碳纳米管负载的Pd-Ag-Sn催化剂对甲酸的电氧化

张媛媛 易清风＊,,2 李 广 周秀林

（1湖南科技大学化学化工学院，湘潭 411201）

（2理论有机化学与功能分子教育部重点实验室，湘潭 411201）

0 Introduction

Nowadays,considerable attention to seeking renewable resources has been paid to reduce or even stop the rapid consumption of fossil fuels and the increasing emissions of automobile exhaust[1-3].As environmental friendly electrochemical energy devices,fuel cells have received extensive attention in view of their outstanding performances.Among them,direct formic acid fuel cell （DFAFC）possesses such significant advantages as lower operating temperatures,higher theoretical open circuit voltage and energy density,safer storage and transportation and less crossover rate of formic acid through Nafion membrane compared with direct methanol fuel cell （DMFC）[4-11].There are many factors affecting the performance of DFAFC,one of which is the electroactivity of the anode catalyst.A great number of reports have demonstrated that Pt and Pt-based catalysts exhibit excellent catalytic activity for formic acid oxidation in alkaline and acidic circumstances,including Pt/C[12]and Pt-M（M=Au,Li,Sb,Ru,Ir,Bi）[13-20]and so on.Nevertheless,extremely low natural reserve and the exorbitant cost of Pt severely limit the large-scale commercial applications of Pt or Pt-based catalysts in DFAFC[21-22].A large numbers of studies have shown that pure Pd or Pdbased catalysts are found to be more promising alternative anode electrocatalysts for DFAFC owing to lower price and greater abundance of the metal Pd on the earth′s crust compared with metal Pt[23-27].Li et al.[28]synthesized phosphorus doped carbon supported Pd catalyst （Pd/P-C）by liquid reduction method,which exhibits the better electrocatalyst activity （0.8 A·mg-1）and stability for formic acid oxidation in acid medium.It is generally accepted that formic acid oxidation on Pd catalyst takes place primarily through a direct pathway,leading to the direct formation of CO2.However,there is still a small amount of formic acid being oxidized by an indirect pathway,resulting in the gradual accumulation of intermediates on the surface of the catalyst during the process of formic acid oxidation.These intermediates will make the catalyst got poisoning and lead to the decline in catalyst activity and long-term stability[29-31].Inspired by this,an effective strategy has been implemented by alloying of other transition metals with Pd to enhance both the electrocatalytic activity and long-term stability of the Pd catalyst such as bimetallic Pd-Pt[32],Pd-Ag[33],Pd-Sn[34-35],Pd-Ni[36],Pd-Au[37],trimetallic Pd-Ni-Cu[29],Pd-Ni-Ag[38]and Pd-Pt-Ni[39].Typically,Lu et al.[40]have successfully synthesized nanoneedle-covered Pd-Ag nanotubes through a galvanic displacement reaction with Ag nanorods at 100 ℃ （PdAg-100）and room temperature （PdAg-25）and obtained higher catalytic activity and stability than bulk Pd.Liu and coworkers[41]have reported Pd-Sn nanoparticles supported on Vulcan XC-72 carbon by a microwave-assisted polyol process,and results indicate that Pd2Sn1/C and Pd1Sn1/C catalysts exhibit higher current density for formic acid oxidation compared with the prepared Pd/C catalyst.Carbon supported ternary PdNiCu catalyst was prepared by Hu et al.[29]and exhibit an increased electroactivity for formic acid oxidation compared to that of binary Pd-Ni and Pd-Cu catalysts.Multi-walled carbon nanotube （CNT）supported Pd1Cu1Sn1ternarymetallic nanocatalyst was also studied by Zhu et al.[42]through chemical reduction with NaBH4as a reducing agent and it reveals a higher mass activity of 534.83 mA·mg-1Pdtowards formic acid oxidation compared with bimetallic PdCu/CNTs and PdSn/CNTs.These studies have revealed that Pd-based bimetallic and ternary-metallic catalysts show a superior electrochemicalactivity and stability for formic acid oxidation compared with pure Pd catalyst in virtue of synergistic effect between metals,electronic or surface effects[22,43].However,ternary-metallic catalysts are more effective than the corresponding bimetallic catalysts in tuning the electronic properties and composition of catalytic surfaces.Furthermore,ternary Pd-based catalysts are able to further improve Pd usage efficiency and enhance their electrocatalytic performances.Consequently,it is necessary to develop novel ternary Pd-based catalysts with less cost and higher performance for formic acid oxidation.In addition,the choice of suitable support for Pd-based catalyst is also significant to reduce the Pd loading and improve the dispersion of catalyst nanoparticles,such as carbon black,graphene,carbon nanotubes,conductive polymers and so on.Recently,carbon nanotubes （CNTs）as a potential carbon carrier have been reported by many researchers for Pd-based catalysts[42,44-46].As a support,CNTs possess unique structure and properties like high specific surface area,outstanding electronic conductivity and high chemical stability,which would be conducive to the dispersion and stability of Pdbased catalyst particles and further enhance their electroactivity[44,47].Therefore,carbon nanotubes are a prominent support in the development of electrocatalysts.

