Diet in neurogenic bowel management: A viewpoint on spinal cord injury

Marco Bernardi, Anna Lucia Fedullo, Elisabetta Bernardi, Diego Munzi, Ilaria Peluso, Jonathan Myers,Florigio Romano Lista, Tommaso Sciarra

Abstract The aim of this review is to offer dietary advice for individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI) and neurogenic bowel dysfunction. With this in mind, we consider health conditions that are dependent on the level of lesion including skeletal muscle atrophy, autonomic dysreflexia and neurogenic bladder. In addition, SCI is often associated with a sedentary lifestyle, which increases risk for osteoporosis and diseases associated with chronic low-grade inflammation, including cardiovascular and chronic kidney diseases. The Mediterranean diet, along with exercise and dietary supplements, has been suggested as an anti-inflammatory intervention in individuals with SCI. However, individuals with chronic SCI have a daily intake of whole fruit, vegetables and whole grains lower than the recommended dietary allowance for the general population. Some studies have reported an increase in neurogenic bowel dysfunction symptoms after high fiber intake; therefore, this finding could explain the low consumption of plant foods.Low consumption of fibre induces dysbiosis, which is associated with both endotoxemia and inflammation. Dysbiosis can be reduced by exercise and diet in individuals with SCI. Therefore, to summarize our viewpoint, we developed a Mediterranean diet-based diet and exercise pyramid to integrate nutritional recommendations and exercise guidelines. Nutritional guidelines come from previously suggested recommendations for military veterans with disabilities and individuals with SCI, chronic kidney diseases, chronic pain and irritable bowel syndrome. We also considered the recent exercise guidelines and position stands for adults with SCI to improve muscle strength, flexibility and cardiorespiratory fitness and to obtain cardiometabolic benefits. Finally, dietary advice for Paralympic athletes is suggested.

Key words: Neurogenic bowel dysfunction; Body composition; Mediterranean diet;Food–drug interactions; Microbiota; Paralympic athletes

INTRODUCTION

Spinal cord injury (SCI) may result in motor paralysis and sensory loss below the level of the lesion[1-5]and impaired function of the autonomic nervous system (ANS)originating from the spinal cord[6]. The physio-pathological consequences of the SCI are therefore manifold, including an injury level-dependent impaired function in thoracic and abdominal organs and their related tissues[6]. The lack of motor stimulation below the level of SCI induces changes that can result in neurogenic obesity via adipose tissue accumulation[7]. The latter is associated with the release of proinflammatory adipokines that lead to chronic low-grade inflammation[7,8].Although both under-nutrition and over-nutrition can be observed in individuals with SCI[9], compared to the guidelines for general population, individuals with chronic SCI have lower fibre intake and greater energy intake relative to energy needs[10]. Among individuals with SCI, daily intakes of whole fruits, vegetables and whole grains were lower than recommended dietary allowances[11-13]. Appropriate nutritional recommendations[14]and exercise[7]for individuals with SCI could play an important role in decreasing the risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) and cardiometabolic syndrome (CMS).

On the other hand, symptoms of bowel dysfunction, including constipation and faecal incontinence, have a high impact on quality of life of individuals with SCI[15]. It has been reported that many characteristics of abdominal pain among patients with SCI resemble those of able-bodied individuals with chronic idiopathic constipation[16].Dysmotility and abdominal discomfort have been attributed to the ingestion of certain carbohydrates (CHO) in individuals with gastrointestinal disorders, including irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) and functional constipation[17]. In addition to dietary advice, lifestyle recommendations, including exercise, have been suggested for patients with IBS[18], in particular in those with slow or uncoordinated transit[19]. It has been suggested that exercise may modulate intestinal permeability and motility, stool transit time and consistency[20].

In this review, considering the above-mentioned issues, we will discuss dietary management of neurogenic bowel dysfunction (NBD) among individuals with SCI and suggest a Mediterranean diet (Med-D)-based pyramid and nutritional advice for Paralympic athletes with SCI.

NEUROGENIC BOWEL DYSFUNCTION IN SPINAL CORD INJURY

NBD refers to bowel dysfunction consequent to the ANS injury and/or lack of central nervous system control (mainly from hypothalamus and brainstem)[21]. Although symptoms of both upper (esophageal[22]/gastroesophageal[23]) and lower (intestinal)gastrointestinal disorders can occur, the latter are highly prevalent in SCI and include constipation (prevalence ranging between 56% and 80%) and faecal incontinence(range 42%-75%)[21]. Colon dysfunction following SCI can be divided into two main types, depending on the level of the lesion: An upper motor neuron syndrome and a lower motor neuron syndrome[21]. Typically constipation and incontinence occur for injury above and below the thoracic (T)11/T12 region, respectively[24]. On the other hand, given that traumatic SCI usually occurs at the cervical or thoracic levels, the spinal defecation centre, located in the sacral spinal cord, is typically intact in these individuals[25].

In patients with motor complete SCI, Vallèset al[26]identified three different neuropathophysiological patterns. Pattern A is characterized by frequent constipation, moderate delay in colonic transit time (CTT) and the absence of anal relaxation during the defecation. Pattern B is characterized by defecatory difficulty,moderate delay in CTT, increased anal resistance during the defecation and preserved sacral reflexes; Pattern C is characterized by severe incontinence associated with severe delay in CTT and absence of sacral reflexes.

In a long (19-year, 1996-2015) follow up study on living with SCI, no significant changes in quality of life and faecal incontinence were found, whereas a higher prevalence (from 19% to 31%) of the population with SCI considered themselves to be constipated and increased with time the use of oral laxatives[27].

It has been suggested that constipation is a major cause of abdominal pain or discomfort after SCI, rather that neuropathic pain, with pain considered more intense and unpleasant among individuals with chronic idiopathic constipation compared to patients with SCI[16]. Furthermore, there was no association between neurological level of SCI and abdominal pain as 79% of individuals with cervical and thoracic SCI and 86% with lumbar SCI had pain[16].

