BACE1 inhibition as a therapeutic strategy for Alzheimer’s disease

Robert Vassar

Department of Cell and Molecular Biology,The Feinberg School of Medicine,Northwestern University,Chicago,IL 60611,USA

BACE1 inhibition as a therapeutic strategy for Alzheimer’s disease

Robert Vassar

Department of Cell and Molecular Biology,The Feinberg School of Medicine,Northwestern University,Chicago,IL 60611,USA

1.The identifcation of β-secretase as β-site amyloid precursor protein cleaving enzyme(BACE)

Following the discoveries of β-amyloid(Aβ)and the firs amyloid precursor protein(APP)mutations that cause familial Alzheimer’s disease(AD),it soon became clear that the β-and γ-secretase enzymes were prime therapeutic targets for the development of small-molecule inhibitor drugs for the treatment of AD.Thus,their molecular identities were vigorously pursued.The properties of Aβ generation and secretase activities in cells and tissues led to the development of cell-free and cell-based assays that could be exploited for the identifi cation of the secretases.Subsequently,5 groups independently reported the molecular cloning of the β-secretase enzyme, which they variously named BACE,Asp2,and memapsin 2.1–5It is important to note that all the groups agreed on the same polypeptide sequence even though they used different experimental approaches to identify the β-secretase,lending strong support for the conclusion that the authentic β-secretase had been cloned.

BACE has all the molecular and cellular characteristics that had been previously predicted for the β-secretasein vitroandin vivo.It is a type I transmembrane aspartic protease of 501 amino acids in length that is closely related to the pepsin family of aspartic proteases.The catalytic domain of BACE harbors 2 aspartic protease signature motifs of the sequence DTGS and DSGT that come together to form the active site of the enzyme. As required for β-secretase,the BACE active site is topologically oriented on the same side of the membrane as the β-secretase cleavage site in APP.Additionally,the activity of BACE has an acidic pH optimum and the catalytic domain resides within the lumen of acidic intracellular compartments, including endosomes and the trans-Golgi network.Moreover, BACE levels are highest in neurons of the central nervous system(CNS);BACE has the correct sequence specificity and BACE overexpressed in cells cleaves APP and increases Aβ production.

Soon after the discovery of BACE,a homologue,BACE2, was identifiethat has～64%amino acid similarity to BACE (henceforth referred to as BACE1).The extensive degree of homology between the 2 enzymes suggested that BACE2 might also function as a β-secretase.However,this possibility seemed unlikely because BACE2 is not expressed to a high level in neurons,in contrast to BACE1.Moreover,BACE2 predominantly cleaves APP within the Aβ domain,so that the generation of Aβ is precluded.These data,together with the findin that BACE1-null mice are devoid ofAβ,suggest that BACE2 is not likely to be a β-secretase in the CNS.

2.Physiological functions of BACE1

2.1.BACE1-/-mice

To justify BACE1 inhibitor drug development efforts,it was necessary to providein vivovalidation that BACE1 is the primary β-secretase enzyme in the brain.To do so,gene targeting in embryonic stem cells was used to produce BACE1 knockout(-/-)mice.6–9Initial reports showed that BACE1-/-mice were viable and fertile and did not have detectable abnormalities.Their normal morphology and behavior,tissue histology,and blood cell and clinical chemistry characteristics suggested that BACE1 inhibition as a therapeutic approach for AD might lack mechanism-based toxicities.Additionally, APP-overexpressing transgenic mice that also lack theBACE1gene are devoid of cerebral Aβ,amyloid deposition,and Aβ-associated memory impairments.10–14It is important to note that these data validate BACE1 as the major β-secretase in the CNS and indicate that BACE2 does not compensate for BACE1 loss of function,at least for the production of Aβ.Furthermore, they strongly suggested that BACE1 inhibition should be a safe and effective therapeutic strategy for AD.

Although initial studies of BACE1-/-mice indicated that BACE1 was not required for viabilityin vivo,further investigations were necessary to elucidate the physiological functions of BACE1 and to fully understand the potential for mechanismbased toxicities of therapeutic BACE1 inhibition.For example, BACE1 protein is highly concentrated in presynaptic terminals of CNS neurons,suggesting that BACE1 has a role insynaptic function.Moreover,in agreement with high BACE1 expression and presynaptic localization in neurons,deeper analyses of BACE1-/-mice have uncovered numerous subtle neuronal phenotypes,such as axon targeting errors,reduced myelination,memory impairments,reduced muscle spindles, neurochemical abnormalities,alterations in neurogenesis and astrogenesis,increased age-related neurodegeneration,reduced spine density,retinal pathology,endophenotypes of schizophrenia,and seizures.Future investigations may reveal even more BACE1-null phenotypes.Any of these BACE1-null phenotypes in theory could represent mechanism-based side effects of BACE1 inhibitor drugs in humans,thus raising a note of caution that therapeutic inhibition of BACE1 might not be completely free of toxicity.