In this study,carbon nanotubes supported Pd and Pd-based binary/ternary catalysts（Pd/CNT,PdAg/CNT,PdSn/CNT,PdAgSn/CNT）weresuccessfully synthesized by the NaBH4reduction method.The electrochemical activities of the prepared catalysts towards formic acid oxidation in both acidic and alkaline media were evaluated by cyclic voltammetry（CV）and chronoamperometry （CA）techniques.The results demonstrate that ternary Pd-Ag-Sn catalysts exhibit much higherelectrochemicalactivityand stability towards formic acid oxidation in both acid and alkaline media.

1 Experimental conditions

1.1 Chemicals

Palladium chloride,stan nouschloride,silver nitrate,sodium borohydride,ethylene-glycol,formic acid,sodium hydroxide and sulfuric acid were analytical purity grade and used as received without further purification.Water was deionized water subjected to the double distillation.Before used,multi-walled carbon nanotubes （CNTs,＞90% （w/w）,outside diameter:10～20 nm,length:5～20 μm ）were added to a mixture of concentrated H2SO4and concentrated HNO3（the volume ratio was 3 ∶1）,and heated at 60 ℃ under stirring for 8 h to obtain the acidified CNTs.

1.2 Catalyst synthesis

Catalystswere synthesized according to our recent report[48].Typically,the ternary Pd7Ag1Sn2/CNT catalyst was prepared via the following steps:A metal precursor composed of 8.9 mg PdCl2,1.2 mg AgNO3and 3.2 mg SnCl2was added to the mixing solvent of 12 mL ethylene glycol and 4 mL water.Then the solid salts were fully dispersed for 30 min with ultrasonication to make them be completely dissolved.Then,30 mg of the acidified carbon nanotubes was added to the resulting solution and the mixture was further treated with ultra-sonication to obtain a uniform black ink.3 mL of 50 g·L-1NaBH4dissolved in ethylene glycol was added dropwise to it under stirring to reduce the metal ions,and the mixture was stirred for 5 h.Finally,the resulting suspension was filtered,washed with water and dried at 40℃in vacuum for 10 h to obtain the Pd7Ag1Sn2/CNT catalyst.Other catalysts （Pd/CNT,Pd7Ag3/CNT,Pd7Sn2/CNT,Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT and Pd7Ag3Sn2/CNT）were prepared according to this procedure by adjusting the metal molar ratio in the metal precursors.For synthesis of Pd/CNT catalyst,the precursor was composed of 8.9 mg PdCl2.For Pd7Ag3/CNT catalyst,the precursor was composed of 8.9 mg PdCl2and 3.6 mg AgNO3.For Pd7Sn2/CNT catalyst,the precursor was composed of 8.9 mg PdCl2and 3.2 mg SnCl2.For Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst,the precursor was composed of 8.9 mg PdCl2,2.4 mg AgNO3and 3.2 mg SnCl2.For Pd7Ag3Sn2/CNT catalyst,the precursor was composed of 8.9 mg PdCl2,3.6 mg AgNO3and 3.2 mg SnCl2.

1.3 Characterization

In order to further explore the microstructure and particle size distribution of the prepared catalysts,transmission election microscopic （TEM）images were recorded with a JEM-2100F.The X-ray diffraction（XRD）profiles of the prepared catalysts were collected to analyze the compositions of the samples in a D/MAX2500X diffractometer （Japan）operating with Cu Kα radiation generated at 40 kV and 250 mA （λ=0.154 18 nm）and 2θ=20°～90°.The elemental compositions and valence states of the samples were investigated by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy （XPS）operated with an ESCALAB 250Xi spectrometer（VG Scientific Ltd.,England）.Inductively coupled plasma（ICP-AES-7510,Shimadzu）data of the nanoparticles were acquired to determine the Pd loading relative to the total mass of the catalyst.XRD profiles,XPS and ICP of the prepared catalysts were also investigated in our recent work[48].