Sensory stimuli below the injury level due to bowel management are among the common triggers for autonomic dysreflexia (AD), which is a complex syndrome characterized by sudden episodic high vasoconstriction-induced hypertension and resulting symptoms due to massive sympathetic ANS activity deriving from the lack of hypothalamus and brainstem control. AD generally occurs among individuals with SCI at or above the T6 level[6], above splanchnic sympathetic outflow.

Inskipet al[28]found that in a group of about 150 individuals with SCI at T7 or above, 74% experienced at least one AD symptom during bowel care including“goosebumps, spasticity, flushing and sweating” in about half population, along with general unwellness (43%) and headache (38%)”. “Heart palpitations, irregular heartbeats, or a feeling of fluttering in the chest” globally considered as symptoms of arrhythmia consequent to AD were found in 45 of 141 (32%) individuals with SCI at or above T7[28]. Longer durations of bowel care due to SCI and more severe AD were associated with lower quality of life[28].

The NBD score has been identified as a condition-specific tool to assess quality of life as "subjective well-being" among individuals with SCI[29]. NBD score includes frequency of bowel movements (0-6 points), headache, perspiration or discomfort before or during defecation (0-2 points), tablets and drops against constipation (0-2 points each), time used for each defecation (0-7 points), frequency of digital stimulation or evacuation (0-6 points), frequency of faecal incontinence (0-13 points),medication against faecal incontinence (0-4 points), flatus incontinence (0-2 points)and perianal skin problems (0-3 points)[30]. According to Kroghet al[30]a severe NBD score is ≥ 14, moderate an NBD score of 10-13, minor an NBD score of 7-9 and very minor an NBD score of 0-6. Liuet al[31]reported that differences in NBD scores were dependent on both completeness and level of injury. Severe NBD was observed in 71.1% of individuals with American Spinal Injury Association (ASIA) classification A(loss of motor and sensory function at S4-5 level), whereas lower percentages were found in patients with incomplete SCI (prevalence of 32.4%, 24.2% and 27.1% in ASIA classifications B, C and D, respectively)[31]. Furthermore, a higher percentage of individuals with cervical (48.2%) and thoracic (40.0%) SCI had severe NBD, compared to those with lumbar SCI (14.3%)[31]. Other factors, including use of laxatives and fibre intake, affect NBD score among individuals with traumatic SCI and minor to moderate bowel dysfunction (NBD Score: 8.01 ± 4.49), whereas neither the use of anticholinergics nor opioid agents were significantly associated with NBD[32]. In conclusion, living with SCI and NBD has an impact on dietary intake (amount or type of foods) and habit (time restricted or skip meal)[33], with potential effects on nutritional status.

DYSBIOSIS IN SPINAL CORD INJURY: POTENTIAL TARGET FOR FIBRE, DIETARY INTERVENTIONS AND EXERCISE TRAINING

Antibiotic treatment, due to recurrent infections, and altered CTT significantly alter the composition of gut microbiota in individuals with SCI[34]. The use of antibiotics decreases microbial diversity by 25% and increases theBacteroidetes/Firmicutesratio[35].In the “Guidelines for Management of Neurogenic Bowel Dysfunction in Individuals with Central Neurological Conditions” of the Multidisciplinary Association of Spinal Cord Injured Professionals[36], it is concluded that there is some evidence that the use of probiotics may help to restore colonic flora after antibiotic treatment.

Several clinical studies have evaluated the intestinal microbiota among individuals with SCI and all have reported decreasedFirmicutescompared to healthy controls[37-39].Furthermore, the reduced microbial diversity in individuals with SCI[37,38]has been associated with unfavourable metabolic profiles[37]. At the phylum level,BacteroidetesandFirmicuteswere negatively[38]and positively correlated with high density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL)[37], respectively, andFirmicuteswere negatively correlated with serum glucose (GLU)[38]. Exercise[40,41]and Med-D[42]are known to improve metabolic (serum GLU and lipids) markers and cardiorespiratory fitness was reported to be significantly correlated to both microbial diversity[20,43,44]andFirmicutestoBacteroidetesratio in healthy adults[45]. Animal-based diets increased the abundance ofBacteroides[46,47]and decreasedFirmicuteswhich metabolize dietary plant polysaccharides[47].Prevotella[48]abundance was associated with long-term fibre intake,estimated using the Diet History Questionnaire[48]. In individuals with SCI, GLU was negatively correlated withPrevotella[38]andMegamonas[37,38](more abundant in a healthy group than in groups with SCI)[37-39]. Although,MegamonasandPrevotellamay have a positive effect on CHO metabolism, they were positively correlated with the NBD score, probably due to gas and short-chain fatty acids (SCFA), the end products of microbial fibre fermentation[38]. In IBS, discomfort, constipation and altered faecal consistency can be influenced by the presence of dietary fibre and fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides, and polyols (FODMAP)[18,49].

Reported mean fibre intake, ranging between 15.0 g/d[11]and 16.9-17.6 g/d[10], met the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics Evidence Analysis Library minimum target range for individuals with SCI (which starts at a minimum of 15 g/d and increases up to 30 g/d as tolerated)[50]. Stoffelet al[51]reviewed studies on neurogenic bowel management and reported that a high-fibre diet prolonged constipation and increased CTT and NBD score in persons with SCI and suggested that clinicians may recommend a low-fibre diet to reduce CCT. In a recent systematic review, Yeunget al[52]concluded that consumption of about 15 g/d of dietary fibre could be beneficial in managing neurogenic bowel in SCI, whereas an increase in fibre intake from 25 g/d to 31 g/d increased CTT and evacuation time.

Increased stool consistency (looser stool with high transit time) was inversely related to microbiota diversity and positively associated withBacteroidetes/Firmicutesratio and increased CCT[46]. SCFA can increase levels of serotonin, triggering contraction of the smooth muscle in the gastrointestinal tract[46]and SCFA levels have been negatively correlated with CTT[53].

