A Polyanionic, Quasi-zero-strain and Open-framework K0.76V0.55Nb0.45OPO4 for Sodium-ion Batteries①

LIU Jian-Dong-Yong YU Xu

BAO Jing-Zea LIN Ying-Xia②

a (CAS Key Laboratory of Design and Assembly of Functional Nanostructures,and Fujian Key Laboratory of Nanomaterials, Fujian Institute of Research on the Structure of Matter, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Fuzhou 350002, China)

b (College of Chemistry, Fuzhou Uniνersity, Fuzhou 350108, China)

ABSTRACT A carbon-coated K0.76V0.55Nb0.45OPO4 (KVNP@C) polyanion material was successfully synthesized by a simple sol-gel method. The KVNP@C possesses a highly stable inorganic open-framework structure,which is hard to be affected by the Na+ intercalation/deintercalation when used as an anode material for sodium-ion batteries (NIBs). The assembled KVNP@C/Na half-cell shows a capacity retention of 81.2% and an average Coulombic efficiency of 99.8% at a current density of 300 mA/g after 1500 cycles. In-situ XRD analysis reveals a single-phase solid solution reaction mechanism with a lattice expansion of 4.76%. This work sheds insights into the quest for developing novel polyanion-based anode materials for sodium-ion batteries.

Keywords: anode material, sodium-ion batteries, high structural stability, solid solution reaction;

1 INTRODUCTION

At present, lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) are ubiquitous through small consumer electronics, electric vehicles, and grid-scale energy storage systems. The rapid development of LIBs has led to the continuously increasing costs of Li resources and the sharp decrease in their amount[1]. To solve this problem, alternative batteries, such as Na, K-ion batteries,have been emerging. Compared with lithium, sodium is evenly distributed and rich in reserves (the fifth most abundant element in the earth's crust), which has attracted extensive attention in recent years[2]. However, the large ionic radius of Na+(1.02 Å) results in the large volume expansion of the anode materials during sodiation/desodiation processes,causing structural instability and rapid degradation of capacities. Therefore, developing a new type of anode material with high stability[3,4], long cycle life, and excellent rate performance is particularly crucial. Potential anode materials include carbon materials (hard carbon, soft carbon,etc.) and alloy compounds. However, they can hardly satisfy the requirements of anode materials for sodium-ion batteries.For example, the low working voltage makes the hard carbon form sodium dendrites easily during the sodiation process,causing safety problems[5]; alloy materials (such as Sb, WS2and so on) often suffer a large volume expansion, which will destroy the electrode material structure and cause serious capacity degradation[6]. Therefore, it is particularly important to develop anode materials with a safe operating voltage and a stable structure.

Polyanionic compounds, which have inorganic frameworks and high thermodynamic stability, perform well in sodium storage. The phosphate-based polyanions, such as LiFePO4,LiMnPO4, Li3V2(PO4)3and Na3V2(PO4)3, have been extensively studied and explored as electrode materials for lithium/sodium-ion batteries. Compared with other anodes,phosphate-type polyanion compounds have higher structural stabilities; and strong covalent bonds give them good thermal stability and long cycle life. In addition, the phosphate (PO43-)allows fast ion diffusion in an inorganic framework and stabilizes the redox potentials[7-10]. So, phosphate-type polyanion compounds possess a higher operating voltage than carbon materials and can remain stable by avoiding the formation of sodium dendrites. Therefore, phosphate-type compounds have a potential as anode materials in sodium-ion batteries.

In this work, a new type of inorganic framework material carbon-coated K0.76V0.55Nb0.45OPO4(KVNP@C) was synthesized by a simple sol-gel method. The open framework enables reversible (de) intercalation of 0.75 Na+performula unit, delivering a reversible capacity of 95.4 mAh/g and capacity retention of 75.9% after 100 cycles. Even at a high current density of 300 mA/g, it still delivers a considerable capacity of 53.5 mAh/g. The in-situ XRD analysis reveals a reversible single-phase solid solution reaction with a low lattice volume expansion during the cycling.

2 EXPERIMENTAL

2. 1 Preparation of KVNP@C

The carbon-coated KVNP was synthesized by a sol-gel method. First, 2.27 g H2C2O4·2H2O and 0.5 g H5Nb3O10were dissolved in 10 mL of deionized water, placed in an oil bath at 76 °C, and stirred at 400 rpm for 2 h to obtain a clear solution A. Then, 1.26 g C6H8O7·H2O, 0.69 g NH4H2PO4, and 0.39 g NH4VO3were dissolved in 5 mL of deionized water and stirred at 76 °C to obtain a dark blue solution B; 0.83 g K2CO3was dissolved in 5 mL of deionized water to obtain a clear solution C; subsequently, solution C was slowly added dropwise to solution A. When the mixed solution no longer generated bubbles, solution B was added dropwise. After mixing, the solution was stirred in an oil bath at 76 °C at 400 rpm for 1 h to form a blue transparent solution. The formed gel was dried in an oven overnight at 120 °C. Then the precursor was calcined at 350 °C for 4 h and then 900 °C for 20 h in an argon-hydrogen mixed atmosphere (Ar:H2= 95:5)to obtain carbon-coated KVNP (KVNP@C).