1.4 Electrochemical measurements

All electrochemical measurements of the prepared catalysts for formic acid oxidation in both acid and alkaline media were conducted in a conventional three-electrode system using an AutoLab PGSTAT30/FRA electrochemical workstation（Eco Chimie,The Netherlands）.The counter electrode was a Pt sheet.A Ag/AgCl in saturated KCl solution was used as the reference electrode,and all potentials reported in this work were quoted versus the Ag/AgCl reference.The working electrode was a glassy carbon （GC）coated with a film of catalyst,which was fabricated as follows:the glassy carbon（GC,3 mm diameter,from LanLiKe,TianJing,China）was firstly polished with a 0.3 μm alumina suspension to give a mirror surface.Then,5 mg oftheas-synthesized catalystwasdispersed ultrasonically in the mixed solution containing 0.94 mL of ethanol and 60 μL of 5% （w/w）Nafion solution to obtain a homogeneous ink.Finally,15 μL of this ink was dropped onto the top surface of the polished GC disc by a micropipette and dried at room temperature to get the working electrode.The blank CVs of the electrocatalysts were recorded in both 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4solution and 1.0 mol·L-1NaOH solution,and the corresponding electrocatalytic activities towards formic acid oxidation were investigated both in the solution of 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4in the presence of HCOOH and in 1.0 mol·L-1NaOH containing HCOOH.For the sake of comparison,electroactivity of the commercial Pd/C for formic acid oxidation was also examined under the same conditions.All measurements were performed at room temperature （22±2）℃）.

2 Results and discussion

2.1 Physical characterization

Fig.1 TEM images and the corresponding size distributions of the Pd/CNT （a）,Pd7Ag3/CNT （b）,Pd7Sn2/CNT （c）and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT （d）samples

Fig.1（a～d）show the TEM images of the prepared Pd/CNT,Pd7Ag3/CNT,Pd7Sn2/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysts as the typical samples.The corresponding inset is the particle size distribution histogram of the catalyst sample.It is evident from the images that the metallic nanoparticles have been successfully decorated on the surface of multi-walled CNTs for all prepared catalysts.In addition,Pd/CNT,Pd7Ag3/CNT and Pd7Sn2/CNT catalysts exhibit obvious agglomeration between the nanoparticles and some particles are even stacked together to form clumps as shown in Fig.1（a～c）,and their average particle sizes （Daverage）are 3.6,4.7 and 3.7 nm,respectively.For the ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst,however,most of the nanoparticles are well uniformly dispersed on the surface of CNTs except for a small amount of agglomeration as indicated in Fig.1d.Furthermore,the ternary Pd-Ag-Sn catalyst exhibits a smaller average particle size of 2.3 nm compared to Pd/CNT and binary Pd-Ag（or Pd-Sn）catalysts.Results indicate that an appropriate amount of Ag and Sn additives can effectively improve the dispersion of the Pd nanoparticles in the ternary Pd-Ag-Sn catalysts.

XRD patterns and XPS data of the prepared catalysts were recorded as indicated in Fig.2.Fig.2a shows that the peaks at 40.1°,46.6°,68.1°and 82.1°are attributed to characteristic diffraction peaks of face-centered cubic （fcc）crystalline Pd for Pd/CNT catalyst.However,a slight negative shift is observed with regard to the angle position of the Pd diffraction peaks on the Pd7Ag3/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysts compared to the Pd/CNT catalyst,while the Pd7Sn2/CNT catalyst does not show such a shift.This reveals that the alloy formation between Pd and Ag arises in the binary Pd7Ag3/CNT and ternary Pd-Ag-Sn catalysts.As is shown in Fig.2b,the binding energies at 335.7 and 340.4 eV are ascribed to Pd3d3/2and Pd3d5/2spin orbit states of zero-valent Pd[49].But the other two distinct peaks located at 337.3 and 342.7 eV are related to Pd3d3/2and Pd3d5/2peaks of Pdギ,which is indexed to the Pd oxide.These results indicate that the prepared Pd-based catalysts contain the metal Pd and Pd oxide.Fig.3b shows the XPS spectra of 3d for Pd7Ag3/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysts,and the two obvious peaks centered at 367.9 and 373.9 eV are related to Ag3d5/2and Ag3d3/2respectively[50],revealing that Ag ions are reduced completely during the preparation of the catalysts.Similarly,as indicated in Fig.3c,Sn3d XPS spectra are divided into two peaks located at 486.8 and 487.4 eV,which are associated with Sn and SnO2[51],confirming that the metal Sn in the Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT and Pd7Sn2/CNT catalysts exists in the form of Sn and SnO2.

