Perovskite crystallization

Lili Ke and Liming Ding

1Hunan Key Laboratory for Micro-Nano Energy Materials and Devices, School of Physics and Optoelectronics, Xiangtan University,Hunan 411105, China

2Center for Excellence in Nanoscience (CAS), Key Laboratory of Nanosystem and Hierarchical Fabrication (CAS), National Center for Nanoscience and Technology, Beijing 100190, China

In recent years, perovskite solar cells (PSCs) have attracted tremendous attention due to their high power conversion efficiencies (PCEs) and tailorable optoelectronic properties.Up to now, the certified PCE of lab-scale PSCs has climbed up to 25.5% (see https://www.nrel.gov/pv/cell-efficiency.html).However, there still exists a large efficiency gap between small-area devices and large-area solar modules.The main reason refers to the difference between morphology and crystallinity caused by different perovskite film formation.To address this issue, it is of great necessity to make high-quality perovskite films.Currently, efforts are being devoted to exquisitely modulating the nucleation and crystal growth of perovskite films[1−3].

The nucleation and crystal growth are two processes in the formation of perovskite films.The nucleation is triggered by the supersaturation of the precursor solution (Fig.1(a))[1].Reaching a high nucleation rate before crystal growth is critical in forming high-quality perovskite films.A variety of approaches to facilitate the supersaturation of perovskite precursor solution appeared to accelerate the nucleation[4−6].Chenget al.and Seoket al.simultaneously proposed the antisolvent method[4,7].The introduction of an antisolvent (e.g.toluene, chlorobenzene, or diethyl ether) during the spin-coating process induced instant supersaturation of the precursor solution, causing fast nucleation for uniform, ultra-smooth perovskite thin films (Fig.1(b)).Other solvent engineering methods were introduced to achieve a similar effect such as preparing perovskite film in an antisolvent bath[5]and adopting solvent mixture[8].In addition to these solvent engineering methods, other strategies were also applied to instantly create supersaturation of the perovskite solute.Grätzelet al.reported a vacuum flash-assisted solution process (VASP) to accelerate nucleation, yielding shiny, smooth and crystalline perovskite films over large areas (Fig.1(c))[6].Analogously, a high-temperature thermal annealing method was developed by Kimet al.to accelerate supersaturation of the perovskite solute, obtaining a smooth and uniform film with an average grain size of 1μm[9].

The nucleation can be divided into homogeneous and heterogeneous modes, which have different sensitivities to the supersaturation of solution due to different nucleation energy barrier[1].Particularly, the heterogeneous nucleation probably dominates the growth mechanism because that nucleation generally occurs on foreign surfaces orvianuclei.As the heterogeneous nucleation rate is limited by the total area of the foreign surface, this nucleation can be promoted by increasing the surface roughness of substrate or employing surface treatment.Yanget al.modeled that the heterogeneous nuclei preferred to form in the concave regions on rough substrate[10].The perovskite films on a mesoporous structure or on a layer of nanoparticle with a proper thickness are generally more compact and uniform with less pinholes and smaller crystals.

Various methods were utilized to modulate electron-transport layers (ETLs) and hole-transport layers (HTLs).Recently,Grätzelet al.reported that MXene quantum dots-modified SnO2ETL could rapidly induce perovskite nucleation in precursor solution, forming an intermediate perovskite phase upon anti-solvent treatment[11].Chenet al.modified ZnO-coated substrate with hydrophilic 3-aminopropanioc acid (C3-SAM) in one-step perovskite deposition (Fig.1(d))[12].The facilitated heterogeneous nucleation on a hydrophilic substrate surface contributed to increase grain size and high crystallinity.However, in two-step perovskite deposition, the pre-nucleation of PbI2will take place if the substrate is hydrophilic,which is unfavorable for forming high-quality perovskite films.To suppress the heterogeneous nucleation of PbI2,Huanget al.investigated the effects of hydrophobicity of various HTLs on perovskite film morphology (Fig.1(e))[13].With the increase of hydrophobicity of HTLs, the perovskite crystal size significantly increased from 200 nm to >1.5μm.Moreover, appropriate substrate selection can initiate the epitaxial growth of perovskite single crystals.Switzeret al.reported epitaxial growth of CsPbBr3single crystal on SrTiO3substrate[14].The chemical bonding between SrTiO3and perovskite layer with similar crystal structures can lower the energy barrier of heterogeneous nucleation and the surface energy.

Control over the nucleation location is critical for manipulating the crystallization process, especially in 2D perovskites.Choiet al.reported a formation mechanism for vertically orientated 2D perovskite in which the nucleation arised from the liquid-air interface (Fig.1(f))[15].Only vertical stacking provided a direct pathway for charge transport through the perovskite, and the subsequent templated growth from heterogeneous nucleation resulted in preferential crystal orientation, boosting the efficiency of resulted solar cells.In terms of doctor blading method, Yuanet al.used hot-air blowing to accelerate DMF volatilization on precursor solution surface.The nucleation on top of solution triggered a downward growthof BA2MA3Pb4I13perovskite with out-of-plane orientation[16].Moreover, seeding growth is regarded as a new strategy to manipulate the morphology evolution.Heterogeneous nucleation sites are intentionally introduced into the precursor solution, which can effectively control the concentration of nucleation center.Sargentet al.developed a perovskite seeding method with Cs-containing perovskite as the seed source[17].The perovskite seeds facilitated heterogeneous nucleation,yielding large grain and preferential crystal orientation of perovskite film.