2. 2 Material characterization

The XRD patterns were collected on a Rigaku Ultima IV powder X-ray diffractometer (CuKαradiation). The microscopic morphology of the material was characterized by a scanning electron microscope (SEM, Hitachi SU-8010) and transmission electron microscope (TEM, FEI Tecnai G2 F20).The energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) was used to characterize the elemental composition and distribution of KVNP@C. Inductively Coupled Plasma (ICP, JY Ultima-2)was used to determine the content in KVNP@C.

2. 3 Preparation of working electrode

The active material (KVNP@C), conductive carbon black(Super P Carbon), and carboxymethylcellulose (CMC) binder were mixed at a weight ratio of 8:1:1 and then stirred at 800 rpm for 12 h to obtain a uniform black slurry. Then, the black slurry was evenly coated on aluminum foil and placed in a vacuum oven at 100 °C for 12 h. The mass loading of the KVNP@C electrode is about 1.4 mg/cm2.

2. 4 Half-cell assembly

The coin-type cells (CR2032) were used to assemble half-cells in a glove box filled with high-purity argon (both water content and oxygen content are less than 0.1 ppm). The electrolyte was 1 M NaClO4in EC/DEC with 10% FEC. The in-situ battery used a self-made battery device.

2. 5 Electrochemical measurements

Galvanostatic cycling tests and rate performance tests were carried out on LAND-CT2011A battery-testing instruments under room temperature, where the voltage range was from 0.1 to 2.2 V (vs Na/Na+). Cyclic voltammetry (CV) was measured on a CHI660E electrochemical workstation(Shanghai Chenhua, China) with a voltage range of 0.1～2.2 V(vs. Na/Na+). Rate-scan CV was performed on a Bio-Logic SP-300 electrochemical workstation with scan rates from 0.02 to 0.15 mV/s.

2. 6 In-situ XRD test

An in-situ battery was made with a beryllium window capable of penetrating XRD rays, and a galvanostatic charge and discharge test at 10 mA/g was performed on LANDCT2011A battery-testing instruments. In the meantime, XRD signals were continuously collected at a scanning rate of 5 °/minute by Rigaku Ultima IV powder XRD with CuKαradiation at a voltage of 40 kV and a current of 40 mA.

3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

As illustrated in Fig. 1a, the KVNP@C is composed of NbO6/VO6octahedra and PO4tetrahedra with K-ions filled in the open channels, showing a typical KTiOPO4(KTP)structure[11]. Besides, the elements of Nb prefer to occupy the center of octahedra, while the V occupies the center of the residual octahedra. The VO6octahedron is more regular than NbO6[12], reducing the whole distortion degree of octahedra,which would greatly reduce the possibility of lattice deformation during the intercalation of sodium ions. Fig. 1b shows the results of X-ray powder diffraction (XRD) Rietveld refined of KVNP@C (Rwp= 6.87%,Rp= 4.96%). It can be seen that all the diffraction peaks are consistent with the theoretical values and indexed in an orthorhombic system. The unit cell parameters obtained by the refined structure area= 12.93,b=6.47 andc= 10.73 Å, respectively. The inductively coupled plasma emission spectroscopy (ICP-OES) result gave a K:V:Nb molar ratio of 0.76:0.55:0.45, so the chemical formula can be determined as K0.76V0.55Nb0.45OPO4. Due to the low potassium content in KVNP@C, a large number of vacancies and open channels are expected to host sodium-ions without damaging the structure. The SEM image (Fig. 1c) of KVNP@C exhibits a uniform particle size of about 500 nm.And, the high-resolution TEM (HRTEM) image of KVNP@C shows a well-covered (the carbon layer is about 2 nm) KVNP with a lattice space of 0.56 nm, indexing to the (201) lattice plane (Fig. 1d). Furthermore, TEM-EDS mapping proves that various elements in the sample are uniformly distributed (Fig. 1e).

