report on the mechanical cleavage of atomically thin single-crystalline carbon film, namely graphene, and its extraordinary transport properties by Geim, Novoselov and coworkers1in 2004 had ignited the resurgence of a class of fascinating functional nanomaterials,i.e., two-dimensional (2D)materials2-10.2D materials now have been recognized as a type of nanomaterials which have a sheet-like morphology featuring with a large lateral size from hundreds of nanometers to tens of micrometers or even larger but a thickness in single or few atomic layer2,3.Such a unique structural feature of 2D materials endows them with various unconventional physical, chemical,optical, electronic and magnetic properties as compared to their bulk, zero-dimensional (0D) and one-dimensional (1D)counterparts2.Owing to their unusual properties, 2D materials have been proven to be one of the most promising candidates for numerous potential applications like electronics11-14,optoelectronics15-20, catalysis21-26, energy storage27-34, solar cells35-38, biomedicine39-45, sensors46-49, environments50-54,etc.Driven by their unusual properties and promising applications, a large number of novel 2D materials beyond graphene, such as transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs including MoS2, MoSe2, MoTe2, WS2, WSe2, ReS2, TaS2,etc.)55,56,hexanol boron nitride (h-BN)57,58, graphyne59,60, noble metal dichalcogenides (NMDs: PdSe2, PtSe2, PtS2,etc.)61,62, elemental 2D materials (e.g., black phosphorus (BP), tellurium, silicene,germanene, borophene,etc.)63-65, layered metal oxides66,67,layered double hydroxides (LDHs)68,69, graphitic carbon nitride(g-C3N4)70,71, MXenes72, metals73, organics/polymers74,75,metal-organic frameworks (MOFs)76,77, covalent-organic frameworks (COFs)78,79, organic-inorganic hybrid perovskites80-82,and transition metal halides83,84, have been synthesized by various synthetic methods in the last decade.It is worth pointing out that the number of materials in the family of 2D materials is still continuously growing every year.
On the basis of the previous research works, the last five years have witnessed some major breakthroughs made in the field of 2D materials in all aspects.Firstly, a large number of novel 2D materials have been reported, including NMDs85-87, tellurium88,89,selenium90, and so on.Secondly, some novel methods have been developed for synthesis of 2D materials with higher quality,larger size, or better control, such as oxygen plasma- or Auenhanced mechanical exfoliation91,92, organic intercalationassisted liquid exfoliation of layered materials (e.g., BP, TMDs,InSe,etc.)93-95, salt-assisted chemical vapor deposition (CVD)growth of a library of 2D thin layers96,97, CVD growth of waferscale high-quality 2D thin films98,99, pulsed laser deposition(PLD) of BP thin films100, vapor phase synthesis of high-purity 1T′-phase 2D TMD crystals101, and liquid metal-assisted synthesis of metal oxide nanosheets102.Thirdly, some new promising applications of 2D materials have been demonstrated,such as integrated circuits based on wafer-scale 2D thin films103and infrared imaging sensor systems based on graphene104.More importantly, some newly emerging research directions have been extensively explored on 2D materials in recent years.For example, the phase engineering of nanomaterials (PEN)including 2D materials has been recognized as a promising way to fine tune their physicochemical properties and enhance their performances in addition to other conventional structural characteristics, such as size, thickness, defects, vacancies, and interlayer spacing105,106.As another typical example, by simply stacking two 2D graphene in a specific magic angle, namely magic angle 2D superlattices, the properties of graphene can be tuned from a conductor to a superconductor or insulator107,108.Inspired by the unexpected properties of magic angle graphene superlattices, magic angle 2D superlattices have become one of the most interesting materials to explore new properties in condensed matter physics.
Although many review articles related to 2D materials have been published previously, most of them were published in several years ago or even earlier, and most of them focused on a selected type 2D materials (e.g., graphene, graphyne, TMDs,MOFs, elemental ones, metals, MXenes,etc.)4,55,73, or specific application (e.g., electronics, optoelectronics, energy storage,electrocatalysis, sensors, biomedicine,etc.)27,31,39.Bearing this mind, offering a comprehensive review article to cover all of the 2D materials from all aspects with highlights on recent progress in this growing field is of great significance for its further development.To this end, this review aims to critically summarize the recent progress on 2D materials with particular focus on the last five years.Following a brief background introduction, the major synthetic methods for 2D materials,including the mechanical exfoliation, liquid exfoliation, vapour phase deposition, and wet-chemical synthesis as well as phase engineering of 2D materials are first discussed.The superconducting, optical, magnetic properties and chirality of 2D materials along with newly emerging magic angle 2D superlattices are then introduced.Thereafter, we summarize the great potential of 2D materials in various applications like electronics, optoelectronics, catalysis, energy storage, solar cells, biomedicine, sensors, environments,etc.Following that,recent progress on the theoretic calculations and simulations of 2D materials is also discussed.Finally, we conclude this Review by summarizing the current process and offering some personal insights on the existing challenges and future opportunities in this promising field.
2 Synthetic methods
2.1 Mechanical exfoliation
Mechanical exfoliation has been recognized as an efficient method to obtain fresh atomically flat surface of layered materials109,110.In 2004, a new tape-based exfoliation method developed in Geim’s group was used to prepare monolayer and few-layer graphene from graphite1,111.As one of the most popular “top-down” strategy to date, this mechanical exfoliation technique has been widely used to get a large number of 2D crystals, such as MoS2112,113, WS2114, SnS2115and BP115,116.The exfoliated 2D materials are ideal samples to study their intrinsic electronic117,118, optical119and mechanical properties.However,there are a few shortcomings for the conventional mechanical exfoliation.Firstly, the sample size of exfoliated 2D materials is usually in the range of few to tens of micrometers.Secondly, the yield is quite low.With the discovery of new layered materials,novel mechanical methods are desired to prepare high-quality,large-area 2D materials with relatively high efficiency.
Although the exfoliation processes are generally simple, some scientific questions were not well understood at the beginning.In the early stage, many researchers believed that a bulk crystal should be exfoliated many times to get thin layers on tape and then transferred onto SiO2/Sisubstrate, which has been demonstrated to be wrong later120.The interaction between tape and monolayer or few layers is stronger than the interaction between the solid substrate surfaces (e.g., SiO2) and 2D materials.Therefore, it is difficult to transfer a monolayer flake from tape to solid substrates.Besides, when the bulk crystal is exfoliated by tape for many times, it will be broken into small pieces.It is worth pointing out that the monolayer or few-layer flakes are exfoliated from multilayer crystal adhered on the tape instead of the ones adhered on the tape itself.More importantly,the interaction between layered crystals and solid substrates depends on the dipole interaction of different atoms.For example, the interaction between C atoms and O atoms is stronger than the one between C and other atoms121.As a result,the oxide substrates could work well for graphene but not so well for BP, FeSe or some other layered materials.
In the year 2015, Huangetal.proposed a new oxygen plasma enhanced exfoliation method, which is very effective for getting large-area monolayer graphene and Bi2Sr2CaCu2Ox120.They pointed out that the surface of oxide substrates has a thin layer of absorbed molecules, which serves as a buffer layer between layered crystal and oxide substrate surface.The oxygen plasma treatment could remove the absorbed molecules and enhance the interaction between 2D materials and substrate.As shown in Fig.1, there are four steps for this optimized exfoliation.(1) Oxygen plasma is used to remove the small molecules on SiO2/Si substrate surface.(2) A new cleaved graphite surface is put together with tape onto substrate.(3) The tape/graphite/substrate are baked at about 100 °C for 1-2 min.(4) The sample is taken out from hot plate and cooled down to room temperature, then the tape with graphite is removed.After these steps, large-area monolayer and few-layer graphene with a size ranging from few hundred micrometers to millimeters can be easily observed by optical microscope or even naked eyes120,122.Some graphene bubbles formed in the baking process are often observed on these samples120,123.The unique structure of the bubble provides an ideal model for exploring some interesting phenomena of graphene and other 2D materials under strain, such as standing wave oscillation and band structure changes123,124.
Fig.1 Illustration of the oxygen-plasma-enhanced exfoliation process for graphene.(a) Optical image of the SiO2/Si substrate and adhesive tape with graphite flakes.(b) Oxygen plasma cleaning of the substrate.(c) Contact between the graphite decorated tape and the substrate surface, followed by heating of the substrate (with tape) on a hot plate in air at ~100 °C for 2 min.(d) Removal of the substrate from the hot plate and peeling off the tape.(e) Optical image of the substrate after graphene exfoliation.(f) Optical micrograph of one large scale graphene flake on the substrate.(a-e) Reproduced with permission from Ref.120, Copyright 2015 American Chemical Society.(f) Reproduced with permission from Ref.122, Copyright 2018 Acta Physica Sinica.
However, the oxygen plasma enhanced exfoliation is not very effective on exfoliating MoS2, WS2and many other 2D materials, because these materials do not have strong interaction with oxide substrates.Magdaetal.deposited a thick layer of Au(100 nm) on mica and peeled off the metal layer, then the Au layer was put into contact with fresh cleaved MoS2and heated at 90 °C125.This method can get MoS2in the size of several hundreds of micrometers, but it still consumes the precious gold and induces many cracks on 2D materials.Desaietal.optimized this gold-layer enhanced exfoliation using thermal-release tape and transferring the sample onto other substrates92.KI/I2solvent was used to etch Au layer and obtain large-area monolayer MoS2, WS2,etc.
Commonly, based on the lattice structure of common layered materials, the out-most atoms in the unit layer are non-metallic elements such as P, As, S, Se, Te, Cl, Br, I,etc., while the inner elements are usually transition metals (Mo, W, Ti, Fe, Cr, Ni, Ta,etc.) or some main group metals (Ga, Sn, In).Thus, the roadmap for optimizing mechanical exfoliation can be considered as selecting suitable substrates which have strong interaction with these non-metallic elements.In 2020, Huangetal.reported a more universal mechanical exfoliation method based on their systematic experimental and calculation results (Fig.2)126.They pointed out that the adhesion energy at the interface of 2D materials and substrate is the key parameter for exfoliation.Their calculation results suggested that the 2D crystal-Au interaction could be sufficient to overcome the interlayer interaction to realize the successful exfoliation of monolayers from a wide range of layered materials.Based on the theoretical guidance,Huangetal.developed a new gold-assisted mechanical exfoliation, which was successful to get 40 different 2D materials, including MoS2, BP, PtTe2, FeSe, CrCl3,etc.The size of exfoliated monolayer ranges from millimeter to subcentimeter, which is visible to the naked eyes (Fig.2).The new gold-assisted mechanical exfoliation method has two main steps.Firstly, two metal layers of Au/Ti (or Au/Cr) in sub-nanometer range are deposited onto SiO2/Si or other substrates by electronbeam or thermal evaporator instruments.The second step is to put a bulk crystal with fresh surface onto the Au/Ti, and peel off the tape with crystal after gentle press.
Fig.2 (a) Schematic of the Gold-assisted mechanical exfoliation process of different monolayer materials.(b-d) Optical images of exfoliated MoS2 on SiO2/Si, sapphire, and plastic film.(e) 2-inch CVD-grown monolayer MoS2 film transferred onto a 4 inch SiO2/Si substrate.(f-g) Optical images of large exfoliated 2D crystals: BP, RuCl3, Fe3GeTe2, FeSe, CrSiTe3, PtSe2, PtTe2, and PdTe2.Those exfoliated monolayers highlighted in the red box are, so far, not accessible using other mechanical exfoliate method.(h) Optical image and Raman spectra of a MoS2/WSe2 heterostructure.(i) Raman and photoluminescence (PL) spectra of suspended monolayer WSe2.(j) Optical image of suspended WSe2 with different thicknesses (1L to 3L) and a PL intensity map of the suspended monolayer.Reproduced from Ref.126.
In summary, mechanical exfoliation technique has greatly promoted the rapid development of the field of 2D materials in the past 17 years.While this technology has received extensive attention and undergone in-depth research in the past five years,it is believed to continue to play important roles in the research of 2D materials in the future.There are two aspects which may be crucial for the development of mechanical exfoliation.The first one depends on the progress of developing high-quality bulk crystals.Growing wafer-scale and high-quality layered materials is the prerequisite for exfoliating a single layer of wafer size.Secondly, promoting the development of this technology towards cheap and controllable industrial applications is also an important question.With breakthroughs in these two aspects,mechanical exfoliation will be widely used not only in basic scientific research but also in industrial applications, especially for 2D semiconducting materials.
2.2 Liquid exfoliation
Liquid exfoliation methods, mainly including direct exfoliation in solvents and intercalation-based exfoliation, offer versatile and scalable routes for preparation of solutiondispersed 2D materials127-130.Previous studies have demonstrated the successful production of monolayer or few-layer 2D nanosheets (e.g., MoS2, MoSe2, MoTe2, WS2, TaSe2, NbSe2,NiTe2, Bi2Te3, BN, graphene, and BP) by direct sonication of layered crystals in a number of solvents, such asN-methylpyrrolidone (NMP),N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF),N-vinylpyrrolidinone (NVP), cyclohexyl-pyrrolidinone (CHP), isopropanol (IPA), dimethylsulphoxide (DMSO), and acetone128-130.Recently, other kinds of 2D materials have also been exfoliated by this method, such as tin sulfide (SnS)131, lead iodide (PbI2)132,topological insulators Bi2TeI133, calcium metal-organic framework (Ca-MOF)134, hematene135, metal hydride (e.g.,TiH1.924, ZrH2, CaH2, and HfH1.983)136, and various organic nanosheets137,138.Meanwhile, the available solvents are still limited by the matching degree of surface tension between the layered materials and the solvent.For example, surface tension of solvent need to close to 40 mJ·m-2for the exfoliation of graphite129.Although adding mixed-solvent139, surfactant140-142,or polymer143,144has been proven to be an effective solution for this limitation, direct liquid exfoliation is also plagued by the low yield of the monolayers and low efficiency.
Intercalation-based exfoliation of layered materials has been recognized as a mature and controllable method for production of 2D materials with a remarkable advantage of high-yield monolayers127,145-147.It involves chemical or electrochemical intercalation of foreign species into the interlayer gap of layered bulk materials and a subsequent mild sonication process in solvent (e.g., water).Studies about intercalation and exfoliation of layered materials date back to several decades ago127,148-150.Very recently, the development of this method has been greatly boosted since 2011 by the chemical151and electrochemical152,153lithium-ion intercalation-based exfoliation of 2D TMDs.Since then, lithium-ion intercalation-based exfoliation method has been wildly reported for preparation of 2D monolayers25,154-161.However, the rising prices of lithium, and the sensitivity of lithium intercalation compounds to ambient conditions along with its flammability make finding alternative intercalation species necessary.Up to now, a host of intercalation species beyond lithium ion have been proven to be effective for the intercalation-based exfoliation, including cations (e.g., Na+and K+162,163,, quaternary ammonium cation165-168), anions, and molecules (e.g., H2O175,Lewis bases176, Brønsted acids177, dimethyl sulfoxide178, 4,4′-dipyridyl disulfide179,n-propylamine180).For example, Dinget al.used 4,4′-dipyridyl disulfide as intercalation species to exfoliate MOFs and obtained ultrathin (~1 nm) 2D MOF nanosheets in ~57% overall yield179.In addition, Liuetal.demonstrated the production of BP nanobelts by electrochemicalintercalation-based exfoliation method173.As a notable example, Wangetal.have demonstrated that monolayer BP molecular superlattices can be produced from bulk BP by electrochemical intercalation-based exfoliation method using cetyl-trimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) as intercalant93.Very recently, CTAB intercalation-based exfoliation method have also used for production of mica (eMica) nanosheets181,and the exfoliation of the sodalite precursor RUB-15 into the crystalline 0.8-nm-thick nanosheets182.Besides, Linetal.have also reported the exfoliation of a large number of 2D nanosheets,including MoS2, WSe2, Bi2Se3, NbSe2, In2Se3, Sb2Te3and BP, by electrochemical intercalation-based exfoliation strategy with tetraheptylammonium bromide (THAB) as intercalant94.Importantly, this method prevented the undesired phase transition from 2H to 1T during the intercalation-based exfoliation process, achieving the preparation of high-purity 2H phase MoS2nanosheets.
Alternatively, multiple intercalation species as tandem intercalants176or as co-intercalants183have also been recently reported for the production of 2D materials.For example, very recently, Lietal.demonstrated an electrochemical cointercalation-based exfoliation process183.Using quaternary ammonium cations solvated with propylene carbonate molecule as co-intercalants, they successfully prepared a series of TMD nanosheets, including NbSe2, NbTe2, TaSe2, TaS2, TiSe2, TiS2,and MoTe2.As a general and scalable synthesis method, it realized a high-yield (> 75%) preparation of TMD monolayers with large lateral dimensions (up to 300 μm) and highcrystallinity, which is better than the monolayers grown by molecular beam epitaxy184or chemical vapor deposition185methods.
As mentioned above, a number of intercalation-based exfoliation methods have been established based on different intercalation species.However, there is still room for improvement for effective and high-yield production of monolayers.Therefore, reasonable selection of intercalants and rational design of the exfoliation process remain crucial for the synthesis of atomically thin nanosheets to achieve specific application purposes.
2.3 Gas vapor growth
In comparison with the top-down approaches, the bottom-up approaches based on the gas-phase vapor growth has been regarded as an efficient and controllable synthesis strategy for growth of high-quality large-area 2D materials, which are promising for meeting the requirements of industrial applications, especially in electronics and optoelectronics186-188.Gas-vapor growth generally occurs in the system composed of a tube furnace.Under high temperature, gaseous precursors containing the elements of 2D materials are transported into the reaction zone, followed by nucleation, growth and final formation of 2D flakes or continuous films on the target substrates.Common gas vapor growth includes chemical vapor deposition (CVD), thermally assisted conversion (TAC) and physical laser deposition (PLD)
2.3.1 Chemical vapor deposition
Since the first successful demonstration of CVD growth of monolayer graphene on Cu foils189, CVD approaches have gradually become the dominant method for preparing various kinds of 2D materials including graphene, h-BN190, metal disulfides (MX2, M=Mo, W, Ta, Cr, Nb, Re,etc., X = Se, S,Te)191-195, ternary compounds as well as 2D material-based heterostructures196,197.The properties and applications of 2D materials are highly dependent on the thickness, domain size,geometric morphology and crystalline orientation, defect densities and dopant types, all of which can be controlled by optimizing the parameters in CVD growth.Accordingly, the strategies can be categorized to precursor design, space-confined growth, additive-assisted growth and substrate engineering.
As for graphene growth, methane (CH4) is commonly used gaseous precursors, enabling the precise control on the elementary steps of CVD growth for graphene by accurately tuning the gas flow rate187,189.In contrast, the growth of MX2usually requires two kinds of solid precursors, metal-containing precursors (e.g., metal foil, metal oxides, metal chloride) and non-metal precursors (e.g., S, Se, Te), which are located at different heated regions191.In this case, the metal and non-metal precursors are separately volatilized by heating and transported to the substrate in the high-temperature reaction zone assisted by carrier gas.Subsequently the chemical reaction occurs to form MX2on the substrates.Since the heating temperature of the solid precursors is the key parameter which would determine the vapor pressure of the solid precursors.Hence, it is still challenging to accurately control the amount of volatilized solid precursors by solely setting the temperature, making it rather difficult to effectively adjust the growth process of MX2.To this end, metal-organic precursors hold great promise for controlled synthesis of the 2D materials, which can ensure introducing a precise and stable amount of precursors into the CVD system198.In this respect, Kangetal.grew continuous 4-inch wafer-scale MoS2and WS2films by employing Mo(CO)6, W(CO)6as metal precursor and (C2H5)2S as non-metal precursors, respectively.
Since precursors are the reactants for growing 2D materials,tuning the elemental compositions of the precursors can enable the direct growth of doped, alloyed as well as ternary 2D materials199-203.For example, Wuetal.employed Bi2O3and Bi2Se3as two isolated precursors to successfully prepared ultrathin Bi2O2Se flakes (Fig.3a), which exhibited excellent air stability and high-mobility semiconducting behaviors201,202.In another recent work, Hongetal.grew 2D layered MoSi2N4by CVD on a Cu/Mo bilayer substrate, in which NH3gas and pure Si plate were employed as the N and Si sources, respectively203.The as-grown MoSi2N4demonstrated semiconducting behaviors, high mechanical strength and excellent ambient stability.This synthetic strategy can be also extended to other ternary MXene such as WSi2N4.
In a regular CVD system, the thickness and domain size of asreceived 2D materials can only be controlled by adjusting the related growth parameters including the growth temperature, the gas flow of carrier gas and precursors, and the chamber pressure.However, the complex intermediate reactions inevitably result in the non-uniformity of thickness, adsorption of impurities and slow growth rate.To improve the uniformity and growth rate,space-confined growth has emerged as a promising growth strategy.With this novel configuration, growth of large graphene single crystals can be achieved with a high growth rate by facilitating the decomposition of CH4precursors and decreasing the nucleation density (Fig.3b)204,205.In another work, Linetal.relies on a new configuration of catalyst to achieve the scalable production of super-clean graphene (> 99% clean regions)viathe stacking of Cu foil and Cu foam206, where the Cu foam can provide sufficient supply of Cu vapor during the entire growth to continuously catalyze the decomposition of carbon species(Fig.3c).For other 2D materials, Wangetal.achieved the preparation of 2D all-inorganic halide perovskites (2D AIHP)with adjustable morphologiesviaa vertical mass transport with the space-confined channel207.Confined spaces can improve the vapor pressure of sulfur, so that PtS2 thin films can be readily achieved in a scalable and controlled manner in a modified quartz tube208.
Despite recent progress on the growth of 2D materials, many 2D crystals remains difficult to be directly grown on substratesviadirect CVD growth owing to high melting points of their metal/metal oxide precursors as well as thermodynamics instabilities of metastable phases.To this end, molten salts as additives are introduced into CVD process for achieving the growth of high-quality 2D materials97,210,211.With the assistance of NaCl and KI, Zhouetal.synthesized the growth of 47 compounds including 32 binary compounds, 13 alloys and two heterostructures97.Investigation of the related growth mechanism confirmed that the salt can decrease the melting point of the reactants and facilitates the formation of oxychloride compound as intermediate products that are energetically favorable to be sulfurized or selenized.Meanwhile, the alkali metal ions can also reduce the growth barrier, synergistically increasing the overall reaction rate and promoting large-scale production of high-quality 2D materials with fine uniformity.With the aid of trace amount of Na catalysts released from the glass substrates, Yangetal.successfully prepared a 6-inch uniform MoS2monolayer film with the domain size larger than 400 µm on solid soda-lime glass with an improved growth speed,relying on a face-to-face metal-precursor supply method212.However, the residue of molten salts and possible dopants might influence the stability and pristine property of as-grown 2D materials, which still needs further study.
High-quality 2D materials single crystal with no grain boundaries are highly desired for the applications in electronics and optoelectronics, in which a high carrier mobility of 2D materials is highly needed.Therefore, main focus becomes the synthesis of wafer-scale single crystals of 2D materials.CVD technique shows a unique merit in producing wafer-scale 2D thin films.By deliberately designing the single-crystal substrates which have fine lattice matching with the target 2D materials,the epitaxy growth of well-aligned 2D crystal domains can be realized.After the well-aligned nucleation, the subsequent seamless stitching would enable the growth of wafer-scale 2D single crystal.Hence, the epitaxy growth of graphene with identical orientations on a Cu (111) substrate toward singlecrystal graphene film has received great attention209,213.In this regard, Dengetal.synthesized a 4-inch wrinkle-free singlecrystal graphene wafer on a twin-boundary-free single-crystal Cu (111) thin film prepared on sapphire substrate through strain engineering (Fig.3d)209.Furthermore, the growth of 100-square-centimetre single-crystal BN monolayer on Cu (110) and wafer-scale growth of WS2 film onc-plane (0001) sapphire have been successfully demonstrated214,215.
Fig.3 (a) Layered crystal structure and CVD growth of Bi2O2Se with Bi2Se3 and Bi2O3 as precursors 201,202.(b) Fast growth of millimeter-sized graphene within confined space; reproduced with permission from Ref.204, Copyright 2016 John Wiley and Sons.(c) Experimental design of Cu foil-foam stacked structure for the growth of super-clean graphene 206.(d) Epitaxial growth of single-crystal graphene wafer with free wrinkles on as-deposited Cu (111) thin film; reproduced with permission from Ref.209, Copyright 2017 American Chemical Society.
2.3.2 Thermally assisted conversion in CVD system
One effective strategy to prepare wafer-scale continuous films involves the sulfurization (or selenization) of pre-deposited metal films or metal oxide on the substrates in a conventional CVD system.The pre-deposition process can be realizedviathermal deposition, atomic layer deposition, electron beam deposition, magnetron sputtering and spin coating.For instance,the preparation of wafer-scale and homogenous 2D PdSe2film with thickness of 1.2-20 nm can be readily achieved by thermally assisted conversion of the as-deposited Pd layer with gaseous Se216.Likewise, other 2D noble disulfides (such as PtSe2) as well as MoS2and MoSe2with adjustable layers are achieved relying on the TAC approaches217-219.It is worth mentioning that this strategy cannot only offer good control on film uniformity and thickness, but also can contribute to an improved air stability of as-received 2D crystals.Gao discovered that the direct selenization of magnetron-sputtered Nb film for 2D NbSe2films can effectively avoid the reaction of the NbSe2with H2O and O2, which can exhibit a superior and stable superconductivity220.
2.3.3 Pulsed laser deposition
PLD is an effective and controllable approach to deposit 2D materials on target substrates, which has demonstrated the following advantages: (i) the active species from the precursors can reduce the surface activation for the deposition; (ii) the thickness of the deposited film can be manipulated by the repetition rate, laser energy and deposition pressure; (iii) further sulfurization or selenization is not required; (iv) the use of expensive and potentially dangerous precursors can be avoided221.Wuetal.recently reported the controlled PLD strategy for the growth of high-quality, few-layer BP on the centimeter-sized scale100.The unique plasma-activated region induced by laser ablation is energetically favorable for the formation of BP cluster and the following coalescence of monolayer BP flakes into continuous films.Moreover, manipulating the number of laser pulses during the deposition can enable the precise control over the thickness of as-received film.Moreover, few-layer WSe2thin film on a centimeter-scale can be achievedviaa PLD method, in which the thickness can be readily controlled by varying the number of introduced laser pulses222.In addition, the PLD technology also enables the preparation of uniform tellurium films with a thickness of sub-7 nm over a centimeter square,which exhibited hexagonal,P3121 structure223.
2.4 Chemical synthesis
Besides vapor phase growth and exfoliation methods,chemical synthesis methods are also explored extensively owing to their simple, low-cost and high-output characteristics.This section discusses recent advances developed in the wet-chemical synthesis of representative 2D materials.
2.4.1 2D metal nanomaterials
Despite the intrinsic non-layered characteristics and strong isotropic metallic bond, various strategies have been developed for synthesizing metallic nanosheets73.The template method is one of the strategies by means of confined-space effect and metal-support interaction.The template used could be divided as hard templates and soft templates.2D materials like graphene and TMDs are commonly used hard templates.For example,Huangetal.adopted single-layer MoS2nanosheets as templates to produce small Pd, Pt and Ag nanosheets through epitaxial growth161.Jiangetal.synthesized single-crystalline Pd square nanosheets enclosed by (100) facets on reduced graphene oxide224.Confined growth of metal in the interlayer of layered materials is another effective hard template method.Wangetal.controlled the crystal growth of ultrathin Au nanosheets by introducinginto the interlayer space of LDHs through anion exchange and followed by chemical reduction (Fig.4a)225.The acquired nanosheets are [001] oriented and have the thickness of only a few atomic layers.Furthermore, inorganic salts have been found as a useful temple to synthesize 2D materials.Wuetal.reported a general synthesis method for ultrathin amorphous noble metal nanosheets through adjusting the heating temperature between metal acetylacetone precursors and inorganic salts226.Besides hard templates, some soft materials with lamellar structures are also used.For instance,Niuetal.reported a polymer-free lamellar hydrogel as soft template to synthesize large area single-crystalline Au membranes227.The acquired membranes are flexible, ultrathin and with atomically flat surface because of the slow diffusion of precursor ions in the confined 2D space.
Another popular method for preparing metallic nanosheets is using molecule adsorbents229,230.For example, ultrathin PdMo nanosheets were synthesized by Luoetal.through one-pot wetchemical approach with mixing of Pd(acac)2and Mo(CO)6,which is curved and has the sub-nanometer thickness231.Yangetal.synthesized 2D PdCu alloy nanosheets by co-reduction of Pd(acac)2and Cu(acac)2with Mo(CO)6232.Besides CO and analogues, halide ions also show potential as shape guider by adsorption in specific crystal face and changing the reduction potential of metal.For instance, triangular Au nanoplates are obtained by selective binding and oxidative etching role of iodide ions233.
In addition to the two common methods mentioned above, a variety of effective means are developed in regulating the morphology of metallic nanosheets, such as photocatalytic synthesis, self-assembly method, mechanochemical method, and oxidation etching234-239.Besides noble metal 2D materials,nanosheets of non-noble metals are also acquired240,241.2D Cu nanosheets were prepared by Lucetal.by chemical reduction of Cu precursor with the presence of surfactants240.Luoetal.synthesized sub-2-nm Al nanosheets by wet-chemical synthesis using AlCl3and LiAlH4(Fig.4b)228.The ultrathin Al nanosheets were steadied by oxygen adsorption on (111) facets.
Fig.4 (a) Schematic illustration of the synthetic route of 2D Au nanosheets using LDH as template 225.(b) The synthesis process of ultrathin Al nanosheets 228.
2.4.2 Layered double hydroxides
Among various 2D materials, LDHs have attracted much attention in the field of energy storage and conversion owing to their large surface area, low cost, adjustable structure and composition242-244.As a typical class of layered anionic compounds, LDHs compose of divalent cations (M2+, such as Mg2+, Ni2+, Co2+, Zn2+or Fe2+), trivalent cations (M3+, such as Al3+, Fe3+, Mn3+, Ga3+or Cr3+) and hydroxyl groups in laminate,and charge-compensating anionsin interlayer, which can be represented by the general formula(Fig.5).LDHs can not only be used as catalysts, but also act as carriers to support other active materials to achieve synergistically enhanced performance.In this section, we summary the recent progress of LDHs and LDH-based materials in the field of energy storage and conversion from the perspective of synthesis.
Fig.5 Illustration, synthesis and applications of LDHs.
In recent years, a variety of methods have been explored to prepare LDHs and LDH-based materials.Among them,coprecipitation and electrochemical deposition can directly synthesize LDHs with controlled structure245.Exfoliation(-reassembling) strategies provide effective ways for preparing LDHs with few layers and single layer, as well as other LDH-based multi-functional nanomaterials246,247.Furthermore, LDHs can be used as precursors to synthesize various 2D transition metal compounds through topological transformation248.In order to achieve excellent electrochemical performance, it is necessary to construct active sites with high intrinsic activity or expose more active sites, which puts forward higher demands for the design and synthesis of novel LDHs249.With the development of synthetic techniques, more effective methods have been developed in addition to conventional methods,providing wider options in promoting the synthesis and application of LDHs.
The coprecipitation method is one of the most used methods for preparing LDH-based materials, however, the thickness and microstructure of the obtained material cannot be precisely controlled, which prevents the full exposure of the active sites.Thus, it is necessary to update the synthetic conditions of coprecipitation to obtain more exposed active sites.Lietal.synthesized ultrathin Ga doped CuZn-LDH nanosheetsviathe aqueous miscible organic solvent treatment method and applied the products as catalyst precursors for the further synthesis of other active materials250.This ultra-thin structure is conducive to the full exposure of active sites.Intercalating large-size molecules between the LDH layers can increase the layer spacing, promote the mass transfer, and even bring other useful functions.Up to date, various guest species, including inorganic and organic molecules, have been successfully intercalated into LDHs, which usually requires a separate interlayer anion exchange process.Calhauetal.incorporated a kind of photoactivatable CO-releasing molecule into the ZnAl-LDH host by a one-pot coprecipitation method, which simplified the synthesis process251.Doping is another effective way to improve the intrinsic activity of LDH-based materials.A variety of metal elements have been introduced into the LDH laminateviahydrothermal coprecipitation method, such as highly charged metal ions (V4+and Mn4+) and precious metal ions.The doped sites can modify the electronic structure of LDHs, thereby enhance the electrochemical properties252,253.Other modified coprecipitation methods have also been reported, such as separate nucleation and aging method254.
In the past few years, electrodeposition method was developed to fabricate LDHs facilely on conductive matrices, using nitrate or sulfate solutions which contained appropriate metal ions at negative potential.Lietal.has successfully fabricated various ultrathin LDH nanosheet arrays (200-300 nm in lateral length and 8-12 nm in thickness) on various macro/micro conductive substratesviaelectrodeposition method255.To further expand the types of elements suitable for the synthesis of LDHs, the lanthanides (La3+) was introduced and NiLa-LDH with adjustable Ni/La ratio were prepared256.Owing to the advantages of simplicity, electrodeposition can combine with other methods to controllably prepare composite materials with complex structures257,258.
Exfoliation(-reassembling) strategy allows us to obtain LDHs with few layers or even single layer with maximal exposure of active sites.It also allows to further assemble LDHs with other guest species to produce LDH-based multi-functional nanomaterials.During this process, exfoliating bulk LDHs into uniform monolithic layers is a critical step.However,conventional exfoliation methods that require toxic organic solvents are time-consuming and less controllable, and the resulting monolithic layer is easily reunited during applications.To overcome this, Wangetal.developed a “dry exfoliation”method that uses Ar plasma to etch bulk CoFe LDHs into ultrathin LDH nanosheets with multiple vacancies259.Zhaoet al.successfully explored an electrostatic layer-by-layer technique to assemble the exfoliated LDH nanosheets with commercial conductive polymer into a superlattice heterostructure without accumulation260.In this heterostructure,LDH can provide a restricted microenvironment for the accommodation of the conductive polymer, allowing the high charge carrier mobility.
In addition, LDHs can be used as precursors for synthesizing various 2D transition metal compoundsviatopological transformation261.Until now, various transition metal oxides,sulfides, nitrides, phosphides and selenides have been prepared by Shao’s and Wei’s groups and have demonstrated excellent electrocatalytic activity262-266.In addition, they recently reported a new strategy for constructing Co single atom-based integrated electrodes through topological transformation of organic molecules intercalated LDHs, which further expanded the choices of materials that can be prepared using LDH267.Apart from topological transformation from LDHs to transition metal compounds, the resulted compounds can be reversibly transformed back to LDHs owing to the unique memory effect268.Taking advantage of the memory effect of LDH, Yuanetal.synthesized NiFe-LDH with multiple vacancy defects that significantly improved the electrical conductivity and electrochemical surface area, which exhibits enhanced performance toward water splitting269.
2.4.3 2D metal-organic framework
During the last decade, a series of methods have been developed to prepare 2D metal-organic framework (MOF) nanosheets, which can be categorized into bottom-up synthesis (e.g., modulated synthesis270,271, sonication-assisted synthesis272,273, surfactantassisted synthesis274-276, three-layer synthesis277,278, and interfacial synthesis279,280) and top-down exfoliation (e.g.,sonication exfoliation281-283, chemical exfoliation179, and Liintercalation exfoliation284).These methods have been summarized in some review articles77,285-287.Here, we only introduce some recent progress in the preparation of 2D MOF nanosheets.
Recent reports demonstrated that 2D metal oxide/hydroxide nanosheets could be used as hard sacrificial templates for the bottom-up synthesis of 2D MOF nanosheets288,289.In this method, metal ions are leached in a controllable manner under hydrothermal/solvothermal conditions.Therefore, metal ions are enriched near the surface of metal oxide nanosheets, which induces the confined growth of 2D MOF nanosheets.In a typical work, aqueous dispersions of monometallic (Ni, Fe, Co and Cu)and bimetallic (FeCo, NiFe, CoCu) oxide nanosheets, prepared by the reduction of corresponding metal nitrates with sodium borohydride, were added into an DMF-water-ethanol solution of H4DOBDC (DOBDC = 2,5-dihydroxyterephthalate) ligand,respectively, and corresponding 2D MOF-74 (M2DOBDC, M =Fe, Co, Ni, Cu or their combination) nanosheets were formed after keeping the mixtures at 100 °C for 24 h (Fig.6a)289.
In another report, carbon dioxide has been used as a capping agent to control the growth of MOF nanosheets.For example,CuBDC (BDC = terephthalate) nanosheets were preparedviasolvothermal treatment of the methanol solution of Cu(NO3)2,H2BDC and triethylamine under CO2atmosphere.As nano-sized CuBDC building blocks initially formed, CO2molecules were preferably adsorbed on (20) plane, thereby selectively eliminating (20) crystal facets stacking along [20] axis (Fig.6b).As a result, the growth of (110) plane was much faster than that of (20) plane, thus enabling the formation of 2D CuBDC nanosheets.Meanwhile, the dissolution of CO2caused liquid volume expansion and viscosity reduction, which accelerated the growth of MOF crystal; hence, a higher pressure of CO2led to a smaller size and a higher yield of the resultant CuBDC nanosheets290.
For the top-down synthesis of MOF nanosheets, alkali etching route has been proposed for exfoliating 3D MOFs into 2D nanosheets.Generally, as for certain metal cations (e.g., Mn, Co,Ni, Cu, and Zn), the coordinative bonding with nitrogen-based ligands is more stable than that with carboxylate ligands in alkali media.Based on this, when multivariant MOFs containing both nitrogen-based linkers and carboxylate linkers are treated with alkali, the carboxylate linkers can be selectively removed (Fig.6c).In a typical study, Zn-TRZ-TDA (TDA = 2,5-thiophenedicarboxylic acid, TRZ = 1,2,4-triazole), a 3D bulk MOF consisting of Zn-TRZ layers connected with each other by TDA,was etched with sodium hydroxide in methanol-water system,and Zn-TRZ nanosheets were obtained as expected291.Inaddition, stepwise expansion has been observed in some layered MOFs, which enables the exfoliation of MOFs in a layernumber-controlled fashion.For example, kgmSMe, a layered MOF fabricated with 5-methylthioisophthalate and Cu2+in a kagomé lattice, underwent a stepwise expansion that formed bilayer or monolayer expanded structures when being immersed in certain solvents, and a gentle agitation led to the exfoliation into bilayer or monolayer nanosheets accordingly.The layer number of nanosheets depends on the type of solvents (Fig.6d).For example, methyltetrahydrofuran and cyclopentanone tend to the formation of bilayer nanosheets, while tetrahydrofuran,dioxane and DMF favor monolayer nanosheets292.
Fig.6 (a) 2D oxide sacrifice preparation of MOF-74 nanosheets;reproduced with permission from Ref.289, Copyright 2019 John Wiley and Sons.(b) Structural units of CuBDC and CO2 along [20] axis(left) and (20) plane (right) 290.(c) Alkali etching exfoliation for the preparation of MOF nanosheets; reproduced with permission from Ref.291, Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society.(d) Stepwise expansion and exfoliation of layered kgmSMe MOF; reproduced with permission from Ref.292, Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society.
2.4.4 Xenes
Elemental 2D materials, often referred to as Xenes, are elemental materials with layered or sheet-like structures (Fig.7a)293.The name Xenes derives from graphene, the first and most studied 2D material.Beyond graphene and its derivatives, over a dozen emerging Xenes, including antimonene, arsenene,bismuthine, borophene, BP, gallenene, germanene, silicene, and tellurene, have been experimentally realized, while others like aluminene and indiene are still in theoretically prediction, as summarized in Table 190,199,294-308.Xenes have attracted a considerable amount of recent attention due to distinct properties and performances across various research fields.Xenes possess rich atomic structures, such as puckered structure for BP302and black arsenene309and buckled structure for β-antimonene310and grey arsenene311, which have also lead to structural anisotropicity.In addition, Xenes possess various electronic structures from metallic to semiconductors.For example,different from other 2D semiconductors like TMDs, Xenes such as BP and arsenene often exhibits direct bandgap and high mobility311-313.Their distinct properties render extensive applications in diverse research fields, including (opto-)electronics and many energy storage and conversion applications64,314-316.
Table 1 Overview of elemental 2D materials explored by experimental and theoretical methods.
Despite significant synthetic challenges, many Xenes were successfully prepared and characterized with controlled crystal structure and morphologies in recent years.The synthetic strategies can be generally categorized into top-down and bottom-up methods.Top-down methods mainly include various exfoliation techniques such as mechanical exfoliation, liquidphase exfoliation and electrochemical exfoliation, which break the van der Waals (vdW) interaction between the atomic layers in source crystals.Top-down approaches are straightforward and relatively cost-effective, however also limited by the dependence on the source materials, low yield and inhomogeneity.Xenes including BP, antimonene, arsenene and bismuthene have been obtainedviafacile liquid exfoliation method.On the other hand,electrochemical exfoliation strategy is highly efficient,controllable and productive, showing excellent results in BP,antimonene and bismuthene.Unfortunately, electrochemical intercalation is not suitable for most Xenes due to either the difference in intercalation kinetics or the lack of layered source crystals.
Bottom-up methods refer to the direct synthesis of monolayer to few-layer Xenes through chemical reactions in either liquid(wet chemistry) or gas (CVD and molecular beam epitaxy).“Bottom-up” methods generally show good yield and does not require source crystals.However, the most used methods like MBE and CVD rely on the chemical interaction/bonding between precursors and substrates and largely limited by their lattice parameters.Currently, MBE is conveniently used in the synthesis of Xenes in IIIA and IVA groups, such as borophene294,silicene320and germanene321with fine-tuned combination of chemical composition, substrate lattice and deposition conditions.Meanwhile, wet-chemical methods generally produce Xenes with limited control in chemical composition and morphologies.And they are incapable of producing self-support monolayer Xenes.And the surfactants resulted from the synthesis process are undesirable in the consequence applications.Currently, only a few Xene members have been obtained in wet-chemical processes, such as silicene317,tellurene89, antimonene322and bismuthene323.The 2D Si nanomaterials show novel properties and have plenty of applications towards optical, electronic devices and energy storage and conversion.As shown in Fig.7b, Langetal.prepared ultrathin Si nanosheets by chemical leaching of Li13Si4using ethyl alcohol317.Group VI tellurium displays distinct inplane anisotropic properties due to the unique chiral-chain vdW crystal structure.Te nanostructures tend to adopt the 1D form because of the chain structure.Inspiringly, Wangetal.synthesized 2D Te nanosheets using sodium tellurite as precursor and hydrazine hydrate as reducing agent with the presence of polyvinylpyrrolidone89.Layered materials black arsenic, which is the analogue of black phosphorus with the orthorhombic structure, shows the tunable bandgap and great potential in optical properties.Besides mechanical and liquid exfoliation method, Antonatosetal.prepared the black arsenic through crystallization of amorphous arsenic using mercury vapors324.Up until now, it is still very challenging to realize general,effective, high-yield and low-cost synthesis of Xenes.
Fig.7 (a) Schematic model of one example of Xenes (borophene).(b) The synthesis process of Si nanosheets through chemical etching.Reproduced with permission from Ref.317, Copyright 2017 John Wiley and Sons.(c) HAADF-STEM image and (d) AFM image of Bi2O2Se nanosheets.Reproduced with permission from Ref.318, Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society.(e) TEM images of PtSe2 nanosheets 319.
2.4.5 2D covalent organic framework
Besides MOFs, 2D covalent organic frameworks (COFs) are another important class of organic crystalline porous materials due to their charming advantages including the pre-designable structure, manageable function, small mass density and good chemical stability (Fig.8a).Since the first COF appeared in year 2005325, a large number of 2D/3D COFs materials have been designed and synthesized for broad applications in gas storage and separation326,327, drug delivery328,329, catalysis330-332,photoelectronic devices333,334, supercapacitors335,336, and batteries337-339.Normally, 2D COFs can be prepared through the polycondensation reactions or coupling reactions, and their structures are confirmed through the structural simulation together with the powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) pattern matching.More recently, their single crystal structures can be determined by electron diffraction or single-crystal XRD337,339.In principle, AA and AB stacking modes can be adopted.In order to further evaluate the structures and compositions of 2D COFs,other general methods for characterization could also be applied,such as solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (ssNMR),Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FT-IR), and so on.Herein, the recent progress, design strategies, and future perspectives of 2D COFs regarding their luminescence,stimulus-responsive ability, and electrochemical properties will be briefly discussed.
Fig.8 Schematic models of examples of (a) 2D covalent organic frameworks (COFs), (b) 2D perovskite and (c) 2D Mxenes (Ti3C2Tx).
Until now, numerous luminescent 2D COFs have been designed and prepared through introducing various luminophores into the skeleton338, and their luminescent mechanisms involve excimers, aggregation-induced emission(AIE), excited state intramolecular proton transfer (ESIPT),intramolecular charge transfer (ICT), two-photon induced (TPI)emission, and phosphorescence.In one pioneering work, Wanet al.developed the first luminescent boronated-linked 2D COF through the condensation reaction, which exhibits strong blue fluorescence peaks at 474 nm originating from the excimer emission of pyrene340.Later on, these excimers emission properties in 2D COFs can be tuned by changing building blocks, linkage types, or stacking distances.Besides, the introduction of AIE luminogens (such as tetraphenylethene) into skeleton can also construct the luminescent 2D COFs because theπ-πstacking in COFs can restrict the rotation of the four phenyl groups and obtain high luminescence quantum yield341.Moreover, choosing different linkages can effectively change their stacked rhombic topology together withπ-πstacking, thus leading to different fluorescent behaviors.By introducing resorcinol units with ESIPT property into COFs system342, a kind of luminescent COFs with dual emission properties are developed, in which the dual emission of COFs originates from the enol state and ESIPT emission, respectively.When these COFs are dissolved in different polar solvents, their emission colors can be tunned because the equilibrium of keto and enol forms is broken.However, these polar solvents also could influence their chemical stabilities.Furthermore, combining the largeπ-conjugation area with strong charge transfer character,COFs with TPI emission can be realized343.Note that the larger conjugation extension and strong charge transfer between electron acceptors and donors are vital for TPI emission.Recently, several phosphorescent 2D COFs have been reported by introducing organic phosphors as building units344, but so far,none of them shows persistent RTP behavior under ambient conditions.
The physicochemical properties of COFs could be dynamically varied under external stimuli, which are defined as stimulus-responsive 2D COFs345.Generally, stimulusresponsive 2D COFs consist of physical and chemicalresponsive COFs, depending on the different stimuli manners.Since the first nitro explosives responsive 2D COF was reported in 2013346, more stimulus-responsive 2D COFs materials have been widely developed347-349.Such stimulus can be metal ions,pH values, gas molecules, solvents, temperature, light,electricity, and so on.In general, stimulus-responsive 2D COFs are prepared by rational incorporation of functional groups into the conjugated skeletons or the active sites that can capture different guest molecules.The responsive performances of functional monomers and linkers endow these resulting 2D COFs with dynamically controlled optical or electrical properties.Moreover, the ordered and porous structures of COFs make real-time responses possible.Nevertheless, the responsive behaviors of most smart 2D COFs always occur in the presence of structure changes or solvents181,350, leading to possible structure collapses and shortened lifetime of COFs.Therefore,suitable stimulus types with no solvent contact or structure variations are necessary.In order to achieve smart 2D COFs with good durability, two key countermeasures should be adopted in the future: one is to develop more and new electrochromic COFs,in which the red-shifted absorption is triggered by new formation of the stable cation radical without structure changes, and the other is to introduce photoinduced radical molecules into COFs,where radical can bring improved optical properties upon light excitation.
Besides, 2D COFs materials attract increasing attention in extensive electrochemical applications (e.g., fuel cells351,supercapacitors352, batteries353and so on) due to the following reasons: (1) the well-defined active sites and controllable porosities in COFs favor electrocatalytic processes and efficient mass transport; (2) various redox-active sites can be rationally introduced into COFs, which endows them with the enhanced pseudocapacitive performance; (3) the mass transport, electrical conductivity and mechanical stability of COFs materials can be improved by compositing other materials, such as poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene) and 3D graphene.Although many efforts have been paid to the development of COF-based materials for electrocatalytic applications, they still suffer from several challenges, such as low chemical stabilities, limited durability, and the poor processability.Therefore, it is desirable to construct novel COFs materials with good stability and processability through synthetic approaches and processing methodologies.Particularly, new cyanovinylene- or olefinlinked COFs should be developed due to its good recyclability(robustness) and superior charge transport properties under strong aqueous acidic/alkaline electrolytes.
2.4.6 Other emerging 2D materials
In addition to the abovementioned 2D materials, new promising 2D materials are rapidly expanding the family of 2D materials.This section briefly discusses a few representative examples.