Fig.2 XRD （a）and XPS （b～d）spectra of the Pd/CNT,Pd7Ag3/CNT,Pd7Sn2/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT samples:（b）Pd3d,（c）Ag3d,and （d）Sn3d

2.2 Electrochemical performance analysis

Fig.3a shows CV curves of the prepared catalysts and Pd/C in 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4solution.All catalysts reveal a similar CV curve to Pd/C in acidic solution.A well-defined hydrogen adsorption/desorption peaks around 0 V arises on all samples,and the cathode characteristic reduction peak （rp）of the Pd oxides produced during the forward potential scan is vividly observed at ca.0.48 V for all the catalysts.Also,the rppeak current density on the Pd/C,Pd/CNT,Pd7Ag3/CNT,Pd7Sn2/CNT,Pd7Ag1Sn2/CNT,Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT,Pd7Ag3Sn2/CNT catalysts is 6.6,6.9,10.4,8.6,11.5,15.2 and 12.2 mA·cm-2,respectively.Fig.3b shows cyclic CV curves of the prepared catalysts and Pd/C in 1.0 mol·L-1NaOH solution.Similarly,the cathode reduction peak （rn）at ca.-0.41 V is attributed to the formation of Pd oxides during the forward-going,and the rnpeak current density is 14.3,17.0,20.5,24.6,20.2,31.4 and 24.0 mA·cm-2for Pd/C,Pd/CNT,Pd7Ag3/CNT,Pd7Sn2/CNT,Pd7Ag1Sn2/CNT,Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT Pd7Ag3Sn2/CNT catalysts,respectively.Based on the charge of PdO reduction peak in each CV,the electrochemical active surface area （ECSA）of Pd for the samples can be calculated by using the methods reported in the literature and corresponding results are listed in Table 1[42,52-53].Results reveal that Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst possesses the largest ECSA value of 9.56 m2·g-1in H2SO4solution and 15.34 m2·g-1in NaOH solution among the prepared catalysts and Pd/C,which is consistent with the results observed from TEM images.

Fig.3 CV curves of the samples in 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4 （a）and in 1.0 mol·L-1NaOH （b）at a scan rate of 50 mV·s-1

Table 1 ECSA values of Pd/C and the prepared samples in both 1 mol·L-1NaOH and 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4solution

Fig.4 CV curves of the samples in 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4containing 0.5 mol·L-1HCOOH （a）and in 1.0 mol·L-1NaOH containing 0.5 mol·L-1HCOOH （b）at a scan rate of 50 mV·s-1

Electrocatalytic activity of the prepared catalysts for formic acid oxidation was measured in 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4solution containing 0.5 mol·L-1formic acid by CV as indicated in Fig.4a.A characteristic anodic peaks jf1caused by formic acid oxidation is observed for all catalysts.In general,all the as-synthesized Pdbased catalysts exhibit better electrocatalytic activity for formic acid oxidation than Pd/C.Further,the ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst shows the largest jf1peak current density of 108.8 mA·cm-2,which is 6.7 times higher than the Pd/C catalyst.Also,the jf1peak current density on the binary Pd7Ag3/CNT and Pd7Sn2/CNT catalysts is 2.7 and 2.3 times larger than that of Pd/C catalyst respectively.This may be contributed to the synergistic effect between Pd and Ag/Sn[2,26].Furthermore,ternary Pd7Ag1Sn2/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysts display an onset potential （OP）of ca.-0.06 V for formic acid oxidation in acidic media,which presents a negative shift compared to that of ca.-0.045 V on the other catalysts.Fig.4b shows the CV curves of all samples in 1.0 mol·L-1NaOH solution containing 0.5 mol·L-1formic acid.Compared to formic acid oxidation in acidic solution （Fig.4a）,the formic acid oxidation in alkaline solution （Fig.4b）presents a much negative onset potential of ca.-0.82 V.Fig.4b also shows that during the forward-going scan,formic acid oxidation current density displays an almost linear increment with the positive shift of the anodic potential until an anodic peak jf2at ca.0.2 V arises.The anodic current density for formic acid oxidation in alkaline medium follows the order:Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT＞Pd7Ag1Sn2/CNT＞Pd7Ag3/CNT＞Pd7Ag3Sn2/CNT＞Pd/CNT ＞Pd7Sn2/CNT ＞Pd/C.Obviously,the ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst presents the best electrocatalytic activity for formic acid oxidation in alkaline medium among the prepared catalysts.