Fig. 1. (a) Crystal structure diagram of KVNP; (b) XRD Rietveld refinement of KVNP@C (Rwp = 6.87%, Rp = 4.96%);(c) SEM image of KVNP@C; (d) TEM image of KVNP@C; e) EDS element distribution image of KVNP@C

Fig. 2a presents the initial three cycles of cyclic voltammetry (CV) profiles at a scan rate of 0.1 mV/s. The reduction peak of the first cycle between 0.9 and 1.1 V (vs Na/Na+) corresponds to the intercalation of Na+and the formation of solid electrolyte interface (SEI). The oxidation peaks at around 1.15 and 1.57 V correspond to the extraction of sodium ions. After the initial cycle, the CV curves of the following two circles almost overlap, indicating a highly reversible process. The inset in Fig. 2b is the first cycle voltage profile of KVNP@C/Na half-cells at a current density of 5 mA/g (rate of ～0.05 C), the reversible specific capacity of KVNP@C is 95.4 mAh/g (the volume energy density is 312.9 mAh/cm3), implying a 0.75 sodium-ion intercalation in each KVNP@C molecule (calculated based on the theoretical specific capacity). The initial Coulombic efficiency (CE) of 46.8% is mainly attributed to the formation of irreversible SEIs, which is common for anodes in sodium-ion batteries[13].Even at such a low current density (5 mA/g), KVNP@C still exhibits a reversible specific capacity of 72.4 mAh/g after 100 cycles, remaining 75.9% of the initial capacity. The charge and discharge curves during the cycle are shown in Fig. 2c.The voltage profiles and the inset of the fifth dQ/dV curve indicate a voltage plateau of 0.99 V for the insertion of Na+and a voltage of 1.05 V for the deintercalation of Na+progress.The dQ/dV curve also shows a narrow polarization voltage for only 0.06 V. The voltage plateau can always be observed in the charge and discharge curves of different cycles, which is consistent with the CV profiles, indicating that KVNP@C can maintain a stable structure during the extraction/intercalation process. Compared with other polyanion anodes[14-26],KVNP@C has the lowest operating voltage (0.99 V), which is beneficial to achieve a higher energy density for the full-cell application.

Fig. 2. (a) CV profiles of the KVNP@C electrode at a scan rate of 0.1 mV/s; (b) Galvanostatic cycling of the KVNP@C electrode at a current of 5 mA/g. The inset shows the voltage profile of the first cycle; (c) Voltage profiles of the KVNP@C electrode at a current of 5 mA/g. The inset is the corresponding dQ/dV curve at the fifth cycle; (d) Comparison of average platform voltages of polyanionic compounds

Fig. 3 displays the long-cycling performance of KNVP@C,which was tested at current densities of 100 and 300 mA/g followed by two-cycles of activation at 5 mA/g. The KNVP@C delivers a reversible capacity of 79.9 mAh/g at 100 mA/g with a CE of 97.5%. After 1000 charge/discharge cycles,a capacity of 82.5% can be retained. Moreover, KNVP@C achieves a capacity of 53.5 mAh/g at the high rate of 300 mA/g, and the capacity increases to 66.1 mAh/g at the 296thcycle. The final capacity retention is 81.2% and an average CE of 99.8% can be achieved after 1500 cycles. The above results exhibit the excellent cycling stability of KNVP@C,attributed to the reducing structural distortion benefiting from Nb/V co-doping.

Fig. 3. (a, b) Electrochemical cycle performance of KVNP@C at current densities of 100 and 300 mA·g-1,respectively; Insets in (a) and (b) are the corresponding voltage profiles, respectively

As shown in Fig. 4, rate CV was performed to investigate the Na+storage kinetics of KVNP@C electrodes. The scanning voltage window and the scan rates were selected in a range of 0.1～2.2 V (vs Na/Na+) and from 0.02 to 0.15 mV/s,respectively. With the increase of scanning rate, the oxidation peak gradually shifts to the high voltage position, and the reduction peak shifts to the opposite direction. It shows that the faster scanning rates will affect the electrochemical oxidation-reduction process and cause electrochemical polarization. Then, we calculated the Na+diffusion coefficients of KVNP@C electrodes by the Randles-Sevcik equation. To qualitatively analyze the contribution of diffusion and surface-induced capacitance, the functional relationship (Equation 1) between current (i) and scan rate (ν)is shown as follows, whereaandbare the adjustment constants.

i=aνb(equation 1)[27]

Generally, the value ofbvaries between 0.5 and 1.0. When the value ofbis around 0.5, it indicates the electrochemical process controlled by diffusion behavior[28-30]; while the b-value of 1 refers to a surface-induced behavior, i.e.pseudocapacitance. Herein, the value ofbis determined by slope of log(i) and log(ν) obtained from CV curves (Fig. 4b),which shows values of 0.86 and 0.75 for peaks 1 and 2,respectively[31,32]. It indicates that the electrochemical process of KVNP@C is partly controlled by capacitive behavior,resulting in the fast sodium-ion reaction kinetics.