Fig.1.(Color online) (a) Nucleation rate vs supersaturation ratio curves for homogeneous and heterogeneous nucleation.Reproduced with permission[1], Copyright 2019, American Chemical Society.(b) Antisolvent engineering method.Reproduced with permission[4], Copyright 2014, Wiley-VCH.(c) Vacuum-flash assisted solution process.Reproduced with permission[6], Copyright 2016, Science (AAAS).(d) C3-SAM-induced permanent dipole formation and involvement of the C3-SAM in perovskite crystalline structure.Reproduced with permission[12], Copyright 2015, American Chemical Society.(e) The water contact angle (left) and SEM top-view images (right) of MAPbI3 grown on varied HTLs.Reproduced with permission[13], Copyright 2015, Springer Nature.(f) Possible crystallization from nucleation sites at liquid-air interface.Reproduced with permission[15],Copyright 2018, Springer Nature.

Crystal growth occurs after the formation of stable nuclei.For obtaining efficient solar cells, high-quality perovskite films with large grains are prerequisite.Generally, slow crystallization results in high-quality perovskite films.Based on this cognition, a variety of thin-film engineering approaches are used to retard the crystallization.Lewis acid-base adduct approach is a commonly used strategy to slow down perovskite crystal growth[18].PbI2is a Lewis acid, which can form adduct with Lewis base molecules containing S, N and O atoms.This method was reported by Parket al., in which DMSO was chosen as the Lewis base[19].DMSO was added into the solution of CH3NH3I and PbI2in DMF during the dissolution (Fig.2(a)).The Lewis acid-base adduct CH3NH3I·PbI2·DMSO was evidenced by infrared spectroscopy, eventually leading to a highly uniform MAPbI3layer.The formation of solvated phase can retard the crystallization of 3D perovskite.Solvent with high donor number is often added into precursor solution to form stable solvated phase.Yanget al.introduced a Lewis base additive, urea, into a perovskite precursor solution, leading to increase of grain size and reduction of defect density[20].Urea could slow down the crystal growth and passivate defects at the grain boundary (Fig.2(b)).

Moreover, additive engineering is regarded as one of the effective ways to retard the crystal growth of perovskite films.The commonly used additives include 1,8-diiodooctane (DIO),hydrohalic acids and chlorine-based additives, which can form chelation with Pb2+.Yuanet al.revealed that the incorporation of AX salts (such as NH4Cl, MACl, NH4I, MAI and MABr) into precursor solution could effectively suppress the nucleation rate of PbI2-based solvated phase, further retarding the crystal growth[16].They also reported that the growth speed of phenylethylammonium-based Ruddlesden-Popper(RP) perovskite was gradually lowered by adding increasing amount of Rb+ions into the precursor solution[21].Rb+ions accumulated at crystal growing front could be used as a superficial crystal growth inhibitor, properly retarding the adsorp-tion and diffusion of constituent ions (Fig.2(c)).Huanget al.introduced 3-(decyldimethylammonio)-propane sulfonate inner salt (DPSI) into perovskite precursor solution as an additive to regulate the growth of perovskite single crystals[22].DPSI ligands anchoring with Pb2+on perovskite crystal surfaces could tune the growth rate of different facets (Fig.2(d)).

Fig.2.(Color online) (a) The fabrication process and SEM images for MAPbI3 films made by one-step spin-coating of DMF solution with and without DMSO.Reproduced with permission[19], Copyright 2015, American Chemical Society.(b) MAPbI3 crystallization without and with urea.Reproduced with permission[20], Copyright 2017, Elsevier.(c) Illustration of the retarded crystal growth by Rb+ binding on perovskite surface.Reproduced with permission[21], Copyright 2020, Wiley-VCH.(d) Crystal growth at the crystal surface where DPSI molecules modulate the diffusion of metal ions to reach perovskite surface.Reproduced with permission[22], Copyright 2021, Springer Nature.(e) Methylamine-induced defect-healing (MIDH) of MAPbI3 films.Reproduced with permission[24], Copyright 2015, Wiley-VCH.

Ostwald ripening is another effective method to manipulate the crystal growth of perovskite film.Huanget al.reported solvent annealing to effectively increase the crystallinity and grain size of CH3NH3PbI3film[23].During the solvent annealing process, DMF embedded in perovskite precursor films could induce Ostwald ripening of perovskite grains.The grains with various sizes were dissolved by DMF to different degrees.Consequently, large grain coarsening occurred upon the adsorption of small grains.In addition to Ostwald ripening, other post treatments, like VASP method[6], thermal annealing[9]and CH3NH2gas[23], were also adopted to optimize the crystal growth of perovskite film.Cuiet al.reported methylamine (CH3NH2) induced defect-healing (MIDH) of CH3NH3PbI3thin films based on ultrafast, reversible chemical reaction with CH3NH2gas at room temperature[24].During perovskite-gas interaction, an intermediate CH3NH3PbI3·xCH3NH2liquid phase was formed (Fig.2(e)).MIDH process can heal the defects in perovskite film, thus forming a dense film with high crystallinity.

In summary, modulating crystal nucleation and growth in perovskite films is extremely crucial for pushing the efficiency of PSCs to the theoretical limit.Based on this cognition, a variety of thin-film morphological engineering approaches are highlighted, including adjusting nucleation rate and nuclei density, manipulating nucleation region and retarding crystal growth.More efforts are needed to make largearea perovskite films with high quality and high performance.

Acknowledgements

L.Ke thanks the Natural Science Foundation of Hunan Province (2019JJ50776).L.Ding thanks the National Key Research and Development Program of China(2017YFA0206600) and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (51773045, 21772030, 51922032, 21961160720)for financial support.