It is generally considered that there are two possible parallel pathways for the oxidation of formic acid[42,44]:（i）a “direct pathway”in which formic acid is directly oxidized to CO2without production of any intermediate and （ii）an “indirect pathway” which involves two steps including the dehydrogenation of formic acid and the adsorption of CO intermediate on the Pd catalyst surface.The choice of the pathway greatly depends on the properties of the catalyst used.Normally,the direct pathway prevails for formic acid oxidation on Pd-containing catalysts[54-55].The processes of formic acid oxidation in acidic solution are based on the following equations （1）～（3）[44]:

During formic acid oxidation,the adsorbed HCOOad（HCOO-Pd）species are firstly formed via the adsorption of formic acid molecules on the surface of Pd-based catalysts and subsequent break of O-H bond in the adsorbed HCOOH （HCOOHad）（Equation （1）.Then,decomposition of the HCOOadspecies produces CO2by breaking C-H bond （equation （2）.In alkaline media,electro-oxidation of formic acid on Pd-based catalysts follows a similar mechanism to that in acidic media except that the adsorbed HCOOadspecies on Pd can be formed easier because of the neutralization reaction between HCOOH and NaOH,leading to the much negative onset potential of formic acid oxidation.In general,the addition of others metal or metal oxide to Pd catalyst can significantly improve its electroactivity due to the synergistic effect of different metals.It is noticed from Fig.4 that the Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst displays the highest current density of formic acid oxidation in both acidic and alkaline media among the prepared catalysts,reflecting that the addition of proper amount of Ag or Sn isconducivetoenhancetheelectrochemical activity.It is known from the XRD data of the prepared catalysts that the alloying between Pd and Ag arises.Based on the so-called bifunctional mechanism therefore,the adsorption bond of intermediates like absorbed CO （COad）and COOH （COOHad）at the surface of catalysts,produced by formic oxidation during the forward scan,can be efficaciously weakened by the Pd-Ag bimetallic alloy.This makes the decomposition of formic acid to CO2go into easier.Furthermore,the presence of Pd-Ag alloy can also prominently reduce the accumulation of poisoningintermediates on the catalyst surface and release more Pd active sites.The presence of SnO2observed from the XPS data may also contribute to the removal of toxic intermediates to accelerate the adsorption and desorption of formic acid on the catalyst surface.

Effect of formic acid concentration on the kinetic characterization of formic acid oxidation was further investigated.Fig.5a shows the CV curves of ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst in 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4solution with different formic acid concentrations at 50 mV·s-1,and Fig.5b depictstherelationship between the anodic peak current density and HCOOH concentration.As can be seen from Fig.5b,the jp1peak current density exhibits a rapid rise with the formic acid concentration in the range of 0.5 to 1.8 mol·L-1,while it displays a decrease from 1.8 to 2.5 mol·L-1.In addition,the jp1peak potential shifts to more positive direction at the higher concentration of formic acid.In 1 mol·L-1NaOH solution,dependence of the jp2peak current density upon HCOOH concentration is also studied as indicated in Fig.6（a,b）.A similar changing trend of the jp1peak current density vs HCOOH concentration to Fig.5b is observed,revealing that the HCOOH concentration hasthe same effecton electroactivity of the ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst in both acidic and alkaline media.At high concentrations of HCOOH,the jp1peak current density for the oxidation of formic acid on the Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalystdecreases.Thismay be related to the saturated adsorption of HCOOH on Pd active sites at high concentrations of HCOOH.On the other hand,high concentrations of HCCOH may result in partial decomposition of HCOOH to produce CO（equation（4）,which is absorbed on the surface of the catalyst and reduce the electroactivity of the catalyst.