Fig. 4. (a) CV curves at various scan rates, (b) Fitting line of log (sweep rate, mV/s) vs. log (Ipeak, mA) of KVNP@C, (c) capacitive contributions at 0.04 mV/s, (d) Ratio of capacitive contribution at various scan rates, (e) Rate capability

In detail, the contributions of capacitive and diffusion can be calculated based on equation 2:

wherek1νandk2ν1/2represent surface capacitive and diffusion control processes, respectively. Fig. 4c presents the pseudocapacitance contribution of the KVNP@C electrode at a scan rate of 0.04 mV/s, in which the proportion is about 82.61%.The proportion of pseudocapacitance increases as the scan rate increases, which grows from 82.58% to 96.12%. The calculated results imply that the inorganic framework of KVNP@C can possess abundant pathways for the Na+going through electrodes and electrolytes, leading to fast charge transfer for a better rate performance.

Additionally, the rate performance is investigated at different current densities ranging from 5 to 500 mA/g (Fig.4e). The KVNP@C/Na battery delivers charging capacity of 95.8, 91.6, 86.9, 82.6, 77.8, 69.2, 56.4, and 46.0 mAh/g at 5,10, 20, 30, 50, 100, 200, 300 and 500 mA/g, respectively.After two repeated rate cycles, the charge capacity still maintains 90.5 mAh/g when going back to the initial current density. Based on the above analysis, it can be shown that the KVNP@C anode boasts an excellent rate performance and long-cycle stability.

To verify the structural evolution of the KVNP@C electrode during the intercalation/deintercalation of Na+,in-situ XRD technology was conducted (Fig. 5a and b). Three obvious peaks changed during Na+(de)intercalation, which can be assigned to (201), (203), and (022) Bragg peaks.During the entire discharging process, all three peaks shift slightly toward a lower angle and there are no additional peaks emerging, which means the formation of solid solution in the compound. The charge follows the same but inverse peaks shifting, revealing a highly reversible phase change process. Fig. 5b shows the diffraction patterns at different states of charge. The lattice parameters obtained from Rietveld refinement have been summarized in Fig. 5e. The selected calculated results (Fig. 5d and f) show that the lattice constants a, b, and c increase from 12.86, 6.44, and 10.71 Å to 13.04, 6.50, and 10.98 Å, respectively (RwpandRpare 4.89%,4.74%, and 2.26%, 2.23%, respectively). Consequently,despite the large size of Na+, the total volume difference between the original sample and fully discharged KVNP@C is only 4.76% (Fig. 5e), which is less than those of alloybased compounds (Sn4P3, Sb, Sn, P) and metal oxides (SnO2,Fe2O3)[33-38]. Compared with reported polyanionic materials in sodium ion batteries, KVNP@C shows the most minimal volume expansion (Fig. S1), revealing the superiority of its structure. Based on the above experimental results, we confirm that the small volume change is the key point that enables the great cycling stability of KVNP@C as a novel promising candidate anode for next-generation NIBs.

Fig. 5. (a) Contour plot and (b) line patterns of in-situ XRD patterns of the KVNP@C electrode with a different state of charge,and (c) the corresponding charge-discharge profile of the electrode, (d) XRD pattern and the corresponding Rietveld refinement of the initial KVNP@C, and (e) the sodiated KVNP@C, (f) Lattice-constant evolution upon cycling.Solid and dashed lines represent the discharging and charging process, respectively

4 CONCLUSION

In summary, a new type of negative electrode material KVNP@C for sodium-ion batteries was successfully prepared by a simple sol-gel method. Electrochemical research results show that KVNP@C has excellent cycle stability and good rate performance. Under low current density discharge (5 mA/g), the capacity retention rate of KVNP@C is 75.9% after 100 cycles. Even at a high current density of 300 mA/g (≈ 3 C), the capacity retention rate and average Coulombic efficiency are 81.2% and 99.8% after 1500 cycles, respectively, indicating that the material has high reversibility of electrochemical sodium (de)intercalation. Kinetic mechanisms show that KVNP@C as an anode material has a rapid sodium-ion transfer rate. Moreover, the in-situ XRD analysis verified that the sodium-ion intercalation process of KVNP@C is a single-phase solid solution reaction with a lattice volume expansion of merely 4.76%. Based on the above analysis, KVNP@C material has high structural stability and good electrochemical performance, which has a potential to be applied to the anodes of next-generation sodium-ion batteries.