On the other hand, individuals with metabolic syndrome (Met-S) had reduced SCFA[54]and SFCA were positively correlated with adherence to the Med-D pattern[55].Triglycerides (TG) in individuals with SCI were negatively correlated withEubacterium_rectale, a butyrate-producing bacterial genus[37].Dialister(decreased in SCI)[37,39]was negatively correlated with low density lipoprotein cholesterol and positively correlated with HDL.

Gungoret al[39]found that, compared to healthy controls, there was a preferential decrease inMarvinbryantiain the upper motor neuron group, whereas in the lower motor neuron group,Roseburiawas decreased[39]. Gungoret al[39]suggested that although the identity of the genera that are dysregulated in both groups may differ,the reduction of butyrate (a SCFA) production would be expected to be similar. High fat diets decrease butyrate levels and can induce gut dysbiosis, dysmotility and constipation[46]. On the other hand, physically fit individuals had increased abundances of key butyrate-producing taxa, includingRoseburia[43].

SCFA are also involved in gut-brain signalling implicated in the regulation of metabolic and immune homeostasis[53]. Sympathetic noradrenergic nerves innervate the vasculature and tissue parenchyma of the gut-associated lymphoid tissues[56].Norepinephrine released by sympathetic post-ganglionic nerve terminals binds to beta (β)-adrenergic receptors on innate and adaptive immune cells leading to suppression of their antimicrobial functions[56].

In pre-clinical SCI models, intestinal epithelial cell permeability is increased and is associated with enhanced bacterial translocation and endotoxemia [increased lipopolysaccharide (LPS)][56]. Data from animal models suggest that gut dysbiosis, LPS and gut-associated lymphoid tissues[57]lead to the chronic low-grade inflammation associated with Met-S after SCI[53,56]. LPS elicits strong inflammatory responses by binding to extracellular toll-like receptor 4. In mouse studies, gut dysbiosis, free fatty acids, and the activation of toll-like receptor 4 are associated with enteric neuronal death, damaged function of the enteric nervous system and delayed transit time[46]. In this context, LPS was negatively associated with adherence to the Med-D[55]and cardiorespiratory fitness was negatively correlated with LPS[43]. Therefore, both exercise and diet could reduce endotoxemia and inflammation induced by dysbiosis in individuals with SCI.

DIETARY ADVICE AND MEDITERRANEAN DIET-BASED PYRAMID FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH SPINAL CORD INJURY

Individuals with SCI experience significant skeletal muscle atrophy mainly below the level of injury[58], which may contribute to decreases in resting energy expenditure[59].On the other hand, the immune system is an energy consumer and during chronic inflammation re-allocation of energy-rich fuels to the activated immune system, called"energy appeal reaction", can lead to inadequate energy regulation, muscle protein breakdown, low vitamin D levels, cachectic obesity, insulin resistance, dyslipidaemia,Met-S and inflammation-related anaemia and osteopenia[60,61].

The SCI-SCREEN, a nutritional screening model developed in a neurorehabilitation unit, incorporated the Lagerström’s proposed body mass index (BMI) cut-offs for SCI patients, differentiating between individuals with paraplegia (estimated muscle mass reduction of 7.5%) and those with tetraplegia (estimated muscle mass reduction of 12.5%)[62]. On the other hand, the “Guidelines for Identification and Management of Cardiometabolic Risk after Spinal Cord Injury” of the Consortium for Spinal Cord Medicine expert panel suggested definitions of obesity as: > 22% of fat mass (FM) or BMI ≥ 22 kg/m2, given that waist circumference is not a validated proxy for obesity in SCI[63].

Recommendations for energy intake in individuals with SCI in the subacute and community living phases were 22.7 kcal/kg and 27.9 kcal/kg of body mass (BM) for individuals with tetraplegia and paraplegia, respectively[50]. Recommendations for protein intakes did not differ between individuals with tetraplegia and paraplegia,amounting to 0.8-1 g/kg (of BM)[50]. Higher energy and protein recommendations were suggested for individuals with pressure ulcers[50]and for Paralympic Athletes[64].Wheelchair athletes have been reported to have low energy availability, low protein consumption and CHO intakes near the lower limit of the recommended range (3.0-12.0 g/kg)[65]. This suggests that wheelchair athletes could be at risk of post-exercise ketosis. The latter (about 0.5-1.0 mM in response to 2 h of exercise performed in an overnight fasted state) depends on the intensity and duration of the exercise performed, as well as on the nutritional status and on the ketone body uptake by skeletal muscle, which are able to extract about 50% of circulating ketone bodies when concentrations are low (0.1-0.5 mM)[66]. In a case report, a 36-year-old man, wheelchair bound secondary to genetically confirmed spinal muscular atrophy, presented to an emergency department with epigastric pain and vomiting due to ketoacidosis, and reported decreased food intake in the preceding week in an attempt to lose weight,with a diet consisting mainly of proteins and vegetables with minimal CHO in the 48 h prior to his presentation[67]. The authors suggested that the severity of the ketosis,which seemed inconsistent with moderate starvation alone, could be due to other factors, including low muscle mass[67].

On the other hand, the sublesional muscle atrophy with SCI significantly reduces the primary storage site for CHO, promoting increased circulating GLU and risk of type 2 diabetes[14]. The reduction in fat free mass (FFM) and the increase in FM are key features in people with SCI that could increase the risk for CMS[14]. In an environment of reduced mobility, energy needs are reduced, and there is an increased risk of obesity-related chronic diseases, making energy balance a critical and fundamental issue in SCI[68]. The spinal nutrition screening tool has been validated for patients with SCI to assess the malnutrition risk[9]. The spinal nutrition screening tool assesses eight criteria: History of recent weight loss, BMI, age, level of SCI, presence of comorbidities, skin condition, appetite and ability to eat[9]. These authors reported that patients with paraplegia were less likely to be malnourished (33.7%) than those with tetraplegia (66.1%) and readmitted patients had a lower incidence of under-nutrition(41.6%) than newly injured patients (50%)[9]. On the other hand, a 67% of individuals with SCI were at potential risk of over-nutrition (BMI > 22 kg/m2)[9]. It has been reported that the components of CMS (abdominal obesity, hypertension, insulin resistance, and dyslipidaemia) are not equally weighted; sarcopenic obesity is a highly prevalent finding after SCI and appears to be the most relevant risk factor, followed by insulin resistance[63].