Layered bismuth oxychalcogenide (Bi2O2Se) has appeared as a compelling 2D material with high carrier mobility and thickness-dependent bandgap354.As shown in Fig.7c, d, Ghoshetal.relied on the electrostatic interactions between oppositely charged alternating layers to assemble the single crystalline Bi2O2Se nanosheets by a wet chemical method318.Because the nearly full occupation ofdorbitals brings unique interlayer vibration, 2D noble-transition-metal dichalcogenides have emerged as a more attractive materials compared with other transition metal dichalcogenides.Therein, straightforward aqueous-phase reaction method with thermal annealing were developed by Umaretal.to acquire mesoporous PtSe2nanosheets (Fig.7e)319.
2D halide perovskites (Fig.8b) have arisen as the nextgeneration halide perovskites with intriguing physical properties and improved performances in optoelectronics355.Particularly,2D perovskites and their hybrids demonstrated great potentials in outperforming conventional 3D perovskites in terms of stability and conversion efficiency356,357.As a result,engineering the phase and heterostructures of 2D halide perovskite and integrating them with other 2D materials have become an effective strategy to expand the possibility of future perovskite-based applications358.The preparation of 2D perovskites can be realized by solution-based synthesis,mechanical exfoliation, epitaxial growth, as well as spaceconfined growth359.Recently, the direct growth of atomically thin, square-shape (C4H9NH3)2PbBr4perovskite has been achieved in a solution based method80.The growth solution containing precursors of the perovskite was drop-casted directly on the substrate and majority of the products were molecularly thin withn= 1.In another work, solution-based crystallization method was applied to synthesize a series of 2D organicinorganic hybrid perovskites360.The authors made use of different types of bulky ligands to sterically prevent the intermolecular aggregation and thickening during the crystal growth, resulting in the formation of nanometer-thick 2D perovskites.
MXenes are another group of 2D nanocrystals composed of transition metal carbides, nitrides, or carbonitrides.MXenes adopts a general formula of Mn+1XnTx(n= 1-3), where M is the transition metal, X represents carbon and/or nitrogen, and Txis the surface terminations (a typical example of MXenes, Ti3C2Tx,is shown in Fig.8c).Thanks to the conductive layered structure and tuneable surface properties361, MXenes have demonstrated excellent performances in applications such as energy storage362,363, sensing364, and catalysis365,366.The synthesis of MXenes can be realizedviathe high-temperature molten-salt approach, as well as wet etching362.Particularly, the most used method is selective wet etching from a layered precursor followed by delamination.To date, different strategies have been employed in the etching and/or delamination processes to modulate the structure and composition of the resultant MXenes towards desired properties and functions.Examples include edge functionalization367, single metal atom substitution366,368,controlled self-assembly of MXenes369, and so on.
2.5 Phase engineering of 2D materials
2.5.1 Overview of phase engineering in 2D materials
Phase engineering of nanomaterials (PEN) focuses on the significant impact of the distinct atomic arrangement on the physiochemical properties of nanomaterials, and its incorporation towards unique properties and applications105.PEN has gradually become a powerful strategy to engineer the property and performance of nanomaterials in applications across a multitude of research fields such as photonics,electronics, condensed matter and energy applications106,370.The concept of PEN has deep root in 2D materials, showing intriguing development in TMDs, noble metals, metal oxides,MOFs, COFs and perovskites.In addition, amorphous 2D materials which lack long-range atomic ordering is a new development in PEN, showing enhanced performance in many energy applications.In this section, we will elaborate on the PEN-related studies in 2D materials with a particular focus on TMDs.
2.5.2 Phase engineering of transition metal dichalcogenides
TMDs are among the most studied nanomaterials in the field of PEN.The early attempt of phase engineering in TMDs could date back to the 1980s when the phase transition was observed during the Li intercalation of MoS2371.Phase engineering of TMDs gains significant tracking in the last decade and finds importance in both fundamental science101and practical applications370,372,373.Polymorphism is one of the key characteristics that defines TMDs and their applications in various research fields145,374,375.In general, layered TMDs can be categorized into different phases based on their atomic arrangement of chalcogen atom and transition metal atom,including 2H, 3R, 1T, 1T′ and 1Td.The importance and effectiveness of phase engineering in TMDs is largely attributed to the unique band-structure modulation upon phase transformation.Specifically, group VIB TMDs, such as MoS2and WSe2, in their conventional phase (hexagonal, 2H) are semiconductors, with large bandgaps range from ~1 to ~2 eV,which are intensively studied in next-generation electronics113.However, their unconventional phases (octahedral, 1T and 1T′)are semi-metals with metallic charge transport, demonstrating extensive application in energy storage and conversion applications154,370.Such dramatic change in electronic properties is a result of the change in the filling state of thedorbitals of the transition metal upon change of the crystal phases375.Although various PEN strategies have been developed in the past decade, the continuous progress of this field is largely limited by the difficulty to obtain metastable TMDs with high phase-purity and high yield, due to the unstable nature of these unconventional-phase materials.There are currently two main PEN strategies in obtained metastable-phase TMDs, phase transition and direct chemical synthesis.The former refers to the various methods to tune the TMDs materials from their thermodynamically stable phases to metastable phases, while the later refers to the more recent development in the CVD and solid-gas phase reactions.In this section, we will elaborate on the synthetic success of metastable TMD materials.More comprehensive review of the phase engineering of TMDs and their application in specific fields can be found in these recent reviews105,370,375.
2.5.2.1 Phase transition of TMDs
Phase transformation from thermodynamically stable phase to metastable phase is the most studied strategy to obtain metastable phases of TMDs.The various phase transformation methods not only provide convenient and effective approaches readily applicable in many applications, but also play critical roles in understanding the fundamentals of how crystal phases impact the properties.Early discovery of phase transition of TMDs is a byproduct of Li intercalation process as a general route to exfoliate TMDs into colloid suspensions371.However,the extensive studies of phase transition process in the recent decade show its true potential in many applications including electronics and catalysis.Based on the difference in transition mechanism, phase transition in TMDs can be roughly divided into two categories, those based on the direct injection of electrons into the lattice and the ones based on thermal activation of the lattice.
2.5.2.1.1 Phase transitionviadirect electron injection
The direct injection of electrons into TMDs can be achieved by lithium intercalation process which simultaneously induces phase transition.Most chemical intercalation methods roughly follow the similar procedures where 2H TMDs can be chemically intercalation with Li ions by immersed TMD flake or powders into then-butyllithium solution under various reaction conditions.As shown in Fig.9a, the intercalation of alkyli ions(in most case Li+) results in electron injection into the TMDs which induces phase transition from hexagonal (2H) to octahedral (1T) or distorted octahedral (1T′).Although very convenient and widely adopted, chemical intercalation methods generally lack control over the intercalation and phase transition processes and show excess damage over of integrity of 2D structures.Such defect-rich morphology is often favored in catalytic applications such as electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution (HER)154, due to its richness in active sites combined with the enhanced charge transport from the semi-metallic metastable phases155.
Inspired by the electrochemical cells used in Li-ion battery,the electrochemical intercalation was development in 2011 to overcome these disadvantages152.It not only assures a fine control over the whole intercalation processes, but also enable diverse intercalant ions for different applications such as various alkali metal-ion (Li, Na, and K) and organic intercalants93,376.Till now, various metal ions and organic cations have been used to intercalate TMD crystals to produce high-quality suspension of nanosheets in large quantity.Electrochemical intercalation has found extensive utilization in thin-film applications in both electronics and catalysis.More importantly, it is a highly versatile method that can be easily integrated with variousinsitucharacterization techniques to monitor the intercalation process,as well as study the evolution of the structure and properties.
Aside from the intercalation methods, there are other means to directly inject electron into TMD lattice such as electron beam irradiation377and hot electrons injection from plasmonic metal nanostructrure378.However, such processes generally produce localized phase transition at the contact area, therefore are unfavored in practical applications.Notably, it is also possible to reverse the phase transition process by extract electron from 1T/1T′ TMDsviaelectrochemical reduction379.In a more recently and rather unique study, field-induce phase transition was observed in MoTe2 nanosheet when a high magnitude of gate modulation was appliedviaionic gating in ionic liquid380.The phase transition is induced by the ultrahigh carrier (electron)injection under high electrostatic doping, and only occurs at the first layer of MoTe2that directly contacts the electrolyte.
2.5.2.1.2 Phase transitionviathermal activation
In addition to the electron injection approaches, thermal activation is another viable and widely used strategy to induce phase transition in TMDs.Both thermodynamically stable and metastable phases of TMDs could undergo phase transition upon absorption of various forms of thermal energy in crystal lattice.The simplest form in this category is the phase transition of TMDs upon thermal annealing at elevated temperature.For example, metastable TMDs spontaneously transfer back to their thermodynamically stable phase upon thermal annealing with a clear transition temperature, as experimentally observed in the TGA experiments in high-purity metastable TMD crystals101,372.On the other hand, due to the extremely small energy difference(tens of meV) between 2H- and 1T′-MoTe2, reversible phase transition between these two phases was observed upon thermal treatment (Fig.9b)381.Alternatively, the thermal energy from laser irradiation could induce localized phase transition on TMD nanosheets, which is much favored in electronic devices381.It is however worth mentioning that laser irradiation often induces structural defects and thinning effect372,381, suggesting undesirable burning of the materials to a certain degree.
Other examples of phase transition in TMDs that cannot be generally categorized include mechanical strain appliedviaAFM tips382or in a diamond avil cell383, plasma treatment384,and surface functionalization385.
2.5.2.2 Direct synthesis of metastable-phase TMDs
Compared with phase transition methods, the direct synthesis of metastable TMDs is more favored to achieve phase purity for exploration in important fundamental properties.Although several wet-chemical syntheses of metastable TMDs have been reported386,387, the products generally lack well-defined morphologies and is highly dependent on the underlying substrates which is not ideal for practical applications.On the other hand, the direct synthesis of metastable TMDs crystals has gaining increasing attention due to the high quality of products,representing an important breakthrough in 2D material synthesis.The earliest success in of direct synthesis of metastable TMD crystals dated back to 1992, when Wypychetal.obtained 1T-MoS2(the detail crystal phase is unclear due to the limitation in TEM techniques at the time) by synthesizing KMoS2and consequently removing the K+from the compound388.Upon further improvement on the strategy of solid-state reaction, the synthesis1T′-MoS2and 1T′-MoSe2with high phase purity were recently reported372.The high phasepurity enables the resolution of the critical role of crystal phases in electrocatalysis.More recently, Laietal.further reported a general method for the large-scale synthesis of metastable 1T′-phase group-VIB TMDs, using a modified solid-gas phase reaction, as shown in Fig.9c101.More importantly, the high quality of the 1T′-TMD crystals makes it possible to clearly solve the crystal structures of 1T′-MoS2, 1T′-WS2, 1T′-MoSe2and 1T′-WSe2with single-crystal X-ray diffraction.
Fig.9 (a) Schematic illustration of the intercalation of TMD crystals with alkali metal to exfoliate 2D nanosheets while induce phase transition.Reproduced with permission from Ref.105, Copyright 2020 Springer Nature.(b) Schematic illustration of laser-induced phase transition of MoTe2 at the top layer.Reproduced with permission from Ref.381, Copyright 2015 Association for the Advancement of Science.(c) Schematic illustration of the gas-solid reaction for the synthesis of 1T′-WS2 crystals.Reproduced with permission from Ref.101,Copyright 2021 Springer Nature.
2.5.3 Phase engineering of other 2D nanosheets
Although the vast majority of PEN-related studies in 2D materials focus on TMDs, the concept is expending to other 2D materials such as 2D noble metal nanosheets, metal oxides389,Mexene390and perovskites391.Take noble metal nanosheets for example.The vast majority of noble metals nanomaterials crystalize into face-centered cubit (fcc) phase, same as their bulk counterparts.However, it was found that some thermodynamically unstable phases, such as hexagonal close-packed(hcp) phase (2 h or 4 h type) of gold can be stabilized in 2D gold nanosheets and ribbons obtained by phase-controlled wetchemical synthesis392-396.Phase transformation from fcc to hcp can be realizedvialigand exchange process393and electronbeam irradiation394.Fig.10a elaborates the phase transition from unconventional hcp Au square sheet (2 h) to conventional fcc phasevialigand exchange process393.In addition, the 4H Au nanosheets or ribbons can be used as template to epitaxially grow the other metals in 4H phase such as Pt, Pd, Ag, Ir, and Cu395,397.More recently, a general one-pot wet-chemical method was reported to prepare ultrathin Pd alloy nanosheets with a novel face-centered tetragonal (fct) phase398.
2.5.4 Amorphous 2D materials
Distinctive from crystalline materials with long-range periodicity, amorphous 2D materials refer to a specific type of nanomaterials with 2D morphology, showing no long-range atomic order.Currently studies in this aspect mainly focused on metal, metal oxides/hydroxides399and TMDs.Various top-down and bottom-up methods have been utilized in the controlled synthesis of amorphous 2D materials such as supercritical CO2-assisted exfoliation in TMDs and wet-chemical synthesis in noble-metal nanosheets.However, the research in this area is still in its infancy and most of the synthetic successes are case specific.Recently, a relatively general synthetic approach was reported for the synthesis of noble metal nanosheets (Ir, Rh and Ru)226.In this work, the amorphization is achievedviadirect annealing of metal acetylacetonates with alkali salt at elevated temperature in air, as shown in Fig.10b.The amorphous nanosheets show much enhanced performance in electrocatalytic OER compared to their crystalline counterpart.In a more recent study, amorphous domains were introduced into Pd nanosheets in a one-pot wet-chemical method to create amorphous/crystalline phase heterostructures as heterogeneous catalyst in hydrogenation of 4-nitrostyrene400.It was found that the amorphous-phase rich Pd nanosheets exhibit high chemoselectivity while the crystalline-rich ones exhibit high catalytic activity.
Fig.10 (a) Schematic illustration of ligand exchange induced phase transformation of Au square sheets from hcp to fcc.Reproduced with permission from Ref.393, Copyright 2015 Springer Nature.(b) Schematic illustration of the general synthetic process for amorphous noble metal nanosheets.M.T.: the melting point of metal acetylacetonate 226.
2.5.5 X-ray based characterizations on phase engineering in 2D materials
In principle, controlling the phase of a material is accompanied by initial atomic structure, chemical or electronic make-up.Notably, various X-ray-based techniques have been employed to provide edges in understanding phase engineering of 2D materials.Among the plethora, synchrotron-based X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) are often employed to probe the local atomic environment, electronic states and band structure of 2D materials.Thus, we will mainly focus on XAS and ARPES characterizations herein.
2.5.5.1 XAS study on phase engineering in 2D materials
XAS is the X-ray absorption coefficient of an incident X-ray with an energy range of the absorption edge of a target element in a material, thus becomes a valuable tool in studying the local structure near a particular atom of interest401.In principle, XAS can be distinguished into the X-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES) and the extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS), from which structural information such as the chemical bonding, coordination number, site symmetry, and interatomic distances can be extracted402.As shown in Fig.11a,the XANES and EXAFS spectra are demonstrated to provide detailed information on the oxidation state and coordination environment of Mn atom403, implying that XAS analysis can reveal the nature of interaction sites and the structural changes cause by the intercalation or doping process in 2D materials.In fact, XAS can focus on various atomic sites of different atoms in the same compounds with independent absorption signals404.For examples, Jinetal.utilized XAS to investigate the local coordination of nitrogen vacancies in 2D W2N3, as shown in Fig.11b405.Both the pristine and nitrogen vacant samples show the prominent coordination peak at 2.8 Å (1 Å = 0.1 nm), which corresponds to a W―W bonding405.Moreover, there is a weakening in the intensity at the W―N bond, with the peak at 1.8 Å of the vacancy-induced sample compared to the pristine sample.This weakening in the W―N bonding intensity shows decreased coordination between W and N and an increase in N vacancies.Chenetal.investigated the local bonding environment in Li and Pt intercalated MoS2using EXAFS, as shown in Fig.11c406.The EXAFS spectrum of the pristine MoS2is consistent with the trigonal prismatic phase; in the spectrum of the LixMoS2sample, the Mo―S and Mo―Mo bonds peaks appear much weaker in comparison to the pristine.This suggests a change in the site symmetry caused by a phase transition from 2H to 1T′ phase.In the PtxMoS2, the K-edge EXAFS spectrum indicates the structure is consistent with the 2H phase406.To probe the influence of the Se dopant in the ZrTe2, Zahiretal.studied the XANES spectra of ZrTe2(1-x)Se2xsingle crystals, as shown in Fig.11d407.The Zr K-edges were found to shift to higher energies with an increase in the amount of dopant,showing an increase in the oxidation number of the dopant.
Fig.11 (a) The Mn K-edge XANES and EXAFS spectra.Inset (top left) the X-ray absorption spectrum from a sample showing the XANES and EXAFS regions of the spectrum.The enlargements show the Mn K-edge XANES and the k-space EXAFS data with the corresponding Fourier transform (shown on the right) 403.(b) The FT-EXFAS plots of NV-W2N3 and W2N3.Reproduced with permission from the Ref.405, Copyright 2019 John Wiley and Sons.(c) k2-weighted Mo K-edge EXAFS spectra of Pt-MoS2 in comparison to Mo foil, bulk MoS2 and LixMoS2 406.(d) Zr K-edge XANES spectra of ZrTe2(1-x)Se2x single crystals 407.
2.5.5.2 ARPES study on phase engineering in 2D materials
ARPES is one of the most essential experimental techniques used to study the electronic bands of solids408.Demonstrating the change of phase from a metal to insulator, Hanetal.report the surface doped 2H-MoTe2409.As shown in Fig.12a, they used ARPES to show the emergence of gapped phase indicating a phase transition from metal to an insulator.Zahiretal.intercalated Cu atoms into ZrSe2.The introduction of copper into the material facilitated electron doping into the system and induced a phase transition from semiconducting to a metallic phase410.As shown in Fig.12b, the ARPES results in the intercalated samples reveal a conduction band crossing the Fermi level around L high symmetry point in Fig.12b(iv).Ziaet al.also demonstrated the use of ARPES to study the phase transition of 2D material from semiconducting to a metallic characteristics411.
Fig.12 (a) Doping evolutions of Fermi surface and band structure in the surface-doped 2H-MoTe2.(i-iv) Fermi surface mapping taken in the as-grown sample.(v-vi) the energy-momentum cut taken along the G-K direction in the as-grown sample.(ii) and (vi), (iii) and (vii), (iv) and(vii) are the same as (i) and (v).Reproduced with permission from Ref.409, Copyright 2021 American Physical Society.(b) (i) and (ii) shows the photoemission intensity plots along the G-M direction in the pristine ZrSe2 and Cu intercalated ZrSe2 single crystals, respectively.(b) (iii) and (iv)shows the photoemission intensity plots along the A-L direction in the pristine ZrSe2 and Cu intercalated ZrSe2 single crystals, respectively 410.
3 Physical properties
3.1 Optical properties
In this part, we will review recent progresses on how various 2D materials interact with light and the related spectroscopic features and optoelectronic functionalities, encompassing a broad range of research topics: absorption, reflection, scattering,emission, light-matter strong coupling and nonlinear optical properties.
3.1.1 Optical absorption
Absorption and reflection spectroscopy have been wellestablished to probe inter-electronic band transition, exitonic fine structures and lattice anisotropy down to the monolayer limit.For instance, the evolution of electronic band structure(Fig.13a, b)412,413and 1sand 2sexciton states ofE11transition(Fig.13c)414from bulk BP to its monolayer counterpart have been investigated using reflection and IR extinction spectra.Other intriguing properties of excitons like valley effect415,optical Stark effect416,417, exciton-phonon coupling418,linewidth and lifetime coherence419, transport behavior420and interlayer exciton absorptions421-423, are extensively studied.The lattice anisotropy induced polarization dependent optical responses are observed in BP412,414and other anisotropic 2D materials416,424-429.Furthermore, absorption spectroscopy is a powerful tool to reveal unique excitonic properties modulated by external fields, including dielectric environment430, electrical filed421,431,432, and optomechanical fields433.There are also continuous efforts and progresses on 2D materials with tailored optical functionalities, such as optical absorbers with tunable polarization434, wavelength435-438, and efficiency439.
3.1.2 Raman scattering
Raman spectroscopy reveals abundant information on spinphonon couplings, phonon-fingerprints, electron-photon interactions, interlayer couplings,etc.For instance, Huangetal.reported extraordinarily large magneto-optical Raman effects ofA1gphonon 2D magnet CrI3 due to spin-phonon coupling (Fig.13d, e)440,441.Deep insights are needed on the observation of forbidden Raman modes, including new edge modes related to electromagnetic field distortion of incident and scattered light442,acoustic phonons under double-resonance excitation443and cross-dimensional electron-phonon coupling between 3D phonons and 2D excitons444.
Exotic electron-phonon coupling effects attract significant research interest for 2D matters in a strain/electric/plasmonic field.Huangetal.investigated size-dependent G-band oscillations originated from optical standing waves of a graphene bubble123.Gate-dependent electronic Raman scattering449and phonon polarization450have been studied.To improve the sensitivity and spatial resolution, tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) are often exploited to study local lattice vibrations451,452.
3.1.3 Optical emission
Group VIB TMDs are the most attractive 2D semiconductors owing to their extraordinary properties and great potential in novel optoelectronic and photonic applications.With a direct bandgap and strong excitonic effects at the ultimate 2D limit,monolayer TMDs are expected to show high photoluminescence quantum yield (PLQY).However, the PLQY was greatly constrained below 1% at room temperature by the non-radiative recombination owing to trap states from defects or impurities and inherently enhanced Auger-type exciton-exciton interaction453,454.Tremendous research efforts have been devoted to improving the PLQY of TMDs453-456.
Meanwhile, 2D semiconductors are becoming a unique platform to study many-body physics of excitons.Coulomb interactions among excitons or between excitons and free carriers could facilitate the formation of excitonic complexes,such as charged exciton (trion), biexciton and charged biexciton(or exciton-trion).Several research groups457-460have demonstrated independently that individual emission peaks of excitonic complexes can be observed in monolayer WSe2, and their resonance energy and PLQY can be substantially modulated by applying gate voltages or magnetic fields.
Moreover, when excitons are strongly localized in a point defect or strain field in TMDs, they can serve as quantum light sources to emit single photons445,461-463.Fig.13f, g show that extremely sharp emission peaks of excitons are observed at 10 K in both PL and electroluminescence spectra of monolayer WSe2.Photon correlation measurements are employed to justify the single-photon nature of these sharp emission.Kleinetal.461show that point defects as single-photon emitters can be controllably introduced into monolayer MoS2by irradiating He2+beams.Heetal.462reported that strongly localized biexcitons leads to an emission cascade of single photons.Most interestingly, Chenetal.464proposed that the entanglement between chiral phonons and single photons.These intriguing results render TMDs as potential candidates for developing nextgeneration quantum-optic devices.
Because of the valley degree of freedom in monolayer TMDs,excitons at theKandK′ points in the Brillouin zone are energetically degenerate, but inequivalent, as shown in Fig.13h,which can directly couple withσ+andσ-circularly polarized light446,465,466.Valley-polarized excitons have finite Berry curvatures in Fig.13i, and therefore are expected to show quantum transport phenomenon analogue to those of spin degree of freedom.Indeed, Ongaetal.465investigated exciton Hall effect in monolayer MoS2.Excitons atKandK′ valleys after diffusing over a distance of several microns accumulate at opposite directions as evident from polarization-resolved PL mapping.Such transverse splitting indicates the occurrence of the exciton Hall effect in monolayer MoS2and are promising for novel valleytronic application in 2D semiconductors.
However, exciton valley coherence time is only on a time scale of ~100 fs which is a tradeoff for strong excitonic effect in monolayer TMDs.The prominent Coulomb force between electrons and holes inevitably lead to a strong intervalley electron-hole exchange effect and ultrashort exciton lifetimes466-468.A promising strategy for overcoming this constraint is to construct heterostructures with two TMD monolayers.As a result of a type-II band alignment, electrons and holes can accumulate in different monolayers.Consequently, they can bound together through Coulomb force to form interlayer excitons (IEs) carrying valley information469.IEs show long PL lifetime and valley coherence time on a timescale of ns.In addition, optical properties of IE can be effectively modulated by applying gate voltages or magnetic fields since they have an out-of-plane electric dipole moment469,470.With such a long lifetime, IE condensation is experimentally observed with distinct electroluminescence signatures in MoSe2/WSe2heterobilayers471.
Over the past few years, tremendous progress and significant breakthroughs has been made in understanding and controlling the interlayer coupling in TMD heterobilayers447,472-475.Fluorescence blinking effect was observed in a weakly coupled WS2/MoSe2heterobilayer with limited overlap of electronic wavefunctions (Fig.13j)447.Periodic superlattices, known as moiré patterns, will form as two monolayers with incommensurate lattice constant or a twist are stacked vertically,as shown in Fig.13k448.For both intralayer and interlayer excitons, their optical properties are substantially influenced by the periodic potential of moiré patterns472-477.These so-called moiré excitons show distinct PL emission with valley polarization functionalities and can be fine-tuned by changing the twist angles.For example, Luietal.478demonstrated moiré trion in a WSe2/MoSe2heterobilayer recently.
Fig.13 Reflection contrast spectra of monolayer (a) and bilayer (b) BP 413.(c) 1s and 2s exciton states of E11 Exciton absorption spectra for bilayer BP 414.(d, e) Extraordinarily large magneto-optical Raman effects of A1g phonon due to spin-phonon coupling 441.Single photon emission (f)and photon correlation measurements (g) 445.Schematics of valley polarization of excitons (h) and the exciton Hall effect in monolayer MoS2 (i) 446.(j) Fluorescence blinking effect in a WS2/MoSe2 heterobilyer 447.(k) Schematics of the moiré superlattice and moiré excitons formed in a heterobilayer 448.(h, i) reproduced with permission from Ref.446, Copyright 2018 John Wiley and Sons.
3.1.4 Light-matter strong coupling and exciton polaritons
Excitons can strongly couple with photons to form new quasiparticles, known as exciton-polaritons, in a hybrid structure of semiconductors and optical cavities.Exciton-polaritons are half-matter and half-light bosonic quasiparticles.They can condense to a single quantum state at high temperature and low density, which can bring quantum effects to a macroscopic scale and provide great opportunities for developing all-optical devices.Thanks to the 2D confinement and large exciton bonding energies with giant oscillator strength, excitonpolaritons based on monolayer TMDs are stable at room temperature promising for practical optoelectronic and valleytronic devices479.Zhaoetal.480reported the observation of polariton condensation and lasing with ultralow thresholds in monolayer WS2microcavity at room temperature (Fig.14a-d).
3.1.5 Nonlinear optical properties
Nonlinear optics examines the behavior of light in nonlinear media.The photoelectric field generated by irradiation of light will produce optical linear and nonlinear polarization properties449,450.Generally, since the intensity of natural light is relatively weak, the resulting nonlinear properties are much smaller than linear optical properties, and the nonlinear optical properties can be ignored at this time.When the light source is changed to a higher intensity laser, the nonlinear optical properties will be observed obviously.Nonlinear absorption and refraction are distinct properties of nonlinear materials479,481,482,which are widely used in lasers483, saturable absorbers484,optical switch, photovoltaic cell485,486, and many other applications487-491.
Borophene is a promising nonlinear optical material with both nonmetallic and metallic properties which can facilitate polymorphism in low-dimensional structures.Maetal.492studied intriguing nonlinear properties of borophene prepared with the liquid-phase exfoliation method and their potential applications.The broadband nonlinear photonic characteristics of borophene are shown in the Fig.14.The fundamental modelocked spectrum in Fig.14e reveals that the 3 dB bandwidth and central wavelength are 4.2 and 1560.76 nm, respectively and the output power is 1.1 mW.Fig.14f shows a pulse train within the span of 500 ns with a pulse interval of ~101 ns.The radio frequency spectrum with a resolution of 100 Hz is shown in the Fig.14g and a strong peak with a signal-to-noise ratio of 63 dB can be observed at 10.09 MHz.Furthermore, Fig.14h presents the single pulse duration measured by the intensity autocorrelation and fitted by the hyperbolicsecant function, andthe full width at half-maxima of the pulse is 693 fs.
Fig.14 (a-d) Exciton-polariton condensation and lasing of monolayer WS2 480: (a) Sample structure of monolayer WS2 embedded in an optical cavity formed by two DBRs; (b) Angle-resolved reflectivity map of the polariton in a monolayer WS2; (c) Above-threshold angle-resolved PL map;(d) Real space PL spectrum.(e-h) Pulse Q-switching characteristics when the pump power is 263.1 mW 492: (e) The mode-locked spectrum of borophene; (f) Typical oscilloscope pulse trains of mode-locking; (g) Autocorrelation race fitted by a sech2 profile;(h) RF spectrum of the mode-locked pulses.
In the meantime, a variety of emerging materials has been demonstrated with remarkable nonolinear optical properties and applications recently.Shietal.493applied black arsenicphosphorus saturable absorber to passively Q-switched erbiumdoped fiber laser for the first time.Tianetal.494studied the midinfrared ultra-wideband saturable absorber made of Bi2O2Se.Wuetal.495synthesized a new infrared material, Na2BaMQ4, and studied its nonlinear optical properties.Guoetal.496grew Se on Te nanotubes to construct a Te@Se heterostructure by making use of the instability of light absorption.Saoumaetal.497and several research teams498,499studied the nonlinear optical properties of 2D perovskite materials.In addition, MOFs, COFs and graphyne also exhibit excellent nonlinear optical properties500-504.2D layered NMDs have been attracting extensive attention because of their unique nonlinear optical properties505-508.Tsangetal.509studied the nonlinear absorption properties of PtS2and demonstrated that it can be used in optical limiters and biosensors.The nonlinear optical properties of MXenes include saturable absorption, nonlinear refractive index, and so on are also comprehensively investigated510,511.
3.2 Magnetic properties
The discovery of magnetic vdW 2D materials (i.e.,Cr2Ge2Te6512,513and CrI3514) in 2017 successfully added the fundamental physics — magnetism — into 2D materials.The emergent 2D magnets513,515,516not only provide ideal platforms for the experimental study of 2D spin and magnon physics192,517,but also can couple with disparate electronic, photonic,superconducting and topological materials to create a large influx of new designer heterostructures518-522.These new materials and heterostructures have been enabling superior device performances such as the very large tunneling magnetoresistance in graphite-CrI3-graphite tunneling junctions523-526.
Due to the strong thermal fluctuations in 2D magnetic systems according to Mermin-Wagner theorem527, many researchers had long believed that it was unlikely to experimentally realize 2D magnets.Efforts on seeking 2D magnetism have started since the advent of graphene in 2004 and they can be primarily classified into three categories.Firstly, defects including structural imperfections (i.e., vacancies, edges and grain boundaries) and foreign atoms (e.g., adatoms and substitutional doping)528-532have been widely applied to create local magnetic moments.Yet,it poses severe challenges to align these local moments to make long-range magnetic order.Secondly, magnetic proximity effect533,534has been leveraged by integrating non-magnetic 2D materials with conventional magnetic substrates (e.g., yttrium iron garnet and europium sulfide).This approach can effectively spin polarize the wavefunction of 2D materials535.Yet, such extrinsically induced magnetic responses in 2D materials primarily rely on the properties of the non-vdW magnetic substrates, and any potential device developments have to include the proximitized heterogeneous materials as a whole.Thirdly, flat bands536,537have been actively sought in new materials by theoreticians, since the extraordinarily large density of states (DOS) at van Hove singularity potentially causes Stoner instability and itinerant ferromagnetism.However, it leaves great challenges for experimentalists to prepare the required materials at atomic precision or under extreme conditions (e.g.,high p-doping in deep valence bands537).It is worthwhile to highlight that such flat band related ferromagnetism was recently observed in twisted bilayer graphene and graphene/hBN Moire heterostructures538,539.
It is always instructive to reflect on the challenges confronted during the course of finding and observing intrinsic 2D magnets.A few important causes couple together.Firstly, there have been no mature theoretical calculation methods to predict Curie temperatures of 2D ferromagnets accurately512,536.Even if a first-principles calculation predicted the ground state of a 2D material is ferromagnetic, the absence of precise knowledge on the Curie temperature sets hurdles for experimental exploration.Secondly, many 2D materials in atomic-thinness region are unstable in the air512,514,540, leading to the substantially degraded properties if samples are not carefully protected.Thirdly, it is difficult to characterize the small amount of magnetization from the atomic-thin micrometer-size magnets.The commonly adopted electrical characterizations of magnetism based on anomalous Hall effect cannot be applied on many 2D magnets that are electrically insulating541.Meanwhile, the commonly used bulk characterization techniques such as vibrating sample magnetometry (VSM) is not reliable for 2D flake characterization, since small amount of magnetic impurities or defects in the bulk could bury the true magnetic signal from the 2D flake if any.In contrast, magneto-optical effects512,514(e.g.,magneto-optical Kerr effect and magnetic circular dichroism)could enable the convenient magnetic characterization of asexfoliated micrometer-size 2D flakes, no matter samples are electrically conductive or insulating.
The original discovery of 2D magnets were carried out by magneto-optical Kerr microscopy on two magnetic insulators,Cr2Ge2Te6512and CrI3514.Afterwards, metallic 2D magnets such as FexGeTe2(x= 3, 4, 5, or some non-integer numbers) have been reported542-547.Generally, metallic 2D magnets have higher Curie temperatures than insulating 2D magnets.Intrinsic magnetic topological insulators such as MnBi2Te4and MnBi2Se4548,549are another intriguing class of layered magnets that closely link 2D magnetism with topological physics.Though many new 2D magnets were claimed to be synthesized by molecular beam epitaxy or CVD, the adopted VSM-based characterizations are unable to reliably distinguish 2D flakes from bulk substrates.
Magnetism lays the foundation for spintronics and so it is important to develop the electrical control, which means either voltage or current control.In voltage control scheme542,550-556,one can use voltage to cause electric field or electrostatic doping in 2D magnets.In current control scheme518,557,558, one usually aims to utilize electrical current to switch magnetizationviaspin orbit torque.Besides electrical control, many other stimuli have been attempted to control 2D magnetism, including pressure559-563,chemical synthesis545, light incidence564, to name a few.For example, pressure can artificially change the lattice constants of vdW magnets, chemical synthesis545can easily modify the elemental concentration and stoichiometry, and optical incidence can cause photo-induced doping in 2D magnets565, all of which could lead to the effective control of magnetic properties.
There has also been a surge of interest in 2D antiferromagnets.Due to the absence of net magnetization, it is hard to utilize magneto-optical Kerr effect, magnetic circular dichroism and anomalous Hall effect to directly probe antiferromagnetism.Indirect evidence based on the spin-phonon coupling or spinphoton interaction can be acquired.For example, temperaturedependent Raman spectroscopy566shows observable changes in peak frequency, intensity or linewidth across the Néel temperatures.Exciton emission567-569or second harmonic generation570,571may have linear polarization with a certain direction relative to the spin ordering orientation in layered antiferromagnets.
2D magnetic heterostructure is a vital direction that still leaves vast room unexplored.Magnetic proximity effects have been reported when 2D magnets interface with 2D semiconductors519or topological insulators521.More attentions were paid to the induced effect on the non-magnetic side but not the opposite way(i.e., how the magnetic properties are affected by adjacent materials).When 2D magnets interface with other lowsymmetry materials, the proximitized materials518,519with further reduced symmetry hold the possibility to generate exotic particles.These prospects appear looming on the horizon and we have many reasons to believe a superlative range of exotic physics and phenomena will be discovered in numerous 2D magnetic heterostructures572,573.
3.3 Thermoelectric properties
Due to the increasing demand for clean energy and net-zero CO2emissions goal, the development of renewable energy technology has never been more critical.Thermoelectric (TE)technology, which enables the direct conversion between heat and electricity, provides a promising approach to achieving sustainable energy production, as shown in Fig.15a574.The TE conversion efficiency is determined by the figure of meritZT=σS2T/κ, whereσ,S,κ,Tare the electrical conductivity, Seebeck coefficient, thermal conductivity and absolute temperature respectively.These parameters are all governed by the electronic structure and phonon scattering properties which counteract each other.Great progress has been achieved in 2D materials since Hicks and Dresselhaus predicted that superlattices may show high TE performance based on quantum mechanics575.
The initial TE superlattice enhancement contains two main strategies576,577: (1) the quantum-confinement forms a unique step-like shape DOS which contributes toSenhancement and decoupling betweenSandσ; (2) a new kind of Umklapp process,which is confined in a small Brillouin zone due to the finite thickness and large superlattice constant, is introduced by quantum-confinement, creating preferential interface scattering for phonons than electrons.The development of these concepts has successfully promotedZTof superlattice above 2.However,the complex fabrication technology limits the superlattice’s application.To address this problem, researchers start to pay attention to bulk materials with superlattice-like 2D structures,as shown in Fig.15b.
Like superlattice, TE materials with 2D structures possess superior charge and phonon transport compared with conventional bulk materials with 3D structures (such as cubic structure),i.e., highSand lowκ.However, the underlying mechanisms are very different from superlattices.Since bulk materials with 2D structures are macroscopically 3D and microscopically 2D, quantum confinement is no longer applicable.Instead, complex band structure (none-single parabolic band edges) and strong anharmonicity play critical roles in charge and phonon transport, as shown in Fig.15c.The complex band structure derives from the anisotropic bonding conditions, leading to anisotropic effective mass (m*) along different crystallographic directions.Generally, the in-plane direction has smallerm*than the out-of-plane direction,indicating higher carrier mobility (μ) along the in-plane direction.More importantly, complex band structures projected by 2D crystal structures enable an effective approach to enhancingS, because the multiple band edges with a small energy offset of severalkBTcould simultaneously participate inthe charge transport578,579.As for the phonon transport, due to the different anisotropic chemical bondings between the in-plane and out-of-plane, 2D structures can be regarded as adjacent layers with different electromagnetic properties.Accordingly,lowκcould be obtained in the in-plane direction due to the strong anharmonicity, which has been extensively observed in 2D materials, originating from lone pair electrons580, resonant bonding581, rattling model582,etc.Moreover, phonons with high frequency are also severely scattered along the out-of-plane direction than the in-plane direction, leading to lowerκ.
Fig.15 Schematic of (a) thermoelectric module, (b) electrical and thermal transports in a given superlattice structure;(c) advanced thermoelectric parameters are also elucidated in the bulk materials with a layered structure.
Here we choose SnSe as an example to give a brief review of advanced TE performance in 2D materials.SnSe crystal has a distorted rock-salt structure, as shown in Fig.16a.Each Sn atom is bonded with seven Se atoms to form a highly distorted SnSe7coordination polyhedral with strong Sn―Se bonding withinaandbaxis and weak Sn―Se bonding along thecaxis.Additionally, a lone electron pair of Sn2+is sterically accommodated between the weak Sn―Se bonds.The unique chemical bonding conditions lead to a 2D structure with twoatom-thick SnSe slabs, which is the foundation of the outstanding TE performance in SnSe with lowκand highσS2.The lowκin SnSe originates from the strong anharmonicity due to the ferroelectric-like lattice instability583.The DFT calculated Grüneisen parameters (γ), an indicator of anharmonicity, are all very high, reaching 4.1, 2.1, 2.3 along thea,b,caxis,respectively.Inelastic neutron scattering measurements also reveal significant phonon dispersion softening in both transverse acoustic and transverse optical phonons propagation (Fig.16b),in accordance with highγ.TA modes are considerably softer along theΓ-Xdirection than that alongΓ-Y, in line with the weaker bonding along the out-of-plane direction and the corresponding highest Grüneisen parameter.As a result, lowκis expected according to the relationκ∝γ-2584.On the other side, the anisotropic crystal structure leads to the complex electronic band structure in SnSe, as shown in Fig.16c.The first valence band maximum (VBM1) lies in theΓ-Zdirection,alongside which lies another VBM2.Moreover, VBM3 lies in theU-Xdirection within a narrow energy offset of ~0.13 eV578.As for the conduction band minimum (CBM), there are also two CBM with an energy offset of ~0.1 eV585.The complex band structure in valence/conduction bands facilitate multiple-bands transport when Fermi level is pushed toward CBM or VBM,leading to enhancedm*and thus highS.Moreover, the energy offset even exhibits complex temperature-dependent behaviors579, as shown in Fig.16d.The dynamic band structure enables the wide-range optimization ofμm*3/2, therefore highσS2.The complex band structure has been confirmed by angleresolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES)586, Fig.16e reveals two distinct VBMs alongΓ-ZandΓ-Ydirection,corresponding to VBM1 and VBM2 in DFT calculations.By fitting the dispersion slope, the effective mass can be extracted.It can be seen that dispersions alongΓ-Zare flatter thanΓ-Y,indicating largermalong the out-of-plane direction than the inplane direction.
Fig.16 (a) Crystal structure of SnSe.(b) Phonon dispersions measured by inelastic neutron scattering; reproduced with permission from Ref.583,Copyright 2015 Springer Nature.(c) Band structure of SnSe, green arrows (1, 2) indicate the conduction bands, red arrows (1, 2, 3) indicate the valence bands.(d) Temperature-dependent energy offset in the valence band and conduction band, which enable the high electrical performance through reasonable manipulating band structures.(e) Valence band structure measured by angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy.Reproduced with permission from Ref.586, Copyright 2016 American Physical Society.
Besides SnSe, many other TE materials, such as Bi2Te3587,BiCuSeO588and NaCoO2582, also exhibit excellent TE performance, benefiting from theoretical and experimental achievements in 2D structures.Even though different crystal structures need to be taken into consideration when it comes to a specific 2D material, the common features of 2D materials,complex band structure and strong anharmonicity, are the most fundamental aspects contributing to the high TE performance.It is very likely that continued investigations on 2D materials will further improve their TE performance, including intercalation,bilayer mismatch, vacancy and so forth.
3.4 Ferroelectric properties
The research topics of 2D ferroelectricity have been explored on the theoretical predictions and experimental developments in many systems since last century, including the ultrathin inorganic perovskite oxide and organic fluoride-based polymer systems589,590.The key scientific question of 2D ferroelectricity is to reduce the influence of the suppression for spontaneous polarization from depolarization fields, thus raising a fundamental question whether there is a critical thickness for all of ferroelectric behaviors591.As the rapid development of various growth technologies, the critical thickness has been pushing towards the thickness of sing-unit cell limit in the PVDF, BiFeO3 and YMnO3 films, which indicate the upcoming bloom future of 2D ferroelectricity589,590,592,593.Very recently,the discovery of emerging 2D ferroelectrics have experimentally and theoretically demonstrated that the stable and switchable electrical polarization could be observed in a lot of atomicallythin layered and non-layered films, thus giving the possibility of fabricating polarization-dependent electronic and optoelectronic devices even at monolayer limit593.The low-density dangling bonds and defects density at the surfaces of vdW materials render a rise of 2D ferroelectricity, which could provide relatively inert and stable surfaces to stabilize the electric polarizations.Essentially the chemical bonds of 2D ferroelectrics are normally shown with local covalent bonds other than the long-range interactions for the traditional perovskite oxides, therefore the surface charge accumulated depolarization fields have been confirmed with rather weaker strength that are not enough to suppress the electric polarization.
Layered group IV-VI materials, especially for the group IV monochalcogenides MX (M = Sn, Ge; X = S/Se) and tellurides(MTe), have been predicted to possess intrinsic in-plane ferroelectricity in the monolayer limit, due to their low-level crystal symmetry594-596.In 2016, Changetal.discovered unconventional ferroelectricity in the molecular beam epitaxial grown atomic-thick SnTe, in which the Currie temperature of one-unit cell SnTe film are 270 K and much higher than that of the bulk states (98 K) (Fig.17a-c)597.Nagashioetal.reported the purely in-plane 2D ferroelectricity for monolayer SnS obtained from physical vapor deposition, in which the odd-even effects are distinguished and the critical thickness are explored with 15 layers598.The clear ferroelectric switching phenomena is founded in the in-plane few-layered SnS nanoflakes devices598.More interestingly, Baoetal.observed the gate tunable ferroelectricity in the MBE grown few-layered SnS nanoflakes (Fig.17d-f)599.Some more intriguing theoretical calculations give out the interesting physical properties such asphotostriction induced by an inverse piezoelectric effect,selective valley excitation and persistent spin currents594,596,600.Changetal.also observed the robust ferroelectricity with microscopic domain structure and a critical temperature of 400 K in SnSe monolayer by the scanning tunneling microscopy601.The large-scale synthesis of high-quality monolayer group IV monochalcogenides MX is still very difficult for multiple applications due to the strong interlayer interaction that could benefit the growth in the vertical direction602.Meantime multiferroic states of monolayer group IV monochalcogenides also have been predicted by the theoretical calculations.
Fig.17 (a) Schematics of the SnTe crystal structure (upper) and the SnTe film (lower).(b) The stripe domain of a1-UC SnTe film (imaging conditions: -0.2 V, 30 pA, 4.7 K).The arrows in each domain indicate the direction of lattice distortion.(Upper inset) Topography image across a domain boundary (-0.2 V, 100 pA).(Lower inset) The graphene substrate (-0.1 V, 200 pA).(c) Temperature dependence of the distortion angle for the 1- to 4-UC SnTe films.(Inset) The distortion angle near Tc = 270 K for the 1-UC film exhibiting the behavior of a second-order phase transition.(d) Schematic side view of a bilayer SnS structure.Each SnS layer is ferroelectrically polarized with a net dipole moment aligned with the x-axis.Adjacent SnS layers are anti-ferroelectrically coupled due to the inversion symmetry in the AB-stacked structure (top panel); Schematic view of the wedding-cake morphology of MBE-grown SnS crystals, which are inversion-symmetry broken with non-zero net polarizations at the terraces (bottom panel).(e) (left) STM image of one ML SnS island with the nanoripple pattern.The in-plane armchair and zigzag directions are determined from the lattice constants and marked by the black arrows.The net ferroelectric polarization of this island, determined by the LCPD measurements, is marked by the white arrow.(right) Frequency shift measured as a function of the voltage, collected above the two edges marked by red and blue triangles respectively.Measurements are performed in constant-height mode after compensating the surface tilting and thermal drifting effects.Parabolic fits and corresponding parabola peaks are indicated.(f) The corresponding P-V hysteresis curves of the memory device at different gate voltages.(a-c) Reproduced with permission from Ref.597, Copyright 2016 American Association for the Advancement of Science.(d-f) Reproduced with permission from Ref.599, Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society.
Bulk layered metal thio- and seleno-phosphates (MTPs)originally crystallize in the crystal structures with inversion symmetry, in which metal cations and the framework of[P2S(Se)6]4-bonds in the in-plane layers and form VDH structures603.These family materials are discovered in the late 1800s by Friedel and Ferrand, which have later been extensively explored with ferroic ordering including ferromagnetic,antiferromagnetic and ferroelectric properties.Very recently,size-effect in one of layered MTP material, CuInP2S6, has been discussed for the possible ferroelectricity under the monolayer limit.Both Maksymovych and Kalinin groups reported the switchable polarization could be suppressed below the thickness of 50 nm, in which the ferroelectricity disappears at the thickness of 10 nm604,605.On the contrary, Liuetal.reported the nanoflakes show clear hysteresis loops down to the thickness of 4 nm, in which the polarization dependent diodes are shown the superior performance with the current on/off ratio ~100606.Furthermore, Dengetal.found the critical thickness for in-plane ferroelectricity of CuInP2S6should be between 90 and 100 nm607.The out-of-plane ferroelectricity of ultrathin CuInP2S6nanoflakes seems like still under debate, in which the key questions are from polarization screening and interfacial chemistry.However, from the views of the device’s application,it is clear that the ferroelectric fields of ultrathin MTPs plays an important role in affecting the carriers’ transport.
Wuetal.reported the tunable barrier height by the ferroelectric polarization in the asymmetric chromium-CuInP2S6-graphene devices could be high as 1 eV, thus achieving the tunneling electro-resistance of above 107608.Wangetal.reported a negative capacitance transistor based on the multilayer MoS2and ferroelectric CuInP2S6(20 nm)heterostructures, which shows with a minimum subthreshold swing of 28 mV·dec-1and negligible hysteresis thanks to the NC effect of CIPS that strongly correlated to interface ferroelectric domain switching609.Niuetal.also presents the pyroelectricity of CIPS could be clearly seen at bilayer samples, where the pyroelectric nanogenerators also has been fabricated to convert the thermal induced charges into electric currents610.
Dingetal.firstly predicted the intrinsic in-plane and out-ofplane ferroelectricity for the zincblende and wurtzite structured In2Se3(α-phase) and other III2-VI3VDH materials (Al2S3,Al2Se3, Al2Te3, Ga2S3, Ga2Se3, Ga2Te3, In2S3and In2Te3) by the first-principles DFT calculations611.The origin of ferroelectricity has been interpreted as the Se atom’s displacement in the vertical direction, which also could arouse the intercorrelated lock-in in-plane switchable polarization612.Based on the exfoliated and vapor-phase grown α-In2Se3nanoflakes, Zhouetal.have clarified the vertical displacement of Se atoms by the atomically-resolution TEM imaging and revealed its space group as R3m for the first time, and confirmed the noncentral-symmetry by second Harmonic generation and switchable electrical polarizations by piezoelectric force microscopy612.Subsequently, several groups independently reported the layer-dependent ferroelectricity on In2Se3nanoflakes even at the monolayer limit, in which the Curie temperatureTc, the coercive filedEcand the piezoelectric coefficient were determined with 700 K and 200 kV·cm-1, 0.34 pm·V-1, respectively613.Then the ferroelectricity of α-In2Se3nanoflakes has applied in the ferroelectric semiconductor fieldeffect transistor (FET), tunneling electro-resistance junction devices, neuromorphic computing devices and strain sensing devices614-616.Other groups also reported either in-plane ferroelectricity or antiferroelectricity on the other polymorphs of In2Se3nanoflakes617-620.