Fig.5 （a）CV curves of ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst in 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4solution with different formic acid concentrations at 50 mV·s-1;（b）Relationship between the anodic peak current density and HCOOH concentration （CHCOOH）for ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst

Fig.6 （a）CV curves of ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst in 1.0 mol·L-1NaOHsolution with different formic acid concentrations at 50 mV·s-1;（b）Relationship between the anodic peak current density and HCOOH concentration for ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst

Fig.7（a,b）displays the CV curves for the oxidation of pre-adsorbed carbon monoxide （CO）on Pd/C,Pd/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysts in order to investigate the anti-poisoning intermediates ability of the catalysts.It is shown from Fig.7a recorded in 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4solution that an intense stripping peak of COadis observed on the catalysts.The peak potential of CO stripping on Pd/C,Pd/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysts is 0.792,0.726 and 0.722 V,respectively,reflecting that the prepared catalysts in this work have more negative CO stripping peak potential values than that of the Pd/C catalyst.The lower potential displays the weaker binding energy between Pd and COadon Pd/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysts.Notably,the onset potential of CO oxidation for Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst is measured at 0.67 V,showing a negative shift compared to that for Pd/C（0.72 V）and Pd/CNT （0.70 V）.Results indicate that the COadon the surface of the Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst can be more easily removed.Furthermore,the CO stripping isalso tested forPd/C,Pd/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysts in mol·L-1NaOH solution as indicated in Fig.7b.It is worth noting that the Pd/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysts also exhibit a more negative CO stripping peak potential at ca.-0.19 V compared to Pd/C catalyst（ca.-0.139 V）.These results show that the ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst possesses much better resistance to COadpoisoning than the Pd/C and Pd/CNT catalysts.

The long-term electrocatalytic activity of the Pd/C,Pd/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysts is evaluated by CA measurement in 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4solution containing 0.5 mol·L-1HCOOH at different potentials as depicted in Fig.8.The current density of the studied catalysts exhibits a continuous decay in the initial stage at both 0.05 （Fig.8a）and 0.1 V （Fig.8b）.This may be attributed to the adsorption of CO-like intermediates on the surface of the catalysts,leading to the decline on the number of the active sites[22,56].However,the Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalystexhibits a significantly slower decay rate of current density than the Pd/C and Pd/CNT catalysts.Additionally,at the end of electrolysis （at 3 600 s）,the current density on the ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst is 5.8 mA·cm-2at 0.05 V or 14.2 mA·cm-2at 0.1 V,which is still the highest among the studied catalysts.Fig.9 also shows CA curves of the Pd/C,Pd/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysts in 1 mol·L-1NaOH solution containing 0.5 mol·L-1HCOOH at the potentials of-0.75 and-0.45 V.Apparently,the current density of ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst is 13.7 mA·cm-2at-0.75 V after 3 600 s as shown in Fig.9a,which is almost 3.3 and 7.2 times larger than that of the Pd/C （4.2 mA·cm-2）and Pd/CNT （1.9 mA·cm-2）catalysts,respectively.In addition,it can be also observed from Fig.9b that ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysthas the highest current density among the studied catalysts at the potential of-0.45 V after 3 600 s.The above results demonstrate that the as-synthesized ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst displays excellent electrocatalytic activity and more outstanding durability towards formic acid oxidation in both acidic and alkaline media,which is consistent with the results derived from CV analyses.

Fig.7 CO stripping curves of the Pd/C,Pd/CNT and Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalysts in 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4 （a）and 1.0 mol·L-1NaOH （b）at a scan rate of 50 mV·s-1

Fig.8 Chronoamperometric responses of the Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst in 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4comtaining 0.5 mol·L-1HCOOH at 0.05 V （a）and 0.1 V （b）

Fig.9 Chronoamperometric responses of the Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst in 1.0 mol·L-1NaOH comtaining 0.5 mol·L-1HCOOH at-0.75 V （a）and-0.45 V （b）

Fig.10 shows the CV profiles of the prepared catalysts where the current density is based on the mass of Pd to show the Pd usage efficiency for formic acid oxidation.It can be found from Fig.10a that during the forward-going scan the anodic peak mass current density of the Pd/C,Pd/CNT,Pd7Ag3/CNT,Pd7Sn2/CNT, Pd7Ag1Sn2/CNT, Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT and Pd7Ag3Sn2/CNT catalysts towards formic acid oxidation in 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4solution containing 0.5 mol·L-1HCOOH is 153,274,474,431,1 030,1 364 and 767 mA·respectively,which indicates that the ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst has the highest Pd mass current density among the prepared catalysts.Zhu et al.[42]prepared the ternary PdCuSn/CNTs catalyst with the mass current density of 534.8 mA·Binary PdCo/CFC catalyst was also synthesized with the mass current density of 1 220 mA·by Vafaei and co-workers[57].Compared with the reported catalysts,the ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst prepared in this work exhibits excellent electrocatalytic activity and higherPd usageefficiencyforformicacid oxidation.Additionally,the ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst also displays the highest Pd mass current density in 1 mol·L-1NaOH solution containing 0.5 mol·L-1HCOOH as indicated in Fig.10b,which is as high as 2 640 mA·mg-1Pd.These results reveal that the ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst can be applied to DFAFCs as a promising anodic catalyst for formic acid oxidation in both acidic and alkaline media due to the synergetic effect between Pd and Ag/Sn.