Among the dietary strategies there is the “adaptability of the diabetes prevention program” (DPP) for SCI, consisting of a 24-wk energy-restricted Med-D[14].Preliminary data in men with chronic SCI who were obese and pre-diabetic, showed that a therapeutic lifestyle intervention including diet, exercise, patient education and professional support, resulted in BM reduction that exceeded the DPP criterion (7%).The intervention also demonstrated improvements in insulin resistance and lipid profile (HDL increase and TG decrease)[14]. A systematic review of dietary interventions in adults with SCI emphasized the potential of diet in conjunction with exercise in minimizing CVD risk[69], whereas the “Consortium for Spinal Cord Medicine” noted success in weight loss using the Med-D in the DPP[63]. Med-D has been suggested for Veterans with disabilities[70], patients with chronic kidney disease(CKD)[71]and individuals with chronic pain[72]. Furthermore, Allisonet al[73], recently reported that in individuals with SCI, a 3-mo anti-inflammatory diet similar to the Med-D plus supplementation decreased fat intake and proinflammatory dietary components (trans fatty acids, caffeine and sodium) and increased protein intake and some nutrients with established anti-inflammatory properties, including vitamins A,C, and E, and omega (ω)-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA), with no change in CHO or energy intake[73]. Significant reductions in the proinflammatory cytokines interferon-γ, interleukin-1β, and interleukin-6 were observed and several proinflammatory mediators were negatively correlated with anti-inflammatory nutrients, including vitamin A, carotenoids, ω-3 PUFA, and zinc, whereas the change in total calories as well as individual macronutrients were not shown to be significantly correlated with any inflammatory mediator[73]. Obesity in SCI results in a state of chronic low-grade inflammation primarily due to proinflammatory adipokines secreted from excess adipose tissue[7]. Accordingly, individuals with chronic motor complete SCI, severe lower extremity spasticity and lower FM had lower leptin and fasting GLU than patients with SCI with no or mild spasticity[74]. On the other hand, no differences in bone mineral density (BMD), low density lipoprotein cholesterol, HDL, TG and glycosylated haemoglobin were observed between the two groups[74]. Although it has been reported that protein intake is negatively associated with BMD of lumbar vertebrae in women with SCI[75], in a cross-sectional study, no significant relationships were found between BMD and intakes of protein, calcium,vitamins D and or serum 25(OH)D in individuals with chronic SCI (94% male, lesions from C1 to T12). However, significant associations were found between BMD at the femoral neck and lumbar spine with visceral adipose tissue, insulin and leptin[76].Leptin enhances both arterial and venous thrombosis by promoting platelet adhesion,activation and aggregation[77]and it has been recently observed that some Paralympic athletes with SCI had a higher platelet-derived CVD risk rather than CMS risk[78].Caffeine can increase platelet aggregation, which may be associated with an elevated risk of thrombosis[79]. Conversely, among natural dietary compounds and functional foods of the Med-D with antiplatelet activities (including ω-3 PUFA, olive oil, garlic,onions and tomatoes)[80], O'Kennedyet al[81]reported that a water-soluble tomato extract, having antiplatelet anti-angiotensin-converting enzyme and antiinflammatory activities, became the first product in Europe to obtain an approved health claim[82,83].

Vitamins A, B5, B7, B9, D, E, potassium, and calcium are deficient compared to the USDA guidelines in individuals with SCI[10]. Many of these micronutrients are linked to CHO, lipid, and/or vascular dysfunction, whereas recommendations for pressure ulcer management suggest evaluation for vitamins A and C, zinc and iron[50].

It has been reported that level and completeness of lesion, injury duration,mobility, FM%, time spent outdoors and comorbidities were not associated with plasma 25(OH)D, whereas in a multivariable model (adjusting for age, planned exercise, sex, race, wine consumption, and smoking status) supplement (but not dietary) intake was significantly associated with increased 25(OH)D[84]. Similarly, in a univariable model, stretching, range of motion, or physical therapy was not associated with higher 25(OH)D level, whereas other planned exercise was associated with higher 25(OH)D levels[84].

A systematic review emphasized the potential of diet in conjunction with exercise in minimizing CVD risk in SCI[69], whereas the Consortium for Spinal Cord Medicine did not recommend a single nutritional intervention but noted success in weight loss using the Med-D in the DPP[63]. Med-D has been suggested for Veterans with disability[70], patients with CKD[71]and individuals with chronic pain[72].

In a recent meta-analysis, 86% and 43%-74% of individuals with chronic SCI had excessive intake of CHO, and 43%-74% had excessive intake of proteins[10]. These authors[10]also reported a mean of 57 kcal/d from alcohol and pointed out that participants were also likely to underreport their true alcohol consumption given its effects on weight and health and the stigma that is often associated with alcohol consumption. In a study that included only overweight and obese individuals (BMI >22 kg/m2, mean 30.5 ± 6.33 kg/m2with a range from 22.44 kg/m2to 49.91 kg/m2)with SCI (50% with paraplegia and 50% with tetraplegia), although participants’intakes were within the recommended range of amounts for all macronutrients, they were on the low end of the recommended range for protein and on the high end for total fat[11]. Furthermore, individuals with SCI report excess intake of added sugars,sodium and saturated fat and inadequate intake of healthy fats, seafood, plant protein, fruits, vegetables and whole grains, considering the 2015-2020 Dietary Guidelines for Americans[11]. Yeunget al[52]concluded that further studies are required because it is unclear from the available studies the extent to which confounding factors, such as age, gender, physical activity, level of injury, time since SCI and comorbidities affect outcomes. The prevalence of polypharmacy is expected to increase with age and concurrent urological management must be considered in individuals with SCI.