The first prediction for 2D ferroelectricity was proposed in the Tdphase MoS2monolayer621.Traditionally only insulators could be considered as the ferroelectrics and the ferroelectric metal are very rare, because the high concertation of electrons in metals or semimetals should screen the external electric fields and the polarization between ions.However, it is quite interesting that the direct evidence of switchable electrical polarization has been confirmed in the semi-metallic and metallic 2D materials622,623.Feietal.has differentiated the polarization switching of two or three-layer WTe2by the conductivity measurements using graphene as an electric gate electrode, while the monolayer WTe2nanoflakes does not observed the electric hysteresis loops due to the nonpolar crystal structure622.All of the above results confirm that the electric field could penetrate through the ultrathin 2D polar metal to switch the electrical polarization and indicate the possibility for the integration of ferroelectricity into other physical properties and multiple functional devices622.As shown in Fig.18, in the meantime, Yuanetal.discovered the out-of-plane ferroelectricity in single-layer 1T′ MoTe2at the room temperature(Fig.18c), in which the origin of symmetry breaking is from the relative atom’s displacement of Mo and Te atoms624.Recently,unconventional 2D bilayer Bernal-stacked graphene and boron nitride moiré heterostructures were explored with switchable ferroelectricity, which is attributed by the introducing superlattice potential from the moiré patterns and shows the hysteretic resistance behaviors625.The new ferroelectricity mechanism of unconventional, odd-parity electronic ordering in the bilayer graphene/boron nitride moiré system has been clearly understood625.The emerging of 2D ferroelectric materials not only show us much more rich physical pictures, but also give us the potential opportunities for the high-density polarization controlled functional devices, therefore which apparently raise the important requirements for the large-scale ferroelectric phase-controlled synthesis626-628.
Fig.18 (a, b) Top-view and side-view of charge density difference between ferroelectric MoTe2 d1T and paraelectric 1T phases (green,purple, cyan, orange, and pink colors denote negative charge, positive charge, Mo atom, Te atom, and polarization, respectively); (c) PFM phase hysteretic and butterfly loops of monolayer d1T-MoTe2; (d) I-V characteristic of monolayer d1T-MoTe2 on Pt and inset shows the energy diagram of ferroelectric tunneling junction devices 616.
3.5 Superconductivity
The emergence of superconductivity in 2D materials has attracted tremendous research interests because of the presence of unprecedented physical properties.With the first discovery of superconductivity in Hg at 4.15 K, the intriguing phenomenon has been observed in many other systems.At extremely low temperature (less than 40 K), the superconductivity can be well explained by the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) theory629, in which the famous “Cooper pair” plays an essential role.However, this theory fails to explain the high-temperature superconductivity (higher than 40 K).Owing to the emerging 2D superconductors, researchers can study the intriguing superconductivity at the 2D limit with possible tunability, both experimentally and theoretically, which could provide new clues in high-temperature superconductor research.In this section, we review recent advances in the field of 2D superconductors with unique characteristics.We first discuss the 2D superconductors that can be explained by BCS theory, in which some distinguishing properties such as Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) transition630, charge density wave (CDW)phase631, and Ising superconductivity632will be introduced.Next, we review the field of 2D high-temperature superconductors, including Fe-based and Cu-based 2D superconductors.Finally, we review the unconventional superconductivity in moiré superlattices.
3.5.1 BCS 2D superconductors
BCS theory629describes the “Cooper pair”, paired electrons through the electron-phonon interactions, which can be used to explain superconductivity below the McMillan limit.With advances in fabrication techniques, such as MBE and mechanical exfoliation, researchers can now access the superconductivity in 2D materials.Fortunately, the BCS theory is still applicable in many 2D superconductors, such as metallic thin films and TMDs materials.Nevertheless, there are still many unique properties emerging in these 2D BCS superconductors.In particular, the BKT transition, a topological phase transition derived from symmetry broken in terms of the vortex, can be treated as the signature of a 2D superconducting transition630.It is worth noting, apart from the superconducting phase, that there are many other phases observed with the variation of physical parameters in 2D superconductors.Among them, the CDW phase, a periodic modulation of electronic densities induced by the lattice distortion, is one of the most investigated in 2D superconducting systems.Prototypical systems include NbSe2and TaS2materials631,633.Understanding the relationship between the superconducting phase and CDW phase is important for understanding the underlying mechanism of superconductivity.However, there are still debates about their relationship634,i.e., whether it is cooperative, co-existing, or competitive.Thus, further experiments and theoretical calculations are still needed.
Considering that the time reversal and spatial inversion symmetries are preserved in BCS theory, new superconducting properties can emerge by breaking inversion symmetry.Particularly, in a non-centrosymmetric superconductor with strong spin-orbit coupling (SOC), a unique Ising superconductivity has been proposed and experimentally verified in the NbSe2system632.Furthermore, type-II Ising superconductivity was recently proposed without the participation of inversion symmetry breaking, where spin-orbit locking is suggested to play a critical role635.This type-II Ising superconductivity has been verified636in few-layer stanene in 2020.It is important to mention that the quantum transition phases637-639,i.e., quantum metallic ground state, quantum Griffith singularity phase and enhancement of the Pauli limit,have also been intensively investigated at extreme conditions,such as at extremely low temperature and large magnetic field.
3.5.2 2D high-temperature superconductors
Extremely low temperatures are required in BCS superconductors, which poses the main obstacle for device applications.Thus, the search for high-temperature superconductors is definitely important.Since the discovery of Cu-based high-temperature superconductors in 1986 and Febased superconductors in 2008, this field has received much research attention.However, conventional BCS theory fails to explain the high-temperature superconductivity.In this case,high-temperature superconductors at the 2D limit could function as a new platform with fine tunability to investigate the underlying mechanism of superconductivity.
As for Fe-based 2D high-temperature superconductors, FeSe on SrTiO3heterostructure is one of the most investigated systems640.Notably, only MBE-grown FeSe monolayer on SrTiO3substrates displays high-temperature superconductivity with a transition temperature (Tc) of 60-100 K, in which the interfacial electron-phonon interaction between the monolayer FeSe and the underlying SrTiO3substrate plays an import role in this unique high-temperature superconductivity.However, with the increasing number of layers, theTcdrops rapidly and no longer behaves as a high-temperature superconductor.Thus, it is believed that the monolayer FeSe/SrTiO3heterostructure system is significantly different from previously investigated bulk Febased high superconductors.
To date, most bulk Cu-based high-temperature superconductors are limited to the Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+x, La2-xSrxCuO4and YBa2Cu3O7-xsystems.Previous studies demonstrated that the high-temperature superconductivity is lifted when the bulk materials were exfoliated down to few monolayers.In fact, it is caused by the degradation of the exfoliated samples under ambient conditions.Recently, monolayer Bi-2212 with good conditions641(here, the monolayer refers to a half unit cell that contains two CuO2planes) has been successfully prepared on a cold stage, which was kept at -40 °C, inside an Ar-filled glove box with water and oxygen content below 0.1 ppm.Most importantly, monolayer Bi-2212 features all the fundamental physical attributes of a high-temperature superconductor, e.g.,pseudogap, charge order and the Mott insulating state.Therefore, the monolayer Bi-2212 can serve as an ideal platform to study its high-temperature superconductivity and other strongly correlated phenomena.
In this section, we have given a short and simple understanding of the recent developments in 2D superconductors,which may stimulate further studies in the area and other strongly correlated systems.
3.6 Magic-angle 2D superlattices
As the thickness of graphene increases, the electronic band structure of graphene would be modified under the influence of interlayer coupling.When two graphene layers are stacked together, rotation between layers would enable the production of moiré superlattices, and the moiré pattern period would be determined by the rotation angle.Therefore, by altering the periodicity of moiré superlattices accordingly, the rotation angle can produce a significant impact on the electronic band structures and properties of twisted bilayer graphene642.In this aspect, in the presence of a small twist angle, the strong interlayer coupling will induce the dramatic changes in the lowenergy spectrum.As predicted theoretically in 2011642, when the twist angle is close to a discrete set of magic angles (1.05°, 0.5°,0.35°, 0.24°, and 0.2°), the Fermi velocity vanishes at the Dirac cones, and the lowest moiré band flattens with an enhanced counterflow conductivity (Fig.19a).With slow movement,electrons would be localized in the superlattices, which would cause the strong correlation in magic-angle superlattice.However, after its initial prediction, it was not until the sensational discovery by Caoetal.in 2018107,108that the experimental observation of strongly correlated physics in magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene (MATBG) was achieved.The fabrication of MATBG devices with uniform twist angle is an important issue that needed to be addressed before the real experimental progress in MATBG.The accurate control over twist angle is the prerequisite to fabricate MATBG devices,which was achieved by the “tear and stack” approach, reported by Kimetal.and later Caoetal.643,644.In detail, after tearing a monolayer graphene single crystal into two pieces using h-BN stamping method, the stamp with one piece of graphene would be subsequently used to pick up the other piece on the substrate after rotating the substrate by 1.1° (Fig.19b).Another issue is how to avoid the further interlayer rotation of MATBG to form the most energetically stable configuration, AB-stacked bilayer graphene (zero-twist angle stacking of bilayer structure).To achieve this, the fabrication of MATBG devices should avoid high temperature, the formation of bubble between two graphene layers, and the additional strains.Note that, CVD approach,which is suitable for the production of graphene films on a large scale, is also capable of growing twist bilayer graphene645.However, it remains difficult to produce twist bilayer graphene with fine control over twist angle, especially the magic angle near zero, owing to the overwhelming stability of AB-stack bilayer graphene.Recent progress in the synthesis of wafer-sized graphene single crystals by CVD approaches also provides an alternative route to fabricate MATBG on large scale, the vertical stacking of wafer-sized single crystals with a controllable rotation angle (magic angle)209.
By successfully fabricating the MATBG devices, Caoetal.experimentally confirmed that when the twisted angle is close to the magic angle, the band structure near the Fermi level would become flat, as theoretically predicted107,108.At around 4 K,metal-insulator transition was also observed at half filling of the flat moiré band, indicating the Mott-like insulator behavior and the presence of strong interlayer electrons coupling in MATBG(Fig.19c).Surprisingly, in the temperature-carrier density phase diagram, there exists superconducting domes flanking the Mott insulator states at low temperature (< 2 K), when tuning the Fermi level away from the charge neutrality to be near halffilling of the moiré band (Fig.19d).The superconducting states were observed both in the MATBG devices with twist angle of 1.05° and 1.16°, in which the critical temperature of 1.05°MATBG device (1.7 K) is higher than that of 1.16° MATBG device (0.5 K).The phase diagram is similar with the superconducting states that flanks Mott states in the unconventional superconductors.The other evidence confirming the similarities between MATBG and unconventional superconductor is the observed linear-in-temperature resistance at higher temperature648.The superconducting behavior occurs in low carrier densities, which is significantly lower than those of other 2D superconductors.This makes the MATBG promising for the investigation of strongly correlated physics.It should be also noted that, the nature of the superconducting states remains unresolved and needs further investigations.
Afterwards, through the investigation of MATBG by STM and STS649, the changes in DOS caused by the formation of superlattices and charge distribution at different filling of moiré band were clearly visualized.In detail, a pseudo-gap phase was observed at partial-filling of the flat band, which is consistent with high-temperature superconductors.In addition, without the formation of a perfect twist angle, it is still possible to achieve the superconducting states by applying hydrostatic pressure,which can reduce the interlayer spacing650.
Beyond the twisted bilayer graphene, superconducting states and correlated insulator were also observed in ABC-trilayerhBN moiré superlattices, in which a vertical displacement field enabled the formation of flat band by breaking the inversion symmetry and isolating the moiré band651,652.In twisted AB-stacked bilayer structure with magic angle, the similar correlated insulating states were achieved by several research groups653,654,and in contrast with MATBG, there was residual resistance after the superconducting-like transition.Recently, displacement field-tunable superconductivity with a maximum critical temperature of 2.1 K was realized in the heterostructure composed of three graphene layers that were stacked with alternating twist angles of 1.56°655.
After the observation of the superconducting states in MATBG, Sharpe and coworkers538reported the observation of stable ferromagnetism in MATBG when the moiré unite cell is three-quarters filled.The longitudinal and Hall resistance as functions of carrier densities or vertical displacement field exhibited several additional resistance peaks at the filling of 1/4,1/2 and 3/4 (Fig.19e).Only at the three-quarters filling region,in the magneto-transport results, the resistance exhibited a hysteretic behavior under the external magnetic field (Fig.19f).Although the hysteresis can be observed over a wide range of displacement field, it should be noted that, it only appears near the three-quarters filling of the conduction moiré band.In addition, this ferromagnetism is sensitive to the current direction, enabling the formation of hysteresis loop between ±50 nA dc bias.Later, well-developed quantum anomalous Hall effects was observed in the MATBG system, in which the quantum anomalous Hall effects should be the result of ferromagnetic topological insulator (Chern insulator)656.
Fig.19 (a) The moiré patterns formed in the twisted bilayer graphene (left).The calculated band energy of the twisted bilayer graphene with twist angle of 1.05° using an ab initio tight-binding method (right) 646.(b) Schematic illustration of the “tear and stack” approach for fabricating the MATBG; (c) measured conductance of MATBG device with a twist angle of 1.08° at the temperature of 0.3 K, the lighter-shaded regions denote the locations of superlattice gaps, while the darker-shaded regions highlight the half-filling states; (d) measured Resistance as function of temperature and carrier densities of the MATBG device with twist angle of 1.08°; (e) measured Rxx as function of carrier density and perpendicular displacement field (D) (Top), inset: the OM image of as-fabricated MATBG device, line cut of Rxx as function of carrier density at D/D0 = -0.22 V·nm-1 (bottom); (f) magnetic field dependence of Rxx and Rxy with n/ns = 0.746 (three-quarter filling) and D/D0 = -0.62 V·nm-1 at 30 mK, the solid and dash line correspond to the results measured while sweeping the magnetic field up and down, respectively 647.
The advent of MATBG-based research has already brought many exciting breakthroughs and discoveries in the scientific community.The future research might focus on the construction of theories to understand the nature of superconducting behaviors of MATBG.It would also be promising that we can produce new superlattice using other emerging 2D materials,including 2D superconductors and 2D magnetic materials.
3.7 Chirality
3.7.1 General concepts of 2D chirality
Chirality is a basic property of nature and exists at various scales from subatom to molecule, supramolecule, nanoscale,macroscale and even to the galaxy657.The chirality at a molecular level is strongly related to the biological structures and functions which controls the DNA duplication and protein folding as well as enzymatic catalysis.Thus, the synthesis of chiral molecules, drug discovery and the understanding of their interaction with the biological systems has long been the main topic of chirality research.On the other hand, chiral molecules can rotate the polarization plane of light when the light passes through the substance, thus leading in a series of unique new properties in materials.Therefore, a deep understanding of chirality at the molecular to nanoscale level will add new values of chirality to the materials.For example, the chirality of the carbon nanotube determines their metallic or semi-metallic properties.Accordingly, when chirality meets 2D materials,many new chirality-related issues would emerge.The integration of chirality will endow 2D materials with advanced chiroptical properties including electronic/vibration circular dichroism(ECD/VCD), Raman optical activity (ROA), circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) and so on.These properties not only provide new insights into the material chirality but also afford potential functional applications.This has been well exemplified by the recent achievements in the syntheses of chiral 2D materials and application developments in the fields of chiral recognition/sensing, asymmetric catalysis, enantioselective separation, pharmaceutical chemistry, biological application,optics, and electric and spintronic devices and so on.As an emergent class of 2D materials, many topics have been documented.For example, Dongetal.658reviewed the construction, optical properties, and electronic properties of novel chiral perovskites and Longetal.659provided a comprehensive summary of the optoelectronic activities and applications.Dangetal.and Maetal.supplemented informative discussions on recent advances of chiral perovskites with an emphasis on crystal structures and underlying chirality transfer mechanism, respectively660,661.Zhaoetal.reviewed the structures, properties and applications of chiral graphene hybrid materials662.Fig.20 summarizes the main topics related to the chiral 2D materials.Here, we just address some basic issues covering the origin of chirality and some typical functional applications of chiral 2D materials with the application focus on chiral 2D perovskites.
Fig.20 Main topics related to the chiral 2D nanomaterials.ORD: optical rotatory dispersion; ECD: electronic circular dichroism; CPL: circularly polarized luminescence;VCD: vibration circular dichroism; ROA: Raman optical activity; SHG: Second-harmonic generation.
So far, many types of 2D materials have been fabricated into chiral ones, including the 2D perovskites302,663-670, graphene671-673,TMDs674-677, 2D organic nanoassemblies678and many more.A key scientific issue is how the chirality is originated and how to endow the 2D materials with chirality.Essentially, the synthesis of chiral 2D materials can be produced with or without the introduction of chiral species.When chiral species are participated in generating chiral 2D materials, these chiral molecules can be covalently, non-covalently or coordinated to the surface or inserting into the layers of 2D nanomaterial.Depending on the types of 2D nanomaterials, different ways of synthesis can be used.For 2D perovskites, the introduction of chiral amines, either on the surface on inserting into the layers is efficient inducing the chirality.In this case, amines are used one of coordination components and play important role in inducing chirality as well as their chiroptical performances.Till now,various types of chiral amines have been used666,679-681.For chiral TMDs, the surface modification by chiral molecules is frequently used.L- or D-cysteine and related sulfur-containing chiral molecules are mostly used as the chiral modifiers676,677.For graphene and its analogues, GO and rGO, the modification by chiral species is frequently used and a large number of chiral molecules can be selected682-684.Besides typical inorganic nanomaterials, supramolecular chiral 2D materials have also attracting great interest.Using Bottom-up strategy and the elegant design of the starting building blocks, supramolecular 2D nanosheet, 2D COFs have been fabricated and unique properties are shown685.
However, upon interaction of the chiral molecules and the achiral 2D materials, the chirality is not always produced.Four different induction mechanisms of chirality generation in chiral 2D materials can be summarized as follows: (i) chiral molecules induce crystallization into individual chiral structure; (ii)electronic interactions induced by the large dipole moments between the chiral molecules and achiral structure; (iii) an achiral core and a chiral surface induced by chiral distortion or chiral ligand aggregation; and (iv) achiral nanomaterials-based chiral self-assembly686-690.These formation mechanisms of chirality are essential for the future designs and performance improvements of chiral 2D materials.
3.7.2 Some typical application of chiral 2D materials
3.7.2.1 Chiral graphene
Graphene is the most famous 2D materials.Although twisted stacking and buckling can cause intrinsic chirality into graphene691-693, direct introduction or post modification of chiral small molecules or chiral macromolecules is the most powerful way of fabricating 2D graphene and its analogy (e.g.,GO and rGO)672.The 2D graphene are more investigated in their chemical and biological applications rather than photonics.The structures, properties, and chirality of graphene-based chiral materials have recently been reviewed662.It appears that the chiral hybrid materials can demonstrate promising applications in nearly all specific areas related to chirality, including asymmetric catalysis, enantio-differentiating detection, and enantioselective crystallization, biological applications and luminescent materials.It should be addressed that many of properties of 2D graphene can be rather like a larger pi-conjugate and many functional materials can be developed.
3.7.2.2 Chiral TMDs
TMD semiconductors have shown a wide range of applications in spintronics and electronic devices.Among the family of TMDs, MoS2is particular interest as a chiral material.For example, Purcell-Miltonetal.reported the fabrication of chiral MoS2nanosheets based on sonication-assisted exfoliation using the chiral ligands like cysteine and penicillamine676.Combined with the theoretical calculation, they showed that circular dichroism (CD) of 2D nanosheets arises from folding in preferential direction induced by chiral ligands.Additionally,Linetal.demonstrated circularly polarized (CP) photoluminescence from the atomic layers of WSe2, which was precisely controlled with chiral metamolecules (MMs) and results in 4-times enhancement in optical chirality675.Both the enhanced and reversed CD had been achieved.However, in comparison with the other system, there are still fewer reports on TMDs.
3.7.2.3 Chiral 2D perovskites
Chirality can be introduced from chiral molecules into halide perovskites, leading to a series of physical features, including CD, CPL, nonlinear optics, ferroelectricity, photovoltaic effects,spintronics and ferromagnetism (Fig.21).Billing and Lemmerer first reported chiral 1D hybrid inorganic-organic perovskites in as early as 2003 and gave insight into the crystalline structure of a series of chiral perovskites in 2006 and 2013694-696.
Fig.21 Physical properties of chiral perovskites.Top left panel reproduced from Ref.697.Top right panel reproduced with permission from Ref.698, Copyright 2021 American Association for the Advancement of Science.Bottom left panel reproduced with permission from Ref.699, Copyright 2019 John Wiley and Sons.Bottom right penal reproduced with permission from Ref.700, Copyright 2020 American Chemical Society.
In 2017, the CD optical behavior of chiral 2D perovskite films were explored686.Subsequent studies further demonstrated that the chiroptical properties of chiral perovskites can be generated by the incorporation of organic cations and be manipulated by changing the chemical compositions, crystal orientations, film thicknesses, and electronic band structure666,679,686.Based on the chiroptical properties, chiral perovskites-based circularly polarized light detection was achieved without requiring extra optical elements, and thus is promising for integrated and flexible devices697,701-705.Besides the differential absorption of lefthanded and right-handed circularly polarized lights (LCPL and RCPL), the differential emission of LCPL and RCPL in chiral HOIPs have been also widespread realized without an external magnetic field688,697,701,706,707.Since the mole fraction of the chiral ligands was positively associated with chirality in chiral 2D perovskites, pure chiral 2D perovskites exhibit the largest chiroptical activity and circularly polarized electroluminescence enable room-temperature spin-polarized light-emitting diode(LED)698.In addition, the incorporation of chiral cation can result in broadband white-light emission, which can be ascribed to the synergetic effects of the organic component and self-trapped excitons induced by the incorporation of organic molecules708.
The non-centrosymmetric chemical structure of chiral perovskites implies their potential in nonlinear optics applications.Second-harmonic generation (SHG), a special type of the second-order nonlinear optics response, was first performed in chiral 2D perovskite nanowires (R- and SMPEA)1.5PbBr3.5(DMSO)0.5and thereafter in various chiral perovskites699,709-714.Those studies shown that SHG signals always depend on polarization, particle size, temperature or wavelength.Therefore, inherent non-centrosymmetric crystal structure renders chiral perovskites promising candidates for nonlinear optics-associated applications.
Chiral perovskites have also gained tremendous research attention in electronic properties such as ferroelectrics,photovoltaic effects and spintronics.Recent studies have shown that the ferroelectric behaviors in chiral perovskites are originated from the broken of spatial-inversion symmetry.Yangetal.synthesized the first homochiral chiral 2D perovskite ferroelectric (R- and S-CMBA)2PbI4with a high Curie temperature of 333 K, which exhibited multiaxial ferroelectric characteristics699.The substitution strategy was applied to obtain chiral 1D perovskite ferroelectric with a higher Curie temperature715,716.The utilization of chiral molecules facilitates the materials crystallized in the special point groups, allowing ferroelectric performance.Moreover, chiral perovskites combine polarity and chirality together and thus drive bulk photovoltaic effects (BPVE), which can generate a steady-state photocurrent without a bias voltage.In 2019, BPVE in a pair of chiral-polar perovskites altered by chirality of the assembled organic cations has been demonstrated717.The chiral components defined the direction of electric polarization produced by the alignment of electric dipole moments in a crystal.Later, spin-dependent photovoltaic and photogalvanic responses of optoelectronic devices based on chiral 2D perovskites were further achieved, leading to the potential applications in optoelectronic devices that are sensitive to the helicity of the circularly polarized light718.In those devices,chiral molecules break the inversion symmetry and further give rise to the chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect and the circular photogalvanic effect (CPGE) response, which result in light-helicity-sensitive photovoltaic devices.
Symmetry breaking in chiral perovskites also contributes to spin polarization and subsequent spintronics.It had been verified that spin-related CPL emission could be modulated by magnetic field706and the CISS effect can directly control spin-polarized properties in chiral perovskites, which are essential for chiral spintronic applications666,719.Furthermore, the high spin polarizations enable chiral perovskites to manipulate the valley polarization (average valley polarization surpassing 10%) of monolayer TMDs in chiral 2D perovskite/monolayer TMD heterostructuresviaefficient spin injection (average spininjection efficiency of 78%) without external magnetic fields663,670.In addition, regulating spin injection in chiral perovskites/monolayer TMD heterostructures by applying an external electric and magnetic fields would be expected to greatly promote the development of chiral perovskite-based spintronic and valleytronic devices.
CISS effect also plays an important role in the opto-spintronic response of chiral perovskites.Recently, magneto-optical detection of photoinduced magnetismviaCISS in chiral 2D perovskites/ferromagnetic NiFe heterostructures has been investigated, which laid a foundation for the primary exploration of magneto-optical and spintronic applications720.Afterwards,the breakthrough of the first chiral 2D perovskite ferromagnets(R-/S-MPEA)2CuCl4with clear ferromagnetic behaviors further revealed the potential of chiral perovskites for opto-spintronic applications700.Undoubtedly, the outstanding physical properties of chiral perovskites offer an advantage in various applications especially in next-generation optoelectronic and spintronic devices.
3.7.2.4 Other chiral 2D materials
g-C3N4is also a well-developed 2D materials that demonstrates chirality.Chenetal.fabricated a mesoporous chiral nematic g-C3N4for efficient hydrogen evolution, which could be modulated by polarized light721.It was found that the mesoporous nematic chiral g-C3N4shows a high enhancement factor of 55 in hydrogen evolution in nematic chiral g-C3N4than that in the bulk g-C3N4.Most interestingly, the chiral g-C3N4material shows unique photocatalytic activity, which is modulated by CPL within the absorption region.Besides, the self-assembled organic 2D materials have also attracting great interest.Shenetal.have reviewed the recent progress in supramolecular 2D materials678.The easy design of the building blocks and the unique structural properties of the chiral 2D materials open new avenue in broad applications such as enantiomeric separation, asymmetric catalysis, and optoelectronic devices.
4 Potential applications
4.1 Electronics
4.1.1 Fabrication and architecture of 2d field-effect transistors
The metal-oxide-semiconductor field-effect transistor(MOSFET) is widely used in both analog and digital circuits.Depending on the channel polarity of MOSFETs, they can be divided into n-channel type with most electrons and p-channel type with most holes, which are usually called n-MOSFETs and p-MOSFETs, respectively.Moore’s law has supported the global information technology industry to nearly double the performance and functionality of integrated circuit every two years within a fixed cost and area.However, with the development of Moore’s law, the decreasing trend of node series and size becomes slower.Traditional silicon-based semiconductors are difficult to meet the requirements of International Technology Roadmap for Semiconductors (ITRS).Because of atomic-scale thickness, 2D materials benefit from danglingbond-free surfaces and from good gate control ability in electronics application.Black phosphorus, like other 2D semiconductors, exhibits the steep subthreshold swings due to the suitable band gap.Moreover, black phosphorus holds a reasonably high mobility (exceed 1000 cm2·V-1·s-1).Taking advantage of these exotic features, 2D semiconductors have received significant attention in the post-Moore era.Particularly,owing to natural passivation and gate electrostatics, 2D fieldeffect transistors (FETs) have great potential for next-generation integrated electronics applications.
4.1.1.1 Status of n-FET and p-FET
Different from traditional silicon-based FETs, the channel material of 2D FETs is usually 2D semiconductors at the atomic level.The metal-oxide-semiconductor capacitor locates in the center of the device is the core of the FETs.Metal electrodes are usually used for the source and drain, such as Au, Pt, Cu,etc.Utilizing the application of a gate voltage that passes through the 2D channel, the current is controlled between the source and drain electrodes.On the one hand, the gate voltage can generate a transverse electric field that depletes the carrier channel.Then,there is no current flow between the source and drain electrodes,namely off-state.On the other hand, the transverse electric field also can enhance the concentration of carriers to allow current to flow in the channel region, namely on-state.Usually, the offstate current is as small as possible, and the on-state current is larger than 104-105compared with the off-state current.
For n-MOSFETs based on monolayer TMDs, the electrons in the conduction bands of TMD are the transport carriers in the channel region.Analogously, the holes in the valance bands of TMD are the transport carriers in the channel region of p-MOSFETs.Experimentally, the carrier types of 2D channel materials can be controlled by doping, passivation, and surface modification.When a positive voltage is applied to the gate, the negatively charged electrons are attracted to the surface, forming channels that allow most of the n-type semiconductor’s carrier electrons to flow from the source to the drain.If this voltage is removed, the channel cannot form and carriers cannot flow between the source and drain, which is the gate voltage that can be used to switch the channel on and off.When a negative voltage is applied to the gate of p-MOSFET, the holes in the semiconductor are attracted to the surface to form channels, and most of the carrier holes in the semiconductor can flow from the source to the drain.If this negative voltage is removed, or if a positive voltage is applied, then no channel can be formed and carriers cannot flow between the source and drain.
Usually, the performance of a FET can be assessed in two forms: the output characteristics and transfer characteristics.Transfer characteristics, or transfer curves can be obtained by plotting drain current (Id) as a function of the gate voltage (Vg),often refer to as theId-Vgcurve.At a fixed drain voltage, the different gate voltage could change the energy levels, which are filled at the injection point of the source electrode.On-state and off-state current (IonandIoff, respectively) are obtained from transfer characteristics.Additionally, the subthreshold slope(SS), often used to evaluate the switching speed of the FET, can be extracted from the transfer curve.In general, the SS of MOSFET can not be lower than 60 mV·dec-1at room temperature (300 K).Output characteristics are obtained by drawing drain current (Id) as a function of drain-source voltage(Vds).A FET should presentIdsaturation above certainVds.In an integrated circuit, the constant saturation current withVdsis important because devices are interconnected.As a result, even when theVdsbeing supplied to individual device is different, the current from each device will remains the same722.
4.1.1.2 CMOS demonstration
n-type MOSFETs and p-type MOSFETs are basic components that can be produced on a silicon wafer template.Because n-MOS and p-MOS are complementary in physical properties, it is called Complementary Metal-Oxide-Semiconductor (CMOS).CMOS has the advantage of consuming energy only when the transistor needs to be switched on and off.Therefore, it saves power and generates less heat, and it is also the most basic and commonly used semiconductor device in terms of technology.Low static power consumption and high noise immunity are two important characteristics of CMOS devices.Since one transistor of the MOSFET pair is always at off state, the series combination only draws significant power momentarily during switching phase between on and off states.As a result, CMOS does not generate as much waste heat as other forms of logic devices like transistor logic and NMOS logic,which usually involves some constant current even outside of the switching phase.These features allow CMOS to integrate with high-density on a chip.Consequently, CMOS is without doubt the most widely used technology in very large-scale integration(VLSI) chips.
4.1.2 Key challenges for 2D electronics
4.1.2.1 Contact issue
As the size of transistors continues to shrink, the influence of contact resistance (Rc) on the performance of transistors becomes increasingly critical, especially the current density improvement at the limiting channel size.The main cause ofRcis the energy barrier (Schottky barrier) formed between the contact metal and semiconductor, owing to the energy difference between the work function of the metal and the electron affinity of the semiconductor723.LowRcis essential in device operation,and can be generally achievedviatwo approaches: (1) reduce the Schottky barrier width using highly doped contact; (2) minimize the energy barriers for charge carrier transport (Schottky-Mott rule)viachoosing appropriate metals with work functions matching the semiconductor band edges724,725.In advanced microelectronics industry, silicon based devices realize low contact resistance (Rc< 0.1 kΩ·μm) and high current density (Ion>1 mA·μm-1) by doping the contact region with ion implementation.However, 2D materials do not have good compatibility with ion implementation because the high energy of ion beam will easily destroy the atomically thin lattice structure of 2D materials.Although some methods of chemically doping the contact region have been developed to reduce theRc,these methods have the disadvantage of being unstable726.In order to achieve Ohmic contact, many metals matched with the electron affinity energy of 2D materials are used as the source/drain electrodes of the devices727.However, it is difficult to reduce the Schottky barrier andRcto the ideal level because of the unavoidable chemical disorder and Fermi-level pinning effect at metal-semiconductor interfaces728.
To address this challenge, many approaches have been developed to reduce theRcof devices.For example, phase engineering to create lateral metal-semiconductor-metal heterojunctions373; formation of clean interfacesviavdW contacts using graphene and low-melting-point metal729-732; mechanical transfer of metal films and using h-BN as the tunnel barrier733-735.These methods can effectively reduce theRc, but which are still far from the level of silicon-based devices.Recently, researchers from MIT and TSMC reported the Ohmic contact between semimetal Bi and semiconducting monolayer TMDs where the Femi-level pining effect are sufficiently suppressed and the degenerate states in TMDs are spontaneously formed in contact with Bi (Fig.22a, b).In this work, they achieved a zero Schottky barrier height (Fig.22c), aRcof 123 Ω·μm (Fig.22d) and an onstate current density of 1135 μA·μm-1(Fig.22e) on monolayer MoS2, which is a hallmark breakthrough in the field of 2D electronics (Fig.22f)736.Due to the low melting temperature, the issue of reliability and process compatibility of Bi still need to be further considered.Nevertheless, achieving similar contact resistance with Si CMOS significantly boosts the potential of TMDs as channel materials for sub-2 nm technology node.
4.1.2.2 Doping of 2D semiconductors
Fig.22 (a) Schematic of a 2D FET with a monolayer semiconductor (MoS2) channel and semimetal (Bi) contacts.The degenerate part of Bi-contacted MoS2 due to gap-state saturation (GSS) is marked in orange colour.(b) The DOS of semimetal and semiconductor contact.Because the Fermi level of the semimetal aligns with the conduction band of the semiconductor, and the DOS at the Fermi level of the semimetal is near-zero, conduction-band contributed metal-induced gap states (MIGS) are suppressed and the branching point is elevated into the conduction band.The MIGS, now mostly contributed by the valence band, are saturated, leading to gap-state saturation.(c) Arrhenius plots of the Ohmic Bi-MoS2 (blue) and Schottky Ni-MoS2 (red) FETs at a carrier density (n2D) of 1.5 × 1012 cm-2 and VDS of 1 V.A 30-meV and negligible barrier for Ni-MoS2 and Bi-MoS2 FETs, respectively, are extracted.(d) Contact resistance (Rc) extraction using the transfer-length method (TLM) for Bi-MoS2 FETs on 100-nm-thick SiNx dielectrics.Blue squares and black circles are total resistance vs.channel length at carrier densities of 5.6 × 1012 and 1.5 × 1013 cm-2, respectively.Inset, False colour SEM image of the TLM structure.Scale bar, 1 μm.(e) IDS-VDS curves of a 35 nm LCH Bi-MoS2 FET.VGS changes from -10 V to 30 V with steps of 10 V.Inset, SEM image of the 35 nm LCH device.(f) State-of-the-art contact technology for MoS2 transistors plotted as a function of carrier density, showing the respective Rc of various semiconductor technologies(Si, III-Vs, and MoS2).The black line represents the quantum limit of Rc 736.
In general, doping of semiconductors has two important functions for electronic devices.One is to heavy-doping the contact region to reduce theRcof the device; the other is to realize n-type and p-type material features to construct complementary circuits.For example, in the 22 nm node Si CMOS, the well-designed doping concentration with a relatively high value (> 1020cm-3) under the contact regions and a moderate value (~1018cm-3) within the channel is carefully realized using the advanced implementation technique with ultra-steep doping profiles737.Nevertheless, conventional doping by ion implantation is not suitable for 2D materials due to their atomic thickness722.Hence, sophisticated doping techniques are required to preserve the structure and intrinsic properties of 2D materials as well as modulate them according to required applications.n-type or p-type doping can be realized by substitution depending on the number of valence electrons in the dopant atom738.However, due to the reduced screening in atomically thin materials, the ionization energy is much higher than in bulk semiconductors, leading to low doping efficiency739.Novel synthetic methods have been developed to confront this challenge.For example, the surface doping takes advantage of the charge transfer interaction between the host material and surface adatoms726,740, gas molecules and supporting substrates741.Since the dopants lie out of the transport pathways of the charge carriers, such modulated doping successfully avoid lattice distortion, resulting in high carrier mobility.Among them, doping by surface adatoms and gas molecules may lead to ideal performance however is not practical due to the poor stability.To this end, a promising solution would be the incorporation of high-κdielectrics through industrially friendly atomic layer deposition to transfer charge from the solid dopants742.
4.1.2.3 Mobility engineering
Carrier mobility is the most important figure of merit for the performance of semiconductor devices.Taking monolayer MoS2and WS2 as examples, the theoretical phonon limiting mobility at room temperature is about 410 cm2·V-1·s-1743and 1100 cm2·V-1·s-1744, respectively, which are much higher than the value of silicon on insulator at the same thickness (Fig.23c).This is a clear advantage of 2D materials for transistor dimension scaling and continuation of Moore’s Law.But the experimentally measured results are often much lower than the theoretical values, which is in practice limited by disorder and the presence of scattering sources745.The intrinsic charged point defects or other defects at the semiconductor/dielectric interface or the surrounding dielectric media can trap charges or scatter mobile charge carriers.At close to room temperature, the intrinsic and remote optical phonons in the 2D semiconductor environment can further limit the mobility55.
In order to improve the mobility of 2D materials, the carrier transport process of 2D materials has been analyzed in detail by the theoretical model746.It has been found that the factors limiting carrier transmission mainly include intrinsic electronphonon scattering743,747, surface optical phonon743, coulomb impurities748,749, atomic defect scattering750and charge trap751(Fig.23a).Many approaches have been attempted to improve the performance of 2D transistors (Fig.23c).For example, reducing the atomic defects in 2D materials by optimized synthetic methods98,752,753and by defect repairing745;insituannealing in vacuum to eliminate the impurities originating from the fabrication process or adsorbates from the atmosphere754; using interface engineering (such as high-κdielectrics113,755, h-BN encapsulation749,756and self-assembled monolayer745) to reduce the coulomb scattering by dielectric screening755.Especially the room temperature mobility of monolayer MoS2can reach ~150 cm2·V-1·s-1combining with sulfur vacancy repairing and high-κsubstrate (Fig.23b), which is close to the theoretical value considering remote optical phonon scattering757.At present,high performance single transistors have been experimentally verified, but most of them are based on the preparation of mechanically exfoliated samples736,757.How to achieve the performance of large-area thin film transistor arrays is urgently need to be considered by optimizing CVD or MOCVD growth processes742.
Fig.23 (a) Electron transport mechanism in MoS2 channel devices, including electron-phonon scattering, remote phonon scattering, charge impurity scattering, defection scattering and electron trap.Reproduced with permission from Ref.758, Copyright 2017 Acta Physica Sinica.(b) Field-effect mobility as a function of temperature for two monolayer MoS2 FETs on HfO2 substrate with thiol treatment under n = 10.5 × 1012 cm-2(symbols), together with the best theoretical fi ttings (solid lines), the calculated CI-limited mobility (dashed lines), and the calculated phonon-limited mobility (black dotted line).Reproduced with permission from Ref.757, Copyright 2018 John Wiley and Sons.(c) Mobility vs.semiconductor channel thickness, covering silicon on insulator, some promising 2D materials 5.
4.1.2.4 Gate dielectrics
The dielectric-semiconductor interface has been a central topic not only for conventional Si but also for the emerging 2D semiconductors.The utilization of high-κdielectrics on thin 2D layers is critical to the application of 2D FETs in advanced technology nodes, where the criteria of the high-κdielectrics are similar to the Si FETs, such as good dielectric integrity and wafer-scale uniformity, ultrathin electrical thickness for avoiding short-channel” effects, scalable deposition for top-gate devices, and low defects density in 2D-dielectric interfaces.To achieve high electrical performance in either planar FETs,FinFETs or stacked nanosheet FETs759, it is critical to have the top-gate or gate-all-around process compatibility.Therefore,high-κoxides based on atomic layer deposition (ALD) are still the most promising dielectrics for 2D FET applications.
The surface of 2D semiconductors such as TMDs is in principle free-of dangling bonds, which makes the seeding of ALD oxides challenging.Various approaches have been proposed to overcome the issue.Treatment on surfaces to generate reactive sites and improve precursor wetting on 2D layers: A variety of surface treatment methods have been reported, including UV-ozone760and exposure with different plasma gases (H2, O2, H2etc.)761,762.However, these methods typically introduce damages to the 2D lattices, leading to deterioration in electrical quality.Extended studies involve the modification of conventional ALD process to improve the highκdeposition.Low-temperature physical adsorption of H2O and ALD precursors was used for nucleation and a continuous Al2O3gate oxide with a thickness of less 10 nm on WS2was achieved763as shown in Fig.24a.Adding a buffer layer to promote seeding and avoid damages on 2D: There has been demonstration on the deposition of thin metal seed layer on 2D followed by mild oxidation to form a seeding oxide layer764and the potential damages of 2D were likely related to the initial metal deposition step.Other approaches using organic film or molecules have led to success to avoid damages on 2D layers owing to their lowtemperature processes765although there might be concerns on the controllability of the molecular deposition.A recent work by Lietal.has demonstrated the use of the vapor-phase-deposited PTCDA molecules as the seeding layer followed by ALD HfO2to achieve a high-κoxide with an EOT of ~1 nm film (Fig.24b)766.The reliability of the ultrathin oxides by this approach has also been demonstrated promising767if it can be reproduced more broadly.
Fig.24 (a) Schematic layer structure, AFM topography image and the TEM cross-sectional image of the Al2O3 nucleation layer grown on WS2 layers with 20 ALD cycles at 50 °C with a short N2 purge time of 1 s.Reproduced with permission from Ref.763, Copyright 2020 American Chemical Society.(b) Schematic of using evaporated PTCDA molecular layer as the seeding layer for growing ultrathin HfO2 ALD oxides as shown on the cross-sectional TEM images.Reproduced with permission from Ref.766, Copyright 2019 Springer Nature.
4.1.3 Emerging computing technology based on 2D materials
With many unique electronic and optoelectronic properties768,769, 2D materials are promising for emerging computing technologies.In this section, we will provide a brief overview of recent progress in 2D material-based logic circuits,neuromorphic computing.
4.1.3.1 Logic circuits
The excellent electrostatic control of electrical field over the atomically-thin channel enables 2D materials to be useful not only for ultra-scaled FET770and logic circuits94,771-776, but also in drastically simplifying the complex design of conventional silicon-based circuits777-787.Most of semiconducting TMDs are intrinsically n-type doped and can be used for the fabrication of n-type FET (Fig.25a).Integrating a large number of n-type FETs allows for the realization of logic circuits with complex functions94,771-774.As shown in Fig.25b, a 1-bit microprocessor consisting of 115 CVD-grown MoS2film transistors was successfully demonstrated773.With further advances in the CVD synthesis of wafer-scale 2D materials, higher density integration of MoS2transistors (i.e., 1518 devices per cm2) has been demonstrated for flexible integrated logic circuits applications including five-stage ring oscillators774.In addition to the widely used CVD method, solution-processable 2D semiconductor nanosheets have been used for high-performance large-area logic circuits, opening up an alternative way for scalable fabrication of large-area arrays of 2D FETs94.Alternative to conventional size downscaling, improving area-efficiency may offer another promising solution to improve the performance of logic circuits.By using two surface channels of individual 2D semiconductors, dual-gate single devices can serve as distinct logic gates with higher area-efficiency than silicon-based circuits (Fig.25c)785,787.Changing the dual-gate geometry into splitting gate architecture, 8 different switching states can be realized in the ambipolar WSe2material based electricallytunable homojunction devices (Fig.25d), which is desirable for constructing reconfigurable multifunctional logic circuits in a high area-efficiency manner783.Similarly, 2D semiconductor heterostructure based multifunctional logic circuit (i.e., threevalue logic inverter) was reported by using gate-tunable band alignment, showing great potential for future logic applications778,788.
Fig.25 Logic circuits based on 2D materials.(a) The schematic of a typical n-type FET.(b) A 1-bit microprocessor based on 115 CVD-grown MoS2 transistors 773.(c) High-efficiency logic gate circuit based on 2D materials 787.(d) Reconfigurable logic circuit based on 2D ambipolar transistors 783.
4.1.3.2 Neuromorphic computing
Nonvolatile memory devices are the building block for inmemory computing and neuromorphic computing788-790, which hold promise in solving the challenges associated with the von Neumann bottleneck.As one typical nonvolatile memory,silicon-based flash memory devices have been commercialized,but suffering from the issues of slow writing/erasing speed.By employing the high-quality interface and suitable band offset of vdW heterostructures (vdWHs), around 20 ns writing/erasing speed has been recently achieved in the vdWH based floating gate transistors (FGT), which is orders of magnitude faster than that of the traditional silicon-based floating gate devices (Fig.26a)791-793.When such atomically thin 2D materials based floating gate transistor is used as the memory element, it is suitable for designing a programmable inverter and implementing more complex programmable logic circuits for future low-power electronics794.Thermal stability is critical to the robust operation of the nonvolatile memory devices.Traditional silicon-device cannot be operated above 200 °C without any cooling, limiting their applications in hightemperature electronics.Wangetal.for the first time fabricated the graphene/MoS2-xOx/graphene vdWH robust memristor with operating temperature up to 340 °C (Fig.26b)795, by exploiting superior thermal and chemical stabilities of graphene and MoS2.The memristive behavior was also observed in fewlayer 2D insulator h-BN, which had been used to emulate synaptic behaviors796,797.By further reducing down to monolayer, the memristive behaviors have been recently demonstrated in many 2D semiconducting materials and vdWHs, which are attributed to different working mechanisms(Fig.26c)798,799.Besides the reported field-driven ionic migration mechanism, field-driven lateral migration of grain boundary in the polycrystalline 2D semiconducting materials800and field-driven structural phase transition in 2D thin films801have also been utilized for the implementation of memristive devices for neuromorphic computing.
Fig.26 Neuromorphic computing based on 2D materials.(a) The schematic of a typical floating gate transistor 791.(b) Robust memristor based on graphene/MoS2-xOx/graphene vdWH 795.(c) Atomristor based on monolayer MoS2;reproduced with permission from Ref.799, Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society.
4.2 Optoelectronics
4.2.1 Categorization and figure of merit for optoelectronics
4.2.1.1 Categorization of optoelectronics
4.2.1.1.1 Photodetectors
The photodetector is a type of device which converts a light signal into an electrical signal and plays an important role in various applications, such as imaging, temperature measurement and fire alarm.According to the wavelength of the incident light,photodetectors include ultraviolet, visible, and infrared detectors.On the other hand, due to different photocurrent generation mechanisms, two kinds of photodetectors are introduced.One is a photon detector, in which the photon makes free carriers in semiconductors transit, including the photoconductive effect, photovoltaic effect, and photogating effect.The other is related to the thermal effect, including the photothermoelectric and bolometric effect802.
For example, Lvetal.reported 2D homojunction diodes and multifunctional devices based on the spatially controlled ferroelectric domains803.A MoS2lateral homojunction device was obtained by a probe technique.MoS2homojunction photodetector exhibits an obvious photoresponse under 520 nm laser illumination.The open-circuit voltage is over 0.6 V.Atomically thin 2D heterojunctions with vdW heterointerfaces are fabricated.However, due to serious interlayer Shockley-Read-Hall (SRH) and Langevin recombination, thin 2D heterojunction devices don’t meet the requirements of electronic and optoelectronic applications804.Tanetal.also demonstrated a WSe2/PtS2vdW tunneling heterojunction because PtS2is narrow-bandgap 2D material with high mobility805.The reverse rectification ratio of WSe2/PtS2is over 108.Compared to conventional semiconductors-based backward diodes, vdW tunneling diodes exhibit a higher rectification ratio and show great potential in high-speed and low-power devices806,807.On the other hand, Wuetal.designed a unilateral depletion structure based on AsP and MoS2.A unilateral depletion can effectively reduce the severe interface recombination.Furthermore, a narrow bandgap AsP is an excellent contact layer.Finally, a high external quantum efficiency of 71% and a fast response time of 9 μs are obtained808.It is noteworthy that Chenetal.design a novel vdW nBn structure809.A thick h-BN is inserted and used to block the major carriers.nBn WS2/h-BN/PdSe2devices with perfect interfaces are achieved.Since a large conduction band barrier of h-BN exists, the major carrier-electrons in WSe2and PdSe2do not transport.Therefore, the dark-current of WS2/h-BN/PdSe2photodetector is severely suppressed in contrast to that of vdW junction devices.Further, WS2/h-BN/PdSe2exhibits an obvious superiority in light on/off ratio.