2.2.Substrates of BACE1

The varied phenotypes of the BACE1-/-mice are likely the result of abrogated β-secretase processing of different substrates of BACE1 in addition to APP.Recent proteomic analyses in cultured primary neurons have identifie numerous putative BACE1 substrates that have roles in neuronal functions.15,16The majority of substrates of BACE1 are,like APP,type I membrane proteins,and a few,like neuregulin 1(NRG1),have more complex membrane topologies.Cleavage of most substrates by BACE1 releases an ectodomain fragment that diffuses from the cell in the extracellular milieu.There,it may bind to another molecule on the same(autocrine)or a different(paracrine)cell to affect signal transduction or cell-cell interactions.Perhaps the best-studied example is that of BACE1 processing of type III NRG1,which releases an epidermal growth factor–like domain that binds to the ErbB receptor on the Schwann cell for the stimulation of myelination.Because of the lack of β-secretase processing,BACE1-/-mice have decreased shedding of the NRG1 epidermal growth factor domain,which reduces instructive signals to myelinating cells and leads to hypomyelination.

Another example of β-secretase processing of a neuronal substrate involves the cleavage of the neural cell adhesion molecule close homologue of L1(CHL1)by BACE1.Like APP,CHL1 is a type I membrane protein,and it has a wellknown function in axonal outgrowth and neuronal survival. Cleavage of CHL1 by BACE1 liberates a soluble ectodomain fragment that may bind to neuropilin-1 and semaphorin 3A,2 molecules that are involved in axonal guidance.Thus,the lack of β-secretase processing of CHL1 might account for the presence of mistargeted axons that have been reported in the olfactory bulb and hippocampus of BACE1-null mice.15–17

In addition to cleavage by BACE1,a number of BACE1 substrates undergo ectodomain shedding by proteases in the A disintegrin and metalloproteinase domain(ADAM)family.The extent to which a given substrate is processed by BACE1 versus an ADAM family member varies depending on the substrate. Some substrates are almost exclusively cut by BACE1(e.g., SEZ6,APLP1),whereas other substrates are primarily cleaved by the ADAMs(e.g.,APP,neuroligin-1).One would predict from these results that potential mechanism-based side effects that arise from therapeutic BACE1 inhibition might derive from deficien processing of substrates that predominantly undergo ectodomain shedding by BACE1 rather than the ADAMs.Conversely,potential toxicities of BACE1 inhibition may be less associated with substrates that are primarily cleaved by ADAM proteases over BACE1.

2.3.BACE2-/-mice

The significan amino acid similarity shared by BACE1 and BACE2 suggests that it may be challenging to develop BACE1 inhibitors that do not cross-inhibit BACE2.Therefore,the possibility exists that BACE1 inhibitor drugs might also cause BACE2 mechanism-based side effects in addition to those of BACE1.To investigate this question,BACE2-/-mice were produced by gene targeting.Like BACE1-null mice,the BACE2-/-mice were initially shown to be viable and fertile with no reported phenotype.9Moreover,other than enhanced early postnatal lethality,BACE1-/-BACE2-/-double knockout mice did not have a more severe phenotype than the BACE1-/-single knockouts.9These data suggest that cross-inhibition of BACE2 with BACE1 inhibitors might not be associated with enhanced toxicity in the adult after postnatal development is completed.

Although BACE2-/-mice initially were reported to be normal,further investigations have revealed BACE2 loss-offunction phenotypes.Pancreatic β-cells express significan levels of BACE2.Interestingly,BACE2-/-mice have increased β-cell mass and insulin levels,and the mice exhibit enhanced glucose regulation.18These phenotypes appear to be the result of abrogated BACE2 cleavage of proproliferative type I transmembrane protein Tmem27,a protein involved in the regulation of β-cell mass.Given these results,inhibition of BACE2 may be beneficia for the treatment of type 2 diabetes,although further research into this hypothesis is necessary.

In addition to the pancreatic phenotype,BACE2-/-mice on a C57BL/6 genetic background exhibit hypopigmentation that results in a silvery coat,compared with the dark coat of wild-type C57BL/6 mice.This phenotype is caused by lack of BACE2 processing of the melanocyte protein PMEL,which is expressed in pigment cells of the skin and eye.BACE2 cleavage releases a fragment of PMEL into melanosomes that forms a matrix of amyloid fibril upon which melanin is deposited.19Consequently,abrogated processing of PMEL in BACE2-/-mice leads to abnormal melanosome formation and hypopigmentation.These results suggest the possibility that cross-inhibition of BACE2 by BACE1 inhibitors might cause reduced pigmentation in humans.