A cross-sectional analysis[85]showed that over 1 out of 3 Veterans with SCI had CKD and in a 14-year retrospective cohort study[86], individuals with SCI and CKD had a significantly shorter survival time (10.13 movs10.97 mo), higher 1-year mortality (17.65%vs8.54%), and higher risk of mortality than those with SCI but without CKD (adjusted hazard ratio, 2.25). It has been reported that the overall prevalence of CKD was 8.0% and 22.4%, by serum creatinine-based and cystatin-Cbased estimated glomerular filtration rate, respectively, and was greater in individuals with neurogenic bladder (NB)[87]. However, serum creatinine was not able to detect the early deterioration of renal function in NB patients because they present muscle wasting due to disuse and/or denervation[87]. Comorbid diabetes, small bladder volume, recurrent urinary tract infection (UTI) and proteinuria were significantly associated with CKD in the multivariable analysis[87]. Key findings from the Committee of the “Joint SIU-ICUD Consultation on Urologic Management of the Spinal Cord Injured Patient” include: (1) Renal function deterioration can occur early but can also occur at later stages following SCI, and can be related to ageing,obstruction, stone disease (due to calcium mobilization from bones, reduced mobility and UTI, with urea-splitting organisms); (2) SCI patients have higher rates of prescribed medications from multiple high-risk classes (analgesic–narcotics,anticonvulsants, antidepressants and skeletal muscle relaxants); (3) Osteoporosis and complete sensory or motor injuries are associated with higher risk of fractures; and (4)Clinicians should screen SCI patients for malnutrition and obesity[88]. Patients with SCI most frequently used products to treat pain (68%), constipation (42%), muscle spasm(42%), hypertension (42%), and depression (37%). When including natural health products, vitamins and minerals, polypharmacy was present in 74% of patients with SCI[88]. In particular, NB can be observed in individuals with SCI treated with drugs metabolized by CYP3A4 (oxybutynin, solifenacin and darifenacin)[89]. Therefore,caution has been recommended when simultaneously consuming grapefruit juice during treatment with these drugs[89]. Other citrus fruit juices, cruciferous vegetables(broccoli, cabbage, and daikon radish sprouts), soy foods (soy milk, veggies slices,tofu, and roasted soy nuts), tea and cranberry and pomegranate juices can induce adverse food-drug interactions and should be avoided in individuals in treatment for comorbidity[70,90]. Individuals with SCI are at increased risk of developing symptomatic UTI[91]. The use of cranberries (particularly juice) is widely recommended to prevent and treat UTI[92], although evidence related to the prevention of UTI are inconsistent[93]. On the other hand, the European Food Safety Authority Panel on Food Additives and Nutrient Sources Added to Food, considered the possible association between the consumption of (-)-epigallocatechin-3-gallate (EGCG,the most relevant catechin in green tea) and hepatotoxicity[94]. Catechins from green tea infusion (prepared in a traditional way and reconstituted drinks with an equivalent composition to traditional green tea infusions: EGCG from 90 mg to 300 mg), are in general considered to be safe[94]. However, doses equal or above 800 mg EGCG/d have been shown to induce a significant increase of serum transaminases[94].Furthermore, human studies have reported that consumption of polyphenol-enriched oolong tea (750 mL for 10 d)[95]or a beverage containing black tea polyphenols (55 mg,3 times/d for 10 d)[96]increased faecal lipid excretion. Catechins are among the antinutrient antioxidants that can have pharmacological effects[97], including the inhibition of lipase[98]. The pharmacological inhibition of lipase was associated with the excretion of the inflammatory marker faecal calprotectin in healthy individuals[99].Spices to flavour dishes and other comfort food and beverages (sweet, cocoa, coffee,tea) should be limited and alcoholic drinks should be avoided by individuals with SCI[100], due to the potential interactions of phytochemicals and alcohol with drugs and/or the effect on bowel motility, water and energy balances.

Some foods and beverages, including alcohol, caffeine, tea, coffee, cola and chocolate, prunes, figs and sorbitol containing foods, can overstimulate bowel activity or draw excessive fluid into the colon resulting in very watery stools[36]. On the other hand, individuals with SCI and NBD often have an increase in CCT, resulting in excessive fluid reabsorption and the formation of hardened stools[50]. Therefore, the recommendations for fluid intake are 1/ml fluid per kcal of estimated energy needs plus 500 mL or 40 mL per kg BM plus 500 mL[50](Figure 1).

For all the above-mentioned reasons, we propose a Med-D-based and exercise pyramid for individuals with SCI (Figure 1). This should be integrated with the previous indications for veterans[70], the available recommendations/suggestions for individuals with SCI with or without NBD[14,36,50,63,69,73], CKD[71], chronic pain[72]and IBS(including low FODMAP)[18], and the exercise guidelines for adults with SCI[101], along with the position statement on exercise and SCI of Exercise and sports science Australia[102]. This approach is likely to be effective in improving muscle strength,flexibility and cardiorespiratory fitness, and to obtain cardiometabolic benefits.

DIETARY ADVICE FOR PARALYMPIC ATHLETES

Applying sports nutrition plans is essential for athletes with an impairment and represents an aid when sport and exercise are practiced[103]. This is important as a component for both therapy and rehabilitation[104]in particular for individuals with SCI[101,105,106]. Paralympic athletes exhibit higher quality of life and health status associated with their opportunities to practice physical activities and to participate in sport competitions[107], and these opportunities increased considerably in recent decades[104,108]. Their levels of performance and physical fitness are increased vs. nonathletes with SCI, and many Paralympic athletes are now engaged in intense training sessions that require highly demanding nutritional needs. For example, Gerrishet al[109]reported mean energy intakes of elite Canadian and American athletes with SCI,categorized by level of injury that were above the recommendations for sedentary individuals with SCI [22.7 kcal/(kg·d) in tetraplegia and 27.9 kcal/(kg·d) in paraplegia, see Figure 1][50]. These Authors, indeed, found the following energy intakes among athletes with SCI: 26 ± 7.9 kcal/(kg·d), 28 ± 14 kcal/(kg·d), 36 ± 14 kcal/(kg·d)and 36 ± 16 kcal/(kg·d) for athletes with levels cervical, from T1 to T6,from T7 to T12 and lumbar, respectively[109].