4.2.1.1.2 Photovoltaic devices
Photovoltaic processes mainly occur in the junction (p-n junction or Schottky junction)810,811.During irradiation,electron-hole pairs (photogenerated carriers) are generated from incident photons with energy equal to or higher than the semiconductor bandgap.Due to the internal electric field of the junction, electron-hole pairs are separated and can be collected by the electrodes to generate electricity, so the device’sI-Vcurve will be shifted vertically when exposed to light.Under the working condition, the maximum output voltage generated by the device in the open circuit state is called the open circuit voltage, and the maximum output current of the device when the external circuit load is zero is called the short-circuit current.In order to make a quantitative performance evaluation of photovoltaic devices, one of the important characteristic quality factors is the filling factor (FF), which is defined as the ratio of the maximum available power and the product of the opencircuit voltageVOCand short-circuit currentISC.FF represents the ratio of the maximum power output by the device to the theoretical power.The formula is expressed as
FF =Pmax/VOCISC
where,Pmaxis the maximum power obtained.The shunt resistanceRSH= dV/dIis mainly related to carrier compound loss, and the device characteristic resistance isRCH=VOC/ISC.FF can be further improved by lowering the parameter ofRCH/RSH.In addition, the power conversion efficiency (PCE), which is the percentage of the power of the incident photon converted to electrical power, can also be used as a device performance criterion.PCE can be calculated by the following formula:
PCE =Pmax/Pin
wherePinis the input power.In fact, the atomic thickness of 2D crystals makes them extremely sensitive to the surroundings environments.In photovoltaic devices, the defects and unwanted interface states can not only significantly limit carrier mobility,but also act as recombination centers for the photogenerated electrons and holes, seriously affecting the device’s internal quantum efficiency and overall performance812,813.
4.2.1.1.3 Optical modulator and lasers
Optical modulator is a key functional device in optical fiber communication network and optical interconnection.At present,people have put forward higher requirements for such devices in terms of speed, volume, power consumption, integration and so on.When 2D materials are used to make modulator, the absorbance of the material is controlled by electric field: the absorption characteristics of 2D materials are changed by using different voltages to achieve the purpose of modulation814.The refractive index of a material can usually be written in the form of a complex refractive index:
n=nr+ ini
wherenrrepresents the real part of the refractive index andnirepresents the imaginary part of the refractive index.Both the real part and the imaginary part are changed by voltage regulation.If the voltage is used to change the real part of the refractive index, the phase of light transmission in the medium will change to some extent, and a phase-type modulator can be made.In addition, a better modulation effect can be obtained by enhancing the interaction between the light field and the 2D material.The integrated optical modulator with high modulation speed, small size and large bandwidth is expected to be a low power device for optical interconnection.By integration of modulator and photodetector into waveguide or fiber laser system, high performance ultrafast laser can be realized to produce ultrashort, low loss and wide-band laser.The modulation part can control the laser stability by active mode locking, while the detection part can provide feedback of the laser stability.
In fact, the fundamental cause of modulator operation depends on the nonlinear optical properties of the material which originates from the non-resonant motion of bound electrons under the applied electric field815.Thus, the formulas for simulating the linear and nonlinear responses under the applied electric field,E, can be expressed as:
whereε0is vacuum permittivity, the main factor that concerns the optical nonlinearity of materials is the third-order susceptibilityχ(3).The real part ofχ(3)is related to the nonlinear phase transition of incident light field caused by material, which is known as Kerr effect.
The laser mainly consists of a gain medium which can produce photons, an optical resonator which can make photons get feedback and can resonate and amplify in the gain medium,and a pump source device which can make the medium in the excited state.Due to the strong exciton-photon interaction, the thin layer 2D semiconductor material can be used as the gain medium, and different resonator structures can be designed to obtain ultra-low threshold and ultra-fast optical/electrically modulated lasers816-820.The laser also can be controlled by passive mode-locking without adding a modulator in the fiber.Its basic principle is to use of optical fiber nonlinear effect on the dependence of the intensity of the input pulse, and the effect can be equivalent to a saturated absorber effect.It is equivalent to a special material that has a smaller absorption coefficient for a larger light intensity and a larger absorption coefficient for a smaller light intensity.Thus, the optical pulse can be narrowed.Therefore, it is modeled as
whereαnsis non-saturable loss andαsis modulation depth(saturable loss),Isatis the saturation intensity.
4.2.1.2 Figure of merit of optoelectronics based on photocurrent generation mechanisms
4.2.1.2.1 Photoconductive effect
For the photoconductive effect, the photogenerated excess carriers make free carrier concentration in semiconductors increase, as illustrated in Fig.27.The excess carriers are driven and collected under the applied bias thus forming the photocurrent.For instance, the device possesses a small dark current in dark conditions.When the device is illuminated,electron-hole pairs produced by the absorbed photons are separated by the applied bias and collected by the electrodes,respectively.The photocurrent of the device is larger than the dark current.It is worth noting that the photocurrent of photoconductive effect has to be produced with an applied bias voltage.
Fig.27 (a) Schematic image of PC detector.(b) The energy band structure of PC devices with and (c) without illumination.(c) Typical output characteristic (I-V) curves of PC device in dark and light states and photogenerated current Ip as a function of bias voltage.(d) Typical transfer characteristic (I-Vg) curves of PC devices in dark and light states.(e) Two key parameters (Responsivity and Detectivity) of a detector as a function of wavelength.(f) A key parameter (Response speed) of a detector with two typical presentations.
4.2.1.2.2 Photovoltaic effect
The photogenerated electron-hole pairs are separated and accelerated by the built-in electric field of a Schottky or p-n junction.The direction of the junction determines the direction of the photocurrent.The junctional devices have a low dark current and fast response speed due to the built-in electric field.Thus, this kind of device often works under zero or reverse bias.Meanwhile, a higher quantum efficiency could be realized.By fabricating heavily doped p-n junctions, the avalanche photodiodes can be obtained, which are used to detect weak light, even down to single photon.
4.2.1.2.3 Photogating effect
It is actually a special case of the photoconductive effect.The corresponding devices are considered photoconductive photodetectors.Since low-dimensional materials have a higher defect concentration, this effect is introduced.Generally, the e-h pairs are produced under illumination.If the photogenerated electrons or holes are trapped in the defects or the adjacent semiconductor layer.These charged defects could act as an external and local gate, which would change the channel conductance.The devices usually possess higher responsivity and gain due to a long carrier lifetime.
4.2.1.2.4 Photothermoelectric effect
It is a thermal effect caused by the localized lighting that results in a temperature gradient across the device, when the spot of the illumination is smaller than the size of the channel.This temperature difference would result in a thermoelectric voltage.Alternatively, temperature gradient on the channel could also be induced under a globe lighting when the light absorption at different parts of the device varies.The produced thermoelectric voltage is often small and changes from µV to mV.It is closely related to the Seebeck coefficient of semiconductors and metals821.
4.2.1.2.5 Bolometric effect
The bolometric effect refers to the phenomenon that the resistivity of a temperature-sensitive material increases or decreases when the materials are illuminated and heated by a uniform light.The photocurrent caused by the bolometric effect changes linearly with the applied bias voltage.The key difference between PTE and PBE is that the PTE photocurrent is self-driven, which is similar to that in photovoltaic devices,while PBE photocurrent could be only observed under applying external bias.
4.2.2 Key challenges for optoelectronics
4.2.2.1 Wide and narrow bandgap
Although 2D optoelectronics have been developed rapidly in recent years, there are still several key challenges for 2D optoelectronics.Among 2D materials, those 2D materials with wide bandgaps (3 eV) and narrow bandgaps (< 1 eV) usually exhibit more attractive optical properties.Taking photodetection as an example, 2D semiconductor materials (Fig.28a) with wide bandgaps can be used for ultraviolet (UV) photodetection due to the band-absorption cut-off wavelength.Yangetal.reported UV photodetection under 325 nm based on 2D GeS2with a bandgap of 3.71 eV (Fig.28b)822.Furthermore, Weietal.reported a new 2D material (GaPS4) with an ultralarge bandgap of 4.5 eV at monolayer condition in Fig.28c, showing high responsivity(4.89 A·W-1), high detectivity (1.98 × 1012Jones), and high quantum efficiency (2390%) in the solar-blind ultraviolet region823.There are more and more 2D materials with wide bandgaps are discovered recently824-827, which is meaningful for the missile tracking and national security.On the other hand, 2D materials with narrow bandgaps are also important especially for infrared photodetection.Narrow-bandgap semiconductors have been studied intensively such as black phosphorous (0.3 eV for bulk to 2.0 eV for monolayer)828for near-wave infrared (NWIR)and mid-wave infrared (MWIR) photodetection829,830, AsP (0.3-0.15 eV with varying stoichiometric ratio) for MWIR photodetection831-833, and noble metal chalgenides for MWIR photodetection834,835, and so on836-839.However, most reported 2D semiconductors with narrow bandgaps exhibit poor gatemodulated carrier-transportation characteristics, resulting in uncontrollable optoelectrical properties.Recently, the electrical and optical properties of Te have been simulated indicating that its effective charge carriers masses are three to four times smaller than that of MoS2840, and the optical bandgap has been proved to be ~0.3 eV841.Thus, it is promising for gate-tunable MWIR photodetection.Recently Furukawaetal.synthesized ultrathin Te flakes (Fig.28d)842, which exhibit air-stable performance at room temperature for more than 2 months, on/off ratios on the order of 106, and field-effect mobilities of about 700 cm2·V-1·s-189.Then Huetal.reported high performance MWIR photodetection based on 2D Te flakes under 3 μm840.Thus, 2D Te quickly became one of the most promising candidates for NWIR and MWIR photodetection.However, 2D semiconductors are much difficult for further long-wave infrared (LWIR) detection due to the intrinsic bandedge-absorption.2D semimetals are promising for LWIR even terahertz photodetection due to the nearly zero bandgaps (Fig.28b).
Fig.28 (a, e, f) Schematics of band structure of semiconductor and semimetal.Calculated band structures of GeS2 (b), monolayer GaPS4 (c), Te (d); (b) reproduced with permission from Ref.822,Copyright 2019 John Wiley and Sons; (c) reproduced with permission from Ref.823, Copyright 2021 John Wiley and Sons.(d) Schematic band structure of trigonal tellurium 842.
On the other hand, graphene is a typical Dirac semimetal with zero-bandgap or small bandgap induced by chemical doping,shows great promise in LWIR and terahertz photodetectors843.However, the high dark current and low photoabsorption of grapheme photodetectors result in high noise, lower responsivity and low detectivity, which are not ideal in practical application844-846.Recently, 2D metallic TMDs, such as PdTe2and PtTe2have been discovered as topological semimetals showing exotic band structure such as type-II Dirac cone847,848.Without Lorentz invariance, type-II Weyl fermions can also be realized when inversion symmetry or time-reversal is broken,and possibly exhibit chiral-related transport, such as quantized photogalvanic effect, anomalous thermoelectric, and chiral anomaly.Chenetal.reported a PdTe2-based photodetector with large photogalvanic effects and high anisotropy at terahertz frequency.A responsivity of 10 A·W-1and a noise-equivalent power lower than 2 pW·Hz-0.5is achieved at room temperature847.2D Weyl semimetals (Fig.28c) are a new family of 2D family such as TaIrTe4849, Td-WTe2850, Td-MoTe2851, and so on, which have exhibited much attractive exotic optoelectronic phenomena.For example, under 4-μm excitation at room temperature, TaIrTe4shows a large photoresponsivity of 130.2 mA·W-1, arising from the third-order nonlinear optical response,which approaches the performance of commercial lowtemperature detectors852.In another example, robust edge photocurrent response was demonstrated on layered type II Weyl semimetal WTe2, mainly due to crystalline-symmetry breaking along certain crystal fracture directions853.
4.2.2.2 2D heterostructures for optoelectronics
vdWHs fabricated by stacking 2D materials one by one artificially, but open unprecedented possibilities of combining them for technological use.Due to the lack of lattice matching at the interfaces, such stacking is very different from the traditional bulk semiconductor heterostructures.What’s more,the charge transfers between the layers could be very large which induces large electric fields at the interface and offers possibilities in band-structure engineering, which will affect the optoelectrical properties significantly854,855.For example,infrared photodetectors based on single 2D material usually exhibit photoconductive or photogating effect, resulting in slow response rates from milliseconds to minutes, and high dark currents or low detectivity856.This can be solved by fabricating heterostructures with strong built-in electric fields easily.Huet al.reported that PdSe2/MoS2based photodetector shows a fast response rate of 51.3 μs and a high detectivity as 109Jones even for 10.6 μm LWIR detection856.Also, the ballistic avalanche phenomenon was observed in vertical InSe/BP heterostructures with suitable thickness.In contrast to the conventional avalanche behavior, the ionization collision coefficient per primary carrier is equal to one in the ballistic avalanche effect, resulting in a small avalanche breakdown voltage, a lower avalanche noise,and positive temperature coefficients with an almost constant multiplication factor.Thus, the device are impact-ionization transistors with a steep subthreshold swing (< 0.25 mV·dec-1)and sensitive mid-infrared light detection (4 μm wavelength)857.In another example, an infrared photodetector was realized by the interlayer excitons (ILEs) generated between tungsten and hafnium disulfide.Peak responsivities of 8.2 × 102and 9.5 × 102A·W-1were observed for 3L = WS2/HfS2heterostrucrure on laser illuminations ofλ= 4.7 and 4.3 μm, respectively858.
2D semiconductors with strong exciton binding energies are promising for room-temperature excitonic.However, single 2D semiconductors usually show short exciton diffusion length.To this end, taking advantage of of the spatial separation of e-h pairs in adjacent layers of vdWHs, it is possible to overcome this limitation and enable the operation of mesoscale devices at room-temperature.For example, Lukmanetal.realized the electrical control of exciton flux in a vdWH based on WSe2/MoS2at room temperature, the long-lived nature of the interlayer excitons in these devices result in diffusing over a distance of five micrometres858.Except for electrical control of excitons diffusion, it is also important for control of valleypolarized excitons for next-generation encoding data and information processing.Kisetal.show the generation and transport over mesoscopic distances of valley-polarized excitons in a type-II heterostructure based on WSe2/hBN/MoS2.Engineering of the interlayer coupling can enhance the diffusion of valley-polarized excitons, which can be controlled electrically.The exciton concentration can be further increased by an order of magnitude using electrostatic traps, opening the way for achieving a coherent quantum state of valleypolarized excitonsviaBose-Einstein condensation859.
4.2.3 Unique applications of 2D functional optoelectronics
With the increasing unique applications of 2D functional optoelectronics, devices that can cover multi-band wide spectrum are demanded.In addition, the research of polarizedsensitive photodetector adapted to new applications is also important.2D materials have been considered to be able to improve the performance of devices and have been widely studied860,861.The neural network, which is based on the development of 2D materials, can simultaneously complete the two major tasks of photosensitive behavior and processing images without delay.
4.2.3.1 Wide-spectrum photodetectors
The wide-spectrum 2D photodetectors show great potential in solving the problem of improving the device integration while controlling the cost.In the family of 2D materials, graphene is a promising broadband photodetector material862.However, the zero gap, large dark current and low absorption limited its application in photodetectors.Researchers are gradually studying other low-dimensional materials863.From the first-principles calculations, the theoretical photoabsorption region of different 2D materials can be obtained.The 2D semiconductor materials with narrow band gap are the favorable candidates for wide spectral detection864.For example, photodetector based on Sb2Se3exhibited the ultrafast response speed, while the wide absorption spectrum of Sb2Se3from ultraviolet to near-infrared(300-1000 nm)865.However, the narrow band gap materials have disadvantages of low infrared band gain and low quantum efficiency.The polarized photodetection based on 2D materials can also achieved by defect engineering or building of heterojunctions.For instance, In2Se3is a natural defect crystal material, therefore the photodetector based on In2Se3has a widespectrum response866.A self-driven photodetector based on WS2/ GaAs heterojunction broke the limitation of bandgap and achieves a rapid response from 200 to 1550 nm.It also has strong weak light detection ability867.The 2D/3D MoTe2/Si photodiode also can achieve the ultrafast-wide-spectrum photodetection from 300-1800 nm868.The advantages of silicon compatibility of such devices have enable the development of the 2D broadspectrum photodetector in the commercial application, which are expected to achieve large-scale integration869.
4.2.3.2 2D polarization-sensitive photodetectors
Due to the ever-increasing requirements for the devices and device size, 2D materials with natural anisotropic structure have been well developed in the field of polarization photodetection.In addition to studying the circular polarization information of the incident light870, the linear polarization of light can also be further studied.In 2015, the polarized-sensitive device based on BP/MoS2heterojunction was developed for the first time871.In 2019, a batch of 2D materials that may have polarization sensitivity can be obtained through first-principles calculations872.In 2021, photodetectors based on SiP and Ta2NiSe5materials have polarization sensitivity, which are able to quickly response in visible light 532 nm and near-infrared 1064 nm with the anisotropic current ratio of 2.3 and 3.3 respectively873,874.Currently, the 2D materials with triangular,tetragonal, rhombic, monoclinic and triclinic crystal structures are reported, which can cover ultraviolet to infrared band875.Some of the 2D materials can be used for both broad-spectrum polarization detection, Fig.29 shows some polarized-sensitive photodetectors with broad-spectrum.The photodetector based on (BA)2(GA)Pb2I7(Fig.29a) has obvious anisotropic photocurrent in some different wavelengths of the visible band876.The PdSe2-based device, shown in Fig.29b, has obvious light absorption in visible and near infrared bands, and has obvious polarization sensitivity877.In addition to the single materials,heterostructures are also applied to polarization detection.As shown in Fig.29c, the device based on the Gr/PdSe2/Ge heterojunction has a quick response in the deep ultraviolet to the infrared band, while the anisotropic photocurrent ratio of the device at 650 nm is about 112.2878.Polarization images of targets can be obtained by the polarized-sensitive photodetectors840,879.Fig.29d shows the polarization imaging of the GeSe-based device in near-infrared band.The diagram is clear, and the patterns obtained by different polarization directions have significantly different879.
Fig.29 Polarized-sensitive photodetectors with broad-spectrum.(a) Obvious anisotropic photocurrent of photodetector based on (BA)2(GA)Pb2I7,inset are the crystal structure of material and the image of device; reproduced with permission from Ref.876, Copyright 2021 John Wiley and Sons.(b)2D absorption spectrum of PdSe2 flake from 300 to 1100 nm, and the performance of polarization-sensitive photodetector; reproduced with permission from Ref.877, Copyright 2021 John Wiley and Sons.(c) Wavelength-dependent responsivity, specific detectivity and the polarimetric imaging of the Gr/PdSe2/Ge heterojunction device, inset is schematic diagram of the device; reproduced with permission from Ref.878, Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society.(d) Schematic layout of the image scanning system and the NIR polarimetric imaging of GeSe-based image sensor; reproduced with permission from Ref.879, Copyright 2021 Science China Press.
4.2.3.3 2D neural network image sensors
In order to obtain higher quality image, it is necessary to fabricate an array and integrated a 2D single photodetector.An array device based on MoS2/Graphene heterojunction were reported, which can be directly obtained under different lighting conditions880.Further integration of 2D materials and CMOS transistors can be used to complete the information collection at once with the read out integrated circuit, but it also be affected by the response time of the single device104.In practice, the imaging system that mimics the neural biology architecture can minimize the impact of device response.There is still a lot of work to be done to develop imaging system that imitates mimic the function of the human eyes881-883.The biomimetic human eyes, composed of multiple imaging sensors, are highly similar to the human eye.And the high image resolution can be achieved through electrical addressing884.The lens of the derived machine vision technology is its eyes, which can be passed to the processing unit and realized various visual capabilities after obtaining rich visual information.The construction of artificial neural network (ANN), and some clear images are presented885,886.Such systems can process optical images without delay, and have completed ultra-high-speed machine vision simulations787,887.
4.2.3.4 Near/in-sensor computing
Near/In-sensor computing allows for placing computational tasks near or in the sensory devices and can mitigate the issues related to time delay and power consumption suffered by traditional visual information processing888.Many 2D materials and vdWHs with superior electronic and optoelectronic properties are suitable for near/in-sensor computing applications883,885-887,889-896.With the weight control layer able to trap or de-trap electrons in vdW interface, an optical neural network based on WSe2/h-BN heterostructure synaptic devices(with distinct photoresponse to different visible wavelengths)has been proposed to recognize colored and color-mixed pattern(Fig.30a)883.Similarly, an optical neural network was implemented by integrating 1Kb in-memory sensor arrays and in-memory computing arrays based on MoS2photodetectors that show persistent photoconductivity effect (Fig.30b)886.Compared to near-sensor computing, in-sensor computing enables to perform low-level computations in the sensor and represents a paradigm shift to realize real-time information processing.By using continuously tunable photoresponse of 2D ambipolar WSe2semiconductors, Menneletal.demonstrated a unique image sensor that can simultaneously sense and process optical images within 50 ns, which highlights the huge potential of 2D materials based in-sensor computing in future machine vision (Fig.30c)887.Human retina with a stack of distinct cell layers naturally integrates the functionality of sensing and processing and offers an ideal template for implementing insensor computing.By highly mimicking the vertical structure and biological functionality of human retina, Wangetal.designed a reconfigurable retinomorphic sensor based on gatetunable photoresponse of vdWHs and showed its promising ap plication in reconfigurable image processing (Fig.30d)885.By taking a further step to emulating human vision system, they networked the retinomorphic sensor and memristive crossbar array to build a proof-of-concept neuromorphic vision system,(Fig.30e), which may open up a new avenue for future exploration of neuromorphic vision systems891.
Fig.30 Near-/In-sensor computing based on 2D materials.(a) Optic-neural synaptic device based on h-BN/WSe2 heterostructure 883.(b) 1 Kb vision processor based on MoS2 photosensitive FET crossbar array; reproduced with permission from ref.886, Copyright 2020 John Wiley and Sons.(c)Ultrafast machine vision sensor based on split-gate WSe2 transistors.(d) Reconfigurable vision sensor based on vdWHs 885.(e) A prototype neuromorphic vision system based on the retinomorphic sensor and the memristive crossbar array 891.
4.3 Catalysis
4.3.1 Electrocatalysis
4.3.1.1 Oxygen reduction reaction
Proton exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) is the zeroemission vehicle that best preserves the advantages of gasoline automobiles: long-distance driving, fast start-up speed and fast refueling897.However, the cathode reaction of oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) has become the bottleneck of PEMFC development due to sluggish reaction kinetics898-900.Consequently, the development of high-performance, stable and low-cost ORR catalysts is particularly urgent.Generally, the ORR occurs through either four proton-electron transfers (O2+4H++ 4e-→ H2O) to reduce oxygen to water in acidic environment or a two-proton-electron pathway (O2+ 2H++2e-→ H2O2) to produce hydrogen peroxide (H2O2)249.For the fuel cell or metal-air batteries, the excellent efficiency, and durability in cathode strongly depend on 4e-reduction reaction, while the intermediate product H2O2will destroy the catalyst activity and accelerate the aging of batteries.On the other hand, as the byproduct of 2e-pathway of ORR, H2O2is a crucial chemical in the paper-bleaching and water treatment industries901.Such side production could be a promising alternative strategy towards H2O2production, compared to the traditional synthetic methods902-904.In recent years, the application of various 2D materials including 2D carbon materials, metal-loaded graphene-based materials, noble metal nanoplatelets, 2D MOFs and MXenes as efficient ORR catalysts have been widely reported.
Carbon electrocatalysts have been widely studied for ORR because of their low cost, good conductivity and high stability905.As one of the most attractive 2D materials,graphene-derived materials have been applied as active ORR electrocatalysts through decorating and heteroatom doping906,907.Loading metal particles or single atoms (SAs) on graphene substrates with huge specific surface area and excellent conductivity is a good strategy to obtain high ORR performance.Graphene flakes coupled with isolated Fe atoms(FeNx/graphene) exhibited high activity and durability towards ORR in alkaline solutions908.Besides, Quetal.reported metal SAs on graphene oxide (GO), which were obtained by mixing GO slurry with bulk metals (such as Cu, Fe, Co, and Ni) (Fig.31a)909.Moreover, the half-wave potential (E1/2) for Fe SAs/n-G is 0.92 Vvs.reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE), 90 mV higher than that of commercial Pt/C catalyst (Fig.31b).After 10000 voltage cycles, the activity decay is negligible, illustrating their excellent long-term durability.Moreover, when employed as a cathode electrocatalyst for homemade Zn-air batteries, Fe SAs/N-G delivers a maximum power density up to 275 mW·cm-2.
As state-of-the-art electrocatalysts, the Pt-based 2D materials play a very important role in the development of 2D catalysts for ORR.Huetal.reported the 2D coplanar Pt-carbon nanomeshes(NMs) which were composed of interconnected Pt networks and carbon (Fig.31c)910.The Pt/C NMs achieved current densities of 0.360 A·cm-2at 0.80 V and peak power density of 1.21 W·cm-2in the H2/O2cell (Fig.31d).Furthermore, the PEMFC showed superior stability against aggregation after high current density of 1000 mA·cm-2for 120 h in H2/O2system.The density functional theory (DFT) analysis supports that the suitable 2D morphology and open structure with rich active edges are the predominant factors for the PEMFC activity and durability.
As 2D MOF nanosheets exhibit controllable structures, more exposed metal sites and excellent electrical conductivity.They have been widely studied in the field of electrocatalysis for ORR76,911,912.As shown in Fig.31e, f, Zhongetal.developed a new type of PcCu-O8-Co 2D conjugated MOF mixing with carbon nanotubes, which shows excellent electrocatalytic ORR activity (E1/2= 0.83 Vvs.RHE,jL = 5.3 mA·cm-2)913.TheinsituRaman spectro-electrochemistry demonstrated that good activity is owing to the layer-stacked structures, highly ordered porous framework and well-defined Co-O centers of catalyst.Furthermore, the PcCu-O8-Co material exhibited high performance for air cathode in the Zn-air battery.In addition to metal active sites, high-valence Ni4+active sites in latticestrained 2D NiFe MOF has also shown to be active catalyst for ORR914.
In recent years, MXenes have been emerging as nextgeneration nanomaterials and received increasing attention916.Jiangetal.utilized the iron-cluster-directed cationic Fe-N-C nanosheets and anionic MXenes to assemble a superlattice-like heterostructure with a surface area of 30 m2·g-1and ultra-thin structures with repeating thickness of 0.4 and 2.1 nm (Fig.31g, h)915.The synthesized Fe-N-C/MXene heterostructure has an excellent ORR performance, achieving the initial potential of 0.92 V and good stability of 20 h915.
Fig.31 (a) Schematic illustration for the preparation and (b) the rotating ring-disk electrode polarization curves in 0.1 mol·L-1 KOH of Fe SAs/GO;reproduced with permission from Ref.909, Copyright 2019 John Wiley and Sons.(c) Schematic illustration of 2D coplanar Pt-C nanomeshes.(d) H2-O2 fuel cell i-V polarization and power density plots recorded under different O2 pressure with the cathode Pt loading of 0.10 mg·cm-2 for coplanar Pt/C NMs; reproduced with permission from Ref.910, Copyright 2020 John Wiley and Sons.(e) Schematic structure of PcCu-O8-M,(f) ORR polarization curves of PcCu-O8-Co/CNT in 0.1 mol·L-1 KOH; reproduced with permission from Ref.913, Copyright 2019 John Wiley and Sons.(g) Schematic illustration and (h) LSV plots at the scan rate of 5 mV·s-1 in O2-saturated in 0.1 mol·L-1 KOH electrolyte for Fe-N-C/MXene superlattice-like heterostructure; reproduced with permission from Ref.915, Copyright 2020 American Chemical Society.
Besides, various LDH-based core-shell structures, such as CNT@CoMn-LDH (CNT, carbon nanotube) and Co3O4@NiFe-LDH, were reported, which exhibit superior activity for ORR.The cores can not only promote the uniform dispersion of LDHs,but also facilitate the transport of electron917,918.
4.3.1.2 CO2reduction reaction
CO2reduction reaction (CO2RR) could not only put a positive role in reducing greenhouse gas emissions but also serve as an efficient route to directly synthesize high value-added chemicals and energy storage molecules for energy conversion and utilization919.In recent years, CO2RR has become a continuous research hot-spot in energy- and material-related fields.However, there are still many challenges in the large-scale application of CO2RR, including improving conversion efficiency (reducing overpotential, increasing current density,etc.), regulating selectivity (especially for higher-order hydrocarbons and oxygenates products,etc.) and optimization of related materials and catalytic mechanism study920.The properties of 2D catalysts can be readily adjusted by variations in their thickness, heteroatom modification, and/or external stimulation (electric field, strain, light,etc.), which provides a new route for engineering nanosheets for CO2electrocatalysis921.Accordingly, 2D electrocatalysts, including metals and metal oxides, 2D carbon-based materials, crystalline porous 2D materials and TMDs, have been intensively investigated.
Compared to their bulk materials, 2D metal nanosheets have shown positive results in electrocatalytic performances.Liuet al.successfully synthesized triangular Ag nanoplates (Tri-Ag-NPs), which have yielded one of the excellent performances for aqueous CO2reduction to CO (Fig.32a)922.Compared with Ag NPs, the Ag nanoplates exhibit a significantly enhanced current density and Faradaic efficiencies (FEs) for CO formation at a low overpotential of 0.746 V, suggesting that the CO2RR catalytic efficiency in connection with the morphology of catalyst (Fig.32b).A cheaper, leaf-shaped Bi nanosheet catalyst was reported to catalyze the electrochemical reduction of CO2to formic acid (HCOOH) in 1 mol·L-1KHCO3or KOH solution with a much higher FE (over 85% or 90%) by the flow cell configuration923.
Nitrogen-doped graphene has proven to be a promising metalfree catalyst for electrocatalytic production of CO, HCOO-and CH4921,924.Panetal.developed an N, F-co-doped 2D holey carbon nanostructure (NF-C) (Fig.32c, d)925.After 40 h of testing, the CO2RR performance of NF-C reached CO faradaic efficiencies of 90% and the overpotential as low as 490 mV.The performance is far superior to the comparative n-doped 2D holey carbon nanostructure (N-C) and most of the carbon-free catalysts that have been reported.A large number of pyridinic N provides rich ultrahigh active and selective sites and the high surface area makes these active sites fully accessible.
Crystalline porous 2D materials, such as MOFs and COFs, are promising candidates for electrocatalytic reduction of CO2due to their porous crystalline structures and periodically arranged isolated active sites.As shown in Fig.32e-g, Yietal.reported that Cu2O(111) quantum dots synthesizedinsituon a porous conductive 2D MOF and it can be served as a single type of active sites for electroreduction of CO2to produce CH4with high selectivity of 73%, outperforming most of the reported catalysts(especially MOF-based catalysts)926.In some other works,phthalocyanine molecules as active sites were implanted into 2D conductive MOFs for efficiently CO2electroreduction reaction to CO927,928.Donor-acceptor heterojunctions or tetrathiafulvalene units were integrated into 2D COFs to increase the electron transfer rate, resulting in good catalytic performance towards CO929,930.
In addition, TMDs have been found to significantly improve CO2reduction for CO generation in ionic liquids, and the selenides appear to be the more effective921.On a series of TMD nanoflakes (WSe2, MoSe2, WS2, and MoS2), the formation of CO* from CO2is kinetically more favorable than on Ag(Fig.32h), resulting in high current densities and high CO selectivity931.In addition, LDH-based materials are also reported for catalyzing CO2RR.With NiZnAl-LDH/rGO (rGO,reduced graphene oxide) as precursor, Lietal.reported the synthesis of rGO/Al2O3supported NiO/ZnO which could effectively electrocatalyze CO2reduction to CO with a high Faradaic efficiency of 92%932.
Fig.32 (a) Proposed mechanism for CO2RR to CO on Tri-Ag-NPs.(b) Faradaic efficiencies of CO at various applied potentials (the inset shows the CO, CH4 and H2 overall FE for Tri-Ag-NPs); reproduced with permission from Ref.922, Copyright 2017 American Chemical Society.(c) Schematic illustration of holey NF-C layers.(d) CO FEs over N-C and NF-C; reproduced with permission from Ref.925, Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society.(e) Illustration of prepared Cu2O@CuHHTP.(f) Faradaic efficiencies of different products for Cu2O@CuHHTP.(g) Comparison of CH4 faradaic efficiencies between Cu2O@CuHHTP, Cu2O@CCB, and commercial Cu2O; reproduced with permission from Ref.926, Copyright 2020 John Wiley and Sons.(h) Calculated free energy diagrams for CO2 electroreduction to CO on Ag(111), Ag55 nanoplates, MoS2, WS2, MoSe2, and WSe2 nanoflakes at 0 V vs.RHE; reproduced with permission from Ref.931, Copyright 2016 Association for the Advancement of Science.
4.3.1.3 Nitrogen reduction reaction
Ammonia (NH3) is an important industrial raw material933,934.However, the conventional Haber-Bosch method is a low efficiency and high energy consumption process under the conditions of high temperatures (400-600 °C) and high pressures (150-350 atm, 1 atm =1.01325 × 105Pa)935,936.Therefore, a sustainable and low-energy consumption method to generate NH3is urgently needed.Electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) is an advanced method for sustainable NH3synthesis without carbon emission under ambient conditions937,938.But the NRR process needs suitable electrocatalysts due to the difficult to break strong N≡N triple bond939,940.
4.3.1.3.1 2D metal-based NRR catalysts
Great efforts have been made to explore novel catalysts that can efficiently promote NRR while simultaneously limit the HER.To this end, different methods like constructing superhydrophobic surface layer, alloying, and Li+incorporation have been developed941-943.To date, NRR electrocatalysts based on 2D materials are very rare, but already showing great promise in theoretical studies.DFT simulations suggested that individual Mo atoms supported on the defect-rich boron nitride (BN)monolayers could be used as a promising electrocatalyst for NRR, in which the well dispersed Mo SAs coordinated to the N atoms would contribute good performances in activating the inert N2molecules, stabilizing the N2H intermediate and destabilizing the NH2species944.Hanetal.prepared and optimized Mo SAs supported on the n-doped porous carbon (SAMo/NPC) as a low-cost catalyst (Fig.33) for the electrochemically catalyzed NRR.Because of the hierarchically porous carbon frameworks and high density of catalytically active sites, SA-Mo/NPC delivers a large NH3yield rate of 34.0 ±3.6 µg·h-1·mg-1in 0.1 mol·L-1KOH aqueous solution at ambient conditions, which is much higher than that of the other nonprecious-metal NRR electrocatalysts.Furthermore, SAMo/NPC also possesses excellent catalytic durability.No obvious current decrease was observed during the N2electrolysis for 50000 s.These results indicate that the rational design and synthesis of non-precious-metal SA catalysts could favor the electrocatalytic NRR945.
Fig.33 (a) An illustration of SA-Mo/NPC and its corresponding atomic structure model.(b) A TEM image of SA-Mo/NPC.(c) Mo EDS mapping reveals the homogeneous distribution of Mo on the carbon support; the figure inset is the corresponding HAADF-STEM image.(d) Atomic-resolution HAADF-STEM image.(e) EELS spectra from areas A and B in the atomic-resolution HAADF-STEM image of the inset; area A does contain single Mo atoms whereas area B does not.The two orange arrows point to the signals of the Mo M4,5 and M2,3 edges, respectively.Reproduced with permission from Ref.945,Copyright 2019 John Wiley and Sons.
MXenes have been widely investigated because of their important applications in lithium batteries, electrocatalysis,membrane separation, and photocatalysis134,946-950.Theoretical studies revealed that MXenes with M atoms exposing on the surface can effectively activate the adsorbed N2molecules, and thus favor the reduction of N2to NH3951.Actually, the basal planes of MXenes are typically terminated by OH*, O*and F*,which are bonded with surface M atoms72,952.Note that MXenes with surface terminated by O*would favor the hydrogen evolution rather than NRR due to their relatively weak binding ability toward N2molecules953.Bearing this in mind, great research efforts have been devoted to exposing the active sites of MXenes for N2adsorption and the subsequent activation and reduction.Pengetal.reported a single-atomic Ru modified Mo2CTX MXene nanosheets (SA Ru-Mo2CTX) for highperformance electrocatalytic NRR under ambient conditions(Fig.34).The obtained SA Ru-Mo2CTX shows a high FE of 25.77%, and large NH3yield rate of 40.57 µg·h-1·mg-1at the potential of -0.3 V (vs.RHE).DFT calculations and operando X-ray absorption spectroscopy investigations suggested that Ru SAs supported on the Mo2CTX MXene nanosheets serve as essential electron back-donation centers for the activation of N2molecules, which could favor the N2adsorption and activation behaviors of SA Ru-Mo2CTX, as well as decrease the energy barriers of the first hydrogenation reaction.This study provides an important atomic-level engineering strategy of modulating the NRR performance of catalysts954.
Fig.34 Fabrication and structure characteristics of SA Ru-Mo2CTX.(a) Schematic illustration of the fabrication mechanism.(b) HAADF-STEM image of SA Ru-Mo2CTX, insert is the corresponding SAED pattern.(c) The magnified HAADF STEM image of SA Ru-Mo2CTX.(d) The STEM-EDS elemental mapping of SA Ru-Mo2CTX.(e) XPS spectra of SA Ru-Mo2CTX and commercial Ru/C in Ru 3p regions.(f) The normalized XANES spectra at the Ru K-edge of RuO2, RuCl3, Ru foil and SA Ru-Mo2CTX.(g) The FT-EXAFS spectra derived from EXAFS of Ru K-edge of RuO2, RuCl3, Ru foil and SA Ru-Mo2CTX.Scale bars: (b) 5 nm, (c) 1 nm, (d) 50 nm.Reproduced with permission from Ref.954, Copyright 2020 John Wiley and Sons.
To better understand the reaction mechanism of NRR, it is essential to design transition metal nitrides (TMNs) with simple structure and durable surface vacancy for the correlation of realworld catalysts and theoretical models.2D materials possess onefold and entirely exposed crystal surfaces, which have been extensively utilized as a platform for both practical application and theoretical calculation in electrocatalysis955-958.Simultaneously, various studies reveal that 2D materials possess surface distortions, which could greatly increase the structural stability of both 2D materials as well as their surface vacancies959-961.As a result, vacancy engineering of 2D TMNs is an effective strategy to prepare advanced NRR catalysts.Liuetal.synthesized atomically ultrathin Rh nanosheet nanoassemblies (Rh NNs), which were used as an electrocatalyst for NRR.The obtained Rh NNs exhibit an outstanding catalytic performance toward NRR, with a large NH3yield rate of 23.88 μg·h-1·mg-1and excellent catalytic selectivity (no N2H4was observed) at a very low potential of -0.2 V (vs.RHE), which is much better than most of present NRR electrocatalysts962.The superior NRR performance of Rh NNs is attributed to their extremely large specific surface area as well as the modulated electronic structure.Heetal.fabricated 2D mosaic bismuth nanosheets (Bi NSs) by using aninsituelectrochemical method.Notably, the obtained Bi NSs showed a large NH3yield rate of about 13.23 μg·h-1·mg-1and FE of 10.46% ± 1.45% at the potential of -0.8 V (vs.RHE), which is much better than the Bi NPs.It was proposed that the exposure of abundant edge sites and the decreased Bi-Bi interlayer distance in Bi NSs could contribute to their enhanced NRR performance in comparison with the Bi NPs963.
4.3.1.3.2 Graphene-based NRR catalysts
Graphene is a classic 2D material with superior electronic transport and excellent catalytic performance of many electrocatalytic reactions and its functionalization can improve its pristine properties964-966.Through the functionalization of graphene, it is expected graphene could be an excellent NRR electrocatalysts for effective N2to NH3conversion967.Here, we will discuss the recent works of nanohybrids and heteroatom doped graphene for electrochemical NRR.
The noble metal catalysts are excellent for NRR, but the low abundance and high costs greatly restrict the large-scale applications.Meanwhile, nanomaterials have faced the problem of serious aggregation.To address this problem, the hybrid catalysts consisting of metal NPs and graphene are proposed.As shown in Fig.35a, the metal precursors mixed with reductants,and then formed a highly dispersed PdCu NPs/rGO composites,where the rGO sheets are highly desirable for loading the metal NPs and promote the mass transfer of reactants on the surface of catalyst941.Au is a well-known excellent material for NRR.Lietal.reported an amorphous Au NPs anchored on rGO material968.The N2molecule shows stronger binding with amorphous Au NPs, which possess high catalytic activity.Due to the high price of noble metals, replacing it with non-noble metals is the rational strategy.A series of materials,i.e., TiO2NPs/rGO969, CuO/rGo970, Mn3O4NPs/rGO971, MoP NPs/rGO972, and MoS2nanosheet/rGO973composites,etc., are reported to exhibit high NH3yields.From the viewpoint of size,the NPs and nanosheets are too large to weak the properties of high surface area and conductivity of 2D graphene.To enlarge the advantage of non-noble metal oxide/graphene composites,the QDs/graphene composites have been widely studied for NRR.The metal oxide QDs show exceptional NRR performance equal to and even higher than those of noble metal-based catalysts.The NRR activity of CoO QDs/rGO974, NiO QDs/rGO975, and SnO2QDs/rGO967could efficiently and stably catalyze the NRR at ambient conditions.
Compared to the heterogeneous composite catalysts,graphene delivers high conductivity, tunable structure and com position, and strong tolerance to acidic/alkaline.The theoretical and experimental studies suggest that heteroatoms doping of graphene leads to effective enhanced of the electrocatalytic properties976,977.For example, embedding Fe atom in N3-graphene can well capture the N2molecules (Fig.35b).Through the first-principles calculations, the superior N2fixation activity can be attributed to the high-spin polarization of the FeN3center(Fig.35c)978.Xiaetal.reported an S-doped graphene which possessed superior activity and stability for electrocatalytic NRR979.Further, Tianetal.reported an N, S co-doped graphene which could effectively boost the activity of NRR due to the enhanced N2adsorption and N≡N bond elongation980.Some recent studies show that doping oxygen atom is also effective to enhance the NRR performance.Usually, introducing O atom on carbon catalysts isviaacid oxidation389.But Wangetal.adopted an Ar anneal method of sodium gluconate to obtain O-doped graphene (O-G).Under ambient condition, the O-G catalyst showed high catalytic activity with large NH3yield of 21.3 μg·h-1·mg-1and high FE of 12.6%981.The key to design an effective NRR electrocatalyst is to build an active center which can effectively adsorb and activate the N2molecules.As N2is a Lewis base, it is ideal to create Lewis acid active center to bind N2.Boron (B) is a natural Lewis acid due to the electron deficiency so the B is an important element to induce electron deficiency in graphene982.The B-doped graphene is synthesized by anneal H3BO3and GO in H2/Ar gas (Fig.35d).When the amount of B doping is 6.2%, such a catalyst showed an excellent yield of NH3and high FE of 10.8% (Fig.35e).With the further theoretical investigations, the B-C centers play a key role in N2adsorption and NH3production983.In addition, the defect-rich graphene can also as high efficiency NRR catalyst, but this has only a few reports before984.
Fig.35 (a) Schematic illustration of the preparation of PdCu NPs/rGO composites; reproduced with permission from Ref.941, Copyright 2018 John Wiley and Sons.(b) Optimized structure of FeN3-graphene, (c) moieties of the Fe―N=NH2 intermediate; reproduced with permission from Ref.978,Copyright 2016 American Chemical Society.(d) Schematic of the atomic orbital of BC3 for binding N2 and LUMO and HOMO of undoped graphene and B-doped graphene, (e) the NH3 production rates and FE of B-doped graphene, the error bars represent the average of three measurements 983.
Although the research of electrochemical NRR have made some progress, there are still many problems and challenges that the yield and FE are far below the application level.How to improve the energy efficiency and to repress the side reaction of hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) by optimizing the physical and chemical properties of 2D catalysts remain the main direction to be explored.In addition, the research on the catalytic mechanism with 2D catalysts is still in its infancy and needs more in-depth research through more experiment and theoretical calculation to guide the design of NRR electrocatalysts in future.
4.3.1.4 Methanol oxidation reaction/ethanol oxidation reaction
Direct methanol fuel cells (DMFC) and direct ethanol fuel cells (DEFC) have received extensive interest because of the distinct advantages of ethanol and methanol fuels, such as low cost, easy availability, high energy density, abundance, safety for transportation and storage,etc.Therefore, DMFC and DEFC have been considered as promising power conversion devices and utilization technology in the future985-987.The anode half reactions of DMFC and DEFC correspond to methanol oxidation reaction (MOR) and ethanol oxidation reaction (EOR),respectively.Currently, noble metals Pt and Pd usually used as the electrocatalysts.In order to further enhance the reaction activity of the catalysts, while reducing the amounts of precious metals, researchers have developed a series of Pt-based and Pdbased nanomaterials with ultra-thin 2D structures as highefficiency MOR or EOR catalysts.Yangetal.found that the rGO can promote the generation of 2D Pt nanosheet with thickness of about 9.8 nm in a eutectic molten salt mixture of KNO3and LiNO3.The growth mechanism study revealed that the aggregation and subsequent sintering of individual NPs along rGO surface were involved in the growth process of Pt nanosheets.The electrochemical measurements showed that the obtained composite possess an improved durability and activity toward MOR in comparison with commercial Pt/C catalyst988.Buetal.synthesized PtPb/Pt core/shell hexagonal nanoplates(Fig.36), which show excellent catalytic performance toward alcohol oxidation because of the large internal biaxial tensile strain.They can largely outperform the catalytic performances of PtPb nanoplates and commercial Pt/C in terms of MOR and EOR989.Luoetal.showed that spin control of Pd-Fe-Pt nanomeshes (NMs) could realize great enhancement for the electrooxidation of fuels.It was revealed that Pd59Fe27Pt14NMs possess the largest number of polarized spins, which can facilitate the adsorption of OHadsand thus favor the oxidation of COads.As a result, the optimized Pd59Fe27Pt14NMs show superior MOR stability and activity over those of Pt/C and PtRu/C.Furthermore, the optimized Pd59Fe27Pt14NMs also exhibit excellent catalytic performances toward both EOR and FAOR990.
Fig.36 Morphology and structure characterization of PtPb hexagonal nanoplates.Representative (a) HAADF-STEM image, (b) TEM image,(c) TEM-EDX, and (d) PXRD pattern of PtPb hexagonal nanoplates.(e) SAED and (f) HRTEM of one single hexagonal nanoplate; insets in(f) are the FFT patterns from the white squares at the edge of and inside the nanoplate, respectively.(g) STEM-EELS elemental mapping of PtPb hexagonal nanoplates: HAADF-STEM image, Pt mapping in green, Pb mapping in red, and integrated mapping of Pt and Pb are shown.The compositional ratio between Pt/Pb is 55.9/44.1, as revealed by ICP-AES.Reproduced with permission from Ref.989,Copyright 2015 Association for the Advancement of Science.
Recently, Saleemetal.reported the successful synthesis of free-standing ultrathin Pt-Cu nanosheets with controllable lateral size in the range of 10-50 nm.Benefit from its larger specific surface area (62.8 m2·g-1) and the alloying effect produced by the introduction of Cu, The Pt-Cu alloy nanosheets exhibit excellent catalytic activity in EOR.Electrochemical test results show that the mass activity of PtCu nanosheets is 19 and 2.7 times larger than that of Pt black and Pt/C catalysts, respectively.In addition, the catalytic performance of PtCu alloy nanosheets is also significantly higher than that of PtCu alloy nanocones with the same composition, which fully proves the advantages of 2D structure in MOR catalysis991.Hongetal.prepared ultrathin Pd-Pt-Ag nanosheets with thickness of around 3 nm.Because of their specific compositional and structural characteristics, the obtained Pd-Pt-Ag nanosheets demonstrated much enhanced electrocatalytic performance toward EOR in comparison with their NP counterparts and the commercial Pd/C and Pt/C catalysts992.Hongetal.synthesized hexagonal close packed (hcp) structure PtBi nanoplatelets (NPLs) with the average thickness of 6 nm.The mass activity for PtBi NPL/XC-72 is 470 mA·mg-1, which is much higher than 250 mA·mg-1of commercial Pt/C.Furthermore, The Pt-Pt bond in the PtBi alloy phase becomes longer due to the insertion of Bi atoms, which weakens its combination with the CO intermediate species, and therefore exhibits better resistance to CO poisoning and catalytic stability than pure Pt.Compared with methanol, ethanol is less toxic and safer in transportation and operation.However, since the complete oxidation process of ethanol involves the breaking of C―C bonds, it has a higher reaction energy barrier993-995.