3.Small-molecule BACE1 inhibitor drugs and clinical trials for AD

The extensive validation of BACE1 as the primary β-secretase enzyme in the CNS has spurred vigorous efforts to develop small-molecule inhibitors of BACE1 in both academia and industry.The firs generation of BACE1 inhibitors consisted of noncleavable peptide-based transition state analogues designed after the amino acid sequence in APP at which β-secretase cleaves.Typically,these large peptidomimetic molecules are very potent BACE1 inhibitorsin vitro,mainlybecause the large open active site of BACE1 has evolved to bind polypeptide substrates with high affinit.Unfortunately,the peptide-based BACE1 inhibitors did not possess favorablein vivopharmacologic properties,such as oral bioavailability,long serum half-life,or blood-brain barrier(BBB)penetration.As a consequence,investigators have turned toward designing true small-molecule BACE1 inhibitor drugs.However,the development of nonpeptidic BACE1 inhibitors large enough to bind with sufficien affinit to the enzymatic active site,yet small enough to exhibit satisfactory pharmacokinetics and suitable brain penetration,has proven to be very challenging.Moreover, BACE1 inhibitors should have sufficien lipophilicity to cross both plasma and endosomal membranes for gaining access to the vesicle lumen where the BACE1 active site is located.

《1984》中的监控无孔不入。首先是“老大哥”，这个象征着大洋国最高权力的面相粗犷的男人，他的贴画贴在每一个关键的地方，每幅画的下部都印着“老大哥在看着你”的文字，他的那张留着黑胡子的脸随时凝视着路过的每一个人。其次是电子屏幕，党内的办公室、食堂、党员的住所等都有这么一块金属板，只要你处在它的视野之内，你的一举一动都会被知道。再次是警察，大街上随时都有警卫在巡逻，还有各种密探、特务等。总之，监控渗透在了大洋国的每一个角落，权力关系像毛细血管一样遍布了整个社会。

A crucial advance in small-molecule BACE1 inhibitor development came with the firs X-ray co-crystal structure of BACE1 with a peptidic BACE1 inhibitor.20The BACE1 X-ray structure revealed important inhibitor-enzyme interactions that were exploited in rational drug design efforts.Shortly thereafter,new classes of small-molecule BACE1 inhibitors were developed that exhibited improved pharmacologic characteristics,including small molecular weight,plasma membrane permeability,and better pharmacokinetics.However, most second-generation BACE1 inhibitors were substrates of P-glycoprotein,the adenosine triphosphate-dependent drug efflu pump for xenobiotics in the BBB,and therefore could not reach high concentrations in the brain.

More recently,potent third-generation small-molecule BACE1inhibitors have been developed that achieve satisfactory brain penetration and robust cerebral Aβ reduction in preclinical animal models.Innovative diverse and complex drug development approaches have been employed to design current BACE1 inhibitors.For example,in fragment-based approaches,small molecules are screened from libraries of compounds that exhibit brain penetration and other favorable druglike properties and are selected for BACE1 binding and enzyme inhibitionin vitro.Hits of the screen are then co-crystalized with BACE1,and X-ray structures are determined.Small molecules exhibiting weak interactions with the BACE1 active site are bonded together to form larger molecules that strongly bind and inhibit BACE1 yet still retain favorable brain penetration and drug properties. These approaches have yielded several orally bioavailable BACE1 inhibitor drugs that have entered into human clinical trials.Several compounds are in late clinical phases,including those from Merck,AstraZenica,Eisai,Jannsen,Novartis, among others.Expected trial completion dates range from 2017 to 2024.Although scant information on their progress has been published,preliminary trial results for several BACE1 inhibitor drugs have been reported at recent conferences and indicate that these compounds cross the BBB,robustly inhibit Aβ production in cerebrospinal flui,and appear to be well tolerated.However, we do not yet know whether they will be safe and effective for the treatment or prevention of AD.

Competing interests

The author declares no competing financia interests.

1.Vassar R,Bennett BD,Babu-Khan S,Kahn S,Mendiaz EA,Denis P,et al. Beta-secretase cleavage of Alzheimer’s amyloid precursor protein by the transmembrane aspartic protease BACE.Science1999;286:735–41.

2.Yan R,Bienkowski MJ,Shuck ME,Miao H,Tory MC,Pauley AM,et al. Membrane-anchored aspartyl protease with Alzheimer’s disease beta-secretase activity.Nature1999;402:533–7.

3.Sinha S,Anderson JP,Barbour R,Basi GS,Caccavello R,Davis D,et al. Purificatio and cloning of amyloid precursor protein beta-secretase from human brain.Nature1999;402:537–40.