Fig.10 CV curves based on the Pd mass current density in 0.5 mol·L-1H2SO4containing 0.5 mol·L-1HCOOH （a）and in 1.0 mol·L-1NaOH containing 0.5 mol·L-1HCOOH （b）based on Fig.4

3 Conclusions

In summary,carbon nanotube-supported Pdbased catalysts including Pd/CNT,binary Pd-Ag/CNT and ternary Pd-Ag-Sn/CNT were synthesized by the conventional NaBH4reduction method.The metal nanoparticles of ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst are uniformly dispersed on the surface of the carbon nanotubes with an average size of about 2.3 nm.Among the catalysts investigated,the ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst has the best catalytic performance and stability towards formic acid oxidation in both acidic and alkaline media.These outstanding features may be ascribed to the formation of Pd-Ag alloy and the presence of SnO2,which are conducive to the reducing of the accumulation of poisoning-intermediates and the releasing of the active sites of Pd during the formic acid electro-oxidation.Meanwhile,the ternary Pd7Ag2Sn2/CNT catalyst exhibits the highest Pd mass current density of 1 364 mA·mg-1in H2SO4solution or 2 640 mA·mg-1in NaOH solution,showing the ultra high usage efficiency of Pd in the prepared Pdbased catalysts towards formic acid oxidation.Results imply that the ternary Pd-Ag-Sn catalyst may be a very promising anodic electrocatalyst for direct formic acid fuel cells.

Acknowledgement:Financial support by the National Natural Science Foundation of China （Grant No.21376070）is gratefully acknowledged.

:

[1]Lu X Y,Zheng L,Zhang M S,et al.Electrochim.Acta,2017,238:194-201

[2]Xu H,Yan B,Zhang K,et al.Appl.Surf.Sci.,2017,416:191-199

[3]Budischak C,Sewell D,Thomson H,et al.J.Power Sources,2013,225（3）:60-74

[4]Miao K H,LuoY,Zou J S,et al.Electrochim.Acta,2017,251:588-594

[5]El-Nagar G A,Dawood K M,El-Deab M S,et al.Appl.Catal.,B,2017,213:118-126

[6]Yi Q F,Zou T,Zhang Y Y,et al.J.Power Sources,2016,321:219-225

[7]Yu X W,Pickup P G.J.Power Sources,2008,182（1）:124-132

[8]Rhee Y W,Ha S Y,Masel R I.J.Power Sources,2003,117（1/2）:35-38

[9]ZOU Tao（邹涛）,YI Qing-Feng（易清风）,ZHANG Yuan-Yuan（张媛媛）,et al.Chem.J.Chinese Universities（高等学校化学学报）,2017,38（1）:101-107

[10]Winjobi O,Zhang Z Y,Liang C H,et al.Electrochim.Acta,2010,55（13）:4217-4221

[11]Yi Q F,Zhang J J,Chen A C,et al.J.Appl.Electrochem.,2008,38（5）:695-701

[12]Zhu C X,Liu D,Chen Z,et al.J.Colloid Interface Sci.,2018,511:77-83

[13]Cabello G,Davoglio R A,Hartl F W,et al.Electrochim.Acta,2017,224:56-63

[14]Han Y,Ouyang Y J,Xie Z H,et al.J.Mater.Sci.Technol.,2016,32（7）:639-645

[15]Awaludin Z,Okajima T,Ohsaka T.Electrochem.Commun.,2013,31:100-103

[16]Yang H Z,Dai L,Xu D,et al.Electrochim.Acta,2010,55（27）:8000-8004

[17]Yi Q F,Chen A C,Huang W,et al.Electrochem.Commun.,2007,9（7）:1513-1518

[18]Choi J H,Jeong K J,Dong Y J,et al.J.Power Sources,2006,163（1）:71-75

[19]Yi Q F,Li L,Yu W Q,et al.J.Alloys Compd.,2008,466（1/2）:52-58

[20]ZHANG Li-Juan（张丽娟）,XIA Ding-Guo（夏定国）.Chinese J.Inorg.Chem.（无机化学学报）,2006,22（6）:1085-1089