4.3.1.5 Formic acid oxidation reaction
Direct formic acid fuel cell (DFAFC) has been considered as one of the most promising power supply for next-generation electronic equipments996.Pt and Pd are ordinarily known as efficient formic acid oxidation reaction (FAOR) catalysts, and have been investigated intensively997-999.However, the poor poisoning resistance as well as low mass activity of DFAFC limit their practical application.Recently, great efforts have been devoted to improving the stability and activity of the FAOR electrocatalysts.Lvetal.reported a new class of 2D PdIr bimetallenes with an average thickness of only ca.1.0 nm for the FAOR (Fig.37).The obtained PdIr bimetallenes possess an extremely large electrochemical active area of 127.5 ± 10.8 m2·g-1, and also demonstrate an ultrahigh activity, quite low overpotential and enhanced stability toward the FAOR.Theoretical calculations reveal the generation of concave-convex type electro-active areasviathe effect of surface strain1000.
Fig.37 (a) CVs of PdIr bimetallene/C, PdIr NP/C and Pd/C for FAOR in 0.1 mol·L-1 HClO4 containing 0.5 mol·L-1 HCOOH at the scan rate of 50 mV·s-1; (b) mass activities of different catalysts at the potential of 0.5 V vs.RHE; (c) chronoamperometric curves of the PdIr bimetallene/C, PdIr NP/C and Pd/C catalysts at 0.5 V vs.RHE;(d) CO stripping tests of PdIr bimetallene/C, PdIr NP/C and Pd/C catalysts conducted in 0.1 mol·L-1 HClO4 at the scan rate of 50 mV·s-1;(e) free energy pathway (ΔG) for FAOR under acidic conditions;(f) chemisorption of H and CO2 on the surface (111) 1000.
4.3.1.6 Hydrogen evolution reaction
Hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) is the cathodic reaction of electrocatalytic water splitting, producing high-purity hydrogen, a promising type of clean and renewable energy1001.Many 2D materials are excellent HER catalysts, even showing comparable performance to the conventional noble metal catalysts.
4.3.1.6.1 Transition metal chalcogenides
Transition metal chalcogenides (TMCs) have been widely recognized as promising electrocatalysts due to their predicated low ΔGHvalues1002, low cost, and high stability1003.Various 2D TMCs have been prepared and studied for the HER, including Co3S41004, Ni3S21005,1006, NiS1007, NiCo2S41008, NiSe21009,1010,and so on1011,1012.Among which, transition metal sulfides have been identified as the most promising ones.2D MS2is a type of TMD materials, and similar to graphene, a vdW materials.The vdW gaps lead to a poor transmission of electrons between layers and weakens the overall conductivity of the materials1013.Tributschetal.studied the electrocatalytic hydrogen production of bulk MoS2and confirmed its poor activity due to both its low conductivity and less active sites1014.Therefore, TMDs were not regarded as promising candidates for electrocatalysis.In 2005,Hinnemannetal.predicted the high catalytic activity of the edge sites of MoS2by using density function calculations, and point out the potential HER performance of this material1015.Later,Jaramilloetal.experimentally proved the high catalytic activity of the edge sites of MoS2nanoplates.A linear relationship between catalytic activity and the number of edge sites were observed1002.These new findings demonstrate the huge potential of novel HER catalysts based on 2D materials1016-1020.Currently, the key development in this field is mainly built around the strategies to increase active sites such as the highly active edge sites, grain boundaries1021, and sulfur vacancy1022.
The various defect engineering strategies are built on the fact that defects inside or on the surface of the materials can change the coordination environment of the adjacent atoms, and consequently affect the electronic structure and surface properties1016,1021-1025.In an typical example, Lietal.study the Sulphur (S) vacancies and strain on the effect of the basal plane of monolayer 2H-phase MoS2for HER1022.The experimental and theoretical studies indicate that S-vacancies act as the new catalytic sites in MoS2basal plane.Hydrogen can bind directly to expose Mo atoms.The formation of S-vacancies in the basal plane can produce new bands in the gap near Fermi level.The new gap state is responsible for the hydrogen adsorption on S-vacancies.With the increasement of S-vacancies, the bands of MoS2move closer to Fermi level, and further enhance the H binding.When the concentration of S-vacancies is 12.5%, the free energy of hydrogen adsorption reached the optimum value and near zero.More than this, the adsorption of hydrogen atoms can be further modulated by strain.The positions of these new bands further shift towards the Fermi level as tensile strain is applied.
Designing 2D materials with heterostructures is another effective strategy towards enhanced HER performance206,548,1026-1030.The synergistic effect of composite materials along with and the enhanced charge transport property can improve the catalytic activity.Shahetal.prepared a nickel@nitrogen-doped carbon@MoS2nanosheets (Ni@NC@MoS2) by a simple hydrothermal process for HER1026.The catalyst has shown an onset overpotential with 18 mV and Tafel slope with 47.5 mV·s-1.The excellent performance can be ascribed to the synergistic effect between different composite materials, which including the dense catalytic sites with exposed edges on MoS2and the fast electron transfer from the substrate to MoS2nanosheets.Liuetal.also prepared a MoS2/Ti3C2Txhierarchical“nanoroll”1027.The hierarchical electrocatalyst was synthesized by combining liquid nitrogen-freezing and subsequent annealing.The Ti3C2Txnanosheets with rolled structure and the vertically aligned MoS2crystallites can afford more active sites and facilitate the charge transfer process.The substrate can also influence the electrocatalysis965.Zhangetal.developed a unique two-zone CVD technique and successfully grow 2D TaS2on different substrates like carbon fibers, Mo foil, glassy carbon,and Au foil.They studied the catalyst-substrate interaction and found TaS2on Au foils own the best performance with smallest overpotential and lowest charge transfer resistance.They ascribed the good performance to the charge injection and suitable lattice mismatch between Au and TaS2211.
Metal-support interaction is a key role in heterogeneous catalysis.Turning the metal-support interaction is a feasible way to adjust the catalytic activity and electronic structure of supported metal catalyst.Shietal.prepared four types of SA Pt catalysts on various TMDs supports by using a site-specific electro-deposition technique.They found that the electronic metal-support interaction can activate the acidic and alkaline HER by tailoring the oxidation state of single-atom Pt.They correlate the alkaline/acidic HER activity with Pt-H/Pt-OH interaction and average oxidation states of SA Pt1031.
4.3.1.6.2 Xenes
As a typical 2D material, graphene is inert toward HER with a large ΔGH*(1.85 eV)1003.However, various modifications of materials can change the properties and enhance the electrocatalytic performance.Heteroatomic doping into the graphene matrix can induce the redistribution of charge/spin to graphene layer, which has been confirmed a useful way to improve the HER activity.For instance, the B-doped graphene1032and n-doped graphene1033,1034all exhibit remarkable activity in electrocatalysis.Moreover, the co-doping strategy are increasing being used to achieve high HER performance.For example, N and S co-doped nonporous graphene has shown extremely high catalytic activity in HER,showing comparable performance to the best Pt-free HER catalyst1035.In another example, N and P co-doped graphene demonstrated greatly enhanced electrochemical performance in comparison with single doped counterparts1036.In order to explain the effectiveness of co-doping, they explored various nonmetallic elements doped graphene models using DFT calculations.It shows that the co-doping of P and N would decrease the ΔGH*value to increase the original H*adsorption,resulted in the highest HER activity.Experimentally, the incorporating of both P and N heteroatoms to graphene matrix was realizedviathe chemical doping process.The co-doped graphene catalysts exhibited much higher exchange current density and lower HER overpotential than pure and doped samples.In addition, the synergistic effects of co-doping N and P heteroatoms favor the proton adsorption and reduction, further enhanced the electrocatalytic performance.
Combing 2D heterostructure with other components can providing large surface area and more exposed active sites,leading to high-efficiency HER activities.Zhangetal.developed a 2D NiS/graphene heterostructure composites using a novel deep eutectic solvents (DESs) as precursors.The homogeneous system can provide enough contact of different components and contribute the coupling of NiS nanosheets and graphene.The compound exhibits high electrocatalytic efficiency and stability for HER and OER1037.In another example, the heterostructure of LDH nanosheet and defective graphene also show high activity for overall water splitting1038.Dengetal.designed a hierarchical architecture that composes of ultrathin graphene shell that encapsulates a uniform CoNi nanoalloy to boost its HER activity in acidic media.Base on the theoretical analysis in Fig.38, it shows that the electron penetration from CoNi nanoalloy to graphene surface was greatly promoted due to the ultrathin graphene shells.By decreasing the number of graphene layer and increasing the amount of N dopant, the electron density in graphene shells were significantly increased, which further enhanced the HER activity1039.
Fig.38 (a) Diagram of CoNi alloy encapsulated by graphene with three-layer.(b) Plots of △G(H*) (red line) and electronic potential (blue line) vs.the graphene layers.(c) Electron density redistribution of CoNi covered by one to three layers of graphene.Reproduced with permission from Ref.1039, Copyright 2015 John Wiley and Sons.
4.3.1.6.3 MXenes
MXenes with unique structure and electronic properties are regarded as promising electrocatalyst for HER.Among which,molybdenum carbide (Mo2C) has attracted most attention due to its high electrical conductivity and optimal hydrogen-adsorption properties.Jiaetal.prepared the ultrathin n-doped Mo2C nanosheets (n-Mo2C NSs) for the HER1040.The prepared materials own a single-crystal structure with a thickness of 1.0 nm.The Mo2C NSs with large electrochemical area is beneficial to the diffusion of electrolyte, electrocatalyst, and gas.Besides,the surface of the n-Mo2C NSs are encompass by apical Mo atoms, exposing more Mo active sites.The prepared n-Mo2C NSs has shown high activity for HER, under the cathodic current density of 10 mA·cm-2, with an onset potential of -48.3 mVvs.RHE, Tafel slope of 44.5 mV·s-1and overpotential of 99 mV.The catalyst also shown excellent long-term stability.
Designing MXenes materials with hybrid structure can remarkably improve the catalytic activity548,1027,1041-1044.Duet al.prepared a nickel-based bimetal phosphorus trisulfide(Ni1-xFexPS3) 0D-2D nanohybrids1041.Different Ni : Fe compositions can be obtained by turning the ratio of Ni and Fe during the preparation.The lateral size of NFPS decreases from 50 to ca.15 nm with the increasement Fe content.By changing the Ni : Fe ratio to 9 : 1, the obtained Ni0.9Fe0.1PS3@MXene showed low overpotential (196 mV) for the HER in 1 mol·L-1KOH solution.Besides, the Ni0.7Fe0.3PS3@MXene ||Ni0.9Fe0.1PS3@MXene couples show a low onset potential of 1.42 V and requires just 1.65 V to achieve a current density of 10 mA·cm-2, which is much better than that of noble metal IrO2|| Pt/C electrocatalyst (1.71 mV@10 mA·cm-2).Lietal.prepared a ternary PMo12-PPy/rGO nanocomposite and studied the PMo12content and carbonization temperature on the HER activity1044.The rGO-supported Mo-based catalysts may effectively hinder Mo sources and graphene from aggregating during the preparation process.In addition, the theoretical and experimental results show that the small size of Mo2C NPs can exposure more active sites.And the introduction of heteroatoms (N, P) to the carbon structure leads to charge density distribution and asymmetry spin.During the carbonization process, rGO can improve the dispersion of PMo12and further get highly dispersed Mo2C.rGO with outstanding electrical conductivity can also promote the charge transport process.The conjugation between Mo2C and NPC/NPrGO could favor fast electron transfer.These synergistic effects contribute the potent HER activity for Mo2C@NPC/NPrGO.
4.3.1.6.4 Layered double hydroxides
LDH-based materials also have important applications in HER.As a typical work, Liuetal.synthesized the heterostructures composed of (Ni, Fe)S2nanobox and MoS2nanoarray based on NiFe-LDH precursors, which show greatly improved activity (η10= 130 mV) and durability toward HER1045.The obtained (Ni, Fe)S2@MoS2with abundant active sites offer favorable chemisorption of hydrogen, which account for the easy generation of S-Hadsin the alkaline environment.In addition,LDHs can also be used as an excellent carrier to load other active materials to achieve synergistically enhanced HER performance.For example, Guoetal.found that anchoring Pd nanoparticles on the surface of NiFe-LDH nanosheet can improve HER performance1046.The introduction of Pd induces the defects and lattice distortion as additional active sites, facilitates charge transfer, and adjusted the electronic state of active sites, thus enhancing the adsorption capacity toward H and accelerating the reaction kinetics than NiFe-LDH.
4.3.1.7 Oxygen evolution reaction
Oxygen evolution reaction (OER) is the anode reaction of electrocatalytic water splitting1047.Typically, the OER half reaction significantly restricts the overall water splitting efficiency due to its sluggish reaction kinetics related to a complex four-electron redox process1048-1050.Great efforts have been made to solve this problem.Improving the catalytic activity and increasing the number of active sites are two common strategies to improve the OER performance.2D materials with unique structures, facile surface reaction, fast electron transfer and mass transport, have shown excellent performance in the OER1051,1052.
4.3.1.7.1 Metal organic frameworks
Metal organic frameworks (MOFs) have shown excellent electrocatalytic activity for OER1053-1057.MOFs are consisted of metal atom node and organic ligand with periodic units’structures.However, the poor mass permeability, low conductivity and blockage of active sites by organic ligands have limited their applications.On the other hand, the electron transfer and mass transport properties can be greatly improved by adopting 2D MOF structures1058.Geetal.designed a simple way to prepare 2D MOF-Fe/Co nanosheets by stirring the mixture of Fe/Co salts and 1,4-BDC1058.Water and TEA are important additives to stabilize the MOF nanosheets.The obtained 2D MOF-Fe/Co nanosheets exhibit excellent performance for OER, which is better than the bulk and 3D MOF-Fe/Co samples.Both experiments and DFT calculation were employed to study the reaction mechanism.The introduction of Fe into MOF changes the electronic properties of Co, and reduces the free energy of rate-determining step.
Besides, the coordinatively unsaturated sites are favorable for adsorption1059,1060.Zhaoetal.developed an ultrathin NiCo bimetal-organic framework nanosheet through a simple ultrasound approach for OER electrocatalysis1059.In 1 mol·L-1KOH solution with O2-saturated and scan rate of 5 mV·s-1, the NiCo-UMOFNs electrode exhibits a quite low overpotential of 250 mV at 10 mA·cm-2, much less than Co MOF nanosheets(371 mV), Ni MOF nanosheets (321 mV), bulky NiCo MOF nanosheets (317 mV), and the commercial RuO2(279 mV).The experiments results combined with the DFT calculations indicate that the exposed coordinatively unsaturated metal atoms act as the active centers for OER.The XPS results revealed that partial electron is transferred from Ni2+to Co2+viathe ligands oxygen.As shown in Fig.39, the charge transfer processes can be well explained in terms of the electronic structures.The coupling effects between Co and Ni contribute to the OER enhancement.All these results indicate that turning MOFs with 2D structure can be an effective strategy to construct highly active electrocatalysts.
Fig.39 Illustration of electronic coupling between Co and Ni 1059.
4.3.1.7.2 Transition metal chalcogenides
TMCs have excellent conductivity, which could be used as active electrocatalysts for water splitting both in HER and OER process949,1061-1065.Some TMCs materials can maintain stability during the OER process without damage.Others could be oxidized into the corresponding metal oxides/hydroxides under the strong oxidizing environments, forming aninsituheterostructure317,1066,1067.Modulate the spin states in uniquely exposed active planes can be an effective way for promoting the OER performance.Liuetal.prepared the Co3S4nanosheets for high-efficient water oxidation in both alkaline and neutral environment1061.The HAADF image confirmed the exposed Jahn-Teller-distorted octahedra structure of the Co3S4nanosheets.Moreover, as the nanosheet thins to atomic thickness, the spin state of Co3+in the exposed octahedron adapts from the low spin state to the high spin state.The synergistic effect and electronic configuration contribute the high activity of Co3S4nanosheets.The electrocatalyst exhibits an onset overpotential of 0.31 V and polarization current of 3.97 mA·cm-2at neutral pH with overpotential of 0.7 V.The superior performance of Co3S4 have exceeded most other inorganic nonnoble metal catalysts.
4.3.1.7.3 Layered double hydroxides
In recent years, LDHs, especially transition metal based LDHs, are regarded as one of ideal electrocatalysts toward water splitting because of their excellent OER activity, low cost and high stability in the basic condition1068.Lietal.firstly reported hierarchical MFe-LDHs (M = Ni, Co and Li) nanoplatelet arrayviaa facile electrodeposition method255.Among them, the NiFe-LDH shows optimal activity (η10= 224 mV) and long-term durability for OER.Ordered nanoplatelet array structure facilitates electron transport and electrolyte diffusion, while the good combination with the substrate enhances the stability of NiFe-LDH.However, the inferior electrical conductivity of pure LDHs restricts its further application to some extent.In view of this, Zhouetal.reported the CoMP (M = Fe, Ni and Mg)ultrathin nanosheet arrays by using CoM-LDH as precursors through aninsituphosphidation transformation265.The FeCoP exhibits significantly promoted activity toward water splitting with a cell potential of 1.60 V (at 10 mA cm-2) benefitting from the modified electronic structure of active sites and enhanced electronic conductivity.In addition to water oxidation, LDH-based materials are also widely applied in the oxidation reaction of organic small molecules.Zhouetal.reported a synthesis of CoNi-alloy@CoNi-sulfide with hierarchical nanostructure by topotransformation of CoNi-LDH arrays, which displays excellent electrocatalytic activity and durability for hydrazine electrooxidation264.DFT calculation reveals that the enhanced activity is resulting from facile dehydrogenation process,increased electronic conductivity and ion transport on the surface of CoNi-sulfide.Liuetal.demonstrated NiFe-LDH can efficiently electrocatalyze the oxidation of 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF) to 2,5-furandicarboxylic acid with a Faradaic efficiency of 99.4%1069.HMF oxidation on NiFe-LDH is kinetically more favorable than OER, which can replace OER in water splitting cells to promote H2evolution, as well as produce high-value chemicals.
4.3.2 Photocatalysis
Modern society remain highly dependent on fossil fuels for electricity generation and transportation, creating environmental problems (global warming) through the release of CO2into the atmosphere1070.Clean and sustainable renewable energy technologies must be found to allow a transition away from fossil fuel energy1071, with semiconductor photocatalysis having long been considered a potential route towards alternative fuels,as well as environmental governance (Fig.40)1072,1073.Whilst considerable fundamental advances have been made in recent years related to photocatalysis, many obstacles (especially the low solar conversion efficiency) need to be overcome1074.In an attempt to achieve step-change improvements in photocatalytic property for the energy and environmental sectors, researchers are increasingly turning to 2D photocatalysts as a strategy towards enhancing photocatalytic performance1075.Benefitting from the high specific surface area, tunable bandgap energies(band edge positions) and superior charge transfer performance,2D photocatalysts have been shown to demonstrate remarkable performance (relative to traditional 3D photocatalysts) in a wide range of energy and environmental applications, including water splitting, CO2reduction and removal of organic pollutants,amongst others.In this section, we summarize recent advancements in the smart design of 2D photocatalysts for environmental (e.g., removal of organic pollutants or toxic chemicals, bacteria disinfection, antibiotic degradation) and energy applications (such as water splitting, CO2photoreduction, nitrogen photofixation and organic synthesis).2D photocatalyst discovery, performance optimization and superiority in photocatalysis are prominently emphasized.It is expected to pave a novel avenue to rationally design and develop high-performance 2D photocatalysts for environmental pollution control and sustainable energy development.
4.3.2.1 Water splitting
Fig.40 Schematic illustration of the basic principles of photocatalysis(Eg: bandgap, CB: conduction band, VB: valence band).
The direct route of splitting pure water to H2and O2(including the reduction/oxidation process) H2O using solar energy was considered as one of the most valuable photochemical reactions.To realize overall water splitting,semiconductors need to have an appropriate position of the valence band and conduction (H+/H2O 0 Vvs.NHE at pH = 0 and H2O/O2+ 1.23 Vvs.NHE at pH = 0)1076.Accordingly, the bandgap of the semiconductor must exceed 1.23 eV to initiate this reaction.Under photoexcitation, the excited electrons and holes can produce hydrogen and oxygen from water, also accompanied by the transportation and recombination of electrons and holes that are the main bottleneck, resulting in poor photocatalytic efficiency.Therefore, it is imperative to design and develop semiconductors with appropriate bandgap for efficient water splitting.
Recently, a range of 2D building blocks, e.g., graphenebased photocatalysts1077,1078, 2D oxides1079,1080, 2D chalcogenides1081,1082, g-C3N41083,1084, LDHs1085,1086, and other 2D semiconductors1087,1088have been developed for photocatalytic water splitting.Further, a variety of strategies(such as doping, crystal facet/defect/strain engineering and modification) began to be widely utilized to boost the photocatalytic activity in terms of bandgap, photoinduced carriers’ migration rate, recombination of electron-hole pairs,etc.For instance, Lietal.observed that the X (X = P, S, N, B, F,Br, C) is more favorable to substitute Cl in [Cl] layers1089, rather than [Bi3O4] layers of constructed X-doped Bi3O4Cl models through the substitution energy calculations (Fig.41a).The corresponding charge density contour plots demonstrated that C-doping intensified the nonuniform distribution of charge between [Cl] and [Bi3O4] slices to the most extent.Moreover,the electrostatic potential difference (ΔE) between [Cl] and[Bi3O4] slices of all constructed models revealed that carbondoped Bi3O4Cl with the highest ΔEvalue of 7.36 eV than that of other samples, confirming carbon doping might be the best choice to enhance charge separation efficiency.Inspired by theoretical simulation results, they also synthesized carbondoped Bi3O4Cl with different C-doped concentration for photocatalytic water oxidation.The pristine Bi3O4Cl is inactive for O2evolution, while the carbon-doped Bi3O4Cl achieved outstanding O2-evolving activity originated from the enhanced charge separation efficiency by the carbon doping.In addition,owing to the special superiorities of 2D-2D coupled interfaces,the as-prepared interfaces/engineering have drawn great attention in photocatalysis when compared with 0D-1D, 0D-2D,1D-1D, and 1D-2D interfaces1076.The generated 2D heterojunctions in recent years have been employed as highperformance photocatalysts toward photocatalytic water splitting.In 2016, Lietal.successfully designed 2D Janus (Cl2)-(Bi12O17)-(MoS2) bilayer junctions, which were confirmed by AFM analysis and the advanced aberration-corrected high-angle annular dark-field scanning transmission electron microscopy(HAADF-STEM) (Fig.41b-f)1090.The as-prepared Janus bilayers possessed an ultra-long carrier lifetime (3446 ns),leading to an advanced rate of photocatalytic hydrogen evolution(33 mmol·h-1·g-1) under visible-light irradiation.In recent years,Zhaoetal.synthesized boron-doped nitrogen-deficient carbon nitride-based Z-scheme heterostructure using the electrostatic self-assembly strategy1091.The obtained 2D-2D polymeric heterostructure exhibited an obvious increased photocatalytic performance for overall water splitting and the solar-to hydrogen efficiency with the presence of Pt and Co(OH)2co-catalysts can reach 1.16% under one-sun illumination conditions (AM 1.5G).This work presented a practical strategy for constructing efficient Z-scheme photocatalysts to boost solar conversion efficiency.Photocatalytic water splitting with 2D semiconductors offers ameliorative rates, though most of these works still focused on the semi reaction with the sacrificial agent, rather than for photocatalytic overall water splitting.Therefore, the solar-to-chemical efficiency is still too low to meet industrial requirements.
Fig.41 (a) The constructed X-doped Bi3O4Cl crystal structure and corresponding electrostatic potential diagrams of X-doped Bi3O4Cl(X = P, S, N, B, F, Br, C); reproduced with permission from Ref.1089, Copyright 2016 John Wiley and Sons.(b) Side-view 3D AFM images and(c) corresponding height profiles along the lines in (b); (d, e) the average measured thicknesses and theoretical thicknesses of mono-layered Bi12O17Cl2 and MoS2 in 2D Janus; (f) the corresponding EELS elemental maps of 2D Janus (Cl2)-(Bi12O17)-(MoS2) bilayer junctions; scale bar is 10 nm 1090.
4.3.2.2 CO2photoreduction
CO2photoreduction to CO, CH4, CH3OH, HCOOH and other high value-added multi-carbon products has been considered as a clean and sustainable technique for CO2utilization and reclamation.However, chemical inertness of CO2molecule due to stable C=O bond (ca.750 kJ·mol-1) causes high reaction barrier and difficult to activation, so CO2photoreduction is still in its infancy.Meanwhile, the efficient generation, separation and migration of photogenerated electron-hole pairs in photocatalysis are extremely challenging.To break these obstacles, numerous modification strategies (doping, noble metal loading, crystal facet control and defect construction,etc.)and novel photocatalysts1092, have been extensively investigated.Among these state-of-the-art photocatalysts, 2D photocatalytic materials attracted much attention due to their unique 2D confined structure and inherent physicochemical property, especially the shorter path for migration of electron and hole to the surface329,1075,1092-1096.Herein, we divide them into metal-containing 2D photocatalysts (e.g., LDHs275,1097-1105,TMDs1098,1106-1109, MXenes-based catalysts1098,1110,1111, 2D metal oxides1098,1112-1118,etc.) and metal-free 2D photocatalysts(g-C3N41098,1106,1119-1123, graphene1098,1106,1120,1124,1125,BP1093,1098,1119,1120,1126-1131, h-BN1098,1120,etc.) for simplicity.
As representative 2D metal-containing materials, LDHs have received extensive interest for the selectivity regulation of CO2photoreduction as photocatalysts or precursor due to their controllable components1102.Xiongetal.synthesized a series of ZnM-LDH photocatalysts with different trivalent and tetravalent metal cations (M = Ti4+, Fe3+, Co3+, Ga3+, Al3+), investigating the influence of controllable components on CO2reduction selectivity1100.The selectivity of CO2hydrogeneration can be further regulatedviathe design of catalyst.Chenetal.prepared a series of novel CoFe-based catalysts by the hydrogen reduction of CoFeAl-LDH nanosheets at the range of 300-700 °C1097.When the reduction temperature was increased, the catalytic selectivity of CoFe-xcatalysts showed a shift from CO to CH4,and eventually to high-value hydrocarbons (C2+) (Fig.42a).As for the improvement of activity, LDHs as alkaline photocatalysts also perform a promoted CO2photoreduction activity on account of the strong CO2adsorption capacity of mass alkaline OH groups on the surface of LDHs.For example, CoAl-LDH exhibited a twice capacity for CO2adsorption (2.95 cm3·g-1)than that of P25, leading to a 13 times higher CH4formation rate(4.2 mmol·g-1·h-1) than that of P25 (0.3 mmol·g-1·h-1)1104.Generally, the CO2adsorption capacity of LDHs can be modulated using different synthesis methods1105.Besides, the effect of external alkaline OH groups was also generalized in BP.Through theinsitumodification by OH groups, Zhuetal.achieved a stable visible-light-driven photocatalytic CO production rate of 112.6 μmol·h-1·g-1on BP nanosheets (4 times higher than that of bulk BP)1131.In addition to surface treatment,the construction of effective heterojunction structures (0D/2D,1D/2D or 2D/2D) is another effective strategy for retarding the recombination of photogenerated electrons/holes, further promoting the CO2photoreduction activity.Luoetal.reported that 0D/2D materials of g-C3N4nanosheets and CdSe QDs can reduce the diffusion length of charge carriers, then enhancing the activity of CO2reduction1121.CdSe QDs with different sizes possessed the tunable energy level of the photogenerated electrons, which altered the selectivity of CO2(Fig.42b).
A similar enhancement of activity in 1D/2D heterojunction material can be accomplished (Fig.42c)1132.Moreover, a stable 2D/2D heterostructure of BP/bismuth tungstate (BP/Bi2WO6)with oxygen vacancy was reported for CO2photoreduction to syngas (Fig.42d), whose generation rates of carbon monoxide and hydrogen (20.5 and 16.8 μmol·g-1·h-1) were remarkably higher than the reported BP-based materials1126.The construction of S-scheme 2D/2D heterostructure with coupled oxygen defects widely facilitates the charge transfer efficiency and photocatalytic activity.Although tremendous studies on the flourishing of CO2photoreduction of 2D materials have been concerned, there still are many unknown tracks to dig out.It is an emergency to develop novelinsitudetection technologies to realize a visual observation on the migration of photoelectrons/holes or the variation of reaction intermediates, which is beneficial for a deep understanding of CO2photocatalysis,making a breakthrough on the activity and selectivity of CO2photoconversion.
Fig.42 (a) Illustration of the different CoFe-x catalysts formed by hydrogen reduction of a CoFeAl-LDH nanosheet precursor at different temperatures and the CO2 hydrogenation selectivity of each CoFe-x catalyst; reproduced with permission from Ref.1097,Copyright 2017 John Wiley and Sons.(b) Illustration of the variation tendencies of different polymeric C3N4/CdSe QDs; reproduced with permission from Ref.1121, Copyright 2019 John Wiley and Sons.(c) Schematic illustration of TiO2 and MoS2 heterojunction: charge transfer and separation under UV-visible light irradiation for CO2 reduction.Reproduced with permission from Ref.1132, Copyright 2018 John Wiley and Sons.(d) Mechanism diagram of the photocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction over a Pt/BP-Bi2WO6 heterojunction under solar light irradiation.Reproduced with permission from Ref.1126, Copyright 2021 American Chemical Society.
4.3.2.3 Nitrogen reduction reaction
Photocatalytic NRR utilizing solar light under mild conditions is a green avenue for ammonia synthesis.Efficient photocatalytic NH3synthesis relies on a highly active catalytic site for N2activation and high-efficiency electrons transfer from photocatalyst into N2molecule to accomplish N2reduction1133-1138.As a kind of alternative photocatalysts for high-efficiency NRR,2D semiconductor materials process atomic-level thickness with large lateral dimension, thereby resulting in the short path for migration of photogenerated carriers to surface and abundant surface active sites.In recent years, 2D materials such as bismuth oxyhalides (BiOX)1139, g-C3N41140, LDHs1141, and BP1142have been widely reported for photocatalytic nitrogen fixation through various design strategies.
Recent progress indicated that O, N, and S vacancies exhibited promoting photocatalytic N2activation on account of their excess electrons and coordinately unsaturated metal sites1143-1145.Benefited from high surface atom exposure of 2D materials,anion vacancies could be simply constructed and adjusted on surface by the design of crystal facet, doping and strain1146-1148.Researchers reported that efficient activation and reduction of adsorbed N2to produce NH3were realized on oxygen vacancies(Vo) of BiOBr nanosheets (Fig.43a, b)1149-1151.Furthermore, the distinct structures of Voon {001} and {010} facets resulted in different ammonia synthesis pathways by altering the adsorption structure of N21152.Unlike the 2D BiOX materials whose component modulation is restricted to a small scope, the tunability of cations within the layers of LDHs provide wide spaces for the design of defects.In 2017, ultrathin 2D MIIMIII-LDH (MII= Zn, Ni, Cu; MIII= Al, Cr) nanosheets with abundant Vowere designed and exhibited superior photocatalytic activity for NRR than the bulk counterparts.Particularly, severely distorted structure and compressive strain caused by plentiful Vowas observed in ultrathin CuCr-LDH, leading to remarkable performance compared with other several LDHs (Fig.43c).Furthermore, the doping of Cu2+into ZnAl-LDH could introduce electron-rich Cuδ+and surrounding Vo(Cu-Vo) at surface1153.The abundant Cu-Vosites promoted N2activation and injection of photogenerated electron1154, resulting in remarkable NRR performance of 110 µmol·g-1·h-1.
In addition to the construction of intrinsic vacancy defects,surface modification of 2D materials for photocatalytic NRR has also been widely reported in recent years1155-1157.For example,Zhengetal.decorated a series of single transition-metal atoms(Mn, Fe, Co, and Ni) onto MoS2, prolonging the lifetime of photogenerated carriers, suggesting the single metal modification enhanced charge separation by trapping excited electrons1158.Anchoring single-atom onto carbon nitride can also construct new catalytic active centers and efficiently capture photogenerated electrons1159,1160.Huangetal.demonstrated a valence-electron cloud of single Cu atom on g-C3N4isolated from the conjugatedπelectron of g-C3N4, thereby easily exciting to generate electrons with high energy level1161.Guoetal.reported coordinatively unsaturated single-atom Mo on g-C3N4exhibited strong adsorption to N2molecule with a stretched length of N≡N bond from 1.11 to 1.15 Å1162.Besides, special bonding mode and topological structure enable 2D materials to construct hybrids with a variety of materials (Cu2O, BiO, Ni2P,etc.), achieving improved stable bonding and carrier separation efficiency1163-1168.For Ni2P/BP, the Ni-P bond between BP and Ni2P could act as atomic level channels for charge transfer at the interface to supply photogenerated electron efficiently for N2reduction1169.Alike Ni2P/BP photocatalysts, uniformly sized sub-3 nm Cu2O platelets loaded on LDH nanosheets could be obtainedviaa simpleinsitureduction of CuZnAl-LDH (Fig.43d), exhibiting considerable performance and stability for visible-light-driven NRR1170.
Fig.43 (a) Side and top view of (001) surface of BiOBr with a Vo.(b) The adsorption geometry of N2 on the Vo of BiOBr (001) surface and corresponding charge density distribution; the yellow and blue contour represent charge accumulation and depletion in the space respectively 1149.(c) Schematic polyhedral representation of the ultrathin LDH structure with defective MO6 octahedra at the nanosheet edge or surface and the distortion structure induced by Vo (Vo marked by the yellow dot); reproduced with permission from Ref.1153, Copyright 2017 John Wiley and Sons.(d) Schematic illustration and HRTEM images of the supported ultrafine Cu2O prepared through in situ reduction of LDH using different concentrations of ascorbic acid; reproduced with permission from Ref.1170, Copyright 2020 John Wiley and Sons.
In spite of the rapid development of photocatalytic nitrogen reduction, there are still some bottlenecks restricting improvement of performance for ammonia production.Special optical and electrical properties of 2D materials are expected to provide new approaches to overcome these challenges in the future.Considering that most of current photocatalysts with low solar efficiency were excited by ultraviolet light1169,1170, rational design of 2D materials with unique optical properties and wide absorption (up to visible or near-infrared light) is prime important to achieve remarkable nitrogen fixation performance.In addition, inspired by thermal catalytic ammonia synthesis, the enriching electron density of surface defects is a key to promote nitrogen activation1171-1174.Therefore, the construction of electron-rich structures at the surface of 2D materials in virtue of the confined electron in layered structure may be one of the avenues to high-performance photocatalyst for NRR.
4.3.2.4 Photocatalytic environmental treatment
Among these environmental treatment technologies employed thus far, the semiconductor photocatalysis as a new pollution control technology demonstrates the great potential of degrading and eliminating various emerging pollutantsviaadvanced oxidation processes (AOPs)1175.In recent years, a large number of studies have confirmed that dyes, surfactants, organic halides,pesticides, oils, cyanides,etc.can be effectively removed through photocatalytic decolourization, detoxification, and mineralization into inorganic small molecular substances (e.g.,CO2, H2O and inorganic ions or acids), thereby eliminating environmental pollution1176,1177.Photocatalysis involving O2and H2O as reaction species converted into high-reactivity oxygen species (ROS)1178,i.e., hydrogen peroxide (H2O2),superoxide anion radicalsinglet oxygen (1O2) and hydroxyl radical (·OH) in photocatalysis (Fig.44).
Fig.44 High-reactivity oxygen species generated in photocatalysis.Reproduced with permission from Ref.1178,Copyright 2017 American Chemical Society.
Since the synthesis of ROS is the initial rate-limiting step for photocatalytic environmental pollutant treatment, designing catalyst for enhancing ROS generation is crucial.2D photocatalysts emerge with great potential for settling this matter as they can convert solar energy to ROS efficiently1179.Nitric oxide and nitrogen dioxide (collectively referred to as NOx) as one of the typical outdoor and indoor air pollutants, have attracted extensive environmental concern1180.In particular, the removal of indoor air pollutants at a realistic concentration (ppb level) is technically challenging with reasons for economic infeasibility1181.Dongetal.developed a novelinsitumethod for the synthesis of g-C3N4on structured ceramic foam.The optimized supported g-C3N4with a remarkable NO removal ratio of 77.1% can be obtained under real indoor illumination1182.Through EPR characterization, the reaction mechanism and ROS of photocatalytic NO oxidation were revealed.Further,owing to enough stable g-C3N4on the structured ceramic foam with special chemical interaction, photocatalysts can be employed under the continuous airflow to promote the practical environmental application.Alike NO removal, photocatalysis was considered a presumably critical important technology for the removal of ammonia, which acted as a typical environmental pollutant in water originate from industry, agriculture and domestic sewage effluent1183,1184.Ultrathin g-C3N4with 2.7 eV bandgap and suitable position of CB and VB was fabricated as a metal-free photocatalyst for ammonia removal from water1185.Compared with bulk g-C3N4, the ultrathin g-C3N4can obviously improve photocatalytic performance.It attributed to the 2D ultrathin structure that shortened the photoinduced carriers’migration distance and accelerated separation efficiency to generate more hydroxyl radical for ammonia oxidation1186.Among these 2D photocatalysts studies, catalyst design and screening are especially crucial in terms of extending the lifetime and understanding the kinetic synthesis of ROS in future photocatalytic applications for pollutants removal.
4.3.2.5 Photocatalytic organic synthesis
Photocatalytic organic synthesis is the valorization of small molecules beyond H2O, CO2, and N2, and it has received growing interest and attention recently, albeit an emerging field.Within a few years, a number of systems were explored,including controlled photooxidation (e.g., oxidation of alcohols,amines, and cyclohexane; hydroxylation of benzene;epoxidation of alkenes) or photoreduction (e.g., reduction of nitroaromatics, unsaturated aldehydes, alkenes, and alkynes) of organic molecules.The outstanding electronic characteristics and versatility for structural modifications of 2D materials (g-C3N4, 2D COFs, graphene, BiOX, LDHs,etc.) project them into the field of heterogeneous photocatalytic organic synthesis1187.
In a seminal report, graphene-supported copper NPs are feasible for igniting the coupling reaction of aromatic nitro compounds to corresponding azo- and azoxy-aromatic compounds under visible-light irradiation at 60 °C1188.The ignition is primarily ascribed to excited energetic electrons,which is originated from the localized surface Plasmon resonance effect of Cu and photoexcitation of the bound electrons, facilitating the cleavage of N―O bonds in the aromatic nitro compounds.Whereas Cu and graphene are expensive, many low-cost and metal-free materials have been exploring.For example, Chenetal.reported that a 2D porphyrin-basedsp2carbon-conjugated COF can induce aerobic oxidation of amines to imines under visible light, and the COF is highly stable even under harsh pH condition1189.Daietal.demonstrated that g-C3N4can also selectively synthesize various azo- and azoxy-aromatic compounds from the corresponding nitroaromatics with isopropanol serving as electron donor, and the selectivity can be controlled by different irradiation wavelength1190.Since the oxygen removal process by two H atoms through the generation of H2O is the key step of nitrobenzene reduction, photogenerated electrons and adsorbed hydrogen atoms (Hads) of g-C3N4are pivotal.Insitumass spectrometry ca.remaining O2after the deaerated conditions showed that g-C3N4possesses the fastest O2depletion rates (Fig.45a), hence the most efficient utilization of photogenerated electrons.Besides, the post-mortem temperature-programmed desorption suggested weak adsorption ofHadson the g-C3N4surface, thereby reacting rapidly with the surface absorbed nitrobenzene to azo- or azoxy-benzene (Fig.45b-d).Xiaoetal.demonstrated oxidative couplings of amines to imines by porous few-layer g-C3N4with 2-15 nm pores (Fig.45e, f) whereby diffusion of reactants and products are facilitating1191.However,g-C3N4alone is unsuitable for selective oxidation of 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF) because hydroxyl radicals generated over g-C3N4are detrimental to the oxidation processviaoxidizing HMF directly to CO2and H2O1192.Xuetal.reported that C3N4/H2O2adduct can acquire comparable HMF conversion and higher selectivity of 2,5-furandicarboxaldehyde.Additionally, composite is an efficacious means to change properties of C3N4and heavily improve catalytic conversion and selectivity as well.For instance, the strong interaction between cobalt thioporphyrazine (CoPz) and g-C3N4in CoPz/g-C3N4composite not only enhances the accessibility of the CoPz sites,but also boosts1O2instead of hydroxyl radical generation, thus obviously promoting selective oxidation of HMF to 2,5-furandicarboxylic acid1192.Considering photocatalytic organic conversion involving the hydrogen transfer step is attractive while selectivity and efficiency driven by visible-light are still unsatisfactory.Daietal.developed a basic-site engineered bismuth oxybromide [Bi24O31Br10(OH)δ] that performs remarkably in photocatalytic redox reactions (e.g., thiones to thiols, quinones to quinols, nitrobenzene to azo/azoxybenzene,and alcohols to ketones) involving hydrogen transfer step1193.Such basic sites (OH and undercoordinated O atoms) on catalyst surface can favor the oxidation of alcohols (R―OH), then being donated protons (H*) through oxidative dehydrogenation of alcohols (Fig.45g).The donated protons further accept the conduction band electrons to generate metastableHadsunder irradiation, which can then be rapidly scavenged by hydrogen acceptors (A) to form valuable organic compounds, rather than H2 gas.Moreover, joint utilization of basic surface sites and active lattice oxygen in Bi24O31Br10(OH)δis a promising way to selectively oxidize aliphatic and aromatic alcohols to the corresponding aldehydes/ketones due to boosted dehydrogenation in photooxidation of alcohols1194.Defect engineering in LDHs also play a vital role in the hydroxylation of benzene1195,selective oxidation of aromatic alcohols1196, and hydroxylation of phenol1197.While photocatalytic organic synthesis has achieved huge advances in recent years, most of these works involved sacrificial agents, which make them far from energy economical and practical application.Coupling cathodic and anodic conversion is likely a promising route to efficiently utilize electron-hole pairs.
Fig.45 (a) The consumption of dissolved O2 under irradiation using various photocatalysts determined by in situ MS.(b) Post-mortem TPD spectra revealing the desorption of Hads from the g-C3N4 and A-g-C3N4 surfaces.(c) Scheme of the suggested reaction pathway; the reduction reaction will be hindered if Hads binds strongly to the catalyst.(d) Reaction path for the photoconversion of nitroaromatic compounds to azoxy-,azo-aromatic compounds, and amines.NBS = Nitrosobenzene, NPH = N-phenylhydroxylamine 1190.(e) AFM and (f) TEM image of the few-layer C3N4; reproduced with permission from Ref.1191, Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society.(g) Working principle of the Bi24O31Br10(OH)δ 1193.
Demands for higher energy efficiency, coupled with environmentally-friendly premises provide growing impetus to explore new alternative green energy.Over the next 5-20 years,it is anticipated that photocatalysis combined with 2D materials will be widely adopted for practical energy and environmental applications owing to its technological advantages.Opportunities exist for the discovery of new photocatalytic systems and alternative methods with effective 2D materials.Certainly, how to fully strengthen the 2D photocatalysts’advantages (high surface area with the exposed active site,excellent charge transferability and tunable bandgap structure) is the key to promote solar-to-chemical conversion efficiency.
4.4 Energy storage
2D materials are widely employed for electrochemical energy storage applications due to their layered crystal structure for ion intercalation and diffusion, rich surface functional groups and high redox reactivity, tuneable conductivity as well as structural flexibility.A wide diversity of 2D materials have been studied for energy storage (see examples in Fig.46), spanning from graphene, graphene analogues, COFs, to TMDs, MXenes, BP and 2D metal oxides33,1198.2D materials are applied in both cathode, anode and electrolyte.More specifically, they can be electrochemical active materials (for bulk intercalation or surface adsorption), conductive additives (forming composites with transition metal oxides or sulphides) and surface protectors(to suppress dendrites or pulverization).In this section, we will highlight with examples the application of typical 2D materials in secondary batteries, supercapacitors and microsupercapacitors.
Fig.46 Classification of 2D materials and modification strategies in application for rechargeable batteries.
4.4.1 Batteries
According to the type of charge carriers (Li+, Na+, K+, Mg2+,Al3+, and non-metal cations) and storage mechanisms, electrodes of batteries can be divided into two major types: conversion-type and intercalation-type.Examples for the former are Li-S, Li-Se,Na-S, Li-O2, Zn-O2battery cathodes and the corresponding metal anodes; and examples for the later are the most common Li-ion, Na-ion, K-ion, Zn-ion battery cathodes or anodes.In the following, we will discuss the application of 2D materials in intercalation-type electrode, conversion-type additive, metal anode protection, and solid-state electrolyte (Fig.46, left panel).
In the intercalation-type batteries, 2D materials with an open structure and weak interlayer bonding and adjustable interlayer distance provide more active sites for ions storage and easier ions transfer compared to bulk counterparts.Typical 2D organic materials employed for intercalation-type electrodes include graphene and derivatives, 2D polymers, 2D COFs and 2D MOFs1199,1200.The inorganic type is represented by TMDs, but other 2D graphene-analogous (Si, Ge, Sn, Sb, Bi, B3P, ZnN, ZnP,LDHs,etc.) and are being attempted either experimentally or theoretically1201-1204.
Graphene has been widely applied in the anode for insertiontype batteries.Li+, Na+, and K+can be inserted between the carbon layers and form metal carbides1205,1206.In Li-ion battery,reactive sites generated by the exposed graphene edges exhibit high binding energies between C and Li+, rendering a high specific capacity around 1500 mAh·g-1with the formation of LiC61207.Heteroatom doping can further improve the conductivity and enhance the interaction between charge carriers and graphene layers, leading to improved activity1208,1209.
Following the success of graphene, TMDs are widely employed as the anode host for alkane metal ions.Taking MoS2as an example, because of the weak vdW interaction between the interlayers, it suffers less volume expansion during the accommodation of metal cations than that of other alloying type anodes, such as 2D BP and bulk TMDs1210.However, the pitfall of most TMDs is that they usually have lower electrical conductivity than graphene, thus requires hybridization with conductive agents or creation of atomic vacancies1211-1213.Introducing guest ions or molecules to expand the interlayer distance of TMDs is beneficial to ion diffusion1214.In macroscopic level, engineering the porous or hierarchical structures is a widely employed method to shorten the mass transport pathway and also to alleviate the re-stacking and aggregation during the cycling process1215.Attention should be paid that most TMD semiconductors may experience a decomposition reaction at a lower discharge potential than the potential for intercalation reaction, and this decomposition could be irreversible1216.
LDH-based materials have also been successfully applied in the field of energy storage like batteries.As a typical work, Liet al.reported a series of activated LDHs (CoFe, CoNi and CoAl-LDH) nanoarrays as cation supercapacitor materials through a facile electrochemical activation (ECA) method1217.The ECA process results in the generation of hydrogen vacancies (VH) on LDH host layers, which can provide a 2D open channel for the reversible intercalation of metal cations.These activated LDHVHexhibits remarkable storage capacities for a wide range of metal cations (monovalent Li+, Na+and K+and divalent Ca2+,Mg2+and Zn2+) compared with pristine LDHs.Furthermore,both DFT calculations and experimental studies indicate that the VHin the activated LDH plays an important role in the intercalation chemistry as well as energy storage performances.The ultrathin CoFe-LDH with active-oxygen-rich surface(ULDH-O) was further developed by Lietal.to modulate the deposition/dissolution of Li metal anode for Li-metal batteries1218.The active oxygen on the lithiophilic surface of ULDH-O is thermodynamically favorable for Li atom adsorption and thus promotes the homogeneous nucleation and deposition of Li metal to suppress dendrite formation.Moreover, the ultrathin structures also promote the sufficient exposure of Li nucleation active site and guarantee efficient electron transfer between ULDH-O and conductive substrate.Furthermore, LDHs with inert metal ions (such as Mg2+, Zn2+, and Al3+) have attracted widespread interest by assembling into the ultrathin film to suppress the “shuttle effect” of polysulfides because of the ultrathin nanosheet structures with positive charges1219.Cuiet al.successfully fabricated an ultrathin separator by the assembly of MgAl-LDH nanosheets and GO on a commercial polypropylene separator ((LDH/GO)n) and could effectively act as both a polysulfide barrier and Li+rectifier in the lithium-sulfur battery1220.The experimental results demonstrate that the(LDH/GO)20-assembled lithium-sulfur battery exhibits excellent performance with a large initial discharge capacity, cycle stability and good heat resistance performance.The restricted pathways on the (LDH/GO)nfilm could effectively block polysulfides to stabilize the sulfur cathode but promote the uniform dispersion of Li+to inhibit the generation of Li dendrites on the Li-metal anode.
MXenes with high conductivity are being extensively studied for energy applications include battery anode1221-1223.Charge carriers are stored in the Ti2C3layers.However, the remaining OH and F groups on Ti2C3layers may lower the ions transfer,thus some guest dopants (N, Sn, S, P) are often introduced to modify the surface1224-1227.Similar to 2D MoS2, the interlayer distance of MXenes can also be effectively expanded by filling with nano-structured materials such as CNT, polymers and largesized metal ions to facilitate the ion intercalation1228-1230.