4.Hussain I,Powell D,Howlett DR,Tew DG,Meek TD,Chapman C,et al. Identificatio of a novel aspartic protease(Asp 2)as beta-secretase.Mol Cell Neurosci1999;14:419–27.

5.Lin X,Koelsch G,Wu S,Downs D,Dashti A,Tang J.Human aspartic protease memapsin 2 cleaves the beta-secretase site of beta-amyloid precursor protein.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A2000;97:1456–60.

6.Luo Y,Bolon B,Kahn S,Bennett BD,Babu-Khan S,Denis P,et al.Mice deficien in BACE1,the Alzheimer’s beta-secretase,have normal phenotype and abolished beta-amyloid generation.Nat Neurosci2001;4:231–2.

7.Roberds SL,Anderson J,Basi G,Bienkowski MJ,Branstetter DG,Chen KS,et al.BACE knockout mice are healthy despite lacking the primary beta-secretase activity in brain:implications for Alzheimer’s disease therapeutics.Hum Mol Genet2001;10:1317–24.

8.Cai H,Wang Y,McCarthy D,Wen H,Borchelt DR,Price DL,et al.BACE1 is the major beta-secretase for generation of Abeta peptides by neurons.Nat Neurosci2001;4:233–4.

9.Dominguez D,Tournoy J,Hartmann D,Huth T,Cryns K,Deforce S,et al. Phenotypic and biochemical analyses of BACE1-and BACE2-deficien mice.J Biol Chem2005;280:30797–806.

10.Ohno M,Sametsky EA,Younkin LH,Oakley H,Younkin SG,Citron M, et al.BACE1deficien yrescues memory deficit and cholinergic dysfunction in a mouse model of Alzheimer’s disease.Neuron2004;41:27–33.

11.Luo Y,Bolon B,Damore MA,Fitzpatrick D,Liu H,Zhang J,et al.BACE1 (beta-secretase)knockout mice do not acquire compensatory gene expression changes or develop neural lesions over time.Neurobiol Dis2003;14:81–8.

12.Laird FM,Cai H,Savonenko AV,Farah MH,He K,Melnikova T,et al. BACE1,a major determinant of selective vulnerability of the brain to amyloid-beta amyloidogenesis,is essential for cognitive,emotional,and synaptic functions.J Neurosci2005;25:11693–709.

13.Ohno M,Cole SL,Yasvoina M,Zhao J,Citron M,Berry R,et al.BACE1 gene deletion prevents neuron loss and memory deficit in 5XFAD APP/PS1 transgenic mice.Neurobiol Dis2007;26:134–45.

14.McConlogue L,Buttini M,Anderson JP,Brigham EF,Chen KS,Freedman SB,et al.Partial reduction of BACE1 has dramatic effects on Alzheimer plaque and synaptic pathology in APP transgenic mice.J Biol Chem2007;282:26326–34.

15.Kuhn PH,Koroniak K,Hogl S,Colombo A,Zeitschel U,Willem M,et al. Secretome protein enrichment identifie physiological BACE1 protease substrates in neurons.EMBO J2012;31:3157–68.

16.Zhou L,Barão S,Laga M,Bockstael K,Borgers M,Gijsen H,et al.The neural cell adhesion molecules L1 and CHL1 are cleaved by BACE1 proteasein vivo.J Biol Chem2012;287:25927–40.

17.Hitt B,Riordan SM,Kukreja L,Eimer WA,Rajapaksha TW,Vassar R. β-Site amyloid precursor protein(APP)–cleaving enzyme 1(BACE1)–deficien mice exhibit a close homolog of L1(CHL1)loss-of-function phenotype involving axon guidance defects.J Biol Chem2012;287: 38408–25.

18.Esterházy D,Stützer I,Wang H,Rechsteiner MP,Beauchamp J,Döbeli H, et al.Bace2 is a β cell-enriched protease that regulates pancreatic β cell function and mass.Cell Metab2011;14:365–77.

19.Rochin L,Hurbain I,Serneels L,Fort C,Watt B,Leblanc P,et al.BACE2 processes PMEL to form the melanosome amyloid matrix in pigment cells.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A2013;110:10658–63.

20.Hong L,Koelsch G,Lin X,Wu S,Terzyan S,Ghosh AK,et al.Structure of the protease domain of memapsin 2(beta-secretase)complexed with inhibitor.Science2000;290:150–3.

Received 30 September 2016;accepted 2 October 2016

Available online 21 October 2016

Peer review under responsibility of Shanghai University of Sport.

E-mail address:r-vassar@northwestern.edu

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jshs.2016.10.004

2095-2546/©2016 Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V.on behalf of Shanghai University of Sport.This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).