The first step in providing nutritional advice for both health purposes and sports performance is to estimate daily energy requirements, an estimate that is often difficult to assess in Paralympic athletes. Gramset al[110], in wheelchair basketball athletes, calculated energy expenditures using values provided by Collinset al[111],Abelet al[112]and Bernardiet al[113], and found a high variability in energy intake relative to BM [ranging from 25 kcal/(kg·d) to 64 kcal/(kg·d)].

Existing equations that estimate energy expenditure at rest are based on ablebodied populations and include variables that are difficult to measure accurately in athletes with SCI, such as height or total BM[64]. The approach of Collins and collaborators is preferred in this context[111]. The daily energy requirement should be estimated by measuring the energy expenditure in basal conditions[111]and during actual sport activities[113]and training[114]. Simulations of training and competitions should be assessed on the field[114]and physiological profile of athletes determined in the laboratory[115], testing athletes repetitively to evaluate the effects of training[116]. In order to have a complete energy expenditure assessment, all other activities performed during the day which cannot be actually measured should be taken into account converting the data using at least three-days of activity. Various questionnaires for energy expenditure can be used, including Ainsworth’s tables[117],or by using accelerometers, the Physical Activity Scale for Individuals with Physical Disabilities and the Veterans Administration Physical Activity Questionnaire modified for SCI[118].

Figure 1 Mediterranean diet based and exercise pyramid for individuals with spinal cord injury. Dietary advice from the previous indications for veterans[70],individuals with spinal cord injury with or without neurogenic bowel dysfunction[14,36,50,63,69,73], chronic kidney disease[71], chronic pain[72] and irritable bowel syndrome[18]. 1Limit/avoid: Potential undeliverable effects[11,36,79,94-96]; 2Exercise recommendations, derived from the integration of two recent papers[101,102] devoted to adults with spinal cord injury, are aimed to improve muscle strength, cardiorespiratory fitness, flexibility and cardiometabolic health. As a general rule, the exercise intensity should progress with time from moderate to vigorous at a rate (weeks-months) dependent from the initial level of fitness of the individual. However,personalized training is deliverable associated with sport-type-targeted nutritional recommendations (including timing and supplementation) for Paralympic athletes[64];3Personalized energy and nitrogen balance[50,64]: Ideal body mass 10%-15% and 5%-10% lower that for quadriplegia and paraplegia, respectively; Energy: 22.7 kcal/(kg·d) and 27.9 kcal/(kg·d) for quadriplegia and paraplegia, respectively and 30-40 kcal/(kg·d) in the presence of pressure ulcers; Proteins: Stage II pressure ulcers: 1.2-1.5 g/(kg·d), Stage III and IV pressure ulcers: 1.5-2.0 g/(kg·d); Paralympic athletes: 1.2-1.7 g/(kg·d); 4Low fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides,monosaccharides, and polyols: Banana, blueberry, strawberry, grape, melon, kiwi, cucumber, eggplant, green beans, lettuce, spinach, chives, pumpkin, tomato,zucchini. Cranberry juice may be associated with reduced urinary tract infection but could induce food-drug interactions, which can be observed also with other foods and beverages (conditional exclusion)[70,90]. BM: Body mass; w-3 PUFA: Omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids; CHO: Carbohydrates; FODMAP: Fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides, and polyols.

Paralympic athlete's diet must be appropriate for both the physical activity performed and the characteristics of the individual’s body composition, monitored over time. Assessment of body composition of athletes with impairments is therefore crucial to evaluate the general health status and monitor adaptation to diet and training[119,120], but in individuals with a great loss of metabolically active tissue and an asymmetric distribution of fat above and below the spinal lesion, this assessment may not be accurate[103]and can make it difficult to identify small to moderate changes in physique traits[65].

In athletes with SCI, as already pointed out in sedentary individuals with SCI, a reduction in resting energy expenditure, which depends on the level of the spinal lesion and the consequent loss of actively controllable musculature, is often observed[111]. Male and female athletes with SCI generally have lower energy requirements compared to able-bodied athletes. Despite lower energy needs,Paralympic athletes may still be consuming too few calories[65,121,122]. Aside from taking into account the previously mentioned issues and respecting an appropriate energy balance[114], in general dietary recommendations for athletes with impairments should not differ from those for able-bodied athletes[64].