For the conversion-type batteries, such as metal-sulfur, metalselenium, metal-O2and metal-CO2batteries, 2D materials are often applied as a host, an additive to the cathode, or a coating layer on the separator.An important function of 2D materials is to catalyze the active species conversion or reduce the side reactions during the cycling1231,1232.
In the metal-sulfur system, taking lithium-sulfur battery as an example, it suffers the shuttle effect of soluble intermediateslithium polysulfides, low conductivity of sulfur and final products (Li2S), and the large volume fluctuation during the cycling process (~76%).2D materials with good conductivity such as graphene and g-C3N4are often employed as the host for sulfur1233.The high porosity of such flexible sheet-like material can efficiently accommodate the volume expansion during the cycling.The non-polar carbon-based materials cannot thoroughly prevent the polysulfides shuttling.To enhance the immobilization of intermediates on the cathode, TMDs or MXenes with higher polarity and large exposed planar surface provide a better function owing to the strong Lewis-acid based interaction between the metal ions and polysulfides1234,1235.Vacancies and single atoms modification introduced into the 2D materials are proven useful to enhance the polysulfides conversion kinetics1236,1237.Because of low conductivity, a hybridization and a possible synergistic effect between the porous carbon and polar 2D metal compounds are beneficial to mitigate the issue of volume change and polysulfides shuttling1238.
The role played by 2D materials in the metal-air batteries is similar to the metal sulfur batteries.Specifically, they may accelerate the electrocatalytic ORR and OER process and reduce the polarization during the cycling process1239.For example,graphene with homogeneoussp2hybridized electrons and high specific area can efficiently accommodate and regulate the distribution of insulating products Li2O2/LiO2, avoid the blocking of O2in the cathode and facilitate the ORR and OER process1240-1243.To optimize the nucleation of LiO2, graphene surface may be modified by noble metal or compounds with a similar crystallographic lattice to LiO2, which further reduces the charge overpotential1244.In addition, 2D oxides and LDHs with exposed surface atoms, atomic steps and kinks can facilitate the chemical bonds breaking, and thus boost the OER/ORR process1245,1246.
Generally speaking, for the conversion-type batteries, 2D materials are applied based on the unique interaction between their surface and the unstable or soluble active species since the active species will not be stored inside the crystalline framework.Thus, the anchoring sites for active species (e.g.,edge sites, heteroatoms dopant or vacancies) and the transport of active species (generated by rational design of hierarchical structures) are both significant factors of 2D materials.
In the metal anode research area, prominent issues of dendrite growth and side reactions need to be solved.2D materials are widely studied for anode protection because of their outstanding conductivity and mechanical flexibility1247.For example, the basal plane of graphene can serve as the nucleation template to guide the horizontal growth of the zinc metal which is effective in suppressing the Zn dendrite growth in Zn-ion battery1248.Apart from the nucleation template, graphene can also serve as physical confinement to reduce the dendrite formation by reducing the current density and enhancing the affinity of charge carriers on the surface1249,1250.MXenes with heteroatoms doping or modification are served as the host for Li, Na, Zn and K metal1251,1252.Other strategies are ex-situ artificial SEI layer on metal anode to induce uniform metal deposition1253, or coating on separator to reduce the number of hotspots1254.These are both effective in preventing dendrites from piercing the separator.
In addition to the application as electrodes, 2D materials,especially when surface functionalized have also been added into the electrolyte (solid polymer electrolyte or gel electrolyte)to facilitate the dissociation of the metal salts1247.For example,in the solid lithium-ion battery, 2D graphene nanosheet modified by poly(ethylene glycol) and branched-graft copolymer could efficiently enhance the ionic conductivity by constructing Lewis acid-base interaction with lithium salts1255.Similarly, 2D vermiculite sheets with the substitution of surface Si atoms by Al atoms bring about a negative surface charge state,corresponding to improved ability to dissociate Li salt by absorbing Li+1256.2D COFs and h-BN can also be applied in this area to dissociate the ion pairing of the metal salts and enhance ion mobility1257-1259.
In summary, this section highlights the application of 2D materials in different parts of electrochemical batteries.Typical strategies such as doping, hierarchical structures or heterostructures, and vacancies are discussed with respect to the charge storage mechanisms (Fig.46).Typical strategies in enhancing the redox kinetics, reaction reversibility and electrode stability are presented.
4.4.2 Supercapacitors
Different from battery systems, supercapacitors (SCs) store energyviakinetically faster physisorptions or faradaic reactions on the electrode (near) surface, which are capable of achieving high power density and long cycle life.On the basis of the charge storage behaviours, SCs can are generally classified to electrochemical double-layer capacitors (EDLC) and pseudocapacitors.The former stores charges at the “Helmholtz layer”formed through electrostatic interaction between electrode/electrolyte interface; while the latter stores by(near)surface-confined faradaic reactions.It is not surprising that 2D materials can be useful for both types because of much larger surface ratios than bulk1260-1265, as illustrated in Fig.47a, b.Their reactive basal planes or edges, tunable surface chemistry,and interlayer spacing are desirable features to accommodate Faradaic reactions and insertion pseudo-capacitance.
In terms of EDLC, the capacitance is calculated solely according to a material’s surface area.Hence graphene with extraordinarily high surface area of up to 2630 m2·g-1can theoretically achieve an EDL capacitance as high as ~550 F·g-11266.As reported, single-layer graphene achieved a high capacitance of ~21 μF·cm-2superior to other carbon-based materials1267.Subsequently, explosion of publication on preparations of GO and rGO especially for large-scale or more facile fabrication has been observed.Defects and surface modification can enhance the capacitance by modulating graphene electronic structure and electrochemical properties.For example, an ~150% enhancement (~50 µF·cm-2) in measurable capacitance of few-layer graphene has been observed by defect incorporation1268.The great success of graphene in supercapacitors has intrigued attentions in other 2D single-elemental materials, such as borophene-1269,1270,silicene-1271-1273, and germanene-based1274materials.So far,silicene/germanene are mainly synthesized on substrates due to the lack of thermodynamic stability, so an in-depth study remains at a theoretical stage and advanced synthesis strategies are needed.As for EDL capacitive 2D materials like BP, h-BN, andg-C3N4, the reduction of their large electronic bandgap can be realized through a controlled doping process or forming heterostructures with graphene to mitigate the poor conductivity and restacking issues effectively1275-1277.
In the domain of pseudocapacitor, we will exclude some 2D transition metal oxides such as LDHs as their pseudo-capacitive behavior is generally not intrinsic1278,1279.On the other hand,layered TMDs show strong pseudocapacitance behavior because of their large surface area and variable oxidation states.The most interesting attribute of TMDs is their different polymorphs structures (e.g., 1T and 2H phases) (Fig.47b)370.Acerceetal.demonstrated that the high electrical conductivity and intrinsic hydrophilicity imparted 1T-phase MoS2the ability to intercalate various cations and interesting electrochemical properties for aqueous/organic supercapacitor devices156.Likewise, the exfoliated “distorted” 1T-phase (1T′) WTe2was reported to show good electrical conductivities and deliver a mass capacitance of 221 F·g-11280.2H-phase MoS2and layered oxides (δ-MnO2andα-MoO3) face some issues in common, namely, the poor electronic conductivity and inferior structural stability32.Previous works have tried to mitigate these two issues by foreign ion doping to narrow down the bandgap and improve electron transfer1281.1282.Of course, the most common strategy by hybridizing layered TMDs or oxides with conductive carbonaceous materials is always useful to facilitate charge transport, increase ion-accessible sites, enlarge interlayer space and impede restacking, thus giving rise to improved rate capability and cycling stability.
MXenes, particularly the conductive Ti3C2Tx, with high metallic conductivity and volumetric capacitance are widely explored in supercapacitors1283.In 2013, Lukatskayaetal.demonstrated that various cations (Li+, Na+, Mg2+, K+, NH4+, and Al3+ions) could readily intercalate between 2D Ti3C2Txlayers from aqueous solutions.Among which, binder-free Ti3C2Txpaper in basic solutions exhibited the best performance and yielded volumetric capacitance of up to 350 F·cm-3948.Subsequently, they continued to study the capacitive behavior of Ti3C2Txin organic electrolyte aiming at an extended voltage window and thus a larger energy density.It’s found that solvated or desolvated Li+can be intercalated when different organic solvents were used, which delivered significantly different capacitance1284.The development of Ti3C2Txin SCs also inspires the research of other MXenes like Ti2CTx1285and V2NTx1286.
Beyond inorganic ones, 2D organic materials offer chemical and structural tunability and physicochemical properties toward application in SCs (Fig.47b).Typical examples are conductive polymers, MOFs, and COFs.In general, these organic materials or functionalized organic materials1287,1288exhibit pseudocapacitive behaviourviaredox reactions.However, by virtue of their large compositional diversity, some 2D organic materials can store charge through EDL capacitive1289-1291and insertion pseudo-capacitive behaviour as well1292.Furthermore,2D MOFs and COFs as a novel class of porous crystalline organic materials can be directly applied for capacitive energy storage1293, or as sacrificial templates for resulting sulfide/carbon CoSNC1294and porous carbon1295for supercapacitor electrodes.
As above, a variety of 2D materials have emerged as favourable and competitive candidates in the application of supercapacitors.Modulation strategies, such as defect introduction, surface functionalization, and materials hybridization, are effective in enhancing the performance (Fig.47c).In addition, architecture engineering also has profound effect on electrochemical properties by exposing more reactive sites and regulating charge transports, e.g., vertical alignment of 2D materials1296, and restacking of exfoliated nanosheets into a 3D sponge1297or hydrogel electrodes1298.
Finally, the high mechanical strength and flexibility of 2D materials at atomic dimensions make them promising for the preparation of electrodes that are stretchable, flexible and tailorable (Fig.47d)1283.Research on that has proliferated over the recent years, like stretchable MXene/rGO-based supercapacitor (i.e., up to 300% uniaxial and 200% × 200% biaxial strain)1299, and flexible BP-CNTs-based supercapacitor(can withstand bending, rotating, twisting and folding deformation)1300.This will be a promising direction for 2D materials based electrodes in the study of device with both high mechanical robustness and electrochemical performance.
Fig.47 Supercapacitors based on 2D material electrodes: (a) electrochemical double layer mechanism and (b) pseudocapacitance.(c) Various strategies to enhance the electrochemical properties of 2D materials.(d) Unique mechanical properties of 2D materials compared to bulk electrode materials.
4.4.3 2D materials for micro-supercapacitors
The trend of miniaturizing electronic devices has pushed the development of integrated self-powered systems.The race to pack energy storage units with high energy, power density, low mass, and small volume into tiny devices is very competitive.While micro-batteries are undisputed in terms of energy density,the slow speed of charge-discharge and short cycling lifetime has limited the application in high-rate and cycling-intensive situations.This void has been filled by micro-supercapacitors(MSCs).The popularity of 2D materials as MSC electrode was not serendipitous; instead, their large specific surface area, high conductivity and inherent out-of-plane flexibility are essential for attaining high power density, decent energy density and robust mechanical properties of overall device.Moreover,stacked nanosheets are ideal high-rate electrodes for planar MSCs with interdigitated fingers since they feature more accessible surface and fast in-plane ion transport unhindered by separators used in typical sandwich MSCs, resulting in high power density1301.
For MSCs, four classes of 2D materials have been extensively researched with great success.These include graphene,transition metal oxides (TMOs), TMDs and MXenes.Each of these has specific advantages and disadvantages which decides the target application.For example, graphene is highly conductive but exhibits only EDLC.This makes it suitable for high-rate applications like AC-line filtering over frequency range of 1-10000 Hz, retaining EDLC behaviour even at scan rates of 1000 V·s-11302,1303.MXene-based MSCs exhibit capacitance as high as hundreds or thousands of farads per unit volume1304.In the following, we briefly discuss the suitability and challenges of 2D materials for MSCs without going to details of examples (Fig.48).
Fig.48 Factors of 2D materials that are suitable micro-supercapacitors.High conductivity and fast ionic diffusion are essential for high power performance.The inherently large surface area and engineerable pores increase the possibility to pack high energy density.The mechanical strength and out-of-plane flexibility are attractive for all-weather, wearable MSCs for integrated electronics.Doping, composites, and or heterostructures are general and effective strategies to render high-performance and multifunctional MSC electrodes.
The performance of MSCs is evaluated by three metrics of areal/volumetric capacitance, energy density and power density.At the microscopic scale we need be creative to achieve tradeoffs.Conductive 2D materials readily overcome two bottlenecks of both the surface area and resistance.Typically, graphene is one of the most ideal materials to achieve this, and there has been significant related research into graphene1305,1306.Even graphene synthesized using simple laser-induced reduction of graphene oxide or polymer could achieve capacitance in the range of 10 mF·cm-2and up to 32 mF·cm-2using KOH activation1307-1309.Graphene’s capacitance can be improved further by doping with electron donors or acceptors like N, S, B,which engineers its bandgap for better charge transfer/storage and enriches its surface chemistry by introducing defects and pseudocapacitance, thus increasing the activity1310-1312.Despite several other elemental nanosheets have been isolated,phosphorene is the only one that has been applied in MSCs due to the large interlayer space (5.3 Å) between its puckered lamellar structure allowing fast ion diffusion1275.Because of such unique advantages from 2D structure, it can achieve high power density of around 10 W·cm-3and retain capacitive performance at 100 V·s-11275,1313.Most of its applications for MSCs hybridize it with other materials that offer protection from environment, improve inter-lamellar conduction and prevent reaggregation1300,1314,1315.
The energy output of EDLC materials does not scale well into miniaturized devices.Therefore, it is necessary to employ pseudocapacitive materials (MXenes, metal oxides,etc.)functioning on Faradic reactions at electrode/electrolyte interface.These combine the structural advantage of 2D materials with rich electrochemistry.As discussed above, TMD and TMO nanosheets are attractive pseudocapacitive materials.The 1T phase TMDs have conductivity orders of magnitudes higher than 2H phase ones in addition to larger interlayer spacing and number of active sites1316.However, TMD nanosheets tend to be less flexible due to their multilayer structure and may easily crack if applied to MSC electrodes.Also, TMOs usually employ additional conductive fillers to compensate the poor conductivity.In addition, they are both prone to reaggregation which cuts off both electronic transport and access to active sites.To tackle this challenge, forming composites is an effective solution.Compositing with graphene preserves the active sites and provides fast electronic transport channel which is essential for exploiting their excellent pseudocapacitance.Very recently,an ultrafast photonic reduction technique was reported which could manufacture 30000 graphene/MnO2electrodes in 1 min,with high areal capacitance 128 mF·cm-21317.MXenes overcome the chemical inertness of graphene and low conductivity of TMO/TMDs, thus it is an ideal material for smaller, multifunctional and self-sufficient MSCs packing high energy and power1221,1318-1320.But this superstar material still face shortcomings of moisture-related degradation and brittleness.For instance, nanocellulose additive offers incredible mechanical strength (341 MPa with 20% nanocellulose)1321,carbon or sodium ascorbate coating provides resistance against oxidation1322,1323, and compositing with graphene makes MXene-based electrodes stretchable (300% under uniaxial strain)1299.Such enhancements are important to achieve allweather MSCs that deliver desired electrochemical performance.Incorporation of new materials into MXene-framework may also impart unique functions like pressure sensing1324and selfhealing1325which may not only reduce the footprint of integrated devices but also extend the usable life of such devices.
Finally, 2D materials provide a way for addressing the issue of close approach of ions to active material surface in the form of pore engineering1326.Through theoretical andinsituinvestigations the dependence of capacitive mechanism on pore size distribution through desolvation of electrolyte’s ion hydration shell has been adequately established1327-1329.Porous nanosheets could be the essential building blocks for hierarchical porous structures with nano- and meso-pores that could provide a trade-off between diffusion and charge storage capacity,enabling highly tuneable performance in MSCs by simply changing some synthesis parameters.In this regard, ordered bulk materials with hierarchical porosity could act as source or templates for obtaining nanosheets that inherit the parent porosity1330-1332.For example, Linetal.has made great progress in fabricating well-defined porous graphene from polyimide films using the cost-effective, high throughput laser-scribing method1309.This method can also be used for boron doping which increases capacitance by three times to 16.5 mF·cm-21333.The pore size can be tuned by controlling the laser power1334.Pore engineering of 2D materials is a superb strategy to activate intercalation pseudocapacitance in materials that may exhibit inherent redox activity and thus improve suitability of some materials for MSCs which were otherwise overlooked1273,1335.
Despite the large number of reports, it is unlikely that a single 2D material will remove all the obstacles in the path of industrylevel fabrication of MSCs.As human needs evolve, so will the demand for specific types of MSCs.For such situations we must build a repository of detailed information on protocols for rational hybridization of 2D materials and their mechanisms.
4.5 Solar cells
Solar cells, which directly convert the solar energy into electrical energyviaphotovoltaic effect, are multilayered devices, in which the light harvesting layer is sandwiched between the anode and cathode.In general, charge transport layers in terms of hole transport layer (HTL) and electron transport layer (ETL) are inserted between the photoactive layer and the anode or cathode, respectively, to facilitate the efficient collection of photogenerated charge carriers at respective electrodes.With the development trends in the community of solar cells stepping toward high flexibility, low cost and light weight, the unique mechanical and optoelectronic properties of 2D materials enabled them promising candidates in designing the next generation solar cells.These atomically thin 2D materials have exhibited very large light-matter interaction,unique electrical and structural properties, and controllable optical bandgap structures, making it possible to obtain a high conversion efficiency of solar energy using a minimal amount of active absorber materials1336.The structural properties of 2D materials, including the number of layers, defects and dopants,phase, strain, and composition, could greatly change their properties and thus affect the overall performance of solar devices1337.Recently, 2D materials have been widely explored in the fabrication of high-performance solar cells as electrodes,charge transport layers and photoactive layers (Fig.49),respectively.
Fig.49 Device structure and work mechanism of solar cells, and the application of 2D materials in solar cells.
4.5.1 Electrodes
In general, indium-doped tin oxide (ITO) and fluorine-doped tin oxide (FTO) are frequently used transparent electrodes in solar cells, but their expensive price, time-consuming processing and brittle nature restricted their applications.In contrast, owing to the cost-effective manufacturing, ambipolar conductivities and robust mechanical properties, electrically conductive 2D materials in terms of graphene13382D MOFs withπ-dconjugated coordination1339and MXenes1340etc., are promising candidates to replace the traditional ITO and FTO.It was noted that both the transmittance and conductivity of 2D materials vary with the number of layers.A compromise must be reached between the conductivity and transmittance of the transparent electrodes based on 2D materials, and chemical modifications and heteroatom doping have been realized as efficient strategies to reduce their sheet resistance while maintaining the high transmittance1341,1342.For examples, a single layer of chemically doped graphene was employed as transparent electrode in flexible perovskite solar cells, resulting in an efficiency up to 18% with excellent bending durability.Furthermore, 2D materials, especially graphene, can also be used as top electrode to replace the traditional metals (Au, Ag, Cuetc.), and some promising benefits can be obtained.For examples, graphene electrodes enabled the fabrication of HTL-free perovskite solar cells1343and semitransparent solar cells1344, which open new applications in power generating windows or tandem solar cells.Moreover, the application of 2D materials as electrode in solar cells can boost the device stability compared to the metal counterparts, because the carbon based materials are not diffusive into the neighboring layers and the thick and hydrophobic carbon materials can act as good encapsulating layers to prevent the moisture permeation1345.
4.5.2 Charge transport layers
It is well established that the 2D materials are composed of a monolayer or multilayered nanosheets bondedviavan der Walls forces.The dangling bonds and defect states are generally absent at the 2D thin film surface and their optoelectronic properties are adjustable by varying the number of layers127.Moreover, asformed 2D thin films exhibit atomic-level smoothness, enabling fast charge transport and a good compatibility with the deposition of upper layers.Therefore, 2D materials can be functioned as charge transport layers in solar cells.For examples, TMDs, such as SnS21346, TiS21347and MoS21348, are recently used as efficient electron and hole transport layers in solar cells.The electronic properties of the TMDs can be tuned by modifying the transition metals or chalcogens according to the properties of the photoactive layers, thus resulting in improved stability and efficiency.MXenes such as Ti3C2Txare another type of 2D materials based on transition metals with high versatile chemistry and metallic conductivity.After appropriate treatments, MXenes can be used as charge transport materials to improve the interface property between the MXene and photoactive layer with improved contact intimacy and well aligned energy level1349.And also, 2D metal oxide nanosheets made from conventional charge transport materials such as TiO2were also employed as ETL in perovskite solar cells.Compared to crystalline TiO2, the multilayered 2D TiO2nanosheets prepared at low-temperature process exhibited excellent flexibility and good coverage on a variety of substrates, and also greatly inhibited the photoinduced performance degradation because of the low oxygen vacancy1350.In addition, some 2D materials such as MXenes1351, BP1352,1353, graphene1354and their derivatives were also considered to be incorporated into or combined with the conventional charge transporting layers to enhance their conductivity or optimize the electronic properties.Therefore, the application of 2D charge transport layers in solar cells can bring in synergistic effects with smoothened interface contact, well matched energy level, low defect density and high intrinsic conduction, thus resulting in reduced non-radiative charge recombination at the interface and hence improved device performance.
4.5.3 Photoactive layer
2D materials can principally be used as solely photoactive layers in ultrathin solar cells because of their good light absorbing ability and direct bandgap characters at the monolayer level.Particularly, 2D perovskites such as Ruddlesden-Popper(RP) phase and Dion-Jacobson (DJ) phase, have attracted extensive investigation because of their excellent operational stability compared to 3D perovskites356.In order to improve the efficiency of the 2D perovskite solar cells and make them competitive with their 3D counterparts, recent efforts have been focused on the understanding of the interlayer interaction between neighboring perovskite sheets, which can be strengthenedviacompositional modification on the 2D perovskites to introduce some additional high-energy bonds besides the Coulombic and hydrogen bonds1355.In addition,reducing the quantum well width distribution1356or even fabricating phase-pure quantum well films1357are another strategies to further enhance the device performance.As a result,efficiency up to 18% with significantly enhanced stability can be obtained in 2D perovskite solar cells.And also, 2D materials can be combined with other light harvesting materials to form Si/2D or “all 2D” heterojunction solar cells1358.In particular, a solar cell based on a monolayer MoS2/monolayer WSe2can obtain an efficiency up to 2.56%1359.Even though the “all 2D” solar cells are not as effective as conventional solar cells because of the ultrathin layer thickness, the unique properties such as extremely high ratio of watt-per-gram, flexibility and transparency rendered them promising applications in the next-generation photovoltaics.Similarly, 2D materials including GO1360, BP1361,g-C3N41362, 2D perovskites1363,etc., can also be incorporated into the photoactive layer or used as interface engineer to regulate the crystallization, passivate defect states or encapsulate the photoactive layer, and hence simultaneously improve the device efficiency and operational stability.
4.6 Biomedical applications
Graphene was first demonstrated as an efficient nanocarrier for a water-insoluble aromatic anticancer drug delivery in 20081364.Since then, 2D materials have been investigated extensively for various biomedical applications, such as drug delivery,biosensors, wearable/implantable devices, bio-imaging,diagnosis, therapeutics and regenerative medicine to surmount the limitations found in traditional modalities of diagnosis and treatment, owing to their unusual structure and properties deriving from the ultrathin atom-thick planar surfaces.To data,2D materials have attained remarkable accomplishments and progresses in biomedical fields.
Some family members of 2D biomaterials have been exploited as cutting-edge tools for a host of biomedical utilizations,attributing to their following distinct characteristics, such as (i)the desirable atomic thickness for biosensing and gene-sequence detection; (ii) high near-infrared (NIR) absorption for photothermal therapy (PTT) and photoacoustic (PA) imaging at both the first and second biological window; (iii) substantial generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) under the activation of endogenous chemical activators (e.g., H2O2) or external physical triggers (e.g., light, ultrasound and X-ray) for nanodynamic therapy (e.g., chemodynamic therapy (CDT),photodynamic therapy (PDT), sonodynamic therapy (SDT) and radiodynamic therapy (RDT)); (iv) high atomic number elements allowing them as the contrast agents for precise computed tomography (CT) imaging; (v) effect on the proton relaxation of water enabling magnetic resonance (MR) imaging;(vi) ultrahigh specific surface area for utilization as drug delivery system with the capability of encapsulating plentiful guest molecules (e.g., small molecular drugs, genes,biomacromolecules and fluorescent dyes), controlling ondemand drug release and integrating other functional moieties(e.g., contrast agents) for implementing specific disease theragnostic.
As a typical type known for cancer treatment that utilizes drugs to eliminate tumor cells, chemotherapy has made a dramatic impact in prolonging survival of millions of patients1365.There exist three major challenges during cancer therapy, namely the early detection, tumor metastasis and multidrug resistance (MDR).Moreover, successful treatment cannot be implemented without precise diagnosis.To achieve effective utilization of delivered drugs, the augmented diagnostic imaging-guided and on-demand drug delivery is essential to maximize the use of drugs.Taking graphene for example, graphene modified with functional nanoparticles has been fabricated to provide additional properties and functions for tumor imaging and treatments.In 2014, Chenetal.successfully designed a multifunctional stimuli-responsive doxorubicin(DOX)-loaded nanosystem by co-integration of Fe3O4and MnOxonto GO using a double redox strategy (Fig.50a)1366.MnOxcould realize the pH-/reduction-activated T1-weighted magnetic resonance (MR) imaging.After Fe3O4integration, this nanosystem was not only used for contrast-enhanced T2-MRI,but also acted as a magnetic-hyperthermia nanoagent.By combined treatment with DOX-enabled chemotherapy, such a theranostic planar nanoplatform significantly inhibited the cancer metastasis and reversed the MDR of cancer cells.Notably, the strong and broad optical absorption in NIR region makes 2D materials possible to convert the light energy into heat energy for PTT.Beyond chemotherapy, PTT, PDT, radiotherapy(RT), magnetic hyperthermia and immunotherapy are the major types of monotherapies.
In view of the setbacks of monotherapy, combined therapy could offer superior advantages by making the best of the cooperative enhancement of each individual treatment.Daietal.reported on the integration of graphene with TiO2and MnOx,forming MnOx/TiO2-graphene nanocomposites, which could serve as constrast agents for pH-responsive T1-weighed MRI and nanosonosensitizers for PTT-enhanced sonodynamic therapy on synergistically combating cancer1368.Encouraged by the success of graphene, monoelement 2D nanostructures, such as BP, are distinguished from other 2D materials by its easy and controllable degradation, and its degradation rate mainly relies on the oxygen content and thickness.In consideration of the degradation products such as phosphate anions those are essential for human health, Yangetal.constructed the multifunctional BP-integrated robust 3D-printed bioactive glass scaffold for therapeutic tissue engineering, which could be highlighted as the desirable countermeasure for the efficient topical treatment of osteosarcoma and simultaneous bone regeneration (Fig.50b)1367.Hereafter, research indicates that the degradation behavior of BP in tumor cells is different from that in normal cells, which induces phosphate anions acute accumulation in cancer cells for selective chemotherapy1369.
Fig.50 Biomedical applications of 2D biomaterials.(a) Multifunctional GO-based stimuli-responsive nanotheranostics.(a1) The scheme of double redox strategy to fabricate Fe3O4/MnOx-GO composite nanosystems.(a2) The scheme of MnOx decomposition and Mn2+ release under either mild acidic or redox environment.(b) Schematic representation of the synthesis regarding BP-BG scaffold and the therapeutic countermeasure for osteosarcoma based on osteogenesis by BP-BG.(a) Reproduced with permission from Ref.1366, Copyright 2014 John Wiley and Sons.(b) Reproduced with permission from Ref.1367, Copyright 2018 John Wiley and Sons.
Through continuous exploration and innovation, we have witnessed enormous strides in biomedical application of 2D materials.Higher expectations are inevitably followed by more stringent standards.Obviously, each 2D material possess its own unique advantages and disadvantages.Although bold steps have been made toward 2D biomaterials up to now, they still encounter substantial hurdles for clinical translation.For example, the inextricable issues including difficult batch production, lacking reproducibility, uncontrollable number of layers, indisciplinable morphology and wide size distributions present the benchmarks of 2D materials in clinical trials.The dispersibility and stability of 2D materials in aqueous solutions are of both scientific and technological significance for biomedicine.Furthermore, the potential long-term side effects and cumulative toxicity remain the most important concerns for 2D materials and its derivatives, especially for inorganic 2D materials.According to the current findings, both surface chemistry and size effect play key roles in influencing the biological behaviors, fate and toxicity of 2D materials.However,at this point, much remains unknown regarding whether or not and how 2D materials could be biologically degraded or metabolized in living organism.
4.7 Sensing applications
Since the successful application of graphene in the construction of sensing platforms for chemical and biological molecules detection, 2D materials including TMDs (e.g., MoS2and WS2), MXenes, BP, g-C3N4, graphyne, NMDs, h-BN and transition metal oxides (e.g., WO3and MnO2) have been considered as powerful materials for the design of sensing platforms49,1370-1373.Combined with fluorescence, surfaceenhanced Raman scattering (SERS), surface plasmon resonance(SPR), FET, electrochemistry and colorimetry, the 2D materialbased sensing platforms have been employed to detect heavy metal ions, organic compounds, pesticides residues, antibiotics,nucleic acids, proteins, bacteria and cells1374,1375.
4.7.1 Fluorescence sensing platforms
Since the theoretical and experimental evidence of the fluorescence quenching ability of graphene and its derivatives,hundreds of works have proved that 2D materials have this ability to efficiently quench the fluorescence of fluorophores1376-1379.As a proof of the concept, Heetal.found that GO efficiently quenched the fluorescence of three dyes-labelled single-strand DNA (ssDNA) probes.With the addition of p 16, p 21 and p 53 genes, the corresponding fluorescence of carboxy fluorescein(FAM), cyanine 5 (Cy5) and 6-carboxy-X-rhodamine (ROX)were recovered.According to this phenomenon, this graphenebased sensing platform was used to simultaneously analyze three genes1380.Inspired by this interesting finding, Zhuetal.firstly reported a MoS2-based fluorescence sensor.As we know, MoS2nanosheet has different affinity towards ssDNA and doublestrand DNA (dsDNA), leading to the fluorescence intensity of dsDNA recovering after the addition of target DNA.As a result,the designed fluorescence biosensor can efficiently determine DNA and other biomolecules1381.Similarly, Ti3C2nanosheets1382,MXenes1383, BP1384and MOFs1385have been successful used to construct fluorescence sensing platforms for HPV, bacteria,ctDNA and cyanide detection, respectively.
Besidesinvitroanalysis, 2D material-based sensing platforms have been also used to analyze intracellular molecules.Lietal.immobilized FAM-labelled peptide onto polydopamine and PEG co-functionalized MoS2nanosheet to construct an intracellular sensing platform for the detection of caspase-3 activity.Taking human cervical carcinoma (HeLa) cells as a model, the designed MoS2-based sensing platform can efficiently analyze intracellular caspase-3 activity, which was proved by confocal laser scanning microscopy and flow cytometry1386.To enhance the performance of 2D material-based sensing platforms, Zhuet al.introduced signal amplification strategy into MoS2-based sensing platform.As shown in Fig.51, three Cy3-labelled molecular beacons co-absorbed on the surface of MoS2nanosheet.With the addition of microRNA-21 (miRNA-21),“Y”-shaped three-branched duplex nanostructure was formed and released from MoS2surface, making the fluorescence recover.With the help of catalyzed hairpin assembly (CHA)reaction, the detection limit of this sensing platform was down to 75.6 amol·L-1, which is much lower than other similar detection strategies1387.
Fig.51 Scheme of the MoS2-based fluorescence sensing platform for detection and imaging of miRNA-21 in cells.Reproduced with permission from Ref.1387, Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society.
4.7.2 SPR sensing platforms
The introduction of 2D materials into SPR sensors can efficiently improve their sensitivity.A typical example was given by Wuetal., who found that the sensitivity of SPR sensor improved with the increasing the graphene layer1388.This exciting work pave a way for application of 2D materials in SPR sensing platforms.According to this concept, Kumaretal.systematically studied the performance of SPR sensors based on WS2, MoS2and graphene, respectively.The experimental results showed that monolayer WS2-constructed SPR sensor has better sensitivity (180 (°)·RIU-1) than those constructed by monolayer MoS2(174 (°)·RIU-1) and graphene (157 (°)·RIU-1),respectively.Unexpectedly, monolayer graphene-constructed SPR sensor has smaller full width at half maxima (FWHM),higher quality parameter and detection accuracy1389.In 2019,Xueetal.employed antimonene to develop a SPR sensing platform for ultrasensitive microRNA detection due to the strong affinity between antimonene and ssDNA (Fig.52).More delocalized 5s/5porbitals in antimonene led to lower detection limit (10 amol·L-1) of this SPR sensor, which is much lower than those of published miRNA sensors1390.
Fig.52 Fabrication of antimonene-based SPR sensor for miRNA detection 1390.
2D material-based SPR sensing platforms were also used to detect proteins and bacteria.For example, a SPR sensor was constructed for recognizing and detecting BSA protein based on carboxyl-MoS2nanosheet.Under the same detection condition,the SPR angle signal of carboxyl-MoS2-based sensor was 3.1 folds than that of MoS2-based sensor1391.Kaushiketal.developed a label-free SPR immunosensor for Escherichia coli detection based on biofunctionalized MoS2nanosheets.Under optimal condition, this SPR immunosensor exhibited low detection limit (94 CFU·mL-1) and high sensitivity (2.9 nm/1000 CFU·mL-1) for Escherichia coli detection1392.Construction of 2D materials-based nanoprobes is a popular way to improve the analytical performance of SPR sensing platforms.For example,Nieetal.developed a SPR sensing platform for ultrasensitive detection of miRNA-141 by using gold nanoparticles-decorated MoS2nanocomposites (AuNPs-MoS2) as nanoprobes.Once the formation of a classical “sandwich” DNA structure, resonance angle of this SPR sensor obviously shifted.Therefore, this SPR sensing platform can detect as low as 0.5 fmol·L-1miRNA-141 with the amplification effect of AuNPs-MoS2nanoprobe1393.
4.7.3 Surface-enhanced Raman scattering sensing platforms
Compared with noble metal nanostructures, 2D materials have weaker Raman enhancement due to the chemical enhancement mechanism, which was proved Linetal.1394.Subsequently, h-BN, WS2, MoS2and MXene have been reported as SERS-active substrates with small Raman enhancement factors ranging from 10 to 1001395-1397.Unfortunately, these small enhancement factors limited the application of 2D materials in SERS sensors1370.
To improve the Raman enhancement, hybridization of 2D materials with noble metal nanostructures is a useful way.It is well known that 2D materials possess large surface area, which can load a large number of noble metal nanostructures.As a result, the Raman enhancement of these 2D nanocomposites are much stronger than 2D materials.These exciting findings accelerated the development 2D material-based SERS sensors.For example, gold nanoparticles supported on the surface of MoS2nanosheet to form MoS2-based nanocomposites (MoS2-AuNPs), which exhibited stronger Raman enhancement than MoS2nanosheet1398.Similarly, Singhaetal.reported theinsitugrowth of AuNPs on the surface of three-dimensional MoS2nanoflowers to construct SERS-active substrate for bilirubin detection.It should be noted that the enhancement factor of this nanocomposite is 1091399.Xieetal.developed a SERS-active sensing platform for organic pollutants detection based on gold nanorods (AuNRs)-MXene (Ti3C2Tx) nanocomposites.Large amounts of AuNRs supported on the surface of MXene generated abundant “hot spot”, making the detection limits of this sensing platform for rhodamine 6G, crystal violet, and malachite green detection are down to 1, 1, and 100 pmol·L-1,respectively (Fig.53)1400.For improving the detection selectivity, Shorieetal.combined aptamer with AuNPsdecorated WS2nanocomposite (WS2-AuNPs) to construct a SERS sensing platform for cardiac marker myoglobin (Mb)analysis.Expectedly, this proposed sensing platform showed high detection performance included wide detection range (10 fg·mL-1to 0.1 μg·mL-1), which was ascribed to the high Raman enhancement generated from the synergistic effect of WS2-AuNPs nanocomposites1401.
Fig.53 Schematic illustration of SERS sensing platform for organic pollutants detection based on the MXene/AuNR composite.Reproduced with permission from Ref.1400, Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society.
2D materials are also promising candidates to construct Raman probes for signal amplification.For instance, Fuetal.constructed a SERS immunosensor for cardiac troponin I (cTnI)detection by using GO loaded with large amounts of antibody/Raman reporter-labeled AuNPs as SERS nanotags.With the signal amplification of GO-based SERS nanotags, this designed SERS sensing platform has a wide linear range (0.01-1000 ng·mL-1) and a low detection limit (5 pg·mL-1) for the detection of cTnI1402.Similarly, Achaduetal.group used GO as a SERS-active substrate and molybdenum trioxide nanocube as a SERS nanotag to construct an immunosensor for norovirus detection.Due to the synergistic effect of SERS substrate and nanotag, this proposed immunosensor obtained a ~109-fold signal amplification, resulting in an ultralow detection limit for norovirus detection (~5.2 fg·mL-1).It should be noted that this immunosensor can determine as low as ~60 RNA copy·mL-1in human fecal samples, which is much lower than that of a commercial kit1403.
4.7.4 Field-effect transistor sensing platforms
FET is considered as a promising sensing platform for the analysis of chemical/biological molecules due to its rapid sensing capability and readable electrical signals.Since the discovery of graphene, 2D materials are extensively employed as ideal channel materials to construct FET sensing platform due to their high surface area, large transconductance and exceptional chemical stability and biocompatibility.Graphene has become the main focal point of 2D FET-based chemical and biological sensing, delivering excellent performance in at both single-nanosheet and thin-film level in various chemical and biological sensing1404,1405.Seoetal.utilized graphene to design FET sensing platform for severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) detection due to its high carrier mobility (15000 cm2·V-1·s-1) and large surface area.As shown in Fig.54, an obvious signal was observed when SARS-CoV-2 protein specifically bound with the corresponding spike antibody.This proposed FET sensing platform could determine 100 fg·mL-1SARS-CoV-2 protein and 2.42 × 102copy·mL-1SARS-CoV-2 in clinical samples1406, respectively.To improve the selectivity, Xuetal.immobilized aptamer on the surface of graphene to selectively recognize and detect adenosine triphosphate (ATP).Due to the special binding effect between aptamer and ATP, this FET sensing platform can selectively analyze 0.5 pmol·L-1ATP, which is several orders lower than some published works1407.In 2021, the same group developed graphene-based FET sensing platform to monitor interactions between drug imatinib and Abl1 protein1408.Formation of noble metal nanostructures-supported graphene nanocomposites can efficiently improve the analytical performance of FET sensing platform.For example, Zhang and co-worker designed a labelfree FET sensor for brain natriuretic peptide (BNP) detection based on platinum nanoparticles (PtNPs)-decorated graphene nanocomposites.Experimental results suggested that this sensing platform could determine BNP in whole blood sample1409.
Fig.54 Schematic of graphene-based FET sensor for COVID-19 detection 1406.
Compared with graphene, MoS2possessed thickness-tunable bandgaps and excellent electrical properties, which is considered as an ideal channel material to construct next-generation of FET devices1410.In 2019, Gongetal.utilized MoS2nanosheet to design a label-free FET sensor for high-sensitive detection of fibroblast growth factor 21 (FGF21).As expected, this MoS2-based FET sensing platform can analyze as low as 10 fg·mL-1FGF21 without the assistance of additional adsorption layers.Moreover, this sensing platform can determine FGF21 in complex real samples1411.In the same year, Liuetal.developed a MoS2-based FET sensing platform for screening of Down syndrome.The experimental test suggested that this proposed FET sensor has low detection limit of 100 amol·L-1, high selectivity and high signal response for chromosome 21 detection.The real-time test further proved that this sensing platform could analyze chromosome 21 in the peripheral blood of pregnant women1412.Besides graphene and MoS2, other 2D materials are also suitable for construction of FET sensing platform, such as MXene1413and BP1414.
4.7.5 Electrochemical sensors
Since Zhouetal.successfully employed graphene to construct electrochemical sensing platforms for biological molecules detection1415, 2D materials have attracted more and more attentions in sensing field because of their excellent physical and chemical properties, such as fast electron transfer kinetics, high electrical conductivity, large surface area and so on1416.Nowadays, constructing high-performance sensing platforms with new 2D materials is one of the hot research directions.Generally, 2D materials are often employed as electrode modifiers to construct sensing platforms.For example, Suetal.decorated AuNPs on the surface of MoS2nanosheet to obtain high-performance nanocomposites.Such nanocomposites modified electrodes have been proved as excellent sensing ability for dopamine, uric acid and glucose detection1417-1419.The further study suggested that MoS2-based nanocomposites could efficiently load hemoglobin to construct an electrochemical sensing platform for hydrogen peroxide (H2O2)detection due to their good biocompatibility1420.Besides MoS2,black phosphorene and WS2were also employed to construct enzymatic sensing platforms1421,1422.These exciting findings attracted more researchers to develop 2D materials-based electrochemical sensing platforms with high-performance,accelerating the application of 2D materials in sensing field.
The introduction of 2D materials into electrochemical sensing platforms often bring high sensitivity, high selectivity and high stability.For example, Caietal.fabricated an immunosensor for leptin detection based on porous graphene-black phosphorus nanocomposites.The conductive capability and protein loading capacity of this sensing platform were improved after the immobilization of nanocomposites.As a result, the analytical performance of this immunosensor was improved, which can detect 0.036 pg·mL-1leptin with a wide linear range (0.150-2500 pg·mL-1)1423.Suetal.combined methylene blue with MoS2nanosheet to construct a multifunctional electrochemical sensing platform for the label-free detection of miRNA-21.More interestingly, this designed sensing platform also possesses excellent electrocatalytic ability, which can be used to individually and simultaneously determine dopamine (DA) and uric acid (UA) with satisfactory results1424.Mahmoudianetal.synthesized a Pt/g-C3N4/polythiophene nanocomposite (Pt/g-C3N4/PTh NCs) and used it to construct electrochemical sensing platform for mercury ion detection.From electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) measurements, they found the introduction of g-C3N4could efficiently improve the Pt adsorption, resulting in the electron transfer facilitating.As a result, introduction of g-C3N4can efficiently improve the sensing performance, making the detection limit of this sensing platform down to 0.009 nmol·L-1for Hg2+detection1425.
2D materials and their nanocomposites are also considered as promising candidates to construct nanoprobes, which can efficiently amplify electrochemical signals of sensing platforms.Suetal.assembled horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-labelled carcinoembryonic monoclonal antibody (anti-CEA) on the surface of MoS2-AuNPs nanocomposites to construct nanoprobes.Then, they used HRP instead of bovine serum albumin(BSA) to block the remaining active sites.With the assistance of enzymatic catalytic reaction, this nanoprobe efficiently amplified electrochemical responses of the designed immunesensor for carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) analysis due to the triple signal amplification strategy.It should be noted that MoS2-AuNPs nanocomposite not only used as a substrate to load abundant anti-CEA and HRP, but also used as a nanocatalyst to amplify electrochemical signal1426.Two years later, the same group developed a multilayer nanoprobe (MLNP) for miRNA-21 detection based on MoS2-AuNPs nanocomposites.Experimental data suggested MoS2-based MLNPs brought the proposed sensing platform ultrawide dynamic range (10 amol·L-1-1 μmol·L-1) and ultralow detection limit (38 amol·L-1)for miRNA-21 detection compared with single-layer nanoprobe(SLNP).Moreover, this sensing platform could analyze miRNA-21 in 100 HeLa cell lysates (Fig.55)1427.
Fig.55 Construction of electrochemical sensing platform for the detection of miRNA-21 based on MoS2-based nanoprobes 1427.
4.7.6 Colorimetric sensors
Since the intrinsic enzyme mimetic activity of magnetite(Fe3O4) was discovered by Yan and co-worker, “nanoenzyme”have been received more and more scientists’ recognition1428.The intrinsic peroxidase-like activity of carboxyl-modified graphene oxide (GO-COOH) was firstly reported by Songet al.1429, 2D materials with peroxidase-like, glucose oxidase-like catalytic activities have aroused the interest of researchers in the construction of colorimetric sensors, including MoS2, WS2, Rh and g-C3N41430-1433.A typical example was offered by Leeetal.They combined G-quadruplex DNAzyme with GO to design a simple sensing platform for visual detection of microRNA.The application of GO concentrates the G-quadruplex DNAzyme,enhancing the analytical performance of this colorimetric sensing platform for 1 nmol·L-1microRNA detection1434.Lanet al.investigated the analytical performance of WS2-based colorimetric sensing platforms for DNA detection.Combined the different affinity of WS2towards ssDNA and dsDNA with the ion-induced aggregation, this proposed sensing platform can detect as low as 1.54 nmol·L-1target DNA with high selectivity.After introduction of HCR amplification strategy, the detection limit of WS2-based colorimetric sensing platforms was down to 0.23 nmol·L-11435.
To improve the sensitivity of colorimetric sensing platforms,formation of 2D materials-based nanocomposites becomes a popular method.Generally, 2D materials-based nanocomposites bring better performances due to the synergistic effect of 2D materials and functionalized groups.For example, Wanetal.decorated high catalytic activity of gold@platinum (Au@Pt)bimetallic nanoparticles on MoS2surface to form MoS2-based nanocomposites (MoS2-Au@Pt).The proposed nanocomposites exhibited high peroxidase-mimicking activity towards 3,3′,5,5′-tetramethylbenzidine (TMB) oxidation in the presence of H2O2.The added cysteine inhibited this catalytic reaction, making the solution change from blue to colorless.According to this phenomenon, they constructed a simple and label-free colorimetric sensing platform for cysteine detection with high sensitivity based on MoS2-Au@Pt nanocomposites.More importantly, this sensing platform showed excellent selectivity,which can efficiently distinguish cysteine from homocysteine and 19 other amino acids1436.Similarly, Xiaoetal.reported a colorimetric immunosensor for CEA detection based on the catalytic activity of AuNPs-supported Bi2Se3(Au/Bi2Se3)nanocomposites.As shown in Fig.56, the catalytic activity of Au/Bi2Se3nanocomposites towards the reduction of 4-nitrophenol (4-NP) by sodium borohydride was inhibited after the immobilization of anti-CEA.The reason was ascribed to the catalytic sites of the nanocomposites were blocked by anti-CEA.When CEA added into the detection strategy, the catalytic activity of Au/Bi2Se3nanocomposites recovered and made the solution changed from yellow to colorless.Under optimal condition, this colorimetric sensing platform can detect 160 pg·mL-1CEA with high selectivity1437.Inspired by these exciting works, Zr-MOFs1438, MoS2-AuNPs nanocomposites1439,Prussian blue (PB)-Ti3C2Txhybrid composites1440, Pt-deposited NiCo-LDH1441and copper hydroxide nitrate1442have been employed to construct colorimetric sensing platforms for chemical/biological molecules detection.
Fig.56 Construction of colorimetric sensor for CEA detection based on Au/Bi2Se3 nanocomposites.Reproduced with permission from Ref.1437, Copyright 2017 American Chemical Society.
4.8 Flexible electronics
In the recent 5 years, 2D materials for flexible electronics has been transited from the initial stage of demonstration into deeper understanding and real applications.Herein, we discuss the recent progress of 2D materials for flexible electronics from two aspects: graphene and other semiconducting 2D materials, and outlooked their future.
Due to the superior optoelectronic properties of graphene and the great success in synthesizing large-area graphene, it has attracted tremendous attention for flexible electronics, ranging from the flexible logic circuits1443,1444, displays1445,1446, energy storage and conversion1447,1448devices to wearable healthcare sensors1449,1450.As for the application of high-speed graphene FETs and RF devices, low contact resistance between graphene and metal electrode has been regarded as the prerequisite.Several works have been focused on optimizing the contact resistance by forming various types of graphene-metal geometries, such as bottom-, edge-, and top-contact1451,1452.Liuetal.developed a bottom-contact strategy by transferring CVD grown monolayer graphene onto Au electrode and achieved an ultralow contact resistance (65 Ω·µm) without harsh thermal annealing process (Fig.57a), which is suitable for flexible electronics1453.
