Evidence of a conservative gait strategy in athletes with a history of concussions

Thoms A.Bukly*,Sriknt Vllhjosul,Jssi R.OlhmBrry A.Munksy, Klsy M.Evns,Dvi A.Krzis,Crolin J.Kthm,Eri E.Hll

aDepartment of Kinesiology and Applied Physiology,University of Delaware,Newark,DE 19716,USA

bDepartment of Physical Therapy Education,Elon University,Elon,NC 27244,USA

cDepartment of Health and Kinesiology,Georgia Southern University,Statesboro,GA 30460,USA

dDepartment of Intercollegiate Athletics,Stetson University,DeLand,FL 32723,USA

eDepartment of Exercise Science,Elon University,Elon,NC 27244,USA

Evidence of a conservative gait strategy in athletes with a history of concussions

Thomas A.Buckleya,*,Srikant Vallabhajosulab,Jessie R.Oldhama,Barry A.Munkasyc, Kelsey M.Evansc,David A.Krazeised,Caroline J.Ketchame,Eric E.Halle

aDepartment of Kinesiology and Applied Physiology,University of Delaware,Newark,DE 19716,USA

bDepartment of Physical Therapy Education,Elon University,Elon,NC 27244,USA

cDepartment of Health and Kinesiology,Georgia Southern University,Statesboro,GA 30460,USA

dDepartment of Intercollegiate Athletics,Stetson University,DeLand,FL 32723,USA

eDepartment of Exercise Science,Elon University,Elon,NC 27244,USA

Background:A history of 3 or more concussions is frequently associated with numerous short-and long-term neuropathologies.Impairments in postural control are a known acute consequence of concussion;however,limited evidence exists on the effects of multiple concussions on gait.The purpose of this study was to assess gait stepping characteristics in collegiate aged student-athletes based on concussion history.

Methods:There were 63 participants divided into 3 even groups based on concussion history:≥3 concussions,1–2 concussions,and 0 concussion. All participants completed 10 trials of gait on a 4.9 m instrumented walkway.The dependent variables of interest included both gait stepping characteristics(step velocity,length,and width,double support time,and the percentage of the gait cycle in stance)and coefficien of variability (CoV)measures(step length,time,and width).The gait stepping characteristics were compared firs with a MANOVA with follow-up 1-way ANOVAs and Tukeypost hoctests as appropriate.The CoV measures were compared with 1-way ANOVAs and Tukeypost hoctests.

Results:There were main effects for group for step velocity,length,width,and double support time.Overall,the 0 concussion group displayed typical healthy young gait parameters and performed significant y better than either concussion group.The 0 concussion group had a significant y greater step length Co V,but there were no differences in the step time or width CoV.

Conclusion:This findin provides evidence of subtle impairments in postural control during gait among individuals with prior history of concussion which could be an early indicator of future neurological deficiencies The limited difference in the variability measures is consistent with prior static stance studies and could suggest the individuals constrain their motor systems to reduce variability.Taken together,these findi gs suggest a conservative gait strategy which is adopted by individuals with a history of concussions.

©2016 Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V.on behalf of Shanghai University of Sport.This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).

Balance;Brain injury;Gait performance;Locomotion;Mild traumatic;Postural control;Postural stability;Variability

1.Introduction

A specifi causative relationship between concussion history and later life neuropathology has not been definit vely identified1Long-term population-based studies have found inconsistent results;however,these studies are generally limited to small populations,chart reviews,or self-reported patient information.Among retired National Football League(NFL) players,there was a self-reported increased risk of clinicallydiagnosed depression and mild cognitive impairment in individuals with a lifetime history of 3 or more concussions.2,3NFL players also had a higher neurodegenerative related mortality rate than the general public.4Further,while the specifi neuropathology and epidemiology remain debated,multiple case reports have identifie the presence of chronic traumatic encephalopathy in deceased collision sport athletes.5–7In military settings,there was a positive relationship between increased number of mild traumatic brain injuries and increased risk of depression,post-traumatic stress disorder,and suicide risk;however,this may not be independent of other confounding variables.8,9Conversely,others have reported limited evidence of neurological impairment in either a population-based study or a patient-based neurological examination.10–12