Depending on the type of sport practiced,i.e., skill sports, power sports,intermittent (aerobic and anaerobic alternate metabolism) sports and endurance sports[123], because energy expenditure can vary widely[113], food intake and in particular energy requirements need to be tailored precisely to optimize performance.In particular, in endurance sports, such as Nordic sitting skiing, which requires a high energy expenditure, the competition strategy is similar, in spite of the long race duration (45-50 min) to that of an "all-out" exercise in which the highest speed is maintained from the start to the end[124]. Indeed, successful athletes need not only possess a high aerobic power but also a very high glycolytic capacity[125]. Diet and consequently GLU stores (glycogen) can become a major performance limiting factor of these competitive performances. An adequate CHO intake is essential to maintain training intensity, combat fatigue, protect immune function, sustain training adaptations and provide a key fuel for the brain and central nervous system[126-128].Although some Paralympic athletes (such as Nordic sitting skiers) had mean FM%ranging from 14.1 (best performers) to 15.1 (others), athletes competing in power and intermittent sports, had FM% (20.9 in Alpine sitting skiers and 20.9 in Para Ice Hockey players)[125]similar to those of non-athletic able-bodied men[129]. In male individuals with a normal BMI (18.5-24.9 kg/m2) and age between 20 and 79 years, Sheaet al[129]reported that both medium (FM = 15.3%-20.7%) and high (FM ≥ 20.8%) percentages of FM groups, had a significantly greater proportion of metabolically abnormal phenotypes (12.7% and 26.6% respectively), compared to individuals with low (FM ≤15.2%) percentage of FM, in whom this prevalence was equal to 6.2%. From that, a possible low total FFM can expose Paralympic athletes with SCI to a risk of both postexercise ketosis (due to low ketone bodies uptake by skeletal muscles)[66,67]and type 2 diabetes (due to reduction of muscle CHO storage)[14]. Therefore, in endurance and high energy expenditure intermittent sports, CHO in Paralympic athletes with SCI is an energy source more important than in able-bodied athletes. From the abovementioned reasons, CHO with low glycaemic index (i.e., Med-d cereals) should be preferred in the habitual diet. Adequate intake of sugars before and during exercise and sport should compensate for the low muscle glycogen stores (upper suggested range), whereas after exercise, GLU needs should be lower (lower suggested range)than able-bodied athletes. Before competition, boiled potatoes, which have a glycaemic index (78 ± 4) comparable to those of white bread (75 ± 2) and white rice boiled (73 ± 4) and higher than white spaghetti (49 ± 2)[130], could be a favourable GLU source. We therefore summarize the ACSM nutritional guidelines for able-bodied athletes[131]related to the CHO intake in table 1 that indicates the quantities (ranges)and timing of intake to provide high CHO availability for designated training or competition sessions according to athlete's BM and session characteristics. Unlike the Position statement of the International Society of Sports Nutrition regarding the timing of macronutrients in highly trained individuals, CHO re-feeding [1.2 g/(kg·h)]with a preference towards CHO sources that have a high (> 70) glycaemic index for rapid restoration of glycogen is required (＜ 4 h of recovery time)[132]must be evaluated on the light of possible co-morbidity in SCI[85,87,133].

Paralympic athletes’ dietary protein intake necessary to support metabolic adaptations, repair, remodelling, and for protein turnover, generally ranges from 1.2 g/(kg·d) to 1.7 g/(kg·d)[64](Table 1). In cases of energy restriction, sudden inactivity as occurs as a result of injury, or in athletes competing in weight lifting sports (where classes depends on BM range), elevated protein intakes typically range from 2.0 g/(kg·d) to 2.3 g/(kg·d)[64,126,131]for a limited period of time (2 wk), may be advantageous in preventing FFM loss[134,135]. Mettleret al[135], after a week of habitual diet (week 1, run-in) and a week of isocaloric diet with a macronutrient energy intake composition of 50% carbohydrate, 15% protein, and 35% fat (week 2), compared two energy-restricted diets: one with 15% protein [about 1 g/kg, control group (CP)] and one with 35% protein [about 2.3 g/kg, high-protein group (HP)] for 2 wk (weeks 3 and 4). Decreases in BM (-3.0 ± 0.4 kg and -1.5 ± 0.3 kg for the CP and HP,respectively) and lean BM (-1.6 ± 0.3 kg and -0.3 ± 0.3 kg) were larger in the CP compared to those in the HP and similar FM loss were observed[135]. However, urea was higher in the HP group (8.0 ± 0.4 mmol/L and 7.9 ± 0.5 mmol/L in week 3 and 4,respectively) compared to the CP group (5.3 ± 0.4 mmol/L and 5.4 ± 0.5 mmol/L in week 3 and 4, respectively)[135]. The authors concluded that because body composition data indicate that there was no protein accretion but still a slight loss of lean BM,some of the proteins must have been metabolized, causing increased urea values[135].Considering the risk of CKD typical among individuals with SCI[85,87], protein intakes over 2.0 g/(kg·d) should not be recommended in Paralympic athletes with SCI, even for limited period of time.

Timing is also important for proteins (Table 1). For example, co-ingestion of CHO with protein during the recovery period resulted in improved net protein balance post-exercise. Ingesting protein (approximately 20 g to 30 g total protein, orapproximately 10 g essential amino acids, especially from high biological value sources, like beef, fish, poultry, eggs, and dairy products[64]during exercise or the recovery period (post-exercise) led to increased whole body and muscle protein synthesis as well as improved nitrogen balance[136,137].

Table 1 Suggested intakes and timing of carbohydrate and protein for paralympics[64,131,132]

The IOS 2018[136,137]stated that protein supplements, usually low in CHO and providing 20-50 g protein per serving from high quality sources (whey, casein, milk,egg) or vegetables (e.g., soy), may contain other ingredients, some of which are not evidence-based and may increase the risk of contamination. For these reasons, protein supplements should be taken with caution.

All athletes with SCI should be encouraged to hydrate adequately (2-2.5 L/d unless other indications)[138]. Indeed, athletes with SCI are sensitive to hydration problems, in particular wheelchair-bound athletes tend to reduce their intake of liquids to avoid the complexity associated with toilet hygiene[139]. Moreover, thermoregulatory function may be impaired in Paralympic athletes and individuals with SCI[6,107,140]. In hot conditions poor thermoregulation due to impaired sweat rate can lead to overheating which can be treated by hand cooling, foot cooling, ice vests and spray bottles[102,141,142]. The fluid plan that suits most able-bodied athletes and athletic events consist of an intake of 0.4 L/h to 0.8 L/h[131], although this should be customized to the athlete’s tolerance, thermoregulatory function, and opportunities for drinking fluids.Monitoring changes in BM (before and after exercise) is an easy method to evaluate fluid needs[103,139]. Electrolyte replacement supplements (50-60 mM sodium, 10-20 mM potassium and low CHO 2-4 g/100 mL) can be used for rapid rehydration following large sodium losses during ultraendurance activities, and sport drinks (containing 5%-8% CHO, 10-35 mM sodium, 3-5 mM potassium) during exercise has been identified to be useful for post-exercise rehydration and CHO refuelling by the IOS 2018[136,137]. Although caffeine is among the few supplements (including buffering agents and nitrate) that have been shown to favourably affect performance[136,137],energy drinks containing caffeine should be avoided by athletes with SCI and NBD[36](Figure 1).