Stretchable electronics, which require the devices to withstand a certain mechanical stress, is more challenging and particularly useful in wearable healthcare.Liuetal.achieved stretchable graphene electrodes by utilizing naturally CVD grown graphene to form graphene/graphene scrolls structure, and demonstrated all-carbon transistors which can function very well even up to 120% strain (Fig.57b, c)1454.It is believed that graphene scrolls take the role of connecting cracked domains and increasing the interlayer sliding upon strain.Taking the advantage of this idea,Qiuetal.reported graphene-based epidermal electrodes that are able to endure the stretching of skin and sense weak electrophysiological signals such as electrocardiograms (ECG),electromyograms (EMG), and electroencephalograms (EEG)1455.By semi-embedding the graphene/graphene fibers into an elastomeric substrate, the entire electrode is similar to the structure of bird nest, and can be repetitively used for recording the electrophysiological signals (Fig.57d).The semi-embedding design and 2D/1D hybrid structure enabled the “robustness” of graphene electrodes, pushing CVD graphene further for real applications in wearable healthcare.Although monolayer graphene grown by CVD on Cu foil features in highconductivity and optical transparency, few-layer graphene obtained by solution-processing and laser-fabrication have been widely studied for flexible electronics due to the easy fabrication1456.They mostly start with GO and employ chemical or physical methods to reduce GO to be rGO for higher conductivity.Taking laser-fabrication graphene as an example,versatile flexible devices have been demonstrated, such as generators1457,1458, supercapacitors1459-1461, sensors1462,1463,optoelectronic devices1464,1465, electro-actuators1466,1467and integrated devices1468,1469.Sunetal.fabricated 3D patterned and porous graphene/elastomer sponges by laser induced technique,and demonstrated a gas-permeable and multi-functional device that can sense electrophysiological, hydration, temperature,joule-heating signals at the same time (Fig.57e)1462.Compared with CVD monolayer graphene, laser-fabrication based graphene flexible electronics are advantageous in sensors and supercapacitors, which require massive production.But in terms of optical transparency and smooth surface of the electrode,CVD monolayer graphene show great strengths in optoelectronics, such as OLEDs1470,1471, photodetectors436,1465,and tattoo-based epidermal electronics1469,1472.
Fig.57 (a) Scheme of the concept of graphene-metal bottom contacts to achieve ultralow contact resistance; reproduced with permission from Ref.1453, Copyright 2019 American Chemistry Society.(b) Scheme of all-carbon stretchable transistor, with graphene/graphene scrolls as source and drain electrodes and single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs) as channel, (c) transfer curves, on and off current, on/off ratio, and mobility of such all-carbon transistor at different strains 1454.(d) Left: scheme of fabrication of non-disposable graphene-based skin-electrodes by semi-embedding graphitized electrospun fiber/monolayer graphene into SEBS elastomer; right: such electrode as a robust and non-disposable skin-electrode for sEMG,ECG, and EEG detection; reproduced with permission from Ref.1455, Copyright 2020 American Chemistry Society.(e) Optical images of the on-skin bioelectronic sensing systems, including electrophysiological sensors, hydration sensors, and temperature sensors; reproduced with permission from Ref.1462, Copyright 2018 John Wiley and Sons.(f) Scheme of the MoS2 /Au junction measured using Kelvin probe force microscope (KPFM);reproduced with permission from Ref.1473, Copyright 2020 John Wiley and Sons.(g) Left: a schematic layout of the ultrasound detector combined with the flexible MoS2 FET and piezoelectric device based on P(VDF-TrFE); right: the pulsed-gate switching responses of the ultrasound detector under the applied frequencies of 10 kHz; reproduced with permission from Ref.1474, Copyright 2021 John Wiley and Sons.
Many TMDs (e.g., MoS2, WS2, MoSe2, WSe2,etc.) are semiconductor with unique optoelectronic properties, such as layer-dependent bandgap and high charge mobility2,1475.When the layer number decreases to be monolayer, they exhibit strong photoluminescence due to large exciton binding energy by the nanoconfinement effect1476, thus many monolayer 2D materials are very attractive in optoelectronic devices, such as transistors1477,1478, photodetectors1479,1480, light emitting diodes1481,1482and solar cells1483,1484.MoS2is the most studied 2D semiconducting material.The contact energy barrier between MoS2and metal contacts under stretching or bending was also investigated.Paketal.fabricated two-terminal flexible MoS2devices and studied the contact barrier by kelvin probe force microscope1473.The observation is that tensile strain can increase electron affinity and lower the contact barrier, which will be beneficial to the optoelectronic performance (Fig.57f).However, the biggest challenges for semiconducting 2D materials to be really applicable in flexible electronics are a feasible synthetic strategy of large-area and high-quality materials, and a mature technique for processing these materials into devices on plastic or elastomeric substrates1476,1485-1487.Although MoS2ranks the most studied TMDs, achieving centimeter scale and uniform monolayer MoS2by CVD and transfer on to flexible substrates is still not easy.Lietal.recently reported a modified CVD process to grow wafer-scale MoS2and transferred it onto a PET substrate, demonstrating large-scale flexible and transparent logic circuits based on MoS2FETs774.The FETs exhibited high mobilities (~55 cm2·V-1·s-1), on-off ratios (1010), current densities (35 µA·µm-1) and flexibility, with combinational performances superior than other candidates in semi-conductor industry774.Artificial intelligence and humanmachine interfacing recently attract extensive attention.Integration another device structure such as pressure sensor or photodetector with MoS2FETs to form mechano-, photo- or sound- receptors is a very effective way to obtain high speed and sensitive detection, which are potential in artificial intelligence and human-machine interfacing1488.Naqietal.reported an ultrasonic detector by combining the flexible MoS2FETs with polyvinylidene fluoride trifluoro ethylene (PVDF-TrFE))piezoelectric sensor on a polyimide substrate (Fig.57g).Such detector is highly sensitive (Fig.57g) to the ultrasound wave by shifting threshold voltage, showing pulsed gate switching1474.Besides, TMDs are layered materials with big surface area,attracting a lot of attention in flexible capacitive energy storage,such as battery1489,1490and supercapacitors1280,1491.
Overall, 2D materials for flexible electronic devices is a rapidly expanding area, widely applicable in wearable logic circuits,energy storage and healthcare1443,1444,1447,1448,1455,1469,1472,1483,1484.However, their future largely depends on the development of material synthesis and technological processing for 2D devices on plastic or elastomeric substrates, requiring a lot of scientific understanding and material engineering.
4.9 Environmental applications
The family of 2D materials has attracted increasing attention in numerous environmental applications, ranging from the utilization of natural sources to exhaust treatments and pollution remediations1264.Owing to the intriguing physical and chemical properties, 2D materials and their assemblies have shown significant advantages over other dimensional materials.Firstly,the large surface area of 2D materials (e.g., 2630 cm2·g-1for monolayer graphene1492, 5900 cm2·g-1for a 2D MOF called MIL-1011493, 2060 m2·g-1for an imine-linked 2D COF)1494endow them with large molecular adsorption capacity, making them ideal candidates in the gas, ion, and organic pollute adsorption.Additionally, a proper chemical modification of 2D materials can provide the host-guest recognition, and selectively separate the desired source from a mixture1495.The second advantage of 2D materials for environmental applications is the ultrahigh mass transport and size-exclusive selectivity in the confined space assembled by nanosheets.Nairetal.first reported the unimpeded permeation of water through the 2D capillary made by graphene oxide (GO)1496, inspiring the applications of 2D materials in water treatments1497.Moreover,the ultrafast mass transport and molecular sieving properties in assembled 2D materials provide new opportunities to break through the “trade-off” limits between the selectivity and permeation, opening a new avenue for highly efficient membrane separation technology1498.Thirdly, the unique properties of 2D materials provide new opportunities to utilize green and economic energy sources in environmental applications.For instance, Lietal.fabricated a GO lamellar structure to generate portable water by the solar-thermal energy1499.Additionally, these semiconducting 2D materials can be also used in the electrochemical and photoelectrochemical degradation of organic pollutes1500.Taking of the above advantages in enormous adsorption, highly efficient separation, and diverse driven energy sources, 2D materials play a rising role in the environmental protection of the aquatic,atmospheric and terrestrial ecosystems.
4.9.1 Water treatments
To satisfy the increasing demand for civil and industrial water consumption, it is highly desired to develop economic and green technologies for water treatments.Recently, 2D materials have been used to adsorb, separate, or degrade hazardous compounds(e.g., salts, leaking oil, organic pollutes) to supply clean water.
The first route is to use the 2D materials as adsorbents.2D materials can be used to adsorb organic pollutant205,1501-1505and metal ions1506-1509due to the large surface area and their diverse functional groups.Jiangetal.reported few-layered GO could remove 17β-Estradiol (E2) efficiently from aqueous solutions with the maximum adsorption capacity of 149.4 mg·g-1at 298 K1510.There areπ-electron-rich regions on the GO surfaces which will interact with theπelectrons of E2 — it comes to aππinteraction to adsorption E2 onto GO.Besides, bountiful surface oxygen-containing groups of GO can also construct hydrogen bonds with E2.To remove toxic dyes such as methylene blue (MB), 3D rGO aerogels with different C/O ratios were prepared by grafting neutral, positive and negative redox mediator (Fig.58a)1511.The neutral and cationic redox mediator were selectively adsorbed on rGO throughπ-πand non-covalent electrostatic interactions, respectively.On the contrary, the anionic redox mediator would not be adsorbed in the 3D rGO aerogel due to the repulsive force.High surface area porous h-BN nanosheets, synthesized by heating boron trioxide (B2O3)and guanidine hydrochloride under a cover of H2and N2, have been used to remove pharmaceuticals such as antibiotics tetracycline, chlortetracycline hydrochloride, ciprofloxacin, and norfloxacin from aqueous solution1512.Geetal.developed a Joule-heated graphene-wrapped sponge (GWS) to clean viscous crude-oil spill1502.The graphene is coated onto the skeletons of the sponge substrates to improve hydrophobic and conductive properties so that the GWS can selectively adsorb spilled oil and a voltage can be applied to generate Joule heat to accelerate the adsorption process.Liu’s group reported a simple method about using melamine foam as a sacrificial framework to create a graphene aerogel with arbitrary shape, super elasticity and durability1513.The as-prepared graphene aerogel was applied to absorb various organic solvents depending on the type and density of the solvent (Fig.58b).Graphene/δ-MnO2aerogels with interconnected 3D network microstructure that possesses abundant MnO2nanosheets are homogeneously deposited on the graphene framework show excellent adsorption capacity toward heavy metal ions such as Pb2+, Cd2+, Cu2+and others1514.It expands the adsorption capacity by intercalating metal ions into the interlayer gaps of MnO2compared to GO which only adsorb ions on the surface.Yoonetal.reported the preparation of magnetite/non-oxidative graphene (M-nOG) for arsenic removal1515.M-nOG was found to retain 94.5% of the capacity for As3+removal and 92% for As5+compared to the first cycle after 5 consecutive reuses, which indicate its regeneration and re-usability.The low-cost 2D g-C3N4nanosheets are also a kind of absorbent for both cationic and anionic heavy metals.Xiaoet al.reported convenient one-step calcination to synthesize the g-C3N4nanosheets as absorbents1509.They found besides the lone electrons on nitrogen, the tri-s-triazine units, terminal N-containing groups, and surface amino take part in the adsorption positively.Hazardous salts, such as Hg2+, Cd2+,, can be also adsorbed by 3D foams based on 2D materials1516.Furthermore, proper assembly and interface modification are able to enhance the adsorption capacity of 2D materials, e.g.,MXenes, MOFs, COFs,etc.1517-1520.
Fig.58 (a) Schematic illustration of adsorption mechanisms by GO; reproduced with permission from Ref.1511, Copyright 2020 American Chemical Society.(b) Schematic showing the formation of GA-500, inset: snapshots of stepwise fabrication process; reproduced with permission from Ref.1513,Copyright 2018 John Wiley and Sons.
Another route is to generate clean water by steam generation or membrane separation technologies.Researcher developed the GO and 2D MOF membrane or their aerogel with highly efficient solar steam generation (Fig.59a, b)1499,1521,1522.Recently, along with the understanding of ultrafast water transport in the 2D capillary (Fig.59c, d)1497,1523,1524, the lamellar membranes made by 2D materials have attracted increasing attention in desalination, reverse osmosis, and nanofiltration1525,1526.Numerous chemical modification and cross-linking strategies have been developed to promote the permeation and lifetime of desalination and nanofiltration membranes based on the GO (Fig.59e)1527-1529, MoS21530, MOF1531,and COF848.Perforation on the 2D membrane can also enhance the water permeation, and meanwhile, maintain the ion sieving performance (Fig.59f)159,1532.
Fig.59 (a) Schematic illustration of solar-thermal steam generator based on GO film; reproduced with permission from Ref.1499, Copyright 2016 National Academy of Sciences.(b) The temperature raise for various solar-thermal steam generation materials under solar irradiation of 0.1 W·cm-2;reproduced with permission from Ref.1522, Copyright 2021 John Wiley and Sons.(c) Schematic illustrations of the separation mechanism of 2D material membranes; reproduced with permission from Ref.1524, Copyright 2020 John Wiley and Sons.(d) The size-dependent molecular sieve based on GO lamellar; reproduced with permission from Ref.1497, Copyright 2014 Association for the Advancement of Science.(e) Comparison of the longterm operation times for state-of-the-art two-dimensional material membranes applied in water separation; reproduced with permission from Ref.1529,Copyright 2020 John Wiley and Sons.(f) CNT-assisted plasma perforation on CVD-growth graphene can provide a desalination membrane with high salt rejection and fast water permeation; reproduced with permission from Ref.1532, Copyright 2019 Association for the Advancement of Science.
Photocatalysis based on semiconducting 2D materials is another effective route to utilize economic solar energy to thoroughly degrade pollutants in an aquatic system, taking advantage of the enormous surface area and rational designed electronic band structures.For instance, 2D materials with bandgap absorption at near UV or visible region, such asg-C3N41533, MOF1534and MoS21535, have been developed, and they can generate the radicals for photochemically or electrochemically driven degradation of organic pollutes1536.Furthermore, the membrane based on photocatalytic 2D materials was applied to capture the organic pollutes by their size-exclusion properties, and meanwhile convert them into innocuous compounds1537.
4.9.2 Carbon neutralization and exhaust gas treatment
Due to increasing human activity, the emission of hazardous and greenhouse gases is becoming a topical issue of global climate change.For instance, CO2from the combustion of fossil fuels in the carbon cycle is contributing to the increasing greenhouse effect.Thus, it is urgent to develop efficient and economic CO2capture and separation technologies.2D materials, such as GO, MOF, and LDHs, can be made into molecular sieves with low transport resistance and high permeation fluxes for gas separation, inspiring their applications in carbon neutralization and exhaust gas treatments.
Recently, a great deal of work has been reported in the area of CO2gas separation.In 2016, Shenetal.fabricated GO channels with an ordered height of 0.4 nm by designing external forces applied to the inside and outside of the GO sheet (Fig.60a)1538.As shown in Fig.60b, this sub-nano channel can provide 2-3 orders of magnitude higher H2permeability and 3 times higher H2/CO2selectivity compared to commercial membranes.Zhouetal.introduced CO2-philic piperazine as a crosslinking agent into the GO interlayer1539, the membrane shows excellent CO2permeability of 1020 GPU and a CO2/N2selectivity bursting up to about 680 (Fig.60c).MXenes with nonporous 2D structure also show excellent performance in gas separation.Dingetal.reported that lamellar stacked MXene membranes exhibit excellent gas performance with H2permeability above 2200 Barrer and H2/CO2selectivity more than 160, better than many advanced membranes (Fig.60d)1540.In previous work, it was discovered that LDHs have excellent gas barrier properties1541-1544.Comparing the permeation rates of a variety of gas molecules, it was found that there is a significant difference in the magnitude of the barrier effect of LDHs on different gas molecules.Some acidic gas molecules (e.g., CO2) are subject to a higher permeation.Later on, they constructed LDH-based gas-selective barrier layers on microporous substrates to achieve efficient separation of CO2gas1545.Apart from nonporous 2D materials,there are also a significant amount of works devoted to the development of MOFs and COFs to capture CO2.For example,Huangetal.constructed a Cu-based 2D MOF, FJI-H14, from 2,5-di(1H-1,2,4-triazol-1-yl) terephthalic acid (H2BTTA)1546.The results show that the FJI-H14 exhibits an extremely high CO2capacity of 171 cm3·cm-3at 1 atm and 298 K, with a CO2/N2selectivity of up to 51 for CO2/N2gases mixed at a ratio of 15/85.
The separation membranes based on 2D materials are also applied in biomass utilization, which can significantly reduce the consumption of fossil fuels and promote economic carbon neutralization.Huangetal.reported a polymer-coated GO laminate that can separaten-butanol from the mixture ofnbutanol and water1547.Fig.60e illustrates the organic/water(butanol/water) separation process based on the chitin-decorated GO membrane.With the ultrathin hydrophilic polymeric layer(< 10 nm), the water flux can reach 12 kg·m-2·h-1, and the separation factor can be enhanced up to 1523 forn-butanol/water mixture.(Fig.60f) The surface modification strategy is also applicable to MXenes.Liuetal.inserted hyperbranched polyethyleneimine into Ti2CTxMXene nanosheets to form regular stacked structures, and then the interfacial polymerization with triformylchloride was applied to recover the potential defects1548.Owing to the highly ordered 2D nanochannels, it exhibits excellent separation performance:water content was enriched to > 99% (w) from a 10% (w)isopropanol aqueous.
Fig.60 (a) External force driven assembly approach for fabricating 2D channels, (b) H2 /CO2 separation performance of EFDA-GO membranes compared with state-of-the-art gas separation membranes; reproduced with permission from Ref.1538, Copyright 2016 American Chemical Society.(c) Influence of temperature on GO-piperazine (GOP) hollow fiber membrane performance for mixed gas (CO2 : N2 =15% : 85%, volume fraction)separation under the wet condition 1539.(d) H2 /CO2 separation performance of the MXene membrane compared with state-of-the-art gas separation membranes; the black line indicates the Robeson 2008 upper bound of polymeric membranes for H2/CO2 separation, and the orange dashed line represents the 2017 upper bound of the best current membranes for H2 /CO2 separation 1540.(e) Schematic of the organic/water (butanol/water)separation process using the synergistic effect of a hydrophilic polymer and GO laminates, (f) comparison of GO membranes and the CS@GO membrane with state-of-the-art membranes for water/butanol dehydration; reproduced with permission from Ref.1547,Copyright 2015 John Wiley and Sons.
Additionally, 2D materials play a rising role in the treatment of atmospheric pollution.Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)from industrial activities and transportation are generally considered to be one of the culprits of atmospheric pollution.VOCs, such as aromatic species, are extremely hazardous to living creatures, so it is important to develop efficient technologies and materials for the removal of VOCs.Xieetal.constructed two Zr-MOFs named BUT-66 and BUT-67 as adsorbents, which showed the excellent performance to remove trace amounts of benzene in air1549.Furthermore, the combination of MOFs with carbon nanomaterials, such as carbon nanotubes and GO can improve their stability and adaptability, which makes 2D MOF composites more suitable to be operated in practical applications1550.
4.9.3 Rare earth enrichments and soil remediation
Rare earth elements have been considered as one of the most important strategic resources.However, owing to their similar physical and chemical properties, it is a great challenge to achieve their selective separation and purification.The present industrial technologies for rare earth separation suffer from high energy consumption and pollutions from byproducts1551.Membrane separation technology has been considered as an ideal alternative way due to its simplicity, absence of energy consumption from phase change, low carbon emissions, ease of operation, and suitability for industrial automation applications1527,1552,1553.GO membranes are an emerging class of membranes with nanometer-scale pore sizes that can be used for precise ion and molecular sieving1497,1527,1554.However, the limitation of interlayer spacing in GO membranes leads to low ion penetration.In order to solve this problem, Tanetal.used confinement combustion to synthesize nitrogen-doped nanoporous graphene (NDNG) with adjustable pore size and controlled nitrogen content1555.The NDNG membranes exhibit good separation selectivity (~3.7) for Sc3+from other rare-earth ions and ~1.7 for Tm3+/Sm3+.MOFs, as a group of emerging porous crystalline materials, are size-selective and can be used for the selective separation of rare earth elements (Fig.61a, b).Recently, Wuetal.prepared Zn-BTC MOF/nanoporous graphene composites, showing selectivity of 10,000 for Ce/Lu and up to 9.8 between adjacent rare earth elements (e.g., Nd/Pr)(Fig.61c, d)1556.
Due to the industrial and agricultural developments, highly toxic organic pollutants and heavy metals have been released into the soil ecosphere and consequently entered the biosphere through the food chain.They are potentially mutagenic,teratogenic, and carcinogenic to living creatures1557.In recent years, nanomaterials have become a hot spot in the area of soil remediation due to their huge specific surface area and good catalytic reaction activity.The graphene with a huge surface area can act as an excellent adsorbent for organic pollutants owing to theπ-πor steric interaction1558.Qietal.found that 5.3-20.2 mg·L-1GO significantly enhanced the migration-assistant recycling of 1-naphthol, an initiator to human colorectal tumors(Fig.61e, f)1559.Among the families of 2D materials, MoS2nanosheets exhibit high adsorption capacity of both Hg(0)1560and Hg2+1561, providing a potential solution against the mercury pollution.
4.10 Proton permeation
Fig.61 (a) Effect of pH on the separation for NDNG-1 membrane, (b) permeation flux of REEs as a function of the NDNG-1 membrane thickness 1555.(c) Schematic diagram Zn-BTC MOF/nanoporous graphene in the separation of REEs, (d) adsorption of ZnO/NG, MOF, and MOF/NG to RE3+ (Ce) at the same time (160 min) and pH (2.03); reproduced with permission from Ref.1556, Copyright 2021 American Chemical Society.(e) Effect of concentration on the separation for GO nanoparticles (GONPs), (f) effect of solution chemistry on the separation for GO nanoparticles (GONPs); reproduced with permission from Ref.1559, Copyright 2014 American Chemical Society.
It had long been assumed that despite of their mono-atomiclayer thickness, perfect graphene and related 2D materials are impermeable to all atoms and molecules at ambient conditions:even the smallest of atoms hydrogen is expected to take billions of years to penetrate through the dense electron cloud of graphene lattice1562-1564.On the other hand, it is well known that they are permeable to electrons either by conduction or tunneling.This raises a fundamental question: what about subatomic particles,i.e., protons, the nucleus of hydrogen atoms,permeation through these one-atom-thick crystals?
In 2014, Huetal., first demonstrated that protons are permeable through 2D materials1565.Surprisingly, protons pass through so easily with a remarkable proton conductance that at odds with the large energy barrier predicted by previous theories.Following that, considerable efforts have been devoted to the investigation of both related mechanisms and potential applications.To emphasize its contribution to the understanding of intrinsic properties of 2D materials, Pulizzietal.list proton permeation as one of the 25 key discoveries that shaped the graphene field1566.
4.10.1 Origin of the proton permeation
The origin of proton transport through 2D materials involves two essential steps (Fig.62a).The first one is proton approaching the 2D surface,i.e.entry before jumping through the lattice.The zero point vibration of protons prior to permeation effectively reduces the activation barrier that leads to fast proton transport.For example, in the original experiments1567, the initial state of protons is transiently bonded to oxygen-containing chemical groups.The zero point energies of these hydrogen-oxygen bonds lift the protons in energy with respect to vacuum by 0.2 eV.It is quite remarkable that the zero point oscillation, a pure quantum behavior, is reserved even at room temperature, but seems reconcile with the discrepancy of the lower proton transport barrier found experimentally compared to that from simulations.
The second step is proton translocation, during which proton interacts with the electrons in the 2D lattice and its conductance is highly affected by the electron cloud density in the lattice pore.For example, h-BN with its valence electrons localized near the N atoms is more “porous” compare to graphene with delocalizedπelectrons1565.Due to its strong electric polarity, proton attracts electrons easily and are indistinguishable to hydrogen atoms when translocation.From this perspective, it is not difficult to understand the slow albeit detectable hydrogen atoms penetration through 2D materials1571.The interlayer stacking of 2D materials also affect the proton transport.The AB stacked bilayer graphene completely blocked the proton transport because, intuitively, the atoms in the second layer locates in the center of the hexagonal ring in the first one, while the AA′stacked bilayer h-BN remains permeable to protons1565.
Despite the above discussed general processes, however, the detailed proton transport scenario is still under debate.Water and hydrogenation assisted proton transport models describe the proton-electron and proton-material interactions, though predict a considerably higher proton transport barrier compare to that observed in the experiments1572,1573.In addition, although the proton transport is thermally activated1565, the contribution of possible proton tunneling through one-atom-thick membranes is unclear1574,1575.Recently, a few characterization techniques have been developed for theinsituobservation of proton transport1576,1577, which provides possible route for the understanding of the origin of proton permeation.
4.10.2 Applications of proton transport
Membranes that allow selective proton transport with high conductivities are at the core in some industrial applications, and proton permeable 2D materials should certainly offer a radically new direction for their development.The most commonly appeared such membrane is the proton exchange membranes(PEMs) in fuel cells.As a proof of concept, PEMs made of few layer h-BN and graphene have been demonstrated in the prototype of fuel cell1568,1578(Fig.62b) and flow battery systems1579.Compared to conventional polymer-based PEMs,one of the advantages of using 2D materials is their stability at humid oxygen atmosphere at elevated temperature up to a few hundred degrees Celsius and thus they extend the devices operation temperature1565,1580, yielding extremely high proton conductivities > 103S·cm-2.
An alternative but seemly promising application is to use 2D materials for the separation of hydrogen isotopes.It has been shown that monolayer h-BN and graphene is able to separate protons (H) from deuterons (D)1567.The origin of the isotope effect is attributed to that the energy barrier posed by 2D materials is affected by the zero point oscillation of nucleon, and thus is highly sensitive to its mass.The isotope separation factor between H and D is close to 10, almost one order of magnitude higher than several conventional methods, while with energy consumption being reduced by at least 50% (Fig.62c)1569,1581,importantly, the 2D materials-based electrochemical pump method is operable at room temperature without adding or producing any harmful chemical products.It has been estimated that a 2D membrane with an area of 30 m2produces 40 tons of heavy water per year, comparable with a typical annul output of existing heavy water production plants.
Proton permeation has also been utilized to tune the interaction between monolayer 2D materials and their substrates by proton penetration into the interlayer spacing.A direct outcome is protons/hydrogen atoms encapsulation between 2D materials and substrates (Fig.62d), which offers a route for the application of isolating hydrogen gases1570.Reversibly switching the surface properties, e.g., stiction and adhesion to liquids, of 2D materials is also possible when hydrogen atoms present or absent in the space between 2D materials and substrates1582.In addition, such space provides a confined environment for chemical reactions1583, where protons has been found to decouple the vdW interaction between substrate and 2D materials and assist the growth of ultra-flat 2D crystals352.
Fig.62 (a) Schematic of proton transport mechanism.Bottom right: proton conductivity through varies 2D materials with distinct electron density in their lattice 1565.Typical applications of proton transport: (b) proton exchange membrane fuel cells made by few-layer h-BN,reproduced with permission from Ref.1568, Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society; (c) comparison of 2D material-based H/D separation membrane performance with other techniques for heavy water separation 1569; (d) isolating hydrogen gas using h-BN 1570.
4.10.3 Various approaches to enhance proton conductance
Improving the proton conductance through 2D materials is not only important in terms of highly efficient applications especially in membrane areas as mentioned above, but provides insights to the proton transport mechanism from fundamental level point of view.One strategy is to tune the electrons distribution on 2D materials using proton-binding metal nanoparticles decorated on 2D materials to form heterostructures1565.The built-in electric field at the materialnanoparticle interface can be further enhanced if illuminated with visible light, leading to a graphene areal proton conductance above 2 S·cm-2at room temperature1584.
Design of novel 2D materials is another approach of promoting proton transport.Atomically thin micas with proton areal conductivity exceeding that of defect-free graphene and h-BN by two orders of magnitudes is merely one of the examples1580.Theoretical simulations have predicted more than 10 novel 2D crystals being promising candidates for proton permeation1572,1573,1585.It is worth noting that “defect-free” may not necessarily be important when considering materials’ proton transport properties1586.Recently, atomically thin carbon films with eight-atom-ring defects has been fabricated, showing a 103times higher proton permeability than that of pristine graphene1587.Apart from enlarging the effective pore size for proton conduction, defects also play a positive role by accumulating high concentration of protons as proton source, as exemplified by Cd vacancies in CdPS3nanosheets1588.As a result, a record-high proton conductivity of 0.95 S·cm-1has been achieved.
Proton permeation provides 2D crystal lattice as a novel subatomic sieve.However, there is still a long path towards the real applications.Scalable production of high quality 2D materials1589, their wafer-scale transfer techniques and compatibility with support proton conductive substrate would be logical future investigation directions here.
4.11 Other applications
Besides various applications mentioned above, 2D materials also show application potentials in reinforcing filler, corrosion protection, pollutant adsorption, desalination and so on due to their layered structure, ultrahigh specific surface and excellent mechanical strength.These applications will be discussed in detail in this part.
Ultrathin 2D materials are competent as reinforcing filler1590-1592,conductive filler1593-1595and anticorrosion filler1596,1597in polymer matrix composites.Liuetal.developed two fraction methods to prepare layered and scrolled nanocomposites with high-quality graphene1598.They prepared planar stacking composites of graphene and polycarbonate (PC) by repetition of quadrant fold or segmentation (Fig.63a), and an Archimedean spiral fiber was fabricated with similar a method (Fig.63b).These nanocomposites display substantial mechanical reinforcement and still retain high electrical conductivity and optical transmittance even at very low loadings.Graphene/nanofiller nanocomposites are further developed to avoid graphene agglomeration1599.Songetal.reported the preparation of graphene wrapped B4C nanowires (B4C-NWs) which can strengthen the interfacial interaction between the B4C-NWs and matrix1600.They directly synthesized B4C-NWs@graphene by shear mixing the mixture of graphite powders and B4C-NWs and found the graphene was successfully exfoliated then crumpled and self-assembled onto the B4C-NWs (Fig.63c, d).The threepoint bending tests of the epoxy resin with a different fraction of B4C-NWs@graphene indicate the flexural strength and elastic modulus increased with increasing nanofillers (Fig.63e).2D h-BN nanosheets are an acceptable solution when devices require both great electric insulation and thermal conduction.Choetal.prepared polysiloxane/h-BN nanocomposite films by introducing 15% (volume percentage) h-BN nanosheets into a poly(dimethylsiloxane) elastomer whose thermal conductivity are 15 times that the polysiloxane matrix itself, and the composite can still maintain the electrically insulating nature because of the wide bandgap of h-BN1601.
Fig.63 (a, b) Schematic illustration of the method for planar stacking composites and the transverse shear method for scrolled nanocomposite fiber; reproduced with permission from Ref.1598, Copyright 2016 Association for the Advancement of Science.(c, d) The TEM image of B4C-NWs@graphene, (e) flexural stress-strain curves of epoxy and B4C-NWs@graphene (0.1%, 0.2%, and 0.3%, volume percentage)reinforced composites 1600.
Many 2D materials such as graphene and h-BN are almost impermeable to all molecules with excellent chemical stability.Therefore, 2D materials can be used to cover the surface of the metal to protect them from corrosion.But sometimes pure 2D materials coating like graphene could not protect the metals effectively, or even accelerate the corrosion in a long term, due to the defects of graphene which may trap corrosive media such as H2O and O21602, and the defective area behaves as a cathode that accelerates the corrosion1603.The graphene composites are developed to solve the problems above instead of pure graphene coating.A nonconductive graphene composite through the Diels-Alder reaction between the exfoliated graphene and a bio-based epoxy monomer can work as a long-term anticorrosive coating1604.The insulating h-BN is also a good choice for anticorrosion which can suppress the galvanic corrosion under the ambient environment1605.
Non-toxic 2D inorganic nanosheets can be used for food packaging films for the reason of their high aspect ratio platelet structures which can construct circuitous pathways to impede the diffusion of gas molecules1606.A platelet morphology sample of Mg2Al-CO3-LDH was calcined in the air and then put into the aqueous glycine solution to regenerate and exfoliate the LDH.Bilayer LDH nanosheets with well define shapes were obtained.The LDH nanosheets coating on the polyethylene terephthalate(PET) film show extremely excellent oxygen barrier performance (Fig.64a) and water vapor barrier performance(Fig.64b).
Fig.64 (a) The oxygen transmission rate (OTR) plot against coating gap, (b) the water vapor transmission rate (WVTR) plot against PET, 10% (w) PVA-C, and 10%-60%LDH-C 1606.
Hybrid GO/graphene with a large mechanical strength can withstand osmotic pressure and shear stress for desalination1607.Morelos-Gomezetal.reported a preparation of hybrid GO/graphene layered membranes deposited onto the polysulfone support membrane modified with polyvinyl alcohol(PVA), followed by the thermal treatment and Ca2+crosslinking to enhance the mechanical strength furthermore1608.Water can flow within nanochannels adjacent to the edges of few-layered graphene and the NaCl will be rejected due to the Gibbs-Donnan exclusion.They found the PVA interfacial adhesive layers were the key to enhance the mechanical strength that the membranes with PVA would exhibit any observable peel-off under a strong 1000 mL·min-1cross flow, meanwhile, the membranes without PVA started to peel up at 400 mL·min-1after 120 h.
Besides the above discussions, there are also some interesting applications based on 2D materials due to the promising properties of 2D materials.For example, Luoetal.even developed a unique graphene hair dye1609.The GO or rGO are used to coat on the hair substituting the toxic small molecules which are added in common hair dyes.They found graphene hair dye could improve comfort by enhancing antistatic performance and heat dissipation because of the good electrical conductivity and thermal conductivity of graphene.Also, we believe that the killer applications of 2D materials will be explored in the future and 2D materials will play more important roles in different applications.
5 Theoretical calculations and simulations
In parallel to the experimental investigations, tremendous efforts have also been dedicated into the development of 2D materials by adopting computational strategies, including DFT calculations, molecular dynamic (MD) simulations, Monte Carlo(MC) methods, machine learning (ML) algorithms,etc.On this basis, extraordinary progress has been made in various aspects of 2D materials, such as growth mechanism, stability, property and application.In this section, we will summarize recent advances in theoretical calculations and simulations of 2D materials, with an emphasis on the growth mechanism, surface reactivity and magnetism.
5.1 Growth mechanism of 2D materials via bottomup synthesis
In history, most of the extensively explored 2D materials are first synthesizedviathe top-down approaches, such as the mechanical exfoliation method1,128,1610,1611.The top-down approaches generally produce very high quality 2D materials which are suitable for the exploration of their properties,prototype device fabrications and tests and, sometimes, also can produce 2D materials in large scale, such as graphene.While most of the top-down approaches suffer some acritical drawbacks.For example, 2D materials produced by top-down approaches are generally in small size and small quality.So,most of the top-down approaches do not fit the requirements for industrial applications of 2D materials, especially for integrated device fabrications111,1612-1614.In contrast, the bottom-up approaches, such as the PVD1615-1617, CVD1618-1620, and molecule beam epitaxy1621-1623, can produce large area films of various 2D materials of different thickness, sometimes in the form of wafer-scale 2D single-crystalline thin films.During more than one decade of extensive study of 2D materials, the bottom-up synthesis gradually becomes the main steam approach for synthesis of various 2D materials.
In contrast to the relatively simple top-down approaches,achieving growth of high quality 2D materials by the bottom-up synthesis requires the reactions of various precursors on a suitable substrate at an appropriate experiential condition, and thus many tunable experimental parameters determine the quality of the product1624,1625.To optimize the bottom-up experimental synthesis of 2D materials, a deep understanding on the growth mechanisms of various 2D materials is essential.In the past decade, great theoretical efforts have been dedicated to the theoretical study of the mechanism of 2D materials bottomup synthesis.Here we will mainly summarize the recent achievements on the theoretical studies on the growth mechanisms of various 2D materials, including a general theory of 2D materials epitaxy; the mechanisms of graphene and h-BN epitaxial growth, the current understanding on growth of TMDs and the mechanism of graphene growth on insulating substrates.
5.1.1 Role of substrate in bottom-up synthesis of 2D materials
As shown in Fig.65, the transitional epitaxial growth of thin film is significantly different from the bottom-up growth of 2D materials because of their interactions with the substrate is significantly different.For thin film grown on a substrate, the strong chemical bonding ensures an epitaxial relationship between the crystalline lattice of the overlayer material and that of the substrate (Fig.65a)1626,1627.So, when the growth of 2D materials covering a polycrystalline substrate grain boundary,the 2D thin film have to change its crystallographic orientation to match its lattice orientation with the substrate1626.Therefore,a polycrystalline substrate cannot be used as the template for the growth of a single-crystalline thin film (Fig.65b).In contrast, a stable 2D material generally interacts with most substrates through weak vdW interaction1628-1632, which is not sensitive to the crystallographic orientation of 2D material (Fig.65c)1633,1634.For example, DFT study has proved that the binding energy difference of graphene on a Cu surface for epitaxial growth is only a few meV different from the non-epitaxial growth.Such value is more than two orders of magnitudes lower than the chemical binding energy.Such a small driving force cannot ensure the epitaxial growth of a 2D material on a substrate.Therefore, graphene can pass through substrate grain boundaries easily without changing its crystalline orientation during growth(Fig.65d)1634,1635.Besides, such phenomena have also been observed during the growth of many 2D materials1636,1637,offering a possibility for synthesizing wafer-scale singlecrystalline 2D materials on polycrystalline substrates1638,1639.
Fig.65 The epitaxial growth of thin films vs.2D materials.(a) Schematic of the chemical binding between a thin film and a substrate.(b) Illustration of a polycrystalline thin film growth on a polycrystalline substrate.(c) Schematic of the weak vdW interaction between a 2D material and a substrate.(d) Illustration of the growth of a single crystalline 2D material on a polycrystalline substrate via nucleation control.(d) Reproduced with permission from Ref.1633.Copyright 2012 American Chemical Society.
The nucleation control for wafer-scale 2D single crystal growth requires the nucleation only one seed on a wafer scale substrate in a period of a few hours or longer, which is very challenging and, even it is possible, the productivity is generally very low.In comparison, the strategy of seamless stitching a mass of parallelly aligned 2D islands on a substrate is more practical and efficient.Therefore, it is very important to gain a deep understanding on the epitaxial growth mechanisms of 2D materials on various substrates in order to achieve the parallel alignment of millions of 2D islands on a wafer scale substrate.Recently, numerous DFT calculations have revealed that the alignment of 2D material on a substrate is determined by a simple principle that a high symmetric direction of the 2D material’s crystallographic lattice tends to along a high symmetric direction of the lattice of the substrate195,1640,1641.Fig.66 shows an example of graphene on the Cu(111) surface, the strongest binding energy between edge of the graphene and the Cu substrate appears when a high symmetric zigzag edge of graphene is along a high symmetric <110> direction of the Cu surface.From the charge density difference, we can clearly see that all the edge atoms are well passivated with such a configuration (Fig.66b).In comparison, when the edge is not parallel to a high symmetric direction of the substrate, some atoms at edges are poorly passivated (Fig.66c).This clearly shows that the high symmetric direction of a substrate is very beneficial for passivating the high symmetric edges of a 2D material.More extensive calculations prove that the principle is also applicable for other 2D materials on various substrates.
Fig.66 The interaction between a 2D material and a substrate.(a) Model of a graphene zigzag edge on a Cu(111) surface and the binding energy of the edge on the substrate as a function of the alignment angle, θ.(b) Charge density differences with isovalue of 0.01 Bohr-3 of graphene on the Cu(111) surface with misorientation angles of 0° and 15.3°, where electron accumulation and depletion are denoted by Blue and red colors 1640.
Based on the epitaxial relationship, Dongetal.reported that the equivalent but different alignment number of 2D materials on a substrate can be obtainedviasimple formula1640
where |Gsub| denotes the number of symmetric operations of the substrate and |G2D@sub| denotes that of the 2D material system on the substrate.
Fig.67 presents the possible alignments of 2D materials with various symmetries on several high symmetric substrates,including the h-BN(0001) surface and three low index facets of face-centered cubic (FCC) crystal.The number of equivalent but different directions of these 2D materials on substrates are strikingly in consistent with numerous experimental observations in 2D materials’ epitaxial growth99,213,908,924,1641-1654.It can be clearly seen that the more symmetry operations will give rise to a greater number of equivalent but different directions of the grown 2D materials on the substrate.This implies that substrates with lower symmetries, such as high-index surfaces, are more promising for templating the epitaxial growth of 2D materials.As illustrated in Fig.68, due to the existence of step edges, a high-index surface owns very lowC1orCssymmetry1640,1655.On such a substrate, the energetically most preferred orientations of a 2D material are not degenerated and, thus, uniformly aligned 2D islands may be grown under the optimized experimental condition.
Fig.67 Alignment of 2D islands with various symmetries on the three low-index FCC crystal surfaces and the hBN (0001) surface.The highsymmetry crystallographic orientations of substrates are denoted by green lines.The symmetry groups of the 2D materials, substrates, and the systems of 2D islands on substrates are provided.Reproduced with permission from Ref.1625.Copyright 2021 American Chemical Society.
Fig.68 Schematic of parallelly aligned 2D materials with different symmetries grown on a high-index substrate with steps 1640.
5.1.2 Epitaxy of 2D materials on low-symmetry substrates
Recently, the alignment mechanisms of two most explored examples of 2D materials, graphene and h-BN, on various substrates containing step edges have been extensively studied.Both theoretical and experimental studies reveal that nucleation of a 2D material near a step edge is superior to that on a terrace,because of strong adhesion between the active step edges and the edge of 2D materials1654,1656-1659.
Near a step edge, the alignment of a 2D material is determined by the interaction between the edge of the 2D material and the step edge of the substrate, or the interfacial formation energy1655,1660.Fig.69a shows interfacial formation energy of various graphene edges on a <110> step edge of Cu(111) surface as a function of the tilt angle of the graphene edge1660.It can be seen that the global minimum corresponds to a configuration of a graphene zigzag edge attaching to the <110> step edge.This explains the broadly observed unidirectional alignment of graphene islands on near-Cu(111) surfaces, as illustrated in Fig.69b.Ge(110) surface is a promising candidate for graphene synthesis on semiconductor compatible substrates1661,1663.Under the optimized experimental condition, high-quality waferscale single-crystalline graphene film was recently synthesized on a high index Ge surface which is 15° from the Ge(001)surface and the existence of step edges is critical for the success of the growth of unidirectionally aligned graphene islands,which further proves the effectiveness of using substrates with lower symmetry for single crystalline 2D materials synthesis1664.
Fig.69 Alignment of graphene on high-index substrates.(a) Formation energies of various graphene edges attaching to a Cu<110> step edge as a function of the graphene edge’s tilt angle, θ, where θ = 0 and 30 degrees represent zigzag and armchair edges, respectively.(b) On a vicinal Cu(111) surface, all the nucleated graphene islands, either nucleated on the Cu(111) terrace or nearby the possible step edges,could be parallelly aligned.Reproduced with permission from Ref.1660.Copyright 2014 American Chemical Society.
Besides the epitaxial growth of graphene, the h-BN epitaxial growth on high-index surfaces has also been studied extensively.As exhibited in Fig.70a, on a high-index surface, which can be constructed by many low-index terraces and step edges, the alignment of h-BN islands highly depends on the types of the terrace and step edges1655.Zhaoetal.investigated the alignments of triangular h-BN clusters on the (111) surface of FCC metals and the (0001) surface of hexagonal close packed(HCP) metals, respectively (Fig.70b-e)1665.It is revealed that,due to equivalence of ABC… and BCA… configurations of the neighboring terraces of a vicinal FCC(111) surface, h-BN islands tend to align parallelly on neighboring terraces of a vicinal FCC(111) surface.In contrast, the AB… and BA…configurations of the neighboring HCP(0001) surfaces are equivalent after a mirror symmetric operation, so the orientations of h-BN islands on neighboring terraces of a HCP(0001) surface are anti-parallel (Fig.70b-e).
Both experimental and theoretical studies have showed that,the nucleation of 2D materials near a step edge of a high-index surface is energetically more preferred than that on a low index terrace1658,1659,1666.Generally, step edges of a high index surfaces may along any direction and can be classified into straight step edges and tilted ones1655.In general, a straight h-BN edge, such as armchair or zigzag, attaching to a straight step edge, such as the <110>, <100> or <211> step edge of a surface of a FCC crystal, is energetically most preferred.For example, Wangetal.synthesized vicinal Cu(110) substrates with straight Cu<211>step edges and observed the growth of unidirectional aligned h-BN islands (Fig.70f, g)214.Combining DFT calculations and atomic-resolution STM image, nitrogen-terminated zigzag edge of h-BN attaching to the straight Cu<211> step edges was seen clearly.Chenetal.reported the epitaxial growth of h-BN single crystals on Cu(111) substrates with abundant step edges trending up and down (Fig.70h, i)99.These step edges are highly curved and locally rugged.Atomically, a curved step edge can be constructed by using two types of straight <110> segments and the h-BN islands nucleation on them are antiparallelly aligned(Fig.70h).To explain the unidirectional alignment of the h-BN,the authors used DFT calculations to reveal that the binding energy difference of h-BN islands attaching to the two types of step edges is large enough to drive the dominating nucleation of h-BN near one type only.Therefore, h-BN islands with one orientation will be suppressed under the optimized experimental condition.
In reality, high-index surfaces with straight step edges are rare and most high-index surfaces own tilted step edges and sometimes even highly curved ones.By using DFT calculations,Z hangetal.revealed that a tilted step edge is preferred to be attached by a tilted h-BN edge1655, as illustrated in Fig.70j.In this case, a misalignment angle, Δγ, between the high symmetric directions of the 2D materials and the substrate is no longer zero and its value can be calculated by:
The calculated misalignment angles of h-BN grown on various Cu high-index surfaces are in perfect agreement with the experimentally observations shown in Fig.70k-m.Similarly,Betsetal.propose that tilted step edges having similar kink size with the tilted edge of a 2D material are preferred the epitaxy growth of the 2D material (Fig.70n)1667.
Moreover, recent theoretical study also reveal that high-index surfaces with larger miscut angles or larger step densities are more robust in guiding the epitaxy growth of 2D materials than those with small miscut angles1655.Fig.70o-p show examples of two high-index surfaces with same surface roughness but different miscut angles.Clearly, the direction of step edges of the Cu(5 5 6) surface varies a lot, resulting in two possible h-BN orientations.In contrast, those step edges of the Cu(10 10 17)surface, which has a very larger step edge density than the Cu(5 5 6) surface, the variation step edges direction is very small and the unidirectional alignment of hBN islands is ensured.
Fig.70 Alignment of h-BN on high-index metal substrates.(a) Schematic of hBN on various Cu surfaces and the configurations of various vicinal FCC(100) surfaces.(b-c) Schematic and experimental observation of triangular h-BN clusters on different terraces of the Ni(111) substrate.(d-e) Schematic and experimental observation of triangular h-BN clusters on different terraces of the Ru(0001) substrate.(f-g) Model of a h-BN zigzag edge attaching to the Cu<211> step of a vicinal Cu(110) surface and the experimental observation of h-BN epitaxial growth on vicinal Cu (110) surface with <211> step edges.(h-i) Model of h-BN clusters attaching to Cu<110> steps of a vicinal Cu(111) surface and the experimental observation of h-BN epitaxial growth.(j) Schematic of a tilted hBN edge attaching to a tilted step edge, where the kink heights of the h-BN edge and the step edge are shown.(k-m) Illustration of experimentally observed h-BN orientations on various high-index Cu surfaces, which agree well with theoretical predictions.(n) Schematic of h-BN alignment along a tilted step edge.(o-p) The alignment of h-BN islands on various high-index Cu surface under the same surface roughness.(a, j-m, o-p) Reproduced with permission from Ref.1655, Copyright 2021 John Wiley and Sons.(b-e) Reproduced from Ref.1665.(f-g) Reproduced from Ref.214.(h-i) Reproduced from Ref.99.(n) Reproduced with permission from Ref.1667,Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society.
5.1.3 Growth mechanisms of TMDs on gold substrates
TMDs have the same 3-fold symmetries with h-BN, and thus the alignments of TMDs on various substrates should be similar with those of h-BN.Inspired by the success of h-BN on vicinal Cu(111) surface99, centimeter-scale single-crystalline MoS2monolayer has been recently successfully realized on vicinal Au(111) surfaces924.Soon after, the growth of centimeter-scale single-crystalline TMD monolayers, including WS2, WSe2,MoS2, MoSe2/WSe2heterostructure, and even W1-xMoxS2alloy,on various high-index Au surfaces was reported1668.These experimental successes confirm the effectiveness of using low-symmetry substrate to template 2D materials epitaxy.So, here we briefly introduce the recent understanding of TMD growth on Au surfaces.
In compare with the one-atomic-thick graphene and h-BN, the three-atomic-thick TMDs present various metastable phases, and their growth mechanisms are more complicated1669-1671.DFT-based molecular dynamic (MD) simulations provides an intuitive picture of MoS2growth on Au(111) surface (Fig.71a)1672.Theoretical study reveals that the surface of Au(111) tends to be passivated by sulfurs atoms.Under a sulfur-rich environment,the metal precursor, MoO3molecules, can be gradually transformed into a MoS3molecule by reactions with the surface sulfur atoms.Then the reactions of MoS3molecules on the Au(111) surface firstly lead to a T-phase MoS2nucleus.As the growth continues, the T-phase MoS2nucleus will transform into an H-phase MoS2island when the size is large enough.