Similar to the later life issues,there have been inconsistent results when assessing short-term potential impairments in younger individuals with a history of multiple concussions.Multiple studies suggest that prior concussion history is associated with increased likelihood of future concussion,a worse initial post-concussion presentation,and prolonged recovery of recurrent concussion.13–15A history of concussions does not adversely affect performance on computerized neuropsychological testing in high school or collegiate aged individuals.16–20The effect of previous concussions on self-reported symptoms has been split with finding of both increased symptoms and no differences.17,21Prior concussion history has been associated with altered electrophysiological responses months to even years following the last concussion.22–24Finally,a history of at least 3 concussions has been associated with lower quality of life;specifical y bodily pain,vitality,social functioning,and headache.25

Impairments in both static and dynamic postural control are a known acute consequence of concussion.26,27Standard clinical testing,utilizing non-instrumented static challenges,suggests recovery within 1 week of injury.26,27However,laboratory based investigations,assessing transitional and dynamic postural control,suggest these impairments may persist far longer.28–33Altered gait stepping kinematics have been identifie to persist for up to 1 month following a concussion.29,30,34–39In individuals with a history of at least 1 concussion,both a conservative gait strategy,define as reduced gait velocity and increased time in double support,and altered postural control dynamics have been identified40,41The underlying pathophysiological mechanism for this strategy in individuals has not elucidated,but Martini et al.40speculated a strategy to reduce their time in less stable positions. This is consistent with acute and sub-acute concussive gait studies which have identifie conservative gait strategies marked by reduced step and center of mass(COM)velocity,shorter steps,increased time in double support,and reduced separation of the center of pressure(COP)and COM which is suggestive of incomplete physiological recovery.29,30,34–38,42–44

There is no agreed upon number of concussions which result in neurological impairment;however,a history of at least 3 concussions appears to be frequently associated with numerous deficits2,3,22,25Previous gait studies have either utilized acute post-concussion participants or non-athletes with a history of at least 1 concussion.28–30,34–40,42–44However,the relationship between concussion history and performance on gait tasks has received limited attention and could be an important marker of neurological consequences of concussion.Therefore,the purpose of this study was to assess gait stepping characteristics in student-athletes with differing concussion history;specifi cally,1)3 or more concussions(≥3),2)1 or 2 concussions (1–2),and 3)0 concussion(0).We hypothesized the participants with a history of at least 3 concussions would present with impaired gait characteristics and exhibit a conservative gait strategy compared to the 0 concussion group and the 1–2 concussions group would fall along a range between the 0 and≥3 groups.

2.Methods

2.1.Participants

Sixty-three National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA)Division I student-athletes were recruited at 2 separate universities by members of the research team for the study.The participants were divided into 3 groups based on their concussion history(≥3,1–2,0).The 0 concussion group was selected from a larger database of potential participants by tightly matching the gender,sport,and demographics of the≥3 concussion group.The 1–2 concussions group was then matched upon the same criteria and there were no differences between groups for any demographic variable except concussion history(Table 1). Participants were excluded if they had prior or current orthopedic injury which would impair postural control,or any selfreported balance,psychiatric,visual,or vestibular deficits All participants in the concussion groups were at least 3 monthspost-concussion,denied lingering concussion related symptoms,and were fully engaged in their activities of daily living. All participants provided written informed consent as approved by Georgia Southern University and Elon University Institutions’Review Board.There were no significan differences for age(p=0.08),height(p=0.986),or weight(p=0.342)and exploratorypost hocanalysis identifie no differences between groups.As expected based on inclusion criterion,there was a main effect for concussion history(F=105.78;p＜0.001)andpost hoctesting identifie differences at each level(p＜0.001). There were no differences for group participation in concussion high risk(football,soccer,basketball,and cheerleading)and low risk(softball,baseball,track and fiel,swim and dive,and rifle sports(F=1.159,p=0.321).Exploratorypost hoctesting failed to identify any between-group differences.

Table 1 Participants’demographics(mean±SD)and sports by group.

2.2.Instrumentation

The gait characteristics were assessed using identical 4.9 m GAITRite instrumented walkways(CIR Systems,Sparta,NJ, USA).The GAITRite is a reliable(intraclass correlation coefficien(ICC):0.80–0.98)and valid(ICC:0.92–0.99,compared to motion capture and a clinical stride analyzer)portable walkway gait analysis system with 18,432 sensors over a 0.6 m (W)×4.9 m(L)grid that detect footfalls as the participant progresses its length.45,46The walkway was connected to a computer through a USB cable and program software calculated common spatiotemporal parameters of gait.The GAITRite mat was positioned such that participants had 2–2.5 m of space to walk at both ends of the walkway.

2.3.Procedures

Each potential participant completed a health history questionnaire and personal interview with a member of the research team in order to ensure that inclusion and exclusion criteria were achieved.Data collection was completed in a single testing session in each institution’s respective gait laboratory.

The participants were dressed in comfortable athletic clothing and were barefoot for all trials.The participants initiated each trial at least 1 m prior to the walkway and the third step,at the earliest,was the firs step to be captured by the GAITRite. Thus,steady state gait would have been achieved prior to contacting the GAITRite walkway.47Participants were instructed to walk at a self-selected pace to a mark located 2.5 m past the end of the walkway.All participants completed 10 trials and were instructed not to talk during the trials in order to avoid dualtasking effects on gait.

2.4.Data analysis

This was a cross sectional study comparing the gait stepping characteristics and variability measures including step velocity, step length,step width,double support time,and the percentage of the gait cycle in stance averaged from both limbs.Step velocity was define as the ratio of the distance covered to time taken to cover the distance.Step length was define as the antero-posterior distance between heel position of ipsilateral foot and the heel position of the contralateral foot at the heel strike of the ipsilateral foot.Step width was define as the medio-lateral distance between heel position of ipsilateral foot and the heel position of the contralateral foot at the heel strike of the ipsilateral foot.Double support time was define as the time both the legs were contact with the ground during the gait cycle.The percentage of gait cycle in stance was define as the percentage of time spent on a single leg(stance phase)during gait cycle.The mean of the 10 trials was used for computing the gait stepping characteristics measures.48For variability measures(step length,time,and width)coefficien of variation (CoV=SD/mean×100)was used.The CoV provides a meaningful method of comparing the variability among different dependent measures as it is both dimensionless as well as normalized around the mean and has been frequently utilized in the gait literature.49,50

2.5.Statistical analysis

As gait stepping characteristics are interrelated,all stepping data were firs compared with a multiple analysis of variance (MANOVA).51Once significanc was identifie overall,1-way analysis of variance(ANOVA)was performed to compare each of the stepping dependent variables between groups.If main effects for group were identifie,a Tukeypost hoctest was performed to identify the between-group differences.The CoV dependent variables of interest are independent of each other and therefore were compared with 1-way ANOVAs and,when a significan main effect was identifie,followed with Tukeypost hoc.Thea priori αlevel was set at 0.05.

3.Results

The overall MANOVA was significan for gait stepping characteristics(F(10,112)=5.09,p＜0.001,η2=0.31).There was a significan main effect in the gait stepping characteristics for step velocity(F=9.07,p＜0.001,η2=0.23),step length (F=4.861,p=0.011,η2=0.14),step width(F=9.544,p＜0.001,η2=0.24),and double support time(F=4.407,p=0.016,η2=0.13)(Table 2).There was no main effect for the stance percentage of the gait cycle(F=1.212,p=0.305).Step velocitypost hoctesting identifie differences between the 0 concussion group and both the 1–2 concussions group (p＜0.001)and the≥3 concussions group(p=0.028),but no difference between the 1–2 and≥3 concussions groups (p=0.263).Step lengthpost hoctesting identifie differences between the 0 concussion group and both the 1–2 concussions group(p=0.016)andthe≥3concussions group(p=0.038),but no difference between the 1–2 and≥3 concussions groups (p=0.940).Step widthpost hoctesting identifie significan differences between≥3concussions and both 0 concussions(p= 0.025)and 1–2 concussions(p＜0.001),but no difference between0concussionsand1–2concussions(p=0.238).Double support timepost hoctesting identifie significan differences between 0 concussion and both 1–2 concussions(p=0.049)and≥3 concussions(p=0.024),but no difference between 1–2 concussions and≥3 concussions(p=0.952)(Table 2).

For CoV measures,there was a significan main effect for step length CoV(F=18.144,p＜0.001,η2=0.38),but nodifferences for step time Co V(F=1.973,p=0.148)or step width CoV(F=1.074,p=0.348).Step lengthpost hocanalysis identifiea significanty higher Co V for the 0 concussion group compared to both the 1–2 concussions group(5.51± 1.87vs.2.55±0.76,respectively,p＜0.001)and the≥3 concussions group(5.51±1.87vs.3.59±1.93,p=0.001)(Fig.1).

Table 2 Gait stepping characteristics results(mean±SD).

Fig.1.Gait coefficien of variation.*Significan group differences onpost hoctesting.

4.Discussion

The effect of multiple concussions on neurological function in student-athletes is an emerging research area with inconsistent finding to date.While the majority of studies have investigated neuropsychological or general neurological functioning, there has been limited investigation of postural control among collegiate student-athletes with varying concussion histories. The primary findin of this study was the presence of a conservative gait strategy among student-athletes with a concussion history.Interestingly,while both concussion groups performed worse than the 0 concussion group on the majority of gait stepping characteristics,there was only a significan difference in 1 dependent variable,step width,between the≥3 and 1–2 concussions groups.These differences,albeit subtle as indicated by the small effect sizes,could be early indicators of potential later life neuropathological concussion related sequella.

A conservative gait strategy,characterized by reduced step velocity,increased step width,reduced step length and longer durations in double support phase,has been identifie in acute, subacute,and chronic post-concussion individuals.30,31,34,35,40Both concussion history groups herein demonstrated varying degrees of conservative gait strategies whereas the 0 concussion group had typical healthy gait performance(e.g.,step velocity=1.43 m/s,step length=0.73 m,stance percentage= 60.6%).Indeed,the multiple concussions group’s step velocity (1.25–1.32 m/s)was closer to acute(1.23 m/s)and subacute (1.30 m/s)populations than chronic post-concussion participants (1.46 m/s).35,40Interestingly, the chronic (6-year post-concussion)participants’step velocity on single task unobstructed gait exceeded the 0 concussion group in this study (1.46 m/s and 1.43 m/s,respectively);however,Martini et al.40utilized non-athletes and some evidence exists to suggest that,on average,athletes have slower gait velocities than non-athletes.29While step velocity may have driven many of the additional findings the multiple concussions groups herein also had a 4–5 cm reduction in step length and the≥3 concussions group had an increased step width which were both similar to finding of acute and subacute post-concussion individuals.29,42–44The percentage of time spent in double support for the multiple concussions participants was also similar with non-athletes with a concussion history.40These finding suggest the concussion groups’conservative gait strategy was likely in an effort to maximize stable(e.g.,more time in double support)gait patterns.40

The specifi neurological rationale underlying the conservative gait strategy has not been fully elucidated.One proposed explanation suggests concussions result in long-term neuronal and axonal damage with reduced synaptic plasticity.52Supporting this hypothesis,De Beaumont et al.24,53,54have reported abnormalities in the primary motor cortex resulting in alteration of motor planning and control in individuals with a history of concussions.More acutely,altered motor control strategies, independent of step velocity,have been noted during gait termination despite apparent recovery on clinical concussion measures.28Alternatively,routine participation in collision athletics(e.g.,football,ice hockey,and soccer)results in numerous head impacts that do not elicit concussion symptoms and are thus referred to as“subconcussive blows”.These subconcussive impacts may cause acute neurophysiological deficit and have been speculated,but not proven,to result in long-term neurodegeneration including chronictraumatic encephalopathy.55–57

Physiological variability was previously considered as an unwanted“noise”in biological systems;however,recent studieshave shown that variability is inherent in our system.58,59Indeed,a certain amount of variability present in physiological signals like heart rate often indicates a healthy system.60,61However,in gait analysis,excessive variability is indicative of increased fall risk in the elderly and is a marker of multiple neurological disorders including Parkinson’s disease,Huntington’s disease,and multiple sclerosis.62–66Following a concussion, increased swing time variability has been identifie both acutely and nearly 1 month post-injury which was suggestive of incomplete recovery.39Conversely,Cavanaugh et al.67,68repeatedly identifie reduced variability in approximate entropy during static stance post-concussion and suggested that decreased brain region coupling could increase the regularity of the cortical oscillations.Finally,Sosnoff et al.41suggested variability could be specifito the difficult of the task. Herein,and contrary to the study hypothesis,the participants with 0 concussion had increased step length variability,but still below the 7% Co V postulated threshold,compared to either concussion history group and there were no differences noted in step time or width variability.69This finding in agreement with Cavanaugh et al.,67,68suggests a postconcussion strategy to constrain their motor systems to reduce variability.This reduced gait variability along with slower step velocity and shorter step lengths together suggest a conservative gait strategy employed by the multiple concussions groups, particularly the≥3 concussions group;however,the physiological rationale for this strategy was beyond the scope of this study and requires further investigation.

The number of steps required to calculate valid and reliable variability measures is inconsistent in the literature with recommendations up to 400 steps.70However,gait variability measures have been calculated from as few as 3–5 steps; nonetheless,the 4.9 m length of the instrumented walkway, allowing approximately 7 steps per trial,utilized in this study may have been a limitation.49,50The participants were tightly matched based on demographic characteristics and there were no group differences;however,leg length was not measured and thus absolute,not relative,stepping data are presented herein. Further,self-reporting of concussion history,while common in the literature,has only moderate reliability which could have resulted in participants being grouped incorrectly;however,the research team extensively interviewed participants in an effort to minimize this limitation.71This study investigated college aged NCAA Division I student-athletes only so the results may not be extrapolated to other populations(e.g.,high school). Future studies should address these limitations as well as expand the testing protocol to move beyond gait to incorporate additional motor and cognitive challenges(e.g.,transitional movements,athletic related activities,and similar)to postural control.Finally,while logistically challenging,serial tracking of individuals with extensive concussion histories would substantially improve the scientifi understanding of the sequella.

5.Conclusion

The primary findin of this study was an apparent conservative gait strategy(slower step velocity,shorter steps,wider step width,and increased time in double support with decreased step length variability)adopted by individuals with a history of concussions.These finding are suggestive of an either persistent defici in post-concussion postural control or as a canary in a coal mine early indicator of neurological consequences of multiple concussions.Previous concussion history is an established predictor of future concussion,and perhaps nonconcussive sport related injury,and the impaired postural control identifie herein could be a contributing factor to be considered in future studies.14,72

Acknowledgment

This project was funded,in part,by an NIH/NINDS grant (1R15NS070744-01A1)and a Georgia Southern University Faculty Development grant.Two authors,Drs.Buckley and Munkasy,are primary investigators on both grants.The funding agency had no role in the development of the manuscript,the interpretation of the results,or the decision where to submit the manuscript.

Authors’contributions

All authors were involved in the development of this manuscript.TAB was responsible for the conception,overall project design,assisted in data collection and analysis,was primarily responsible for data interpretation,and drafted the manuscript. SV,CJK,and EEH were responsible for data collection,analysis,and interpretation at the second site involved in the study and provided feedback on the manuscript.SV and EEH were also involved in the overall project design.JRO was involved in data collection,analysis,and interpretation and helped draft the manuscript.BAM,KME,and DAK were involved in the data collection,analysis,and interpretation from one of the project sites and provided feedback on the manuscript.BAM and DAK were also involved in the conception and design of the project. All authors have read and approved the fina version of the manuscript,and agree with the order of presentation of the authors.

Competing interest

None of the authors declare competing financia interests.

1.McCrory P,Meeuwisse WH,Aubry M,Cantu RC,Dvorˇák J,Echemendia RJ,et al.Consensus statement on concussion in sport:the 4th International Conference on Concussion in Sport,Zurich,November 2012.J Athl Train2013;48:554–75.

2.Guskiewicz KM,Marshall SW,Bailes J,McCrea M,Cantu RC,Randolph C,et al.Association between recurrent concussion and late-life cognitive impairment in retired professional football players.Neurosurgery2005;57:719–26.

3.Guskiewicz KM,Marshall SW,Bailes J,McCrea M,Harding Jr HP, Matthews A,et al.Recurrent concussion and risk of depression in retired professional football players.Med Sci Sports Exerc2007;39:903–9.

4.Lehman EJ,Hein MJ,Baron SL,Gersic CM.Neurodegenerative causes of death among retired National Football League players.Neurology2012;79:1970–4.

5.McKee AC,Stein TD,Nowinski CJ,Stein TD,Alvarez VE,Daneshvar DH,et al.The spectrum of disease in chronic traumatic encephalopathy.Brain2013;136:43–64.

6.Karantzoulis S,Randolph C.Modern chronic traumatic encephalopathy in retired athletes:what is the evidence?Neuropsychol Rev2013;23: 350–60.

7.Hazrati LN,Tartaglia MC,Diamandis P,Davis KD,Green RE,Wennberg R,et al.Absence of chronic traumatic encephalopathy in retired football players with multiple concussions and neurological symptomatology.Front Hum Neurosci2013;7:222.doi:10.3389/fnhum.2013.00222

8.Bryan CJ,Clemans TA.Repetitive traumatic brain injury,psychological symptoms,and suicide risk in a clinical sample of deployed military personnel.JAMA Psychiatry2013;70:686–91.

9.Spira JL,Lathan CE,Bleiberg J,Tsao JW.The impact of multiple concussions on emotional distress,postconcussive symptoms,and neurocognitive functioning,in active duty U.S.marines independent of combat exposure or emotional distress.J Neurotrauma2014;15:1823–34.

10.Casson I,Viano D,Haacke E,Kou Z,LeStrage D.Is there chronic brain damage in retired NFL players?Neuroradiology,neuropsychology, and neurology examinations of 45 retired players.Sports Health2014;6:384–95.

11.Savica R,Parisi JE,Wold LE,Josephs KA,Ahlskog JE.High school football and risk of neurodegeneration:a community-based study.Mayo Clinic Proc2012;87:335–40.

12.Randolph C,Karantzoulis S,Guskiewicz K.Prevalence and characterization of mild cognitive impairment in retired National Football League players.J Int Neuropsychol Soc2013;19:873–80.

13.Covassin T,Moran R,Wilhelm K.Concussion symptoms and neurocognitive performance of high school and college athletes who incur multiple concussions.Am J Sports Med2013;41:2885–9.

14.Castile L,Collins CL,McIlvain NM,Comstock RD.The epidemiology of new versus recurrent sports concussions among high school athletes, 2005–2010.Br J Sports Med2012;46:603–10.

15.Collins MW,Lovell MR,Iverson GL,Cantu RC,Maroon JC,Field M. Cumulative effects of concussion in high school athletes.Neurosurgery2002;51:1175–9.

16.Iverson GL,Brooks BL,Lovell MR,Collins MW.No cumulative effects for one or two previous concussions.Br J Sports Med2006;40: 72–5.

17.Brooks BL,McKay CD,Mrazik M,Barlow KM,Meeuwisse WH,Emery CA.Subjective,but not objective,lingering effects of multiple past concussions in adolescents.J Neurotrauma2013;30:1469–75.

18.Brooks BL,Mrazik M,Barlow KM,McKay CD,Meeuwisse WH,Emery CA.Absence of differences between male and female adolescents with prior sport concussion.J Head Trauma Rehabil2014;29:257–64.

19.Broglio SP,Ferrara MS,Piland SG,Anderson RB,Collie A.Concussion history is not a predictor of computerised neurocognitive performance.Br J Sports Med2006;40:802–5.

20.Solomon GS,Haase RF,Kuhn A.The relationship among neurocognitive performances and biopsychosocial characteristics of elite National Football League draft picks:an exploratory investigation.Arch Clin Neuropsychol2013;28:9–20.

21.Silverberg ND,Lange RT,Millis SR,Rose A,Hopp G,Leach S,et al. Post-concussion symptom reporting after multiple mild traumatic brain injuries.J Neurotrauma2013;30:1398–404.

22.De Beaumont L,Brisson B,Lassonde M,Jolicoeur P.Long-term electrophysiological changes in athletes with a history of multiple concussions.Brain Inj2007;21:631–44.

23.Theriault M,De Beaumont L,Tremblay S,Lassonde M,Jolicoeur P. Cumulative effects of concussions in athletes revealed by electrophysiological abnormalities on visual working memory.JClinExp Neuropsychol2011;33:30–41.

24.De Beaumont L,Mongeon D,Tremblay S,Messier J,Prince F,Leclerc S, et al.Persistent motor system abnormalities in formerly concussed athletes.J Athl Train2011;46:234–40.

25.Kuehl MD,Snyder AR,Erickson SE,McLeod TC.Impact of prior concussions on health-related quality of life in collegiate athletes.Clin J Sport Med2010;20:86–91.

26.McCrea M,Guskiewicz KM,Marshall SW,Barr W,Randolph C,Cantu RC,et al.Acute effects and recovery time following concussion in collegiate football players:the NCAA Concussion Study.JAMA2003;290: 2556–63.

27.McCrea M,Barr WB,Guskiewicz K,Randolph C,Marshall SW, Cantu R,et al.Standard regression-based methods for measuring recovery after sport-related concussion.J Int Neuropsychol Soc2005;11:58–69.

28.Buckley TA,Munkasy BA,Tapia-Lovler TG,Wikstrom EA.Altered gait termination strategies following a concussion.Gait Posture2013;38: 549–51.

29.Parker TM,Osternig LR,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.Balance control during gait in athletes and non-athletes following concussion.Med Eng Phys2008;30:959–67.

30.Catena RD,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.Different gait tasks distinguish immediatevs.long-term effects of concussion on balance control.J Neuroeng Rehabil2009;7:25.doi:10.1186/1743-0003-6-25

31.Powers KC,Kalmar JM,Cinelli ME.Recovery of static stability following a concussion.Gait Posture2014;39:611–4.

32.Gao J,Hu J,Buckley T,White K,Hass C.Shannon and Renyi entropies to classify effects of mild traumatic brain injury on postural sway.PLoS One2011;6:e24446.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0024446

33.Slobounov S,Sebastianelli W,Hallett M.Residual brain dysfunction observed one year post-mild traumatic brain injury:combined EEG and balance study.Clin Neurophysiol2012;123:1755–61.

34.Parker TM,Osternig LR,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.Recovery of cognitive and dynamic motor function following concussion.Br J Sports Med2007;41:868–73.

35.Parker TM,Osternig LR,VAN Donkelaar P,Chou LS.Gait stability following concussion.Med Sci Sports Exerc2006;38:1032–40.

36.Catena RD,van Donkelaar P,Halterman CI,Chou LS.Spatial orientation of attention and obstacle avoidance following concussion.Exp Brain Res2009;194:67–77.

37.Catena RD,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.The effects of attention capacity on dynamic balance control following concussion.J Neuroeng Rehabil2011;8:8.doi:10.1186/1743-0003-8-8

38.Howell DR,Osternig LR,Koester MC,Chou LS.The effect of cognitive task complexity on gait stability in adolescents following concussion.Exp Brain Res2014;232:1773–82.

39.Powers KC,Kalmar JM,Cinelli ME.Dynamic stability and steering control following a sport-induced concussion.Gait Posture2014;39:728–32.

40.MartiniDN,SabinMJ,DePesa SA,LealE W,Negrete TN,Sosnoff JJ,et al. The chronic effects of concussion on gait.Arch Phys Med Rehabil2011;92:585–9.

41.Sosnoff JJ,Broglio SP,Shin S,Ferrara MS.Previous mild traumatic brain injury and postural-control dynamics.J Athl Train2011;46:85–91.

42.Parker TM,Osternig LR,Lee HJ,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.The effect of divided attention on gait stability following concussion.Clin Biomech2005;20:389–95.

43.Catena RD,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.Altered balance control following concussion is better detected with an attention test during gait.Gait Posture2007;25:406–11.

44.Catena RD,van Donkelaar P,Chou LS.Cognitive task effects on gait stability following concussion.Exp Brain Res2007;176:23–31.

45.Menz HB,Latt MD,Tiedemann A,Kwan MMS,Lord SR.Reliability of the GAITRite walkway system for the quantificatio of temporo-spatial parameters of gait in young and older people.Gait Posture2004;20: 20–5.

46.Webster KE,Wittwer JE,Feller JA.Validity of the GAITRite walkway system for the measurement of averaged and individual step parameters of gait.Gait Posture2005;22:317–21.

47.Caderby T,Dalleau G,Leroyer P,Bonazzi B,Chane-Teng D, Manh-Cuong D.Does an additional load modify the anticipatory postural adjustments in gait initiation?Gait Posture2013;37:144–6.

48.Inc CS.GAITRite electronic walkway technical reference manual. Available at: http://www.gaitrite.com/downloads/WI-02-15_Technical _Reference_L.pdf;2013[accessed 14.08.2014].

49.Roemmich RT,Nocera JR,Vallabhajosula S,Amano S,Naugle KM, Stegemöller EL,et al.Spatiotemporal variability during gait initiation in Parkinson’s disease.Gait Posture2012;36:340–3.

50.Mbourou GA,Lajoie Y,Teasdale N.Step length variability at gait initiation in elderly fallers and non-fallers,and young adults.Gerontology2003;49:21–6.

51.Hass CJ,Gregor RJ,Waddell DE,Oliver A,Smith DW,Fleming RP,et al. The influenc of Tai Chi training on the center of pressure trajectory during gait initiation in older adults.Arch Phys Med Rehabil2004;85:1593–8.

52.Gosselin N,Bottari C,Chen JK,Huntgeburth SC,De Beaumont L,Petrides M,et al.Evaluating the cognitive consequences of mild traumatic brain injury and concussion by using electrophysiology.Neurosurg Focus2012;33(E7):1–7.

53.De Beaumont L,Lassonde M,Leclerc S,Theoret H.Long-term and cumulative effects of sports concussion on motor cortex inhibition.Neurosurgery2007;61:329–36.

54.De Beaumont L,Tremblay S,Henry LC,Poirier J,Lassonde M,Theoret H. Motor system alterations in retired former athletes:the role of aging and concussion history.BMC Neurol2013;13:109.doi:10.1186/1471-2377-13 -109

55.Baugh CM,Stamm JM,Riley DO,Gavett BE,Shenton ME,Lin A,et al. Chronic traumatic encephalopathy:neurodegeneration following repetitive concussive and subconcussive brain trauma.Brain Imaging Behav2012;6:244–54.

56.Talavage TM,Nauman EA,Breedlove EL,Yoruk U,Dye AE,Morigaki KE,et al.Functionally-detected cognitive impairment in high school football players without clinically-diagnosed concussion.J Neurotrauma2014;31:327–38.

57.Littleton A,Guskiewicz K.Current concepts in sport concussion management:a multifaceted approach.J Sport Health Sci2013;2:227–35. 58.Preatoni E,Ferrario M,Dona G,Hamill J,Rodano R.Motor variability in sports:a non-linear analysis of race walking.J Sports Sci2010;28:1327–36.

59.Preatoni E,Hamill J,Harrison AJ,Hayes K,Van Emmerik RE,Wilson C, et al.Movement variability and skills monitoring in sports.Sports Biomech2013;12:69–92.

60.Acharya UR,Joseph KP,Kannathal N,Lim CM,Suri JS.Heart rate variability:a review.Med Biol Eng Comput2006;44:1031–51.

61.Guzzetti S,Magatelli R,Borroni E,Mezzetti S.Heart rate variability in chronic heart failure.Auton Neurosci2001;90:102–5.

62.Maki BE.Gait changes in older adults:predictors of falls or indicators of fear?J Am Geriatr Soc1997;45:313–20.

63.Hausdorff JM,Cudkowicz ME,Firtion R,Wei JY,Goldberger AL.Gait variability and basal ganglia disorders:stride-to-stride variations of gait cycle timing in Parkinson’s disease and Huntington’s disease.Mov Disord1998;13:428–37.

64.Socie MJ,Sosnoff JJ.Gait variability and multiple sclerosis.Mult Scler Int2013;2013:645197.doi:10.1155/2013/645197

65.Lord S,Howe T,Greenland J,Simpson L,Rochester L.Gait variability in older adults:a structured review of testing protocol and clinimetric properties.Gait Posture2011;34:443–50.

66.Hausdorff JM.Gait dynamics in Parkinson’s disease:common and distinct behavior among stride length,gait variability,and fractal-like scaling.Chaos2009;19:026113.doi:10.1063/1.3147408

67.Cavanaugh JT,Guskiewicz KM,Giuliani C,Marshall S,Mercer V, Stergiou N.Detecting altered postural control after cerebral concussion in athletes with normal postural stability.Br J Sports Med2005;39:805–11.

68.Cavanaugh JT,Guskiewicz KM,Giuliani C,Marshall S,Mercer VS, Stergiou N.Recovery of postural control after cerebral concussion:new insights using approximate entropy.J Athl Train2006;41:305–13.

69.Nakamura T,Meguro K,Sasaki H.Relationship between falls and stride length variability in senile dementia of the Alzheimer type.Gerontology1996;42:108–13.

70.Owings TM,Grabiner MD.Measuring step kinematic variability on an instrumented treadmill:how many steps are enough?J Biomech2003;36:1215–8.

71.Kerr ZY,Marshall SW,Guskiewicz KM.Reliability of concussion history in former professional football players.Med Sci Sports Exerc2012;44: 377–82.

72.Nordstrom A,Nordstrom P,Ekstrand J.Sports-related concussion increases the risk of subsequent injury by about 50%in elite male football players.Br J Sports Med2014;48:1447–50.

Received 28 August 2014;revised 15 December 2014;accepted 9 March 2015

Available online 12 June 2015

Peer review under responsibility of Shanghai University of Sport.

*Corresponding author.

E-mail address:TBuckley@UDel.edu(T.A.Buckley).

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jshs.2015.03.010

2095-2546/©2016 Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V.on behalf of Shanghai University of Sport.This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).