Nitrates are popular supplements for prolonged submaximal exercise and highintensity, intermittent, short-duration efforts. Increasing nitric oxide and enhances muscle blood flow, but potential risks for gastrointestinal upset in susceptible athletes have been suggested[136,137]. High nitrate-containing foods include leafy green and root vegetables, including spinach, rocket salad, celery, and beetroot[136,137]. It has been suggested that beetroot juice (among functional beverages) may improve performance[143,144]. However, the positive effects of beetroot juice seen in young individuals were not observed in older adults[145]. In a recent randomized (placebocontrolled) cross-over study in upper body trained able-bodied individuals and Paracyclists with SCI (lesion level between C4 and L4), Para-cyclists showed higher nitrate concentrations after beetroot juice, whereas no differences were found in performance in either group[146]. Although a meta-analysis reported nitrate-independent blood pressure lowering effects of beetroot juice[147]and we found only a case report of interaction with methotrexate[148], supplementation in patients with in CKD requires further studies[149]. Furthermore, caution with chronic use of beetroot juice to enhance sports performances has been suggested due to increases in carcinogenic N-nitroso compounds in urine after consumption[150].

In general, an analysis of a Paralympic athlete’s sweat loss and dietary intakes is recommended to evaluate fluids, carbohydrate, protein, iron, and vitamin D status to detect nutrient insufficiencies that greatly impact athletic performance[64]. Indeed,Paralympic athletes often fail to meet the recommended dietary allowances for vitamin D, vitamin E, pantothenic acid, magnesium, potassium, iron (females),calcium (females), vitamin A (males) and folate (males)[151]. Many Paralympic athletes are at higher risk of low bone density and osteoporosis; therefore, it is important to optimize all the nutrients and factors that support bone health. Calcium-rich foods such as dairy products, fish with soft bones, and calcium-fortified foods should be encouraged, as athletes with impairments are often found to consume insufficient calcium[64]. But since Paralympic athletes are also at high risk of being deficient in vitamin D due to the nature of their health conditions or inadequate micronutrient intakes, and vitamin D can impact morphology and functionality of human skeletal muscles, testing for vitamin D status is highly recommended. In addition, promotion of safe exposure to the sunlight and vitamin D–rich food sources, such as oily fish and eggs is recommended[64]. In addition, supplementation should be provided in cases of deficiency.

Commonly consumed supplements by Paralympic athletes are vitamin D, protein powder, sport bars, and sport drinks[151,152]. In a recent study, elite athletes with SCI improved handgrip strength after a supplementation protocol based on initial 25(OH)D concentrations, whereas no change in 20-m wheelchair sprint performance was observed[153]. Vitamin D is among the nutraceuticals with moderate evidence of efficacy for immune health in athletes, along with vitamin C and probiotics[136,137].However, according to the “IOC Consensus Statement: Dietary Supplements and the High-Performance Athlete” (IOC 2018) careful monitoring is necessary to avoid its toxicity[136,137].

The dietary recommendations, in addition to taking into account the requirements related to training and sport type, require careful consideration of the specific characteristics and physiopathology of the athlete to accommodate the unique issues of individual athletes regarding health status, nutrient needs, performance goals,physique characteristics (i.e., age, gender, stage of development, body composition),practical challenges, food preferences, and environmental conditions. Similar to ablebodied athletes there is no "one size fits all" approach. Nutrition plans need to be personalized to the individual athlete to take into account the nature of the health condition and the consequent impairment and its impact on functional capacity, the use of medications, and any coexisting medical conditions and responses to various strategies. Special nutrition recommendations are needed since athletes with impairments and in particular those with SCI are at major risk of medical complications, including low bone density and osteoporosis, epithelial wound and pressure ulcers, urolithiasis and UTI, and chronic constipation.

DISCUSSION

Bowel function, as codified by the International Classification of Functioning,Disability and Health is frequently compromised after SCI. Among International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health ICF domains, the greatest impact of NBD is on personal and environmental factors, with 45.3% reporting need of assistance, 45.3% in emotional health and 46.9% in loss of privacy[154].

Relationships among inflammation, fatigue pain and behaviour aspects have been discussed[155]. Although a 3-mo anti-inflammatory diet with increased intake of vitamins A, C, and E, and ω-3 PUFA and reductions in trans fatty acids, caffeine and sodium, reduced chronic inflammation in individuals with SCI[73], barriers to adhering to this diet have been reported[156]. Among the reasons for low compliance are the reported increase in NBD Score after high fibre intake[51,52]. On the other hand, exercise training, reducing constipation and restoring eubiosis, can improve quality of life in individuals with SCI and NBD. Moreover, exercise improved semen quality[106]and upper limb aerobic training increased aerobic fitness[116]and reduced inflammatory cytokines[8]and oxidative stress[105]. Different sport activities have different effects on physical fitness components[113,125]. In the “Veterans Exercise Testing Study”, Myerset al[157]demonstrated that fitness is inversely related to overall health care costs among veterans.

Paralympic athletes, like individuals with SCI, had low diet quality, in terms of fruits, vegetables, legumes and cereals and there is a need for nutrition education for this population[158]. Due to a reported low nutritional knowledge[159], personalized nutrition and education related to different macro and micronutrients requirements compared to able-bodied athletes is recommended. Furthermore, mixed (outdoors and indoors) training programs[160]could improve vitamin D status[161]. Concerning sport-related muscle pain[162], we included in our Med-D-based and exercise pyramid(Figure 1) the suggestions from the Med-D for individuals with chronic pain[72].

CONCLUSION

The present review suggests dietary advice for individuals with SCI and NBD and underscores that multidisciplinary risk reduction programs, including dietary advice[114]and exercise[118], are recommended, as depicted in the Med-D-based and exercise pyramid for individuals with SCI (Figure 1). Finally, we agree with the recently suggested systematic control needed to re-adapt nutritional programs for wheelchair athletes[163].