Sulfurization of pre-deposited transition metal containing films offers another strategy for synthesis of TMDs1673-1676.Fig.71b presents an atomic-level mechanism for the initial sulfidation of a MoO3surface1677.In this study, a three-steps reaction process is proposed, which includes (i) the selfreduction of the MoO3surface, (ii) followed by SO/SO2formation and S2-assisted reduction, and (iii) then the sulfidation of the reduced surface and formation of Mo―S bonds.In Fig.71c, typical Mo―S termination and Mo―S―Mo bridge formed during the simulation are shown.It is worth noting that the synthesized TMDs are generally multilayer and polycrystalline by this method.
Fig.71 Growth mechanism of TMD on various substrates.(a) First principal molecular dynamic (MD) simulations showing that the nucleation of T-phase MoS2 on the Au(111) surface is preferred and the transformation from T-phase to H-phase will occur during the further growth process.(b) Schematic of the sulfidation of a MoO3 surface to synthesize a MoS2 film.(c) Close-up of Mo―S termination and Mo―S―Mo bridge structures created during reactive MD simulation.(a) Reproduced with permission from Ref.1672, Copyright 2021 American Chemical Society.(b, c) Reproduced with permission from Ref.1677, Copyright 2017 American Chemical Society.
5.1.4 Growth of polycrystalline 2D materials on liquid substrates
Liquid metal surfaces have also been widely used to grow 2D materials.Gengetal.reported the randomly aligned hexagonal graphene flakes at the initial stage of graphene growth on liquid Cu surface and, with the increasing of the graphene coverage,these islands become unidirectional aligned gradually1678.The parallel alignment of h-BN islands on liquid Au surfaces was also reported1651.However, the underlying mechanisms of the unidirectional alignment of 2D islands on liquid substrates is still unclear.Besides single-crystalline 2D materials, polycrystalline 2D materials with controlled misalignment angles or lattice orientations is also of great interests for both fundamental studies and practical applications.
In 2019, Dongetal.studied the formation mechanisms of polycrystalline graphene grown on liquid Cu surfaces1679.The grown graphene islands on liquid Cu surfaces are randomly aligned but can rotate freely because of the high mobility of the liquid substrate1680.The curve of the formation energy of grain boundary (GB) in graphenevs.the misalignment angle of the GB have two minima, zero degree corresponds a perfect single crystal and ~30° corresponds a highly stable GB with the formation of pentagon-heptagon lines.So, the coalescence of two graphene islands either leads to the seamless stitching of them or a polycrystal with ~30° GB, as shown in Fig.72a, b.If many graphene islands coalescence together on a liquid surface,30 types of graphene polycrystals with 30° GBs could be formed.As shown in Fig.72c, 27 of 30 predicted graphene polycrystals are observed experimentally.
Fig.72 Growth of graphene polycrystals on liquid Cu surface.(a) Formation energy of graphene grain boundary as a function of the misalignment angle of the two graphene grains.(b) Schematic showing two routes of graphene coalescence on liquid Cu surface, a single crystal via seamless stitching of two aligned graphene islands or a graphene polycrystal with a 30-degree GB.(c) The prediction and corresponding experimental observation of graphene polycrystals via coalescence of multi graphene islands on liquid Cu surfaces.Reproduced with permission from Ref.1679,Copyright 2019 John Wiley and Sons.
5.1.5 Growth mechanism of graphene on insulating substrates
For high performance device applications, it is of great important for synthesizing 2D materials directly on an insulating substrate.In experiments, great effort has been devoted to synthesizing graphene on various insulating substrates, such as SiO2, Al2O3, and h-BN, to avoid the wrinkles and contaminations in graphene films formed during the transfer process1623,1681-1685.However, comparing with the growth of graphene on metal substrates, the growth mechanism of graphene on insulating substrates is still poorly understood, especially at the atomic scale.
As shown in Fig.73a, the graphene growth rate on typical insulating substrates are about 3-5 orders of magnitude slower than that of on metal substrates.Besides, the type of insulating substrates has little impact on the growth behaviors of graphene,such as the growth rate and the shape1686.Recently, through extensive DFT calculations and modeling, Chengetal.have successfully explained the slow growth rate and morphology of graphene grown on various insulating substrates1686.They unveiled that the CH3 molecules in the gas phase are the key carbon precursors, and there are three typical main reactions during the addition of new hexagons onto a graphene edge:(i) feed the graphene growth by attaching a CH3radicles;(ii) remove the excessive H atoms of CH3viareaction of CH3+H → CH4, and (iii) form a new hexagonal carbon ring, as illustrated in Fig.73b.Therefore, the growth process on an insulating substrate can be attributed to a vapor-solid growth,which is different from the vapor-surface-solid growth on metal substrates.Besides, the type (ii) reaction is the threshold step that limits the growth rate.Fig.73c exhibits the energy profiles of threshold step reactions for a graphene zigzag and armchair edge.The threshold reaction barrier are 1.94 and 3.00 eV,respectively and the growth rate of the armchair edge is slower than that of the zigzag edge.Based on the kinetic Wulff construction theory, the slowly growing armchair edge gradually dominate the circumference of a graphene island (Fig.73d),which is similar to the experimental observations of graphene growth on the insulating substrates1687-1689.Based on such theory, the growth rate of a graphene edge could be estimated by
where, ΔL= 0.142 nm is the carbon-carbon bond length of graphene,Ebis the threshold barrier of growing graphene,Efis the formation energy of a CH3attached at the edge, andCpd enotes the collision rate of a CH3to the growth site.Fig.73e plots the calculated graphene growth rates at different experimental conditions and a perfect agreement is clearly seen when comparing with the experimental results1686.
Fig.73 The mechanism of graphene growth on insulating substrates.(a) Summary of the experimental data (growth rates and sizes of grown graphene islands) of graphene growth on the insulating substrates and metal substrates.(b) Schematic of vapor-solid growth of graphene on insulating substrates.(c) Energy profile and reaction geometries of the threshold step for a graphene zigzag and armchair edge.(d) Morphology of a growing graphene island on the insulating substrates obtained by the kinetic Wulff plots in theory.(e) Comparison of the graphene growth rate between experimental results and calculated results based on the experimental conditions and Eq.(3).Reproduced with permission from Ref.1686,Copyright 2021 American Chemical Society.
Based on the mechanism, using more active carbon source to lower the barrier of removing excess H atoms or growing graphene at a higher growth temperature (> 1600 K) were proposed as effective strategies for fast graphene growth on insulating substrates.
5.1.6 Summary
Although the growth mechanisms of 2D materials have been explored extensively in last decade, the deep understanding especially at the atomic level, is still very poor and many of the theoretical results are not in consistent with experimental observation.There are still many experimental puzzles, such as why the less active Cu is the best catalyst for graphene growth,how oxygen help the growth of graphene on Cu surface, are not properly explained.Besides, the lack of deep understanding on the atomic processes of 2D materials growth greatly hinders the applications of theory in experimental design and, thus, most of the experimental progresses of bottom-up synthesis of 2D materials are still based on a huge number of experimental tries.To realize true rational experimental design of 2D materials growth, developing new theoretical methods, such as machine learning force fields, to explore the atomic details of 2D materials growth with a high accuracy and with a longer simulation time simulation is critical.On the other hand, the current theory of 2D materials epitaxy based on the symmetry analysis and some simple theoretical calculations are very successful and, based on it, experimental scientists can grow quite a few types of single-crystalline 2D materials in wafer scale.We believe that, in a long term before the theoretical methods allow us to simulate real and complicated experimental systems in a long term, the close collaborations between theoreticians and experimentalists are crucial for the further development of the theory and experimental approaches on the synthesis of 2D materials.
5.2 Surface reactivity of 2D materials
A distinctive feature of 2D materials is their atomic-thin thickness, which endows them unique physical and chemical properties1690-1692.However, the atomic-thin thickness also leads to the relatively high surface reactivity of 2D materials,leading to their environmental instability, as they may be corroded, decomposed, oxidized, segregated and so forth1693.In particular, the few-layer BP show visible surface oxidation within a few hours, resulting in the invalidity of the fabricated devices1694.Apart from BP, many other 2D materials also suffer from oxidation and degradation, such as metal chalcogenides(e.g., InSe and GaSe) and TMDs (e.g., WS2and HfS2)55,1695-1697.In addition, the existence of surface defects can also lead to the further increase of surface reactivity, leading to the degradation of the stability, charge carrier mobility and optical properties.On the other hand, the increase of surface reactivity can significantly affect their properties, offering new opportunities for their applications.For instance, surface vacancies can activate the inert basal planes of 2H-phase MoS2for HER1022; surface defects endow the carbon materials the capability of trapping the single metal atoms to form single atom catalysts (SACs) with enhanced activity1698;etc.Therefore, a fundamental understanding of the surface reactivity will help to identify the key factors that effecting the stability, property and performance for certain applications, as well as the corresponding strategies to enhance the stability and performance1699.In this section, we will summarize the surface reactivity of 2D materials at atomic level, with an emphasis on the oxidation/degradation mechanisms, role of surface vacancies on the properties and activities, as well as theoretical insights into the 2D materials supported SACs (SACs@2D).
5.2.1 Oxidation and degradation mechanisms
5.2.1.1 Light-induced oxidation
Based on the active species in air and the possible energy source, Zhouetal.firstly established a “three-step” mechanism of light induced BP degradation (Fig.74a)1700.Specifically,superoxidecan be generated under light illumination on the surface of few-layer BP; the active superoxide then directly reacts with the surface P atoms to form phosphorus oxides; the H2O molecules decompose the hydrophilic phosphorus oxides and finally causes the breakdown of BP layer.It should be noted that the generation of superoxide is highly depending on the electronic structures of the system.As the energy levels of BP changes with the number of layers, which is also known as quantum confinement, the generation of superoxide can be limited and thus the photooxidation takes much longer for multilayer BP than the thinner ones1701.
5.2.1.2 Water catalyzed oxidation
In addition, the concentration of water is proven to play an important role in the oxidation of 2D materials.Huetal.found that when the water molecules with high polarity gradually approached oxygen, the energy levels ofπ*2pof O2decrease and get close to the valence bands of BP (Fig.74b)1702Consequently,the electrons from BP surface can be transferred to O2molecules with the assistance of water molecules,anions are thus expected to be formed even without light irradiation.The theoretical results explain the experimental findings that both hole and electron motilities of the BP-based device decreased significantly after 19.5 h exposure in dark environment.
5.2.1.3 Defect induced oxidation
The pristine surfaces of TMDs and metal chalcogenides present higher stability than BP, the reported oxidation phenomenon can be attributed to defective sites such as surface vacancies and edges1703,1707.For the defective sites, metals and transitional metals can be exposed to air and react with either water or oxygen molecules.The reaction and the formation of oxides leads to local deformation of the crystal lattice around the defective sites, and the insertion of oxygen atoms can activate surrounding metal-chalcogenide bonds (Fig.74c).The high energy barrier required for the step-by-step intercalation of O2leads to a slow oxidation process that is observed from experiments.
To increase the stability, a direct and most commonly used approach is encapsulation or coating with other materials,include polymer, Al2O3, and h-BN1708-1710.Based on the understanding of oxidation mechanisms for many 2D systems,alternative approaches can be adopted to slow down the oxidation processes.For example, the electronic structures of BP layers can be modulated by several approaches, such as heteroatom doping, chemical modification, interface engineering by small molecule intercalation, covalent modification of polymers (Fig.74d)1705,1706,1711,1712.These methods intend to decrease the energy level of the CBM so that superoxide generation can be restricted, thus the environmental stability of black phosphorus is improved.Combining with experiments, these modification methods are proven to be effective to increase the stability of BP to a large extent1711-1713.
Fig.74 (a) Light induced oxidation: the light-induced ambient degradation process of BP and the electronic structures of BP with the redox potential of ; reproduced with permission from Ref.1700, Copyright 2016 John Wiley and Sons.(b) Water catalyzed oxidation: the polarizatio n effect of H2O on O2 illustrated by theoretical calculations; reproduced with permission from Ref.1702, Copyright 2017 John Wiley and Sons.(c) Defect induced oxidation: schematic of the degradation mechanism for InSe; reproduced with permission from Ref.1703, Copyright 2017 American Chemical Society.(d) Several proposed protection strategies by theoretical calculations and simulations; reproduced with permission from Ref.1700,1704-1706, Copyright 2016 John Wiley and Sons, Copyright 2016 American Chemical Society, Copyright 2017 Royal Society of Chemistry.
5.2.2 Surface vacancies and performance control
In the practical applications of 2D materials, the properties and performance can be largely affected by many kinds of defective sites, including vacancies, grain boundaries, edges, and substitutional impurities, in which surface vacancies are the most abundant and investigated type1714.It can be noticed in the reported literatures that many novel characters are attributed to the presence of defect sites, such as high catalytic activity,quantum states, and color centers1715,1716.With the help of firstprinciple methods, theoretical studies often get insights into the electronic structures and the modulation mechanisms of the defects, thus providing new perspectives for the experiments.
On the one hand, the defects can bring negative effects on the stability (as we discussed in the former section), charge carrier mobility and optical properties of 2D materials.For example,Qiuetal.proposed that the sulfur vacancy defect is the key factor of low mobility of MoS2, and a charge hopping transport scheme mediated by localized defect states is established750.As shown in Fig.75a, the existing sulfur vacancies introduces localized donor states inside the band gap.At low carrier concentration, the electron transport can only be realized by the transition between the induced gap states, which limits the intrinsic mobility of MoS2considerably; with the increase of carrier concentration, the gap states are filled and band-like transport is expected (Fig.75b).The transport model is further validated by transmission electron microscopy and transport experiments.It is, therefore, explained that the actual device mobility is far lower than the theoretical value, which has been a long-standing problem in the field.In addition, thiol chemistry is introduced to the repair of the vacancy-sites based on the calculated reaction mechanisms745.Following the theoretical guidance, the carrier mobility of the repaired MoS2-based device increased by 2-3 times, which further proved the transport model.Similarly, Jiangetal.demonstrated that defect engineeringviamolecule decoration can be used to efficiently modulate the trap states induced by vacancies in 2D ReS2.The defects are then passivated and shallow traps and recombination centers dominate the photo-response, which show much improved response than the as-prepared device1717.By the listed examples, it can be noted that the thiol molecules are widely used to modify the properties of 2D materials, but the corresponding reaction mechanism is still unclear and controversial in experiments1718.One is that thiol molecules fill the vacancy,which leads to the significant improvement of mobility and optical absorption properties1719; another one is that the molecules adsorb on the surfaces to realize the surface functionalization1720-1721.Accordingly, Lietal.performed detailed theoretical calculations on the reaction mechanisms between the defective MoS2and thiol molecules and found that the vacancies can catalyze the cleavage of S―H bond in thiol molecules with two competitive reaction mechanisms: the cleavage of S―C bond, which can repair defects, and the formation of Mo―S bond to modify the surface of MoS2(Fig.75c).Further calculation shows that the two competitive reactions can be effectively controlled by the modification of functional groups (such as electron withdrawing group and electron donating group) and the control of reaction temperature1722.
Fig.75 (a) Band structure and partial density of states for single-layer MoS2 with an SV.The localized states are highlighted by red lines; (b)schematics of electron transport mechanism in perfect and defective MoS2 750.(c) Two competing Reaction mechanisms between a thiol molecule and SV-MoS2, energy units are in kJ·mol-1 and the distances are in Å; reproduced with permission from Ref.1722, Copyright 2017 John Wiley and Sons.
On the other hand, the high activity of the defective sites can be applied to modulate the properties of the system for specific applications such as sensors and catalysis.For instance, Nanet al.reported that defect engineering by oxygen bonding can be used as an effective strategy to enhance the photoluminescence(PL) of monolayer MoS21723.The calculated band structure clear shows that that the existence of sulfur vacancy defects has n-type doping effect on MoS2, which leads the neutral excitations into negative trions and the decreased PL efficiency.However, the defect sites can chemisorb oxygen molecules to form Mo―O bond and the defective states are thus removed.Moreover,oxygen molecules can extract electrons from MoS2to form ptype doping, which leads to the transition from charged excitation to neutral exciton, thus the luminescence efficiency can be improved.The utilization of defective sites as reactive centers for heterogeneous catalysis has been widely investigated1724.The theoretical studies can identify the reactive centers for certain reactions and thus can promote the improvement of the activity and the design of new catalysts.Ouyangetal.systematically evaluated the catalytic activity of hydrogen evolution by 16 intrinsic defects on basal planes of MoS2, including point defects and grain boundaries1725.The results show that six of them (Vs, VMoS3, MoS2PDs; 4|8a, S bridge, and Mo―Mo bond GBs) can achieve promising HER performance.Furthermore, an amendatory band-center model is established to accounts for the different HER activities of defects, and can be applicable to a wide range of systems with localized defect states.
5.2.3 2D materials supported single atom catalysts
2D materials as the substrates for single atom catalysts (SACs)have several advantages as compared to 3D substrates: (1) single metal atoms supported on 2D materials could be more coordinatively unsaturated, which may lead to higher catalytic performance; (2) a more expedited mass-transfer process on SACs@2D, which maximizes the reaction rates; (3) welldefined structures of SACs@2D that can be accurately probed experimentally, which benefit the investigations on the reaction mechanisms and effect of geometric and electronic structures on the catalytic performance both the experimentally and theoretically1726.Therefore, SACs@2D has drawn great attentions during the past years.Here we will focus on the computational investigations on SACs@2D, including the activity descriptors and strategies for the discovery of SACs@2D.
5.2.3.1 Activity descriptors
For SACs@2D, the single metal atom is usually the active center.Therefore, the inherent electronic structure of the supported single metal atom is found to be the determining factor that governs the binding strength with the reaction intermediates1727-1729.On this basis, thedband center (ɛd) of the supported single atom has been widely used as the activity descriptor of SACs@2D for various reactions.Lingetal.proposed that the OER activity ofβ12boron monolayer (β12-BM)supported SACs (SACs@β12-BM) depend closely on the energy level of theɛd.Specifically, the binding strength of all the reaction intermediates during the OER process (*OH, *O and*OOH) present good linear relation against the corresponding ɛdand the lowest overpotential for OER of SACs@β12-BM can be obtained when the energy level ofɛdis about -2.82 eV (Fig.76a)1730.Gaoetal.reported that binding strengths of intermediates on n-doped graphene (N-G) supported SACs (Mn,Fe, Co, Ni, and Cu) will be weakened with the decrease ofɛdand Co@N-G possesses an optimalɛdthat leads to the appropriate binding strength with *OOH.As a result, the Co@N-G can present better ORR activity than the other four systems, which has also been confirmed by their experimental measurements901.
Except forɛd, some other activity descriptors based on the inherent electronic structure of single metal atom have also been developed.By using single Au (neutral, negatively and positively charged) embedding into C3N as examples, Fuetal.demonstrated that spatial structures of frontierdorbitals determine the chemical and catalytic activities of Au@C3N SACs1727.Liuetal.proposed that bonding/antibonding orbital population can well describe the binding strength of *N (key intermediate for NRR) on different nitrogen-doped carbon substrates supported SACs1729.Fuetal.found that the ORR and OER activity of Ti3C2O2-based SACs is actually determined by thedelectrons near the Fermi level instead of all the occupieddelectrons (Fig.76b)1728.
5.2.3.2 Strategies for materials discovery
The large number of 2D materials, the diversity of metal center and coordination environment make the number of possible candidates for SACs@2D enormous.Therefore, it is very hard to synthesize and investigate the entire possible SACs@2D experimentally.Under this circumstance,computational discovery of SACs@2D has drawn great attention, owing to its advantages of low cost and short development period as compared to the experimental means.In this section, we will summarize recent computational strategies for the discovery of SACs@2D.
The first strategy is the rational design of SACs@2D for certain applications based on the basic chemical and physical concepts.For instance, strong binding strength and sufficient activation of N2is the prerequisite of efficient catalysts for NRR976.Some certain transition metal-based materials can bind N2at low temperatures, which can be ascribed to the coexistence of unoccupied and occupieddorbitals.The unoccupieddorbital can accept the lone-pair electrons, while thedelectrons can be donated into antibonding orbitals of N2(πback donation, which can weaken the N≡N triple bond and simultaneously strengthen the metal-N bond).According to this concept, Ling and coworkers proposed that two-coordinated B atom withsp3hybridization possesses one occupied and one empty orbitals, thus can also bind and activate N2molecule (Fig.76c).Moreover, they further designed g-C3N4supported single B atom catalyst, which can catalyze NRR with a very low onset potential1733.The ability of B atom center to catalyze NRR has been confirmed by a series of experiments955,983.
Fig.76 (a) Calculated free energy change for each reaction of OER on different SACs@β12-BM as a function of the d band center;reproduced with permission from Ref.1730, Copyright 2017 American Chemical Society.(b) Calculated ΔGO-ΔGOH on Ti3C2O2-based SACs catalysts as a function of the corresponding DF (defined as , where D(E) and E are the DOS and energy of d states of transition metal atoms, and W(E) is the weight factor 1728.(c) Simplified schematic of N2 bonding to transition metals and B atom with sp3 hybridization; reproduced with permission from Ref.1733, Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society.reproduced with permission from Ref.1730, Copyright 2017 American Chemical Society.(b) Calculated ΔGO-ΔGOH on Ti3C2O2-based SACs catalysts as a function of the corresponding DF (defined as , where D(E) and E are the DOS and energy of d states of transition metal atoms, and W(E) is the weight factor 1728.(c) Simplified schematic of N2 bonding to transition metals and B atom with sp3 hybridization; reproduced with permission from Ref.1733, Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society.
The second one is high-throughput screening, which can give a full assessment of the catalytic performance of a class of materials.Graphene-based SACs have been reported to have potential application in various electrochemical reactions.To fully understand the activity of this class of materials, a series of works by using high-throughput screening strategy have been done.Specifically, Choietal.studied the stability and HER activity of 300 kinds of B, C, N, O and S coordinated SACs and 19 materials were selected with |ΔGH| (free energy for H adsorption) lower than 0.2 eV1734.Backetal.systematically investigated the stability, activity, mechanism and selectivity for CO2RR of 12 metals embedded into the single- and double-C vacancy site of graphene (labeled as sv-G and dv-G,respectively), where Ni@dv-G/Pt@dv-G and Os@dv-G/Ru@dv-G were found to be highly active for CH3OH and CH4production, respectively1735.Ling and coworkers developed a general two-step strategy for the high-throughput screening of catalysts for NRR and on this basis, they extracted 10 promising candidates from 270 kinds of graphene-based SACs1736.Moreover, the activity for certain reactions of some the predicted systems have been confirmed by available experimental reports,such as Co@G1737and Pt@G for HER1738, Mo@G for NRR945,etc.
The third one is the machine learning-aided catalysts screening, which can significantly reduce the computation cost and time bypassing complicated quantum mechanics1739.Wuet al.proved that machine learning-based screening of SACs for ORR is 130000 times faster than using DFT-based approach1740.Besides, machine learning-based prediction can also achieve high accuracy in addition to the high efficiency.Linetal.built machine learning models to predict the limiting potentials of graphene-based SACs for ORR, OER and HER, where the mean square errors are only 0.027, 0.021 and 0.035 V, respectively, as compared to the DFT calculations1741.In general, high efficiency and accuracy make machine learning a powerful technique for materials discovery1742.With the development of machine learning algorithms and database, this technique will unquestionably draw growing attention.
5.3 2D magnetic materials
2D magnetic materials with abundant magnetic, electronic and optical properties promise the development of new magnetoelectronic and magneto-optical applications1743.Firstprinciple calculations have been proven to be one of the most useful methods to investigate novel 2D magnetic materials, and provide valuable guidelines for experimental synthesis of high performance devices in spintronics1744.In this section, we will comprehensively review some of the key roles of theoretic calculations and simulations in 2D magnetic materials, including determination of magnetic ground state, Curie temperature calculation, interlayer magnetic coupling, external field modulation, topological magnets and high throughput searching.
5.3.1 Magnetic ground state determination
The magnetic ground state plays a significant role in determining the fundamental magnetic properties of 2D magnetisms.As in magnetic materials, there are two competing energies in electronic states, one is the hopping energy of electrons between atoms, the other is electrostatic Coulomb energy between electrons, which can be descripted by a Hubbard model
where the hoppingtijis often restricted to nearest-neighbor sites.The operatorcreates an electron with spinσon atomiand the operatorannihilates an electron with spinσon atomi.An interesting example is CrI3, intriguing layer-dependent magnetic order was reported in atomically thin CrI3films.Monolayer and trilayer CrI3remain ferromagnetic, whereas bilayer CrI3becomes antiferromagnetic (AFM) with FM monolayers coupled antiferromagnetically514.There are two phases of bilayer CrI3, namely, rhombohedral structure withsymmetry at low temperature (LT phase), and monoclinic structure with C2/mspace group symmetry at 210-220 K (HT phase).As shown in Fig.77a, Jiangetal.investigated that the interlayer FM state is always kept under differentUvalues1745,indicating the preferred FM ground state in the LT phase, while HT phase is AFM underUlarger than 2.1 eV, such a phenomenon is also obtained in other works1746,1747.Therefore,the interlayer AFM coupling of bilayer CrI3could be maintained in the HT phase, rather than the presumed LT phase, even at low temperatures.Such a phenomenon may be ascribed to structural quenching under rapid cooling rates and/or vertical confinement of the capping layers in measurements.
The magnetic ground state of 2D magnetic materials can also be influenced by interlayer stacking because the superexchange interaction between magnetic atoms in different layers can be changed through interlayer translation.Sivadasetal.performed first-principle calculations for bilayer CrI3 and found that the magnetic ground state is defined by stacking order (Fig.77b)1748.This stacking-dependent magnetism stems from a competition between interlayer AFM super-superexchange (SSE) and interlayer FM SSE.The interlayer exchange interaction between AFM and FM can be tuned by changing the interlayer stacking order.The interlayer stacking order can also influence the interlayer magnetic coupling of 2D vdWHs.Shangetal.found that the preferred magnetic order and electronic properties are largely influenced by interlayer stacking in CrI3/CrGeTe3heterostructure, which is caused by the competition between the nearestneighbor and second nearest-neighbor superexchange1749.In addition, the relative energy is reliable to the choice of vdW functional (Fig.77c)1750-1752.
Fig.77 Energy difference between AFM and FM spin configurations of bilayer CrI3 as a function of (a) on-site U, (b) interlayer stacking orders and (c) vdW functional corrections.(a) Reproduced with permission from Ref.1745, Copyright 2019 American Physical Society.(b) Reproduced with permission from Ref.1748, Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society.(c) Reproduced with permission from Ref.1750,Copyright 2019 American Physical Society.
5.3.2 Curie temperature calculation
The most important feature of FM materials is the phase transition temperature,i.e., Curie temperature (Tc), which defines many intrinsic macroscopic mechanisms of magnetic materials.The exchange interaction parameters,Jij, are determined by the basic Heisenberg Hamiltonian as
whereiandjare lattice sites of local magnetic moment, andSandJdenote the spin operator and exchange interactions,respectively.Usually, it is enough to consider the exchange interactions between the nearest-neighbor magnetic atoms.In theoretical calculations,Jijcan be extracted from the energies of various spin configurations, such as FM, AF-Neel, AF-zigzag and AF-Stripy, and so on1753.Using Monte Carlo (MC) methods,one can obtain theTcaccording to the relation between thermodynamic specific heat or magnetic moment and temperature.Moreover, a simpler method to roughly estimateTcis the mean-field approximation ofkBTc= 2J/3 (kBis the Boltzmann constant), which, however, usually overestimatesTc.Other theories, such as Stoner, Hubbard and Ruderman-Kittel-Kasuya-Yosida (RKKY) mechanism, were also applied to deal with more complicated electron-electron exchange interactions in 2D magnetic materials.As CrI3monolayer is one of the most typical 2D ferromagnetisms, itsTchas been extensively studied.An overratedTcof 80 K was predicted using the Ising model for the overestimation of anisotropic interactions1754.Researcher calculated theTcof 40 K by MC simulations, which is close to the experimental value of 45 K552,1746.Luetal.calculatedTcis 42 K using XXZ Heisenberg model and MC simulations1755.More importantly, it is found that within a wide range of parameter space,Tcshows a linear relationship with magnetic interaction coefficients.As a consequence,Tcof 2D Heisenbergtype magnets can be predicted by the magnetic interactions rather than performing time-consuming MC simulations.Moreover, the selection ofUalso affects the calculatedTc, for a smallerUvalue corresponds to larger exchange parametersJsinceJ~t2/U1756.
In such a manner, one can predict 2D FM materials withTcover room temperature to develop high-performance spintronic devices.Zhengetal.identified an ideal FM Fe3P monolayer,whoseTcreaches ~420 K1757.Furthermore, it was reported that a new 2D pentagon-based monolayer, penta-MnN2displays a highTcof 913 K that can be further improved to 956 K by biaxial tensile strain1758.
5.3.3 Interlayer magnetic coupling
Interlayer coupling is of paramount importance in modulating physical properties of 2D materials.The layer-dependent magnetic coupling of 2D magnetisms originates from the strong wavefunction overlap in the vdW gap, which can form bonding and antibonding states to modulate the electronic and magnetic properties.Such orbital hybridization could lead to charge redistribution of both layers and thus may influence the intraand interlayer magnetic coupling.As seen from the layerdependent magnetism in CrI31745,1747,1748, the interlayer magnetic coupling might regulate the magnetic properties of 2D magnetisms.Wangetal.reported a Bethe-Slater-curve (BSC)-like phenomenon of energy difference between AFM and FM spin configurations in bilayer TMDs (MX2, M = V, Cr, Mn; X =S, Se, Te) and set up the interlayer exchange coupling mechanism at the vdW spacing (Fig.78a)1759.In addition, the in-plane magnetic orders of mono and few layers CrS2can be largely tuned between striped AFM and FM coupling by the charge transfer of Cregandt2gorbitals1760.In experiment, such an interlayer magnetic coupling can be tunedviapressure.Songetal.demonstrated that vdW engineering by hydrostatic pressure can modify the stacking order of CrI3, which shows AFM-to-FM phase transition under a certain pressure559.
With the stacking-dependence of interlayer coupling of vdW layers, it can also be expected that integration of 2D vdW magnets to form heterostructures could provide an efficient platform for spin control and novel physical phenomena.Combining a FM monolayer supported on a AFM substrate,Tongetal.demonstrated a new skyrmions origin in the 2D magnets by different atomic locations in moiré (Fig.78b)1761.The moiré skyrmions strongly relies on the strength of interlayer magnetic coupling and can be largely modulated by strain and interlayer translation.They also investigated the magnetic proximity effect in a 2D vdW monolayer semiconductor/ferromagnet heterostructure with a moiré pattern by the lattice mismatch and interlayer twisting1762.The heterostructure is modeled by a slab consisting of a 2 × 2 supercell of BAs on a 1 × 1 unit cell of CrI3with a lattice mismatch of 1.3%.The different spatial variations lead to lateral modulation of magnetic proximity effect, which shows a miniband spin splitting strongly depending on the moiré periodicity.
2D vdWHs provide an ideal platform to combine materials with totally different electronic or magnetic properties together,such as multiferroics with both ferroelectric (FE) and FM properties, which possess potential abilities of regulating magnetism with electric polarization and vice versa1764.Gonget al.proposed the 2D heterostructure multiferroics by stacking 2D FM CrGeTe3-1 × 1 on FE, leading to allatomic multiferroicity (Fig.78c)572.The magnetism of CrGeTe3is switched as the polarization of In2Se3reversed, which can be achievedvialateral displacement of the middle most Se layer.The corresponding In2Se3exhibits a tunable magnetic semiconductor for the proximity effect of CrGeTe3.They choseU= 0.5 eV,J= 0.0 eV to reproduce the ferromagnetic ground state and small band gap of CrGeTe3, which is consistent with experimental results512.Moreover, the interlayer magnetic coupling of 2D FM materials is tuned by changing electric polarization direction of 2D FE, which results from the dramatic band alignment changing by the strong built-in electric field in FE materials1765.
The magnetic proximity effect of 2D ferromagnetisms could also be applied to manipulate the valley of TMDs by forming vdWHs for the strong charge transfer across the interface and spin-orbital coupling.The coupling between valley spin and the magnetic field of 2D FM substrates dominate the total valley splitting, which can be tuned by twisting, gating1766and interfacial superposition (Fig.78d)1763.Zhangetal.reported large valley splitting of MoTe2/CrBr3, band inversion in WSe2/CrBr3and MoTe2/CrBr3, and valley-polarized quantum anomalous Hall effect in WSe2/CrBr3using first-principles calculations and thekpmodel1767.The generalized gradient approximation (GGA) +Umethod was employed to better describe transition metals.Therefore, integration of TMDs with 2D FM materials can deepen the understanding of the magnetic proximity effect on the valley degeneracy lifting in TMD-based heterostructures, and provide valuable guidelines in valleytronic applications.In addition, the introduced extra superexchange paths can vastly increase the intralayer FM coupling of 2D ferromagnets1768.
Fig.78 (a) Bethe-Slater-curve-like behavior in bilayer CrSe2; reproduced with permission from Ref.1759, Copyright 2020 American Physical Society.(b) Skyrmions in the Moiré of vdW 2D Magnets composed by a FM monolayer on an AFM substrate; reproduced with permission from Ref.1761,Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society.(c) 2D multiferroicity in vdW CrGeTe3/In2Se3 heterostructure 572.(d) Evolution of total valley splitting(ΔK′K, upper panels) and valance and conduction band valley splitting (ΔVB and ΔCB, bottom panels) for different displacements along lattice a of CrI3/WSe2 heterostructure; reproduced with permission from Ref.1763, Copyright 2019 American Physical Society.
5.3.4 External field modulation
The magnetic ground state and exchange coupling strength of 2D magnetic materials are very sensitive to Fermi level, charge distribution, orbital occupation, symmetry, energy level, andetc.There have been theoretically proposed many strategies to modulate these parameters, including strain engineering,external electric/magnetic field and optical controlling.
After 2D layered magnets are exfoliated from their bulk forms or grown by MBE/CVD methods in experiments, they will be transferred on substrates, such as SiO2or other materials for further electric/magnetic measurement.The lattice mismatch between 2D magnets and substrates is thus inevitable and will introduce strain effect into 2D magnets.From the structural view, increasing biaxial tensile strain can be used as an effective strategy to increase the bond length and bond angle between magnetic atoms, while increasing compression strain will have the opposite effect.Therefore, the strain effect undoubtedly changes the orbital hybridization and determines the magnetic exchange parameters, which could cause FM and AFM phase transition.In this regard, it was theoretically reported that the biaxial tensile strain can lead to FM character in NbS2and NbSe2and the predictedTcis above room temperature (Fig.79a)1769.In addition, the tensile strain can significantly enhance the induced magnetic moments, resulting to a half-metallic character and a strong spin polarization near Fermi level.On the contrary,applying a compressive strain causes FM to AFM transition in monolayer CrX3(X = Cl, Br, I) and the magnetic anisotropy energy (MAE) can also be altered1770.
In practice, it is essential to electrically control magnetism by electrostatic doping/ion liquid gating.The atomic thin 2D magnets provide a platform for electrostatic manipulating magnetic properties by changing orbital hopping, exchange splitting, crystalline splitting and carrier densities (Fig.79b)1771,1772.Both electron and hole doping would render monolayer CrI3itinerant half-metallic, and steadily enhance the FM stability withTcabove 300 K1773.In addition, Wangetal.theoretically investigated that MAE of Fe3GeTe2monolayer shows strongly oscillating behavior upon electron doping, totally different with hole-doping, which is caused by the great changes in the band structure around Fermi energy under electron doping.The Te(pz)―Fe(dz2) bond states occupation and splitting play a critical role in modulating MAE1774.Using MC simulations and mean-field solutions, Leietal.predicted that vdW AFM bilayers with weak interlayer and strong intralyer FM coupling possess strong magnetoelectric response, which can be detected in dualgated devices1775.Moreover, electric field can also induce halfmetallicity in magnetic vdW CrI3/CrGeTe3heterostructures by electric-controlled band alignment in the asymmetric band structures1776.
It is natural to use magnetic field to control the magnetism in 2D magnets.On one hand, the Zeeman spin splitting induced by external magnetic field usually induces magnetic ordering.On the other hand, the external magnetic field can also make spin reoriented and thus determines the magnetic ground state.Jiangetal.theoretically demonstrated a direct-to-indirect bandgap transition by rotating the spin order of CrI3from out-of-plane to in-plane (Fig.79c), and the Fermi surface can be significantly changed with different magnetic directions, leading to giant anisotropic magnetoresistance1777.Using an optical-excited double-band-edge transition model, Guoetal.proposed that reversing the magnetization can switch the band alignment of CrBr3/CrCl3heterostruction, which realizes the interlayer magnetic order and spin polarized band structure coupling1778.
Optically modulating magnetic properties is also a promising strategy for its no destruction of geometrical and electronic structures and easily control.Based on first-principles calculations, Tianetal.predicted that the coupling between light and magnetism in monolayer RuCl3is strong, and in turn modulates its magnetic order (Fig.79d).Both of the ferromagnetism andTcare significantly enhanced with optical doping e-h pair density increasing, and particularly,Tcis close to room temperature as e-h concentration reaches 3 × 1013cm-2565.Using real-time time-dependent density functional theory (DFT)simulations, He and coworkers demonstrated that ultrafast spinselective charge transfer between magnetic sublattices can be directly induced by laser pulses in a few femtoseconds in 2D MXenes1021.The magnetic structures show dramatic changes under laser excitation.In addition, they also studied that laser pulses can also induce significant spin injection from Fe3GeTe2to 2D nonmagnetic layers within a few femtoseconds1779.
Fig.79 (a) Tensile strain switched ferromagnetism in layered NbS2 and NbSe2; reproduced with permission from Ref.1769, Copyright 2012 American Chemical Society.(b) Bilayer CrI3 based spin field-effect transistor with generation of spin-polarized current controlled by an electric field; reproduced with permission from Ref.1771, Copyright 2020 American Chemical Society.(c) Band structures of monolayer CrI3 with magnetic moment along the out-of-plane and in-plane, respectively; reproduced with permission from Ref.1777, Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society.(d) Schematic plot of optically modulated magnetism in RuCl3 monolayer; reproduced with permission from Ref.565, Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society.
5.3.5 2D topological magnets
2D materials with coexisting quantum phases provide exciting platforms for exploring novel physic phenomena induced by the interplay between topology and magnetism.Intrinsic topological magnets offer a promising platform for both exploring fundamental physical mechanism and developing nextgeneration technologies based on topological quantum states.Otrokovetal.predicted by ab initio calculations and further confirm in experiments the realization of an AFM topological insulator (TI) in the layered vdW compound MnBi2Te41780.Liet al.also predicted a series of vdW layered MnBi2Te4-related materials showing intralayer FM and interlayer AFM exchange interactions548.Moreover, the electronic, magnetic and topological transitions in MnBi2Te4are thickness dependent and can be magnetically controlled1030.
5.3.6 High throughput search magnetism
According to the above reviews, there are tremendous excellent magnetic and electronic properties in 2D magnetic materials, which, however, always possess low Curie temperature, hindering further development of magnetic materials in spintronic applications.Currently, it is still an expensive process for the discovery of magnetic materials in experiment.Therefore, searching 2D ferromagnetic materials withTcapproaching room temperature is thus an urgent and challenging task.Theoretical simulation offers a more effective way to explore 2D intrinsic FM materials.The recent emergence of first-principle high-throughput calculations and machine learning (ML) techniques greatly accelerate such a process1781,1782.Zhuetal.performed a systematic search for 2D FM materials in the Inorganic Crystal Structure Database (ICSD)1783.From 187,093 entries in the ICSD, they identified eight 2D FM materials (Fig.80a), including three known structural prototypes and two 2D experimentally-discovered FM materials.More importantly, they found two new prototypes of 2D ferromagnets and one promising candidate Cr3Te4with the predictedTcmuch higher than other 2D FM materials.In addition, Liu and coauthors carried out high-throughput first-principles screening to yield 89 magnetic monolayers including 56 FM and 33 AFM materials1784.Interestingly, 2D FM monolayers with highTcand fascinating electronic phases were identified, including coexisting quantum anomalous Hall and valley Hall effect in single materials and half-metals (Fig.80b).In the later studies,combining advanced ML technologies with high-throughput DFT calculations, Luetal.developed an adaptive framework to accelerate the search of 2D intrinsic ferromagnets1785.They screened out about 90 FM materials with both satisfactory bandgap and outstanding thermodynamic stability, and further set up a database containing 1459 2D magnets.
Beyond 2D FM materials, the discovery of MnBi2Te4, a typical intrinsic magnetic topological material, has motivates the exploring of systems with coexisting magnetism and topology.Freyetal.computed 27000 different magnetic orderings for more than 3000 transition metal oxides, and determined the ground states to estimate the effective exchange parameters andTc1786.After performing high-throughput band topology analysis of centrosymmetric magnetic materials and calculating topological invariants, they identified 18 new potential FM topological semimetals (spinel CuCr2O4), axion insulators(spinel CdNi2O4), and AFM topological insulators (e.g.,tetragonal Ca2MnO3) (Fig.80c).
Fig.80 (a) Schematic diagram of the search procedure for 2D FM materials; reproduced with permission from Ref.1783, Copyright 2018 American Physical Society.(b) Quantum anomalous Hall state in FM monolayer RuCl3, including atomic structure (upper left) and band structure with (blue line) and without spin orbital coupling (gray line) (upper right) of monolayer RuCl3, Berry curvature in first Brillouin zone (left lower), and band structure of RuCl3 nanoribbon with a width of 386 Å (low right); reproduced with permission from Ref.1784, Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society.(c) Magnetic topological materials 1786.
6 Conclusions and outlooks
Since 2004, it has been witnessed the development of 2D materials from springing up to prosperity not only in fundamental scientific research but also in promising technological innovation in various disciplines including condensed matter physics, materials science, chemistry and electronic engineering.The unique properties and striking applications of 2D materials have revolutionized our understanding on how they will make a big difference as compared to the bulk materials and 0D/1D nanomaterials.It is worth pointing out that on the basis of previous studies, some major breakthroughs have been made in this promising field from all aspects.In this Review, we have summarized the recent progress in the field of 2D materials with a particular emphasis on that in the last five years.We have categorized the recent progress on 2D materials in the following sections: synthetic methods, properties, potential applications and theoretical calculations/simulations.
Although significant progress has been made in the field of 2D materials in the last decade, it is no doubt that this rapidly growing field still faces some challenges.First, one of the big challenges is how to synthesize 2D materials with desired structural characteristics in a highly controllable manner since the properties and applications of 2D materials are highly related to all these structural characteristics, such as size, layer number,doping, defects, vacancies, inter layer spacing, crystallinity and phase.For example, the phase of 2D materials has been considered as one of the critical parameters to affect their properties and application performance in recent years.However, it is still difficult to precisely engineer the purity of certain phase, the ratio of different phases, or phase patterning of 2D materials,i.e., the research topics on phase engineering of nanomaterials (PEN), which are believed to be important for their further applications in catalysis and electronics.Second,another big challenge in 2D materials is how to realize the massive production of 2D materials or wafer-scale growth of high-quality 2D thin films for practical applications.The current wet-chemical synthesis and liquid exfoliation methods can produce 2D materials with promising performances in catalysis or batteries, but their production still cannot meet the requirement for practical industrial applications.In addition, the large lateral size and atomic thickness of 2D materials endow them with many excellent properties but also inevitably make them very easy to stack together during the storage and further usage, which will dramatically deactivate their advantages.Therefore, the third big challenge is how to prevent the stacking or aggregation of 2D nanosheets in storage and application processes and thus avoid the degradation of the excellent properties and performances of 2D materials.Considering that 2D materials have been widely explored for a wide range of applications, challenges still exist for each specific application.Although 2D materials indeed have the great potential to exceed the Moore’s law by making shorter-channel transistor or constructing monolithic 3D integrated CMOS circuits based on 2D materials, the more realistic goal is to integrate 2D materials with silicon chips rather than to replace silicon.Fourthly, one of the big challenges for the application of 2D materials in electronics is to make the 2D materials processing processes compatible with current silicon semiconductor production technology.Although 2D materials have been demonstrated to be promising in construction of next-generation highperformance photodetectors, most of 2D materials have large bandgap and only can be used for fabrication of photodetectors to detect visible to near infrared light.Fifth, one of the big challenges for the application of 2D materials in optoelectronics is to design and synthesize narrow bandgap 2D semiconductors for fabrication of photodetectors to detect infrared light,especially for the long-wave infrared light.Although 2D materials have been demonstrated to be excellent electrocatalysts in a number of reactions, such as HER, OER and CO2RR, the performance of most of the 2D material-based electrocatalysts degrades fast in long term stability test, which is one of the major limitations for their practical applications in electrocatalysis.Sixth, one of the big challenges for the application of 2D materials in catalysis is to achieve long term stability in catalytic reactions.Although 2D materials have been extensively explored for energy storage, the understanding of the storage mechanisms is still insufficient and the energy storage devices normally are not very stable for long-term operation.Seventh, the challenge for the application of 2D materials in energy storage lies in how to understand and control of the storage mechanisms and achieive long-term electrochemical stability.Eeighth, although 2D materials have been widely used for solar cells, one of the major challenges for the application of 2D materials in solar cells is to syntehesize diverse 2D materials with functional agents to bring in synergistic effects with eliminated nonradiative charge recombination and good compatibility with neighboring layers.Although 2D materials have shown promising application in biomedicine, the biomedical applications of 2D biomaterials still suffers from the critical issue of precise structure/composition control of 2D nanosystems for the strict biomedical utilization.Ninth, one of the big challenges for 2D materials in biologoical applciaiton is to precisely engeer the structure and compsotion of 2D materials for specific biologoical applciaiton.2D material-based sensing platforms have been successfully applied in environmental monitoring, biochemical analysis, disease diagnosis, food safety,public health safety, and even homeland security due to their charming properties, such as excellent sensitivity, selectivity,stability and reproducibility.With the increasing practical detection need, 2D material-based sensing platforms face challenges.Tenth, one of the big challenges for the application of 2D materials in sensing platforms is to understand the interaction mechanism between target molecules and 2D materials, which is important for constructing high-performance sensing platforms.Eleventh, for the application of 2D materials in flexible electronics, one of the major challenges is how to achieve the processing compatibility of 2D materials with plastic substrates.Twelfth, for 2D materials in environmental application is how to reduce the interferences in the operation process, e.g., swelling, fouling and degradation, to maintain the long-term performance of the 2D materials in practical applications.Proton permeation provides 2D crystal lattice as a novel subatomic sieve.However, there is still a long path towards the real applications.Last but not least, one of the big challenges for the application of 2D materials in proton permeation is how to realize the scalable production of high quality 2D materials, their wafer-scale transfer techniques and compatibility with support proton conductive substrate.
Although research on 2D materials has been exponentially growing in last seventeen years, the history of 2D materials is still relatively short in comparison with conventional bulk materials and 0D/1D nanomaterials.Therefore, studies on 2D materials are still far from mature.Without a doubt, there are many opportunities in this bright research field on various aspects and thus lots of works can be carried out in the near future.First, the most straightforward direction in this field is to prepare and explore novel 2D materials despite the fact that a large number of 2D materials have been reported so far.Given that 2D materials are defined by the dimension, it is reasonable to predict that all of the existing materials have the possibility to be grown as 2D materials once proper synthetic methods are established.New 2D materials may exhibit unusual but important properties and innovative functionalities.Secondly,the growth of high-quality wafer-scale 2D thin films with controllable layer number is another promising research direction in this field.The ability to grow high-quality waferscale 2D thin films is critically important for their future applications in the large-area integration of 2D materials in electronics, optoelectronics and flexible electronics.Recent studies have successfully demonstrated the growth of highquality wafer-scale 2D thin films, such as graphene, h-BN and MoS2, by properly optimizing the synthetic conditions of the CVD technique.As a consequence, it is believed that many other 2D materials could also be grown into wafer-scale 2D thin films with high quality in the future.Third, another promising direction in this field is to precisely control or engineer the phase of novel 2D materials,i.e., an important research topic of PEN.The crystal phase of 2D materials has been proven to play an important role in determining their properties and applications.Although some 2D materials with unconventional phases have been synthesized and explored in recent years, the study on phase of 2D materials is still in its early stage.To this end, more 2D materials with new phases would be synthesized in the near future.Fourth, exploring new properties and applications for 2D materials is one of the promising directions.For example, 2D materials have been found to show unexpected appealing magnetic properties in recent years.Most current research on 2D materials only focuses on studying certain properties or applications.Therefore, many new properties and innovative applications of 2D materials are still waiting to be explored in the near future.Last but not least, given that many 2D materials have been demonstrated to be promising in a given application in laboratory, one of the promising directions in this field is to push forward the replacement of some key commercialized materials by 2D materials in real products or by integrating 2D materials with existing technologies or products to further optimize their performances.For example, wafer-scale semiconducting 2D thin films have been used as active channel materials to fabricate integrated circuits.Therefore, wafer-scale high-quality 2D thin films could be used as active materials in the construction of next-generation monolithic 3D integrated CMOS circuits and high-performance room-temperature infrared imaging sensor systems in the near future.