[21]Li R X,Ma Z Z,Zhang F,et al.Electrochim.Acta,2016,220:193-204

[22]Xu H,Zhang K,Yan B,et al.J.Power Sources,2017,356:27-35

[23]Xin Z L,Wang S H,Wang J,et al.Electrochem.Commun.,2016,67:26-30

[24]Wang Y R,He Q L,Wei H G,et al.Electrochim.Acta,2015,184:452-465

[25]Krishna R,Fernandes D M,Marinoiu A,et al.Int.J.Hydrogen Energy,2017,42（37）:23639-23646

[26]CHEN Ying（陈滢）,TANG Ya-Wen（唐亚文）,GAO Ying（高颖）,et al.Chinese J.Inorg.Chem.（无机化学学报）,2008,24（4）:560-564

[27]SHEN Juan-Zhang （沈 娟章）,TANG Ya-Wen （唐 亚文）,LU Tian-Hong （陆 天虹）.Chinese J.Inorg.Chem.（无 机化 学 学报）,2012,28（2）:326-330

[28]Li J D,Tian Q F,Jiang S Y,et al.Electrochim.Acta,2016,213:21-30

[29]Hu S Z,Munoz F,Noborikawa J,et al.Appl.Catal.,B,2016,180:758-765

[30]Jiang K,Zhang H X,Zou S Z,et al.Phys.Chem.Chem.Phys.,2014,16（38）:20360-20376

[31]Haan J L,Stafford K M,Masel R I.J.Phys.Chem.C,2010,114（26）:11665-11672

[32]Yi Q F,Huang W,Liu X P,et al.J.Electroanal.Chem.,2008,619（1）:197-205

[33]Liu D,Xie M L,Wang C M,et al.Nano Res.,2016,9（6）:1590-1599

[34]Tu D D,Wu B,Wang B X,et al.Appl.Catal.,B,2011,103（1/2）:163-168

[35]Yi Q F,Chen Q H,Yang Z.J.Power Sources,2015,298:171-176

[36]Zhang Y Y,Yi Q F,Zou T,et al.Ionics,2017,23:3169-3176

[37]Suo Y G,Hsing I M.Electrochim.Acta,2011,56:2174-2183

[38]Yurderi M,Bulut A,Zahmakirana M,et al.Appl.Catal.,B,2014,160（7）:514-524

[39]Zhang J M,Wang R X,Nong R J,et al.Int.J.Hydrogen Energy,2017,42（10）:7226-7234

[40]Lu Y Z,Chen W.J.Phys.Chem.C,2010,114（49）:21190-21200

[41]Liu Z L,Zhang X H.Electrochem.Commun.,2009,11（8）:1667-1670

[42]Zhu F C,Ma G S,Bai Z C,et al.J.Power Sources,2013,242（22）:610-620

[43]Shen Y Y,Sun Y,Zhou L N,et al.J.Mater.Chem.A,2014,2（9）:2977-2984

[44]Marinšek M,Šala M,Jancˇar B.J.Power Sources,2013,235（8）:111-116

[45]Yi Q F,Chu H,Tang M X,et al.J.Electroanal.Chem.,2015,739:178-186

[46]Cazares-Ávila E,Ruiz-Ruiz E J,Hernández-Ramírez A,et al.Int.J.Hydrogen Energy,2017,42（51）:30349-30358

[47]Carmo M,Paganin V A,Rosolen J M,et al.J.Power Sources,2005,142（1）:169-176

[48]Zhang Y Y,Yi Q F,Deng Z L,et al.Catal.Lett.,2018,148:1190-1201

[49]Xiong B,Zhou Y K,Zhao Y Y,et al.Carbon,2013,52（2）:181-192

[50]Yang Z Z,Wang X L,Kang X,et al.Electrochim.Acta,2017,236:72-81

[51]Lewera A,Barczuk P J,Skorupska K,et al.J.Electroanal.Chem.,2011,662（1）:93-99

[52]Kakaei K,Dorraji M.Electrochim.Acta,2014,143:207-215

[53]Li S S,Wang A J,Hu Y Y,et al.J.Mater.Chem.A,2014,2（43）:18177-18183

[54]Ha S,Larsen R,Masel R I.J.Power Sources,2005,144（1）:28-34

[55]Wang Y Y,Qi Y Y,Zhang D J.Comput.Theor.Chem.,2014,1049:51-54

[56]Zhang S X,Qing M,Zhang H,et al.Electrochem.Commun.,2009,11（11）:2249-2252

[57]Vafaei M,Rezaei M,Tabaian S H,et al.J.Solid State Electrochem.,2015,19（